SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 412th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@pauloliver316511 сағат бұрын
I hear their strong British accent and what I love about evolution is that U.S. English has done to British English exactly what Brazilian Portuguese has done to European portuguese, evolved it into something really beautiful and amazing to hear. 😂
@pauloliver316511 сағат бұрын
I think about the privilege these guys and girls had to have him to talk about evolution to them. They are really or rich or lucky. 😂
@albertleibold141511 сағат бұрын
New buildings evolve into old buildings, right?
@albertleibold141511 сағат бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 411th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@FlandiddlyandersFRS12 сағат бұрын
Albert Leibold keeps exposing his complete ignorance regarding biochemistry... ...not once but 410 times so far 🤷♂️🤪
@albertleibold141513 сағат бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 410th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@albertleibold1415Күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 409th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin759620 сағат бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@albertleibold1415Күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 408th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin759620 сағат бұрын
"Serum Albumin: A Multifaced Enzyme" Remember when you denied the medical definition of an enzyme? Pepperidge Farm remembers.
@albertleibold1415Күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 407th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin759620 сағат бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@albertleibold1415Күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 406th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin759620 сағат бұрын
"A prebiotic template-directed peptide synthesis based on amyloids" Remember when you were embarrassed by amyloids? Pepperidge Farm remembers.
@albertleibold14152 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 405th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin7596Күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@albertleibold14152 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 404th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin7596Күн бұрын
Do you remember all those questions you were asked but never answered? Here's one: You claimed all mutations are harmful. What pathological disorder results from lactase persistence?
@robertbones3262 күн бұрын
Dawkins is sharing incredible knowledge and 90% of the comments are talking about the cameraman smh. I'm 30 minutes in and at no point was i interested in anything except Professor Dawkins lecture and the students questions. Yall have got some ADHD or something 🤦♂️
@Ek29121Күн бұрын
It's not that deep, ffs lol I'm 21 minutes in and the cameraman has caught my attention but I'm still listen to Dawkins, I was even coming to comment on the cameraman until I saw it was mentioned a ton. You didn't get distracted by the cameraman but you did by the comments.. 😂
@FlandiddlyandersFRS2 күн бұрын
Just a quick reminder to any creationists or flat-Earthers in the comments: 1) there is no refutation of evolution in existence 2) logical fallacies and lies are not valid arguments 3) do some research before publicly humiliating yourself
@albertleibold14153 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 403rd time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75962 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@BlahBlahBlah-x3h3 күн бұрын
To be honest his answers are quite hand wavey and if i was a 16 year old i probably wouldn't find his answers satisfactory either. He's talking to them like they are five
@albertleibold14153 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 402nd time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@albertleibold14153 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 401st time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75962 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@albertleibold14153 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 400th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75962 күн бұрын
Falling pathetically behind in your reading assignments, I take it. What will you do when your "challenge" is exposed as the simplistic childishness it is? Oh, that's right --- it already has. And you don't know how.
@albertleibold14154 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 399th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75963 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@albertleibold14154 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 398th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75963 күн бұрын
"The catalysis of the hydration of carbon dioxide and the dehydration of carbonic acid by an enzyme isolated from red blood cells." You'll have to read this entire paper to find the one critical piece of information. Hope you've got the vocabulary.
@albertleibold14155 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 397th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75964 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@albertleibold14155 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 396th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75964 күн бұрын
"World-First Artificial Enzymes Suggest Life Doesn't Need DNA or RNA" A little cutting edge research for you.
@albertleibold14155 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 395th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75964 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@albertleibold14156 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 394th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75965 күн бұрын
"Undefining life's biochemistry: implications for abiogenesis" In case you need another primer.
@albertleibold14156 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 393rd time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75965 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@thomyorke76226 күн бұрын
did they get a student to film this?
@rodin28406 күн бұрын
It was one of Dawkins’ chimpanzees, the one that didn’t😊 evolve.
@EvolutionIsSelfEvident5 күн бұрын
@@rodin2840 Your childlike scientific ignorance is duly noted and laughed at.
@albertleibold14157 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 392nd time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75966 күн бұрын
"Self-Organizing Biochemical Cycles" Looks like you need another primer.
@FYTClips.7 күн бұрын
"God might have gave everyone 2 kidneys so that they can give one away to someone in need" My God that's a stupid suggestion
@albertleibold14157 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 391st time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75966 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@Septemberhello7 күн бұрын
What education is being given in such a developed country all fanaticism in children
@rickmartin75966 күн бұрын
Parents are the gatekeepers. They can keep their children from learning.
@Septemberhello6 күн бұрын
Your country seems to have a third world parenting 😢
@albertleibold14157 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 390th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75966 күн бұрын
"Study shows short peptides can self-assemble into catalysts" Read this before it comes back to haunt you.
@Septemberhello7 күн бұрын
Some fanatic children here
@arkyudetoo95557 күн бұрын
Asking about what was is there before the Big Bang is like someone asking you what's your life is like was before you were born. The difficulty about teaching religious students, especially adults, scientific studies that contradicts a couple of things about what their religion says is that what's stopping them from understanding is because they are always putting god into everything and anything. This is the reason why I never indoctrinated my kids into religion despite the fact that they're baptised as a catholic, because it would've prevented them from learning things that is factual. There was an interesting question about why do people have 2 kidneys when we can only survive with only having 1 kidney. I think the answer is rather simple, it's the same reason why people can still survive with only one leg, one eye, one ear, one arm, etc. But ask those who only have 1 kidneys, what's their life is like or was there any big changes that they have to make after they donated their kidneys.
@albertleibold14157 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 389th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75966 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@c.jishnu3787 күн бұрын
The CAMERAMAN seems to be both VERY GOOD as well as REALLY BAD.
@albertleibold14158 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 388th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75967 күн бұрын
"Self-assembly processes in the prebiotic environment" I understand if you don't want to read this one.
@albertleibold14158 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 387th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75968 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@OwaisIdreesi-tz1jt8 күн бұрын
One more question.. how first cell got the life? And how the first cell formed without any possibility of perfect environment? If there was a perfect environment then who controlled this environment? Okay... If suppose the environment was also perfect then how life(soul) get into this cell? Evolution is just a bullshit theory which is controlled and spread by the opponents of God.
@Lordidude8 күн бұрын
There are answers with evidence to all of your questions. You have to actually prsue your questions if you are interested in the answers.
@OwaisIdreesi-tz1jt8 күн бұрын
@@Lordidude can you please give me time stamp where he is saying that how life (soul) enetered in the cell? And where he said that what is the origin of life? Specifically, what is life? Is life material thing as cell is? Because cell or living body remains still for a specific time when the soul left the body.
@Lordidude8 күн бұрын
@@OwaisIdreesi-tz1jt It's not in this video. If you are interested in the answers to those questions, you have to study abiogenesis and evolution.
@albertleibold14158 күн бұрын
@@OwaisIdreesi-tz1jt: Thank you for your insightful comment.
@OwaisIdreesi-tz1jt7 күн бұрын
@@albertleibold1415 are you kidding 😂😂
@OwaisIdreesi-tz1jt9 күн бұрын
He is great mind thinker but unfortunately he is blind enough as well, because this universe is exactly fined tuned but who tuned this universe ? I have one question. According to current research the brains of our ancestors were 10% more intelligent than ours now. Why our brains didn't evolve with time? 2ndly we human beings speak thousands of languages but every different kind of animals have the same language of their own even these animals living in china or america. But question is that who taught us too much languages? A child can't speak unless he will not listen from his parents or surroundings then how richard dawken's ancestors who were evolved from chimpanzee etc. (after a long evolution from other animals also) started to speak?
@FlandiddlyandersFRS6 күн бұрын
You're obviously an uneducated science illiterate who has been brainwashed with iron-age mythology. Move along and leave the actual science to the grownups.
@albertleibold14159 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 386th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75968 күн бұрын
"Inhibition and catalysis of carbonic anhydrase. Recent crystallographic analyses." You never read this one either, did you? You are missing vital clues.
@albertleibold141510 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 385th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75969 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@baselius66210 күн бұрын
Just gotta love the comments who group "religion" into one and then assume that all is against evolution. Religion is so vague that is can be made to fit any preconception 😂.
@rickmartin75969 күн бұрын
The biggest grouping comes from science denying believers who lump everyone -- believer or not -- into some kind of satanic conspiracy against their version of religion. I think the level of discourse would be elevated if all believers who accept evolution stand up against the noisy few evolution deniers.
@albertleibold141510 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 384th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75969 күн бұрын
"Common origins of RNA, protein and lipid precursors in a cyanosulfidic protometabolism" Vital clue here. Can you find it?
@trchri10 күн бұрын
From an educator’s point of view, he does a fantastic job of adjusting to his audience and working with their current understanding to make connections. Very good stuff
@rickmartin75969 күн бұрын
I think the video's title is somewhat misleading. Dawkins seems to be conducting an exercise in critical thinking rather than delivering a lecture on evolution.
@rodin28409 күн бұрын
Individuals like Dawkins often use words such as science, scientific, critical or rational thinking. However, they are useally only expressing their own beliefs.
@rickmartin75969 күн бұрын
@@rodin2840 How would you know? Anything other than your opinion, I mean.
@rodin28408 күн бұрын
@@rickmartin7596Disregarding the evidence that contradicts the materialist paradigm.
@rickmartin75968 күн бұрын
@@rodin2840 You have no evidence ... only wishful thinking.
@albertleibold141510 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 383rd time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin75969 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@albertleibold141511 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 382nd time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin759610 күн бұрын
"Energy, Enzymes, and Catalysis Problem Set - The Biology Project" Go on ... take a look. What can it hurt?
@FlandiddlyandersFRS10 күн бұрын
@@rickmartin7596 Albert Leibold keeps exposing his complete ignorance regarding biochemistry.
@albertleibold141511 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 381st time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin759610 күн бұрын
Still running away ... still not answering.
@DD-gu9zd11 күн бұрын
This is beautiful to watch - it all starts with questions.
@albertleibold141511 күн бұрын
SOURCE # 10 (OR ANY OTHER SOURCE) visited for the 380th time: "Alteration and Stability of Complex Macromolecular Amino Acid Precursors in Hydrothermal Environments" contains NO (= 0) PROOF that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Rick Martin is completely clueless about ENZYMES in general. Rick Martin obviously refuses to accept that ABSOLUTELY NONE (= 0) of his useless comments is about an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Predictably, Rick Martin posts yet another irrelevant comment in order to underline that he has absolutely NO (= 0) CLUE concerning an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) that could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Unfortunately, Rick Martin is NOT courageous enough to admit that NO SOURCE (= 0) contains proof that an ENZYME (more than 60 amino acids) could be produced without DNA/RNA instructions in a primordial soup or a meteorite. Obviously, there is NO SOURCE (= 0) to support Rick Martin’s unsubstantiated speculation.
@rickmartin759610 күн бұрын
"Subsumed complexity: abiogenesis as a by-product of complex energy transduction" This is in case you need to brush up on some basics.