I am sorry, but I must point out the song itself cries out to atheists.

I love this and he’s so right!!!!

Never gets old.

Wow. That was unexpected. The song. The singer. The ending.

READ THIS WHOLE THING: PRAY FOR ISRAEL. PRAY FOR THE PEACE OF JERUSALEM. THE LORD JESUS CHRIST DIED FOR YOUR SINS AND ROSE AGAIN FROM THE DEAD. WOULD YOU LIKE TO TAKE YOUR PLACE IN HIS HOUSEHOLD? THEN PLEASE REPENT OF ALL YOUR SINS TODAY AND SURRENDER YOUR ENTIRE LIFE TO THE LORD JESUS CHRIST. NOBODY IS OUT OF THE CANDIDACY FOR BECOMING A CHRISTIAN.

Songwriting. Fun. ❤

Steve, you and the Steep Canyon Rangers are AWESOME in Caroline!! Bill Hader is awesome too!!

Wow

I guess you didn't do your job, Steve. At the end of the song I was thinking of a breathtaking epic Western adventure.

I still love this

The young girl lost a bet.

'' Don't have no......'' = double negative. For goodness sake - get it right. Though I love it for its message.

As an atheist i approve this message 😂

Ah, but we do! It’s called, “Imagine.” Yours is funnier though!

Songwriters need evergreen tropes.

Though he’s had a wonderful comedy and acting career over the years just seeing some of his face expressions early in this video seems at peace with himself and is enjoying the later part of his life playing music and being totally happy with life

Tim Minchin provides enough for my Atheist needs, and he's been writing them since before this was released.

That was a fun blast from the past ❤

Man, I went to Mr. Martin’s show with Martin Short a few years back and tried to get him to sign my banjo strap, but he scurried off too fast 😢 He’s brought me so much joy!

I didn't know you was a musician how refreshing

Loved this, it's really funny and exceptionally well done! Incidentally, if anyone is looking for other incredibly intelligent atheist songs, please enjoy the wonder that is Tim Minchin. Particularly his earlier work, and especially the song 'Thank You God' (although he has MANY which would suit this description). Note, he has two live shows available, the Heritage Orchestra show and 'So Fucking Rock'. If you just want to hear 'Thank You God', it's here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/f4vIiIOJmNOiotE (Note, this goes directly to Tim Minchin's official KZbin page, so the $$ go to him. You can find all his other stuff there. He's fucking brilliant).

I am an atheist and I feel sorry for delusional people with no skill for reading comprehension, nor an aptitude for critical thinking. I love all the old hymns. Grew up with them. One needn't be superstitious to enjoy any kind of music. I guess you could say I'm guilty of cultural appropriation, but so far, that's not illegal; although I'm sure the Christians will tend to that soon. They love laws that can be used to control and punish people. L'chaim

I wonder if Steve can still juggle. Also wonder if anyone has witnessed to him about Jesus Christ. Genesis 1. John 3:16-21. 1John1. Psalms 22. Isaiah 53.

Courage: My dear old grandmother died atheist at 102 years.

😂😂😂😂😂

This song has everything: brilliant writing, composition and arrangement, fantastic performers, continuously escalating murder drama sprinkled with comedy, and a dazzling climax with a twist worthy of M. Night Shyamalan. Steve Martin is so ridiculously multi-talented.

I love these two ❤️

I wonder if any of these guys have read 'A bible for atheists'. :)

lOVE You Steven 🤗💋🤗💋

That was exceptional

Thank you Steve Martin for being my unofficial grandad since you were in your mid 20s. It has been extremely humorous on our end as well. Hahaha! I sent auto correct just a jolly whathefuckinever!?

We do now.

Atheists listen and hear songs most people have never heard.

I have to get the album

Very impressive 💯 TYFYS 👍🇺🇸😂AF. So maybe you might want to suggest for a little bit more comedy. I need to have a violinist with the last name of Larry or first name of Larry. And then a DI WHO WAS THE NAME MOE TO SLAP THEM BOTH AROUND THEIR COMPETING😂

"...and likely one of the best 'story songs'. ;-)

What about the Buddhist and the Hindu?

"Atheists have rock and roll". Works for me

May I introduce you to Tim Minchin and Maynard James Keenan, then?

19k thumbs up and only 56 comments? Wow. I listen to this every once in while on repeat. Excuse me while I hit play one more time❤

STEVE !! THAT NOTE!!! BRAVO

And this is why I'm not an atheist, I'm a Satanist

Every song for us

Frankly I have met more atheists with higher moral standards than I have Christians. I compare Buddhism to atheism. Live and let live. Treat others as you want to be treated. Christians seem to think that they can commit sin all week long and go to church on Sunday and pray it away and that's not how it works. You have to be moral at all times you have to be kind and loving at all times. And the atheists I know are raising their kids with high moral standards and a great education

Steve hits those high notes right on. I'm pretty sure. Missed Edie, for some reason she didn't make this cut.

What? I'm pretty sure the average atheist can claim any song they like. Then again, if they don't want any, that's cool, too.

What about the Atheist Tabernacle Choir?

What about Dust in the Wind?

U guys I am watching this cause a a shirt of it

Anyone else in 2024 watching this and remembering the last 10 years? COVID, school shooters, and Donald Trump. Maybe the atheists should have a song.