Good video well explained, I only use continuity as a first line check, but backfeeds through another circuit can cause your meter to beep, sending you on a wild goose chase. Resistance is good for tracing wires that might have been accidentally be crossed. I find an ethernet cable tester with croc clip adaptors both ends very useful during comissioning multi wire installations. But, I use a low value resistor as a load to stress a wire, H4's break to easily in my tool bag! Happy fault finding everyone
@andyloijou627715 сағат бұрын
Ha where get m3 t shirt??
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding5 сағат бұрын
Through Schmiedmann. Do you want to buy one?
@andyloijou627738 минут бұрын
yes
@goodbling1116 сағат бұрын
Absolutely brilliant how to, they always teach voltage drop at the BMW academy to the apprentices but it always fries your head over continuity testing. Volt drop is definitely the way to be checking.
@shaunblakemore715017 сағат бұрын
Voltage drop for the win 👍
@wrongmark17 сағат бұрын
Good tip. Everyday’s a school day.
@mathijs19817 сағат бұрын
Nice one! Thanks for sharing Ben. 😊
@mikimiki19522 сағат бұрын
Why does my N63 have too much suction when I take off oil fill cap when car is running I replaced all vacuume components
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 сағат бұрын
Because the breather diaphragms are split
@mikimiki19518 сағат бұрын
@@allmech_BMW_fault_finding they’re brand new
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 сағат бұрын
We fit a Vaico one to an N63 last month and it filled the manifold full of oil lol. No idea bud why your engine is doing that. You would need to do cylinder leakage test maybe in case rings are stuck in
@mikimiki19517 сағат бұрын
@@allmech_BMW_fault_finding thank you
@maintenancetechnicians2362Күн бұрын
I'm having the same problem just when the mechanism lock opens and stops moving the soft top. Can you advise me?
@crunchynuttcornflake2 күн бұрын
What are you talking about?
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 сағат бұрын
Another garage changed an o-ring on a pipe but the compressor was leaking
@LEOGermanHybrid2 күн бұрын
Hello, I believe we have identified the issue with your EME and have a solution. If possible, we hope to get in touch with you. You can check out the video I just posted, where you can see our ongoing training session. In the video, we are working on the EME for models such as the X5 F15, G38, and F18.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding2 күн бұрын
Hi I will check it out thanks alot 🙂
@astuteventures3 күн бұрын
Not sure if you will reply in time, as im going back to bmw tomorrow. 2 months ago, i noticed car was lowered. I turned engine on and it rasied itself back to normal. This then continued, could lower after an hour or sometimes days and then every time i start engine it would go back to normal. So i bit the bullet, took to bmw and then diagnosed as it needing a new air compressor which i paid around £1.3.k to have sorted. Got car back and week later, it lowered. Gutted i am, because i go back tomorrow for them to take car back and look again and tell me know what they think is wrong. Ive suggested they got it wrong and they relaced a part which dodnt need replacing. They are digging heels in and saying a new fault has happened which is causing it to lower again. Have you got any ideas on how i can approach this. Thanks
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding2 күн бұрын
Has it had new air bellows? They need to be leak tested. I had an X5 last week that I replaced compressor but one side kept dropping. I found 5 corroded wires to solenoid valves. You need to get them to spray soapy water on the air bellows. You also need to know did they replace the valve block and conpressor or just the valve block? And height sensors need to be checked. Hard to say without being there. Dealers are bloody useless mostly. Indies like us are often way more clued up
@astuteventures2 күн бұрын
@@allmech_BMW_fault_finding not changed bellows no, they just said needed new compressor. Then it dropped like before, so I was gutted as feel like they just guessed at it to get loads of money, but I can't prove anything. Receipt says they don't air supply and relay
@astuteventures2 күн бұрын
Done not don't
@astuteventures2 күн бұрын
@@allmech_BMW_fault_finding I've looked up other videos, to me as it always raised back up on once started engine, that tells me the compressor is working and that they shouldn't have changed that to begin with and it was always something else like bellows or solenoid which controls when the compressor kicks in or not kinda thing
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding2 күн бұрын
@astuteventures Usually the compressor wears out prematurely due to the constant activation of it as it attempts to maintain the correct ride height which is constantly dropping due to leaking bags. Even when driving it can activate too often. Bellows or airbags as they call them can pass a leak test but when you remove them lo and behold they will be cracked to buggery once you pull them out and extend their length. If you have owned the vehicle a number of years and have never replaced the air bellows I think there you will find the issue. Please let me know if you find the issue. Ps - arnott bellows are better and cheaper than the originals.
@chrisjfox87153 күн бұрын
What compelled you to need to change them?
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding3 күн бұрын
On this car I needed to remove the cam cover to replace the vanos sprockets and bolt actuators.
@petar4434 күн бұрын
I would unplug the fuel line and hook my flowmeter that i made myself to the pump outlet while the pump is in the tank. Then on my flowmeter i would set the regulator to 5.5 bar while the pump is working and pumping the fuel into a 5 liter bottle. If the pump is PWM i would command highest speed with the scanner. For 3.0l NA motor the pump needs to produce 1.15liter per minute at 5 bar. Then i just start the stopwatch and check the flow for 1 minute i have on my 5 liter graduated bottle.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding4 күн бұрын
Thats a great way to do it 🙂 If I had more time I would make more things like that but I just had the hardest week of problem jobs 😅 I do need to spend time making more tools.
@kevinpalmer74525 күн бұрын
Good advice 👍
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding4 күн бұрын
Cheers Kevin 🙂 New video coming up soon btw
@kevinpalmer74525 күн бұрын
49 years in the motor trade and I’ve never come across a V10 🤷♂️😂
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding5 күн бұрын
Oh I've seen loads lol
@user-cv5oz9ji3v6 күн бұрын
Hi mate, I’ll be honest I’m stressing, I’ve had a EMS light pop up, scanned it and resulted in 3 fault codes: Camshaft Exhaust Sensor Signal Implausible, 130304: VANOS, exhaust camshaft, control jammed, camshaft jammed and a P13C9 code. I’ve change the sensor drove it for a little and the EMS light has not come back. Car starts fine, can’t notice anything with the driving, cleared the fault once came back after 5 days. Can you please tell me if I will need to change these bolts. Thank you.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding5 күн бұрын
Usually its more the Vanos sprocket broken and sticking but if yours is intermittent you might as well change the actuator bolts. If this doesn't cure it you should change the vanos sprockets. If you have a rear wheel drive Bmw its an engine out job I'm afraid. Make sure your I-level is on the latest version as old I-Level is less tolerant to timing drifts.
@AbbottAutomotive6 күн бұрын
😎
@garywarburton17786 күн бұрын
Another great post pal 👍
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding6 күн бұрын
Cheers Gary
@davyarthurs6 күн бұрын
As nice as that BM V10 sounds, you can’t really say it’s the best due to all its issues. However, I’d vote the Lexus LFA as the best V10.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding6 күн бұрын
Most of the issues are easily resolved and most are caused by folk who buy them, cant afford to maintain them then they fail. To be fair all Bmw engines have issues lol. I get your point tho. I should look into that Lexus V10👍🙂
@davyarthurs6 күн бұрын
@@allmech_BMW_fault_finding indeed. Look forward to where you’re going to stick that V10!
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding6 күн бұрын
@davyarthurs 😅
@benreeve91309 күн бұрын
Good job pal. I think i will struggle a lot more without some of the specialist tools you have. I know you didn't show it in the vid but was the hub nut hard to remove mine is well corroded, even if i manage to remove it getting the shaft out of the hub will be my next struggle, any tips on that? Cheers
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding8 күн бұрын
Oh I had that once. Shaft usually sieze it mate and no amount of hammering will free it off from the splines. You need a 12 sided socket and bang it on over the rusted nut. One size down so 36mm to 35mm for example. I forget the size of the nut on those
@Abbo8889 күн бұрын
Never heard anyone speak well of RRG, then again I think all the big groups in the trade were much of a muchness...I used to work for Hartwell (Warrington) and they were bloody awful.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding9 күн бұрын
RRG was something else. I thank RRG especially the fat bastard area manager who, with his disgusting arrogance, contributed to me leaving for Finland 11 years ago. Best move I ever made.
@kevinpalmer74529 күн бұрын
Thanks
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding9 күн бұрын
Wow thanks alot Kevin 🙂
@kevinpalmer74529 күн бұрын
That’s some forest mate those trees are so tall think I read somewhere Finland is 70% forest. Place I work can’t get mechanics or should I say good ones I’ve been there 4 years and 4 of em have been and gone shite they were 😩6 months and I’m done 66 retirement age was thinking about carrying on but my hands shoulders and back are starting to ache time to give up I think.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding9 күн бұрын
Time to walk away mate. This job has buggered alot of us up joint wise, me included. Yes 22 million hectares and 70% coverage. Is it any wonder the trade is struggling, Kevin? The way we get treated and the complexity of the job lol.
@6920jonathan10 күн бұрын
Great video Ben KZbin must be hard work but it will pay off .have you ever thought of doing BMW training for the aftermarket?
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Thanks Jonathon 🙂 in Finland that wouldn't be possible but at my age if anything in English came up who knows. Getting a bit old to be on my feet 7 hours a day if I'm honest 😕
@ehombie10 күн бұрын
You are a top notch mechanic/diagnostisian. I think you have to have a long breath to get where you want to be on the "you tubes". i follow a number of diag people. PHAD, SMA, ... The content is great, also your presentation skills...(i will try to share this channel on dutch forums)
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
So nice of you to do that 🙂 Thank you so much.
@trevormansfield649510 күн бұрын
You’re right that it’s impossible to 100% diagnose faults every time. Not in the real world. I can’t understand why your channel isn’t bigger. I always enjoy your videos and often learn something 👍
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Thanks Trevor. I think building channels just takes a bit of luck and time 🙂 Glad you learn from it buddy as that is my aim.
@wrongmark10 күн бұрын
Onwards and upwards. Keep going.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Thanks buddy 🙂
@kitcht10 күн бұрын
Thanks
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Wow Anthony thanks alot 🙂 Appreciate that buddy.
@kitcht10 күн бұрын
Great video Ben. Just make the videos when you can as it's really informative. Shame it's not getting the traction you deserve. I've shared many of your videos with those friends still in the trade. All the best 👍
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
It will gain traction once I publish twice a week and do more shorts 🙂 My shorts do quite well usually. Thanks for the support mate.
@robertmobileman830410 күн бұрын
Another great informative video , i appreciate what you do , time is money ,but your giving your time and knowledge to the world , which is priceless, pat yourself on your back mate , cheers
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Thanks alot Robert. Lets hope I can fix it lol.
@johnkidd152910 күн бұрын
Haven’t seen a pump issue like that before mate. My money is on someone having been in the tank previously. The joys of intermittent faults! Just this week had a Ram module causing RF interference on the remote receiver, rdci wouldn’t calibrate…took me a while to find that one haha. All the best
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Thats a good fault find you did John 👍 You might well be correct 🙂 Lets see and I will update the blog next week with the outcome
@Pumaspeedracing10 күн бұрын
Enjoyed watching this
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Thats awesome 🙂
@domtdoodar9910 күн бұрын
Did you ever work out what caused it?
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Sadly no as it was bought by a trader who took it away in pieces but my money is on an improperly bled cooling system causing the eme to overheat.
@alexdragomirescu508410 күн бұрын
Beautiful garage 👍
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
Thanks Alex. We need to tidy up a bit - loads of huge jobs at the moment and not enough time to clean up :)
@julianpalmer467410 күн бұрын
Wahey first in 🤣
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding10 күн бұрын
No idea what that was fella. Some weird weight to help the gearstick go back to neutral I guess but it had ridden so high up it was causing issues. Nightmare, job is more like detective work each passing day.
@kriscowley324112 күн бұрын
Hello buddy. We’ve just bought an e90 n43 320i, on 96k. Full history. Very clean and looked after vehicle with every receipt from new. Owner had it serviced prior to handover. Not sure if he used cheap oil and filter. Need to look at receipt. Anyhow, we have a very intermittent oil pressure warning. Once turned off it resets itself. I’m gunna try this fix hope it works. Excellent video. Seems the penetrating fluid worked a treat with a careful patient use of correct tool. I’m quite mechanically minded being a panel/paint man and having been around cars my whole life. I need videos like this as a bit of confidence and guidance. Thanks brother. Would you advise us to use an OE part or a regular eBay job. Old saying, buy cheap buy twice. Edit, receipt for timing chain too 8000 miles ago.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding12 күн бұрын
Hi Kris. Glad the vid helped bud. Buy original but if you managed to watch part 2 of the video you will understand the issue is the sump powder coating. Thats a subframe down job though 😕
@kriscowley324112 күн бұрын
@@allmech_BMW_fault_finding yes mate. Just watched part 2. Question, after seeing the powder coating lifting, bubbling and rusting, in your humble opinion what do you think causes moisture in the sump? Let’s hope it’s just the valve when I take it out Saturday 🙏🙏🙏 I’ll replace with OE, the car deserves it.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding12 күн бұрын
@kriscowley3241 no idea bud but I just sanded most of it off and wiped a load of oil all over where the oil will never reach, if that makes sense
@bikesmart527916 күн бұрын
great video 👍🏻 just came across this at work , one question , the sprocket itself , where should i position it on the cam as i’ve only just found out ur supposed to mark it before removal ,
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding16 күн бұрын
There is no keyway so you should lock the camshafts in place with locking plates. Without those the valve timing will be off.
@KoiKicks16 күн бұрын
New sub here, really like your calm collected style to what is quite an annoying situation 😂. I've got a 2008 automatic 320i petrol with only 59k on the clock. You say its worth removing as part of routine but is it if there's no issue? I'm tempted but worry it would snap. Cheers
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding14 күн бұрын
Thanks for the sub! Just be careful removing it. If you find black debris you would be advised removing the sump as this is where the powder coating comes off that ends up in the control valve.
@alexdragomirescu508418 күн бұрын
Hi! Good explanation. The reason they are using the ground to control the various devices is due to ability to check the system. As you well stated, when the ground is not applied, you will have a 12v return from the motor (in this case). The control module can check for the "feedback" voltage and determine if there is a problem with the circuit or the motor. In this case it measured the voltage return from the motor and determined there's a problem so it triggered the fault - bad motor. Of course you could have a bad wire/bad connection/bad motor, the module doesn't know that, but at least you have a starting point. If it was 12v+ controlled the module couldn't recieve a feedback, because you can't check for ground return. I mean you can, but would always trigger a fault. The fact that you saw a pwm of low voltage on the ground side could mean a bias voltage sent by the module to pinpoint the problem (motor or connection). If there is no low pwm signal returning it means short circuit. It there is low pwm signal returning it means open circuit and the module can trigger the fault code accordingly. I'm used to this systems from industrial machinery. Of course the price of that systems is 10 times more expensive. It's amazing where the car diagnostic systems have arrived....and people are saying..."too much electronics...it was better before..." yeah right...try diagnosing a car with this much accessories without feedback systems on the modules! Keep them coming! Cheers
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding14 күн бұрын
Thanks for the explanation Alex 🙂
@alexdragomirescu508413 күн бұрын
@@allmech_BMW_fault_finding I'm pretty sure you already knew that, but thanks for the appreciation 😊
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding13 күн бұрын
@alexdragomirescu5084 Probably but I wouldn't have put the explanation as well as you did, Alex 🙂
@caerleon917618 күн бұрын
Oh, the blower fan on the E90's will cost you more in chiropractor's visits. A massive PITA to replace with a lot of swearing involved, if you have a wife that does Yoga get her to replace it!
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding14 күн бұрын
Lol. Been a few years but I remember them fondly 🙂
@trevormansfield649518 күн бұрын
An excellent instructional video 👍
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 күн бұрын
Thank you Trevor 🙂
@eunicenolascoVEVO18 күн бұрын
Where is your shop? Can I bring my car to you please 😬😬 Came across loads of channel in youtube and yours looks the best.
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 күн бұрын
In Vantaa, Finland 🙂 Thats really good to hear. Maybe we can do a video together where I can teach a few things, basic tips? Email me 🙂 I want to do different types of videos.
@julianpalmer467418 күн бұрын
Low side drivers are easier to make, insulate and more importantly control, you may only need 3.3V signal to turn a low side 12v driver on and off for instance! If you go looking for them you'll find way more low side (0V ground switching) than high side (supply switching). As for PWM duty cycles, as a kid you may have tried to turn your bedroom lights into a disc by turning them on and off quickly (not recommended) well if you turn them on for half a second and off for half a second (50% duty cycle) your bedroom would theoretically be at half brightness, or a motor would run at half speed. The main reason for not using dropper resistors other than the heat dissipation is the motor looses torque at lower speeds due to the lower voltage across its terminals. Switching a maximum voltage on and off quickly while the average measured voltage looks lower the torque is maintained, within limits. Good video, I think the first garage just didn't know what they were doing or didn't want the work. Make it sound expensive and you can either fleece someone or make tham go away! 🤙
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 күн бұрын
Really interesting explanation Julian and good to understand why they design things this way. Thanks mate 🙂
@jimjam193418 күн бұрын
Great job and a much easier fix than on the E53 X5. I had to do mine earlier this year and as you're no doubt aware, its a dashboard out job. Still it was the original from 2005 on a car with 250k miles👍
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 күн бұрын
Oh those... 😵💫 I remember them lol. The E53 is a brilliant wagon but that motor is a nightmare. Thanks for watching🙂
@wokxngel231218 күн бұрын
N20 problem ❓
@OttoJuhani2419 күн бұрын
When is my B48 engine block rebuild ready on the 2016 4-series :)
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 күн бұрын
Is it yours mate? 🙂 No idea buddy but the lad building it is very good and makes sure the job will be done right 👍
@wrongmark18 күн бұрын
Could it have not been coded to work properly as a retrofit?
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 күн бұрын
@wrongmark No as the heater box is totally different. I dare say some form of coding might have improved it somewhat but it was a High IHKA installed to a base IHK setup. Many of the LIN flap motors were simply not installed to the heater box.
@OttoJuhani2418 күн бұрын
@@allmech_BMW_fault_finding Yep. Glad to hear that :)
@craigwoollett252321 күн бұрын
outstanding mechanic
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 күн бұрын
Thanks alot buddy 🙂
@mattsbeamer21 күн бұрын
You are a genius mate. I wish I had even 1% of your knowledge!! Keep up the great work!!!
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding18 күн бұрын
Thanks alot Matt 🙂
@wrongmark21 күн бұрын
I have the N20 in the wife’s F31 and the N43 in my E90. Am I a glutton for punishment?
@allmech_BMW_fault_finding20 күн бұрын
Not really. Just look after it and change oil and filter every 6k