Why would the light not act like someone standing on the train? Why would the distance increase from mirror to mirror?
@AMC22833 күн бұрын
light is always moving at c
@rajitshrivastava176910 күн бұрын
I was searching this video. I watched this video 7 years ago... Thank you ❤... For creating this video
25 күн бұрын
I believe Einstein's Theory of Relativity is in big trouble. I am told by scientists that Einstein's theories and quantum mechanics cannot both be true because they decisively contradict each other. One of the two has to go. Scientists tell me that Einstein will be the one to give way, because the proof for quantum mechanics is overwhelming and there have always been problems with Einstein's theories. Unfortunately, no one wants to admit this because it would mean admitting that physics has wasted a century on the Einstein cult.
@arnedomiАй бұрын
I don't understand, but of course a 7 year old might cause they are so familiar with light clocks,the idea of testing the speed of light through an ether, and of course the claim that the light in the clock is not travelling at the same forward distance as Einstein in the space ship.😅
@VMTongaАй бұрын
So that's what is taking Jesus so long to come back. He is the light 😊
@icantthinkofaname158Ай бұрын
bro einstein cooked witht his one 🔥
@tomislavukraden4151Ай бұрын
"Everything is relative my dear Albert." (That's what Mileva Einstein used to say to her husband.)
@DirtyThing20Ай бұрын
S=c???? What the hell are you talking about.
@funshots3167Ай бұрын
What if we remove that light clock from the rocket , will condition be same like before?
@helenj4132 ай бұрын
I'm probably too stupid to understand this, but I don't get why it is assumed that the observer inside the spaceship will not notice that it takes more time for the light beam to travel from one mirror to another and therefore he won't notice any dilation. If the light spends more energy travelling forward together with the spaceship, then it moves slower up and down. Why would the person inside not notice this? Then, what if we put the clock horizontally? It will take forever for the light to travel from one mirror to another towards the direction in which the spaceship flies, as the spaceship flies with the speed, close to the speed of light, and it will return back in literally no time. Will the observer inside not notice this too? It's something my brain can't comprehend
@AMC2283Ай бұрын
The observer on the ship and the clock are stationary relative to each other
@jtuds2 ай бұрын
The problem with this explanation is that it doesn’t explain all the concepts. Like saying that time moves and different rates depending on how fast you’re going is all well and good, but explain how and why. Is there no explanation of how that is the case? For most people, if you say “a day travelling close to the speed of light could be 50 years for someone on earth”, they’re going ask “how is that the case?”. This is what needs to be explained, the actual mechanics of why these things happen.
@yonekawa20242 ай бұрын
I proved the mistakes of the theory of relativity by two contradictions. I'd be happy if you could watch the video I made until the end.
@muzzasmsmadness10812 ай бұрын
In the beginning there was light
@boogiewoogie20102 ай бұрын
Where is the proof for this time difference ? This is just a theory.
@richie43512 ай бұрын
Thanks mate now I have a rough idea about what he discovered. Thanks so much
@goldstandardaviation16672 ай бұрын
It is written
@vincenthoogakker25502 ай бұрын
Only now i understand it👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼 ..You make the picture white the fly ship and clock Big eneuf to see it thanks
@Nadir-wm5dw2 ай бұрын
Agree
@SampleroftheMultiverse2 ай бұрын
“U” Shape Waves This model may be related to the your topic. kzbin.info/www/bejne/raOlpKSfepWpfZYsi=waT8lY2iX-wJdjO3 Thanks for your informative and well produced video. You and your viewers might find the quantum-like analog interesting and useful. I have been trying to describe the “U” shape wave that is produced in my amateur science mechanical model in the video link. I hear if you over-lap all the waves together using Fournier Transforms, it may make a “U” shape or square wave. Can this be correct representation Feynman Path Integrals? In the model, “U” shape waves are produced as the loading increases and just before the wave-like function shifts to the next higher energy level. Your viewers might be interested in seeing the load verse deflection graph in white paper found elsewhere on my KZbin channel. Actually replicating it with a sheet of clear folder plastic and tape. Seeing it first hand is worth the effort.
@Yotrek2 ай бұрын
2:45 roll up the window on the rocket. It’s hard to hear you.
@michaelbariso31922 ай бұрын
Anyone using GPS astronomy software, a computerized GoTo telescope or equatorial mount can disprove Einstein's General, Special relativity and big bang in less than 30 seconds by simply dialing in the coordinates. If stars, planets and galaxies were in different dimensions of space-time they couldn't possibly be tracked. The fabric of space-time does not exist, except in the mind of Einstein's disciples. Time cannot slow for multiple moving clock observers as Einstein suggests, unless you're Marty McFly in the movie Back To The Future. Why pay for electricity when Einstein tells us we can see yesterday's light today, just remember to wear a sleeping mask if the light from Earths past is keeping you up at night. Einstein's projectile particle photons do not have the capability to record, reassemble and transport past image events into the future like a movie projector or TV. According to Einstein's space-time the sun, planets and galaxies are still below the Earth's s horizon, even though they can be clearly seen in the night sky. Einstein's disciples never seem to get the joke. Our eyes only retain light and images for 15 ms, if the light and images from galaxies are ( no longer there billions of years in Earths past ) the skys would be dark.. Images of light cannot travel for billions of years without an energy source. When you don't pay your electric bill, the lights go out Rainman. If the speed of light is finite (limited) to 186,000 mi./s explain how light and it's images could ever reach its destination when galaxies, stars and planets are always moving from their coordinates. Unless light has automatic tracking this could not be possible, this is like throwing a ball at a moving target. Only if light and time were instantaneous could this be possible. If there were any delays in gravity traveling at light speed the perfect balance of orbital mechanics in our solar system wouldn't be possible. Our eyes only retain still images for 15 ms if there were any delays there would be missing frames-images-bits of time. Explain how stars planets an galaxies can be gravitationally bound having delays in gravity. Time is not variable, physical matter does not magically move, disappear, change coordinates or be in multiple places simultaneously. According to Einstein space-time, cosmological objects viewed by telescope observers in the night sky won't be in view for another 12 hours. So cosmological objects viewed by telescope observers in the night sky are really still below the Earth where it's still daylight? That means the light and images in our telescopes are penetrating right through the bottom of the Earth and out to the other side, maybe that why the images are so dark :-). If a cosmological object was 1 billion years old when it's light left and traveled for 2 billion years the object would be 3 billion years old, that’s 2 billion years before it existed. You can lead a cult to water but you can't make them think. The power of suggestion can make people believe anything, even that stars, galaxies and people can be in multiple places at the same time :-) Visible light and radio waves are part of the same electromagnetic spectrum. Einstein's disciples believe a galaxies light is billions of light-years in Earth's past (no longer there) then hope to contact aliens from space using radio communications aka doublethink 🙂.If Einstein's space-time were true we'd be blinded by the light from Earth's past, yesterday's light would still be on our, TV's, PC's cell phones and lamps. Einstein knew the light from Earths past would keep him up at night so he always made sure to wear a sleeping mask :-). Explain why (only) light and images from galaxies billions of years in Earths past time travel into our future but not the gravity, electromagnetic forces and galaxies that also reside in the same space-time. Ghosts are believed to appear as images of light from Earths past as well 🙂. Sorry folks Einstein’s ghosts from galaxies past cannot travel anywhere because the past no longer exists. The images taken with the James Webb space telescope are in real time. Space Cat, cult intervention specialist.
@ethannickerson19012 ай бұрын
I'm no physicist, but shouldn't the light particle on the spaceship be traveling WITH the space ship, not perpendicular to it? For example, If Einstein is in the spaceship and turns on a flashlight pointing toward the front of the ship. That would mean the light is traveling the speed of light + the speed of light, which is impossible because the speed of light is constant. Right?
@AMC22832 ай бұрын
it's not traveling with the ship, only the light source is. c is constant, you don't add or subtract velocity to it. it's not in the ship's inertial frame, it's not at rest relative to anything.
@_vlpin2 ай бұрын
Disliked because the video title was auto translated into my language, tricking me into clicking on it. Shame on you and youtube as well!
@naer35133 ай бұрын
OK so there are 2 theories of relativity written by Einstein: 1. (SPECIAL) theory of relativity Not to be confused with 2. (GENERAL) theory of relativity Both theories are aiming to explain the time. - In his 1st (SPECIAL) theory of relativity (that is this video) Einstein experiment with the LIGHT trying to prove how SPEED slow down time. He feels this theory is incomplete so he write the 2nd theory! - In his 2nd (GENERAL) theory of relativity (which is much easier to understand), Einsten figure out that Matter - (massive space objects PLANETS) can bend space (means space can be streched and squized like a chewing gum) also that space and time are one and same (fabric) space-time. This theory even further explain how smaller planets are orbiting around bigger planets. - kzbin.info/www/bejne/qqu0dGarjrFpbbcfeature=shared **General theory of relativity** - kzbin.info/www/bejne/g4W8Yn6gmpWsgsk **Matter bend space - SUPER EASY - to understand**
@gautamsonawane83133 ай бұрын
Oh that Einstein guy was smart though.
@sametsahin103 ай бұрын
Why does the light have to travel an extra distance in the spaceship? 3:05
@AMC22832 ай бұрын
the mirror is in motion relative to the stationary observer
@theconspiracydentist3 ай бұрын
BUT, according to Einstein's own theory of relativity, Einstein can say that he's standing still in his ship and the clock on Earth is the one that's moving near the speed of light, so the observer on Earth would be the one who's time is slowing down, not Einstein in the spaceship. It can't work both ways. Conclusion: This is a bunch of BullShit.
@AMC22832 ай бұрын
non inertial frames aren't equal, only one is accelerated
@theconspiracydentist2 ай бұрын
@@AMC2283 so does the time dilation only occur DURING acceleration? Or does it continue after acceleration is complete?
@AMC22832 ай бұрын
@@theconspiracydentist the clock on the ship continues to tick slower than the one it had been synched to on earth as long as its inertial mass is warping space time to such a degree, ie while coasting
@theconspiracydentist2 ай бұрын
@@AMC2283 theoretically
@AMC22832 ай бұрын
@@theconspiracydentist it’s exhaustively verified
@nuraulia49933 ай бұрын
Bahasa Indonesia nya gak ada yaaa
@beegyoshi84013 ай бұрын
Wut
@AnteBrkic3 ай бұрын
So if i throw an apple in a moving train and you observe tgis from outside, you will see an apple travelling greater distance therefore time dilation? Makes no sense to me.
@AMC22833 ай бұрын
can't demonstrate with apple, it can have different speeds. light can't, therefore time dilation.
@AnteBrkic3 ай бұрын
@@AMC2283 doesn't light hve different speeds when travelling through different mediums? Glass, air, water...
@silverrahul2 ай бұрын
@@AnteBrkic light has same speed in a given medium
@savedbygodsgrace16223 ай бұрын
Gravity doesn’t exist. It’s voodoo science used to make you feel stupid because you don’t understand it. If you understand buoyancy and density, you’re smarter than government actor Albert Einstein.
@AMC22833 ай бұрын
oh--relativity is just against your religion judging by your screen name
@brianrains743 ай бұрын
If i swing my arm real fast, both me and the observer will not see it because it is quicker than the eye. In marvel movies to state flash is also able to see himself traveling at those speeds would indicate his eyes are also that fast. It also would make sense because i assume his whole body got struck by lightning. Not that time slows down or faster for him. However, to say time slows down for him, having normal functioning eyes, contradicts the normal naked eye concept. Especially for the normal observer. And to claim here, Einstein is still calculating by observers, not time itself. No different than calculating universal rime by a world time clock such as time zones. The reading will be inaccurate.
@AMC22833 ай бұрын
i'm afraid comic books aren't a valid counter to relativity.
@brianrains743 ай бұрын
@@AMC2283 Haha. Which is the point. Neither is Einstein's theory. Science is not based upon an observer, (frame of reference),with assumptions and opinions.. If that is the case then everything I witness will be true. Like me seeing that flying marshmallow bat over that marshmallow Bigfoot. Am I observing reality or observing what my brain is seeing? I cannot go with my perception if I want the truth. Most people do though, like yourself 😝. Time is what time will be, not what we observe. Same as Truth. How do we know if it is reality and not something I am imagining. Hope that truth and reality tell you. Until then, just like here, by empirical and tangible experimentations over and over by verifications from different observers, not one. But Einstein only went with how he saw things, even though he used different observers for the train. Einstein, and a few others always claim they don't go with their perception but they wind up doing so. Is why theories are always open to be challenged and argued. They have no concrete truth. Just a close truth with some evidence that may point towards the theory.
@PJWilsonr113 ай бұрын
With the light clock experiment - as the spacecraft travels why is it not the distance that the light traveled between the mirrors, rather than the time?
@AMC22833 ай бұрын
it is the distance---it travels different distances based on who observes, but at the same speed for both
@surtax5323 ай бұрын
Well well. But do you think shorting the time won't change our actual age and we would die lately? I mean will we live more longer??!!
@AMC22833 ай бұрын
metabolism doesn't change, time is relative
@surtax5323 ай бұрын
@@AMC2283 thank yo
@benjaminchen57153 ай бұрын
Well explained. Even a lay person like me can understand.
@octavianr5264 ай бұрын
Why does c must be constant? But regardless of this, if we would have a tennis ball in a cylinder in that train, bouncing up-down, a ground observer could also say the ball is traveling a distance bigger than d, which is false for the observes in the train, but true from that on the ground. It simply depends on the reference, and from the ground saying the ball is traveling more than d is simply stupid. Therefore, I simply don't understand this, despite a bunch of videos and university (bad) classes about it
@AMC22833 ай бұрын
a tennis ball doesn't have to travel at constant speed, light does
@dongskijyu85834 ай бұрын
Of all the videos i watched abt this topic, this is the easiest to understand. Thanks to the simple expkanation and visuals 👏👏👏
@kshamakamath47554 ай бұрын
umm
@VladislavLudan4 ай бұрын
“More of that later…” now 9 years is gone on earth 🧐 maybe that man have some c-speed vehicle
@TheHecticGlow.Okay.2 ай бұрын
check the description, he's beyond the limits of space and time now
@babaybluerocks4 ай бұрын
Thank you! My brain was struggling with this but the visual helped so much!
@michaelbartlett68644 ай бұрын
Consider the concept of time. The past, the present and the future do not all exist together and there is no retro-causality! The past is recorded and the present is evolving into both the recorded past and an unwritten future - atto-second by atto-second! Newton's cosmic clock continues to tick! The thing we call the present does not exist, it is merely an imaginary line used to delineate the past from the future. The present isn't even a planck-length of time! Einstein was, and is wrong, and he knew it! Space is a thing and Time is a thing, but Space-Time is NOT a thing. Dark energy and matter are NOT things. Infinity is NOT a thing and Zero is NOT a thing! Free will and consciousness are things, and they are fundamental! Gravity is also fundamental and is NOT what is referred to as the weak force. Gravity is the Ether of the universe and it is the wellspring of all other forces! Without gravity NOTHING else would even exist. The "Big Bang" never happened and the universe is NOT expanding, but conversely, everything in the observable universe is SHRINKING proportionally at the same time, atto-second by atto-second, returning all the eluded-to matter to the void of the vacuum of energy fluctuations! This is the source of the red shift, not tired photons! Eventually ALL stars and galaxies, and yes, black holes too will evaporate and will wink out of existence for us! The shrinking can be compared to the constantly decreasing volume of a tuning fork that has been struck, or the ringing-down of the signal level in a an LC (inductive/capacitive) electronic, tuned-tank resonant circuit, with the input removed and monitored over a number of time constants. Watch this 17 minute video from Dialect, "Why the theory of relativity doesn't add up" (In Einstein's own words) - It's on KZbin
@jeffreymillway22584 ай бұрын
..
@Lee-wj9lw5 ай бұрын
I can finally stop bashing my head against the wall. Thank you so much for the clear explanation. Now I get it.
@tommyfree56775 ай бұрын
Is it possible to slow the flow of time in stationary?
@Abhishek_bhoi_2225 ай бұрын
Rip vinit💐
@Abhishek_bhoi_2225 ай бұрын
Wow...thanks alot
@malemd5 ай бұрын
Poorly explained..
@marijanmedunic42995 ай бұрын
What I don't understand is: Why the light in the spaceship has to trevel longer path, my opinion is that path is always same, it just looks like it is longer
@silverrahul5 ай бұрын
It does not just look like it's longer. It IS longer
@harimaghaharichannel27715 ай бұрын
Wrong... The only deference is the distance he can go not time vs time. but fast moving cant curve time it only takes you farther than the one who is slower than you. 😅