Пікірлер
@nonexistentfuture519
@nonexistentfuture519 Ай бұрын
The world is cruel but it is also beautiful.
@MoyenAlam_S
@MoyenAlam_S 2 ай бұрын
you have only 54 subscribers but how you explained the movie is so good
@miruajin6448
@miruajin6448 3 ай бұрын
Oh maybe this film is supposed to be watched by the artists relatives as they would know something the general audience dont
@jaydee4588
@jaydee4588 3 ай бұрын
Sarah killed Alice, Sarah killed mia....sarah killed the ex husband his body was in the extra bed in the room at the end of the movie when he went to the house mia was already dead she imagined finding mia...she killed mia. At the end she imagines the ghost of alice walking the the ghost of mia
@logic7753
@logic7753 5 ай бұрын
Was the dead guy the ex husband?
@soteroElias-v4d
@soteroElias-v4d 6 ай бұрын
Me:😮also me:😮😅
@goginga2852
@goginga2852 9 ай бұрын
Incredibly well said brother. Keep doing reviews, you have real potential with content creation
@kevadii
@kevadii 9 ай бұрын
Mullholand Drive and Bladerunner are two of my favorite movies and this might be up there for me now too after having just seen it. It also reminded me a lot of Andrew Tarkovsky’s Stalker (1970). Love the video, keep up the great work
@ifLifeWereAnAnime
@ifLifeWereAnAnime 9 ай бұрын
interesting nice vid
@13mgreg
@13mgreg 9 ай бұрын
These movies are for children. miyazaki does not create for anyone else. Loosely this follows the book boy and the blue heron. Its supposed to help children understand emotions.
@AbdullahMikalRodriguez
@AbdullahMikalRodriguez 7 ай бұрын
I don't think I've ever seen a dumber comment on KZbin
@SourSnail70
@SourSnail70 9 ай бұрын
i think the stone being destroyed by the parakeet was representing the loss of detail animation (in reference to anime because of Miyazaki's view on it lol)
@BinaryDood
@BinaryDood 8 ай бұрын
I think it was about someone being borne and molded completely by a structure of meaning cannot simply rebuild it hastly to keep it from falling. The world is different and requires different views (a new generation) in order to restructure meaning. Without that, older fantasies rely on cardiac arrest and enforce rather than inspire the new agents of the world (children) and are doomed to crumble.
@gabrielchasecanceladosinap3959
@gabrielchasecanceladosinap3959 8 ай бұрын
Well... I can see that. Miyazaki technically is one of the forefathers of anime as we know it. And he had seen how basically the industry he helped creating is self imploding. And so he has a reason of to feel resented with the world he created. But none the less, he cares for it. Enought to choose someone else to leade his world into a New and better direction, instead of choosing someone like the Parrot King.
@BinaryDood
@BinaryDood 8 ай бұрын
@@gabrielchasecanceladosinap3959 precisely!
@gabrielchasecanceladosinap3959
@gabrielchasecanceladosinap3959 8 ай бұрын
@@BinaryDood and someone like the Parrot King could represent people like Toei, or Mappa or many other modern studios and corporations that apreciate animation more as a bussiness than an art form. That or they don't simply apreciate animation.
@BinaryDood
@BinaryDood 8 ай бұрын
@@gabrielchasecanceladosinap3959 I think the Parrot King, regardless what it directly targets to represent, stands for someone born already inside the system, thus was molded by its functions. Especially those who seek power: they will treat the system as a game to be played, rigged and outrigged. That's why a bad king tends to follow a good one. The bad king merely follows the trail unknowingly why it was made such and so in the first place. One such individual, made and defined by the stern rules of society as they are but not as what they ought to be, can't build anything that will last in a world where the only constant is change.
@alexedi
@alexedi 10 ай бұрын
great analysis! you verbalized most of my thoughts about this ridiculously beautiful film. if this is the end, it`s a fitting end to a towering career. an oscar nomination (at least - if not a win) is mandatory. not that this matters to miyazaki, he`s above awards. but the film SHOULD win the oscar, because nothing in this year in animation even comes close.. anyway, good luck with your channel from a new subscriber across the pond! :)
@rubenlaurentiu90
@rubenlaurentiu90 10 ай бұрын
It is not a supernatural movie, but a psychological drama about guilt
@prajnadeva
@prajnadeva 10 ай бұрын
Nice catch on the stone. The thing I still don't get is the birthing room metaphor. What does it symbolizes, why is it taboo to enter, and what happened during that scene. We know it is when Mahito accepted Natsuko as new mother, but what prompted that?
@turtle-reviews
@turtle-reviews 10 ай бұрын
Interesting question. I don’t have a specific answer right now but I will note that wouldn’t it have been interesting if Natsuko had her child in the spirit world? Her child would have been born outside of the temporal world and could have chosen to live in any time line he wanted to by going through a specific door. So much of this film is left up to the audience’s interpretation and I think if we were to read solely into the themes at play in that scene we could say that creation is a sacred process which should not be disrupted by human will. We know that the power stone has a will of its own and could have been responsible for bringing Natsuko into the birthing room in the first place. Perhaps the stone was securing its future by recruiting Natsuko’s child as its new ward? In that line of thinking it’s also interesting that Mahito is almost smothered by the paper in that scene. Perhaps the stone would rather have Natsuko’s child, someone birthed away from the corrupted reality of the real world, inherit the great grand uncle’s power while the great grand uncle would rather have Mahito. Who we know is symbolically the same character who carries malice and imperfections with him.
@prajnadeva
@prajnadeva 10 ай бұрын
@@turtle-reviews yes, any scene should have double or triple meaning. 1. Internal lore of the movie. 2. Miyazaki life. 3. Symbolism audience could take independent of Miyazaki. You just describe (1). Now what I thought about Miyazaki life symbolism is this: his son Gorou was warned by Miyazaki's wife/ Gorou's mother not to enter animation industry. He became architect instead. When He enter Ghibli as director for Earthsea, Miyazaki opposed it. He disliked Earthsea movie. But later he give Up on Poppy Hill screenplay to Gorou, and he did better job on that one.
@patrickrusso877
@patrickrusso877 10 ай бұрын
Another Turtlereviews banger!! Well put analysis of a beauitful lu poetic film. I really enjoyed your take on reflection and it’s presence in the film.
@nettewilson5926
@nettewilson5926 Жыл бұрын
There’s no wondering here. I think this interpretation was off. Mia was NOT possessed: Sarah was. Sarah projected all her guilt onto Mia. Sarah drew those pictures, and started hitting and hurting Mia. She’s a sociopath who tormented and then murdered her sister out of jealousy. She goes full psycho and kills Mia and tosses her body over the cliff and then she has to kill her husband who comes looking. She hallucinates that they find Mia, but there is absolutely no way Pete would have spent the night after finding his wife and Mia like that: he never made it out of the house: she bludgeoned him with the weapon she bludgeoned her sister with: that’s why his head is covered when you glimpse his body on the bed.
@witchy_rabbit
@witchy_rabbit Жыл бұрын
Oh thank goodness someone got it! This a great explanation that nailed the whole meaning of the film. Unfortunately, It flew over so many heads 😢
@aaronfox3613
@aaronfox3613 Жыл бұрын
Turtle Reviews made me understand the meaning of life (it’s not just 42)
@jennahorrall-uw6po
@jennahorrall-uw6po Жыл бұрын
you slayed this analysis
@aaronfox3613
@aaronfox3613 Жыл бұрын
Top notch analytics frfr
@andrewlee7909
@andrewlee7909 Жыл бұрын
Another turtle reviews masterclass, your voice is smooth like butta
@brennonlewis
@brennonlewis Жыл бұрын
Avatar gets a lot of crap and I'll admit the "going native" plot has been done to death and it has a few plot holes. Still the visuals, the actors performances, the lovable characters, and the adventure the movie takes you on is why it's still so high on my list of favorite movies.
@jennahorrall-uw6po
@jennahorrall-uw6po Жыл бұрын
nice video!
@andreafraustoz
@andreafraustoz Жыл бұрын
Avatar 3 will pull a pro-gamer move that Avengers 5 or 6 can't pull off
@CATDHD
@CATDHD Жыл бұрын
What do you mean?
@JETZcorp
@JETZcorp Жыл бұрын
Titanic is in the theaters again for the 25th anniversary, in 4K and 3D. It's spectacular and everyone should see it. I thought it'd be kind of a sweet thing to take my wife for Valentine's because we always liked the movie, but I was blown away by the difference the theater made. I grew up with the movie on that double-VHS big brick set, and was too young to see it when it debuted. James Cameron blew me away with both the Avatar movies, and did it again (weirdly) with Titanic. I love this man's work.
@turtle-reviews
@turtle-reviews Жыл бұрын
That double brick vhs set is iconic!
@jackconsidine2681
@jackconsidine2681 Жыл бұрын
Great vid man. Where do you get your film footage from?
@AlexGarcia-ze4yg
@AlexGarcia-ze4yg Жыл бұрын
How would you like to have worked on Avatar for at least one day?
@anttiharju
@anttiharju Жыл бұрын
Also there's a typo in the title? Thrown -> Throne
@vrknprgrz
@vrknprgrz Жыл бұрын
bro mixed throne+crown
@turtle-reviews
@turtle-reviews Жыл бұрын
😮 thanks for the catch y’all. First time jitters
@aaronfox3613
@aaronfox3613 Жыл бұрын
Love you Antti
@anttiharju
@anttiharju Жыл бұрын
​@@aaronfox3613 it's not often that people say they love me for pointing out a typo 😂
@anttiharju
@anttiharju Жыл бұрын
Cool video! I really liked the spider man climbing b-roll haha