What surprised me was when I realized when I read from right to left, the T-AM-IL sounds as IL-AM-T or ELAMITE in English. The middle easterners read/write from right to left anyway. That alone is a solid proof to start with that there clearly was a connection between modern day Tamil and the ancient Elamites. Also there is a continuity even now, the Tamils in Sri Lanka are called Elam Tamils, at the tip of TamilNadu.

Nice efforts

33:00

Laughing stock 😂

Listen to the ancient Indians - no.menrion of a migration from anywhere. These people wrote the Vedas. Again, no mention of what must have been a multi-generational and mammoth trek. Not a word.

Who were the homosepients found in South India when the first wave of human movement moved from Africa to South India?

Sir, You have talked about the Harappa Civilization and migration of the Indo European Language speakers.. You mentioned nothing about the Indians of the South.India. Were they not civilized then whereby you said nothing about them.?

I would encourage everyone who comes here to listen to the podcast, plz go through the research papers published in Nature and the cell. The findings and conclusions are based on solid genetic research and it’s fantastic…I took time to read the research papers ( gets quite technical). Reading the book now. The author has collated all the findings and gifts us a very delicious book… a happy reading 😊. Plz don’t listen to the crap of Abhijit Chabra and his likes. This is real Science ❤❤

Men walked not women with their children.

People had to walk everywhere.

This pillai at such a young age coming with solid information makes me thinks that he is the future elite historian of India.

In Europe, Middle East, China etc. there were pre-existing archaic species that interbred to a small extent with incoming modern humans. In India at 70,000 to 60,000 years ago there was the Mount Toba eruption (Google it) which wiped out the entire human population in the Indian subcontinent, which then had to be repopulated from the Middle East. Therefore combination with archaic populations in India does not survive if it took place, and any interbreeding with archaic populations in Indians took place in the Middle East before those populations moved into India.

The caste system which seems to have been introduced isn't a race/ethnic based system of social discrimination like western colonialism or the western concept of slavery, but seems to be a job based immigration restriction policy like the US, Australian, and Western European immigration policy today thst has outlived its usefulness. It is not race based, it is based on the jobs you are allowed to take up. I wonder if the reason for the introduction of caste system took place at a time when there was very large uncontrolled immigration into India from outside, and caste was introduced to to prevent social instability from uncontrolled immigration.

Agree; can the owners of this content remove the background music? Seems a fascinating book and conversation otherwise; thanks for sharing 😊

Incredible, Parth, to find you here. The little kid from class IX to see you grow into a fine young man. So proud of you. And yes, you haven't changed one bit

Looks like Politician and missionary funded book.

2 heroes of tamil ❤

I think it someone finds it difficult to write a novel first start with writing short stories and don't publish it then expand a short story into a large story and theme, practice is what is important.

Amitabha bagchi is my DAD!!!!!!!!

Parvathi ji, have you read the Tuzuk I Jahangiri in the original Persian language? Thanks.

Congratulations for writing a new book on Jahangir, the Mughal emperor of India.

AWWWWWW BEST COUPLE EVER

warrior like pastoral from west asia. They must have killed the native population then. But the proof does not exist instead out of India migrations or out of India invasions which are proved by scientific facts and data cannot be believed. What hippocrats these people are. Go read the latest papers and see what grave injustice you did with the truth. Shame on you.

This book is scientifically flawed... it's crap

I have this book

@ c mould etc locked mid 20 dw new

Tony Joseph did great work

love love LOVEEEEEE this book so much

Absolutely love this book ❤️

A Century is not enough thats why he went to spain to make triple century.... He is self centered...

srikaant talageri >>

I have gone through the book for 2nd time it has changed my Outlook and being a scientific minded I crave the hope to translate the book into Assamese, but I don't know the web address, to take permission from the respected author. Will anybody kindly help ?

Proud of him and you also ma'am...

Again very superficial analysis. No concrete evidence neither from archeological or linguistic side. All speculations.

What if mixing of so called early Indians and Aryans happened after a bunch of Aryas were sent out. Same with the other people that were supposed to have moved in.

destroying whatsapp university

Bogus interview

*Her Son

How can I speak with her? Diksha dwivedi

Tony Joseph should enlighten us about srinivas tallagari claims that speakers of indo European migrated from South Asia

turned out to be an L, had high hopes (unfortunate turn out)

Read this book and I can't be more thankful to my life and Tahira herself for giving me an opportunity to read such an amazing book.. ✨💗❤️❤️❤️

The distinguished panel discusses the origins of the Aryan Invasion Theory, its propagation, and how it has been totally discredited. Aravindan Neelakandan gives the insights into the Biblical racist narrative that was used by the Church through the linguists to supplant the original linguist fascination for Sanskrit and the Out of India Theory. kzbin.info/www/bejne/aoeolayGrdCHac0

Oh no... This is the fact based scholarly work: Indian Civilisation: The Untold Story - Revisited | Raj Vedam | Aryan Invasion/Migration Theory ::kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z5PWqpxqr757hpI

Good novel writer 👌.

I am amused, not to mention bemused, by Tharoor's constant refrain of let's be proud of this or that element from our past. Nothing against Tharoor, he's probably addressing some imaginary audience of Indians who feel this way, but it's a very needy way of thinking and betrays one's insecurity. Is it because we have so little to be proud of in the present and the future that we are desperately seeking sources of self-esteem in the distant past? Tony's approach is more emotionally neutral, as it should be since the pre-history as he lays it out is not all that impressive in today's terms. All we can say is the occupiers of the piece of real estate we now call India survived in some form and so here we are. Is that something to be proud of? Too low of a bar in my opinion since it is just the necessary condition for us being here. Of all the Bronze Age civilizations, Mesopotamia gets bragging rights for being the earliest, while Ancient Egypt is the most iconic in terms of its modern day cultural impact. The Harappans are interesting academically, but it's hard for the common man to get fired up about good drainage. This leads us to the strange situation we are in today - a widespread tendency to identify with post-Harappan Vedic culture and the fantastic worlds of the itihasas and puranas but an inability to reconcile all that with a Central Asia steppe precursor. We have found the aliens and they are us.

Love you reading ur book now ❤

Loved it!!😍🤗👍

Yes you really calm me down ❤

Just love her ❤ grabbed 3 of her books from the store today soooo excited now to have them - in my 40’s like her too I think she is going to be my mentor for the rest of my life😅😂