As a director of a private school I can tell you we provided quality education for much less than 10,000 per student.
@KRoc28 күн бұрын
I'm from Louisiana. Texas outperforms us in most industries and Louisiana has much higher crime rates. Given that we spend so much more on education (per student), I don't think you're making a good argument on education spending. More money doesn't equal better education.
@cajonesalt019129 күн бұрын
If you think anyone in this state actually cares about education, I think you're hopeful in a way I only wish I could be. You can just read the comments here. These people only care about their own money.
@Dog.soldier1950Ай бұрын
Over 90 recent of schools funds goes for personnel costs, mostly teacher pay
@aa-hj2fdАй бұрын
Just stop. Where do think all this extra money is going to come from? How about we take away the six figure incomes of the administrators; rely more on donations for stadiums; stop remodeling schools every four years, etc.
@stevekrag1610Ай бұрын
Prices what you pay, value is what you get. What are Texas' student outcomes (proficiencies at grade levels, graduation rates, etc...) compared to other states you compared? Are Texes' better, worse, the same? That answer is where your answer lies. Who knows, maybe Texas is getting better outcomes at a 25% discount?
@faithnfire4769Ай бұрын
As someone who just finished college with a heck of a lot of out of state folks, it's bad. We graduate students at the high end with significantly less college prep courses, with worse grades from mid level schools, and have fairly bad rates of graduation at the struggling ones. We're chronically short on teachers, have an out of date robin hood system, and have a nasty split of haves and have nots.
@cajonesalt019129 күн бұрын
Texas has one of the worst education systems in the nation and the only reason the colleges are any good is because the old boy system pumps billions into them because of the football programs.
@michaelspangle47282 ай бұрын
Wealth stripping funds schools.
@michaelspangle47282 ай бұрын
@Real estate mindset
@MakerDent2 ай бұрын
We should compare outside the US as well. I think the US needs to recognize that our school system is largely a day care program. Other countries teach more with less time. If we accepted 12-20 hours of classroom learning a week, how would we structure schools and our budgets differently? We also need to realize that high school should be preparing for a career. That might mean less time in the classroom. Apprenticeship and co-op programs should be the main focus. If an individual wants to focus on academics/college prep, then they should be in a program that gets them credits.
@manofmartin3 күн бұрын
The colleges that are destroying young people's lives will hate this message. I love it!
@briansmith63062 ай бұрын
Yeah……..well, spending $12,000 per child doesn’t mean the kids are going to be smart. It just means the taxpayers are getting screwed. Paying an elementary school gym teacher in NY $115,000 a year and yet child obesity is a major problem! Throwing money at a perceived problem won’t solve it…..it just makes you poorer!
@yetekt69532 ай бұрын
School PE doesn’t impact childhood obesity.
@XD9scCC2 ай бұрын
Wouldn't it be better to get rid of the inefficiencies of the public school system before asking for more funding? How many of the United State's school funding amounts are less than Texas but more productive? I think school choice and homeschooling produce, dollar for dollar, better results than public schools.
@91thewatcher232 ай бұрын
Public schools provide WAY more than private schools do, and takes our money further. Their mandate to educate EVERYONE, no matter location or background, both produces market inefficiencies by doing things that for-profit businesses wouldn't make a profit on, and also reaps efficiencies that those same for-profit businesses wouldn't by larger economies of scale and centralized planning. Also, private schools produce equal or worse outcomes in terms of test scores and student achievement post-graduation than most public schools, not that private schools are less funded, but that they do less with more than public schools due to standards that public schools have to achieve. There are pros and cons to either, but it is not fair to rural citizens to have their dollars go to a voucher system that their children will never use because there is not a business incentive to create a private school out in the middle of nowhere. My sister, mother, and great grandfather are/were all teachers here in Texas and I hate this voucher program being shoved down our throats. I'm a Christian, and providing equal access to good public schooling to anyone willing to attend and being a part of that process with everyone of all backgrounds is core to our faith. I am really discouraged by the choices of my fellow brethren, citizens, and our state authorities in pursuing this detrimental voucher program that will only benefit owners of private schools.
@XD9scCC2 ай бұрын
@@91thewatcher23 Perhaps on some level. But what are public schools providing other than basic education? There's no shortage of public schools - Baltimore, Chicago, NY, etc. where kids are graduating without being able to read or do basic math. And that's after a tremendous amount of money was spent per student. I still don't think more money is the answer.
@Backburner1118Ай бұрын
@@XD9scCCcheck yourself, those respective states have some of the best public education compared to Texas and other southern states.
@XD9scCCАй бұрын
@@Backburner1118 Maybe. But that's little consolation for the kids in the Chicago, Baltimore, and NY public school systems.
@Backburner1118Ай бұрын
@@XD9scCCidk man, the worst school districts seem to be rural. I don’t see why you’re trying to imply cities are worse overall.
@rl85716 ай бұрын
Oh please.. California paid out $18k per retiree while Texas paid out $28k per retiree. Facts hurt. Texas TRS is greater than CalTRS. Texas takes care of their teachers and if the students are failing then the quality of Teachers need to be reviewed because both states are already spending more than any country combined. Maybe both states can import teachers from India who produce the most CEOs for fortune 500 companies.
@PatrickBlackard24 күн бұрын
Teacher retirement in Texas averages $43,000 per year. In California it's $50,000 per year.
@aliblake36176 ай бұрын
I’m a a new mom. I’d love to talk about how Texas public schools do not offer maturity leave or accommodate pumping moms within the work place.
@jbw531917 ай бұрын
And in Texas, a huge amount goes toward football programs. My high school had 550 students and 22 football coaches.
@WildBill99x7 ай бұрын
What we need is to get the government out of the education business.
@kelleysmith73457 ай бұрын
That is wrong.
@WildBill99x7 ай бұрын
@@kelleysmith7345 Please, tell us why. How is education better under socialism than it would be under freedom and free enterprise?
@kelleysmith73457 ай бұрын
@@WildBill99x It’s not my responsibility to educate you. The founders knew what education could do and everyone deserves a good education - that can’t be done in unaccountable private institutions.
@kelleysmith73457 ай бұрын
@@WildBill99x Also you seem to not understand who has to abide by the constitution and who does not.
@kelleysmith73457 ай бұрын
@@WildBill99x Tell you why. If you don’t know I’m not wasting my energy to tell you. I’m done dealing with fools and idiots.
@linbrew6797 ай бұрын
Vote those in the legislature who support this policy out of office by voting for their opponent.
@CoronaHero7 ай бұрын
So let's make this fair - if you breed kids, you must pay in more than those that have no children and already paying their more than generous part of the taxes. Period! The parent's taxes can each pay in for having more than 2 kids. So your first is free, after that it's on you, I think would be fair.
@AskDrBGood15 күн бұрын
Everyone benefits from a population that has been well educated. They tend to go onto higher paying jobs, paying more taxes, and feeding the economy at a higher level. So everyone needs to be investing in the future by investing in our public schools.
@seh004110 күн бұрын
What about the fact that the vast majority of us were educated in public schools? We all benefit from having high quality education provided free to all kids.
@CoronaHero7 күн бұрын
@@seh0041 Have you seen ISD footage of parents complaining that the education is not quality for their "brats" (actual word used by teachers teaching in the school, I of course would say your angels, right). I agree free education, paid for by those that made them - DNA testing please.
@CoronaHero7 күн бұрын
@@AskDrBGood so let's go there, but it's 2024 and kids don't want a face-2-face institution anymore (I should know I am an educator of many years); just like all jobs many things are being transitioned to AI or computer assisted education systems. Don't worry, they will do fine, Millenials and Gen Z already think they know everything anyways.
@CoronaHero7 күн бұрын
@@AskDrBGood let’s reorient this thought of yours - everyone benefits by clean water, free public utilities & shelter. Make that happen and people who want to seek education will still go on to be geniuses. Throwing education at everyone and having it become a breeders babysitting service is not helping the general public
@laurat72327 ай бұрын
Looking at the break out of their spending as a proportion of a dollar, I can't help but notice the total comes to a $1.02. A penny over for rounding I get, but 2 cents? I have questions.....
@nonyadamnbusiness98877 ай бұрын
I'm surprised Texas doesn't have a voucher system. Invest in students, not systems.
@seh004110 күн бұрын
Taking more funding away from public schools isn't the answer. Schools are already operating on 2018/2019 funding since the state hasn't approved an increase in funding per student since then.
@nonyadamnbusiness988710 күн бұрын
@@seh0041 Clueless
@seh00415 күн бұрын
@@nonyadamnbusiness9887 I consider myself a lifelong learner, so please enlighten me. How does removing money from the public school fund (which is already five years behind) possibly help these schools? I hear the cries of "get creative," but I can see that MOST schools are already doing more with less. They've been doing this for a long time. Compare TX outcomes to states that allocate more per student.
@nonyadamnbusiness98875 күн бұрын
@@seh0041 Read the comment again. Invest in students, not systems. Public schools exist to indoctrinate, not educate. The sooner they are gone, the better.
@91thewatcher237 ай бұрын
The majority of the budget is spent on instruction, but what is the breakdown between the scarce pay for teachers and the massive contracts given to instructional materials publishers like Pearson, McGraw Hill, etc.? Nonetheless, the school system in our home state desperately needs attention and I'm grateful that messages like this are here to help spread the truth.
@chriskasprzyk62357 ай бұрын
What a load of liberal democrat socialist nonsense. Throwing government money at things is pretty universally how you break things, not fix them. The amount of money spent per student is totally meaningless and doesn't do anything except create bigger government bureaucracy and waste. The better question is how well is that money used? Just because someone spends more per student does not equate to a better educational system, or more importantly a better educational outcome for students. Depending on what source you choose to look at, quality rankings vary greatly; but almost all sources consistently rate Texas public schools as better than the majority of your examples, specifically MI, CA, LA, and AL Let's also not forget that cost of living is a big factor here as well. To say that teachers in most of Texas should earn the same salary as teachers in high cost of living states like CT, NY, CA, etc is asinine and completely forgetting basic economics.
@marlenemoore257 ай бұрын
I agree with you totally. As an advocate for my nephew who is 504 and sophomore in Virginia Public School System and friend in Texas with a grandmother, end of assessment need to be throw out as far as an assessment for all student. The vendors of these assessments are get richer every year while students are failing and not being able to graduate from high. My recommendation is advocate for your child all the way through high and if they go to college. Also teach your child to be assertive and speak up for self! I am a certified Human Rights Advocate and you can become one too . Contact USIDHR. Get train and represent others.
@eccolibri8 ай бұрын
So, our Gub'ner touts giving so much money back to us, while at the same time strangling our schools.
@sjmom51192 ай бұрын
they also do not tell people that are rushing to partake in the vouchers and education savings accounts that there are strings tied to that funding and that it means the same aligned curriculum products that the public schools use. school choice is only a choice of location its not a choice of education. we are watching this come out in Arizona right now.
@gingerschultz32588 ай бұрын
What a shame we don’t invest in our students, teachers and schools!
@Dog.soldier1950Ай бұрын
we do most states have half their budget for schools. This is mostly propaganda
@gingerschultz3258Ай бұрын
@ why is it propaganda? Here learning….
@Dog.soldier1950Ай бұрын
@ “more funding for schools”. Really means higher pay for teachers. Over 95% of school budgets go for payroll. Simply throwing more money doesn’t mean better outcomes. If you want better outcome then smaller classrooms and higher parental involvement
@gingerschultz3258Ай бұрын
@@Dog.soldier1950that’s a great idea!
@drayemiller98599 ай бұрын
How do we tell them?
@BroJackKnows10 ай бұрын
But how do we tell them? You missed the most important thing… the action item. Great video, but add HOW we tell them!
@raiseyourhandtexas10 ай бұрын
You can reach out to your representative by email, phone, or in person. Here is a link to find out who represents you with access to their contact information: www.raiseyourhandtexas.org/resource/who-represents/