cool video, though if you do videos where the empire just gets beat hard and doesn't act like a threat then it makes them not intimidating and threatening, you should have had those ties do more is all I'm saying

In the vacuum of space, we only have implosions.

looks like the opening scene of a 10 year old videogame. 😖 just bad....

Cool Video, but not really realistic. According to Zahn, 3 Dreadnaught Class Heavy Cruisers would struggle to match an Imperial Star Destroyer, and it's fighter compliment would be more than a match for the X & Y wings the alliance sent against it here. Best strategy is to pound at the shield generators placed over the bridge and destroy them, then disable the ship with the Y-Wing Ion Bombardments (as was demonstrated in Rogue 1). You'd just need a lot more firepower.

Why don’t they just make missiles with hyperdrives.

Great CG, you might look into The Fan Film Director's Choice Awards, many categories including CG and Animation.

They all have hyperdrives...why do you need a carrier?

I love the Mon Cal "pickle ships!" What a fun vid! I have an affinity for those nice, big, colorful lasers. "Lasers'n'phasers" & other beam weapons in modern sci-fi look like short bursts of energy. Give me the old '78 "Battlestar Galactica" & "Spaceballs" laser blasts anytime!

This is pretty well done, but there's so many little things wrong. Like why do the X-Wings lock s-foils and then immediately close them and never use them again? Or how does a Star Destroyer fall to a planet nose first and then at the last second with no power, level off and almost land? No, I couldn't do it better. But, it just feels rushed.

9 months ago 😅😅

Others have mentioned some quibbles... However, this was an awesome fan film! I look forward to you next one.

Nice I'm not that charitable, first true x-wings and wild wings are equipped with hyperdrives this attack would make sense if it were they were z-95s, also did these people forget how to deploy s foils? But most egregiously where do these people keep coming up with octuple turbo laser cannons, this seriously offends me octuple turbo laser cannons are not Canonical! This is some garbage out of one of the comic books, were the imperials asleep at the wheel or what nobody thought to swing the anti-aircraft guns around to cover the aft, seriously there's at least 10 anti-air guns that can be swung aft.

X-wings cant fire in the "locked" position. They have to be in "assault mode" ie wings open in X formation

Cool level of animation and details, but very biased. ISD is like an NPC here, doing quite nothing and TIE are useless. That wouldn't be the case normally.

Star Wars fan films used to be good. People actually acted in the.......but just like the prequels it all CGI.

REBEL SCUM

nice animation mate , not being a critic but 2 things i want to point out 1. the obvios one x wings s foils weren't locked in the iconic x in attack position 2. the quaser class carrier didnt need to jump into potentil cobat zone even if it was in a safe distance from the star destroyer and 2 its x wings and y wings couldve pre launched in a jump before that combat system and attaccked the isd right coming outta hyperspace jump , that was the defining hit and run tactic of rebels as a whole jump in jumpscare and fuck the imperials and jump out and the quaser fire did nopthing too if there were a few corvettes then we couldve assumed the flagship quaser was there to command the fleet

I think the Invictus(?) class is honestly a better-designed Victory

Weren’t the S-Foils supposed to be in attack position (wings opened)?

How did the quasar carry rebel star fighters if it’s an imperial ship? But other than that nice animation 😊

This is a really well made film. The only issues I seen were, X-wing can only fire one shot with the s-foils down and then automatically open up, (referenced from Rogue Squadron book series). Also the Y-wings and X-wings ha e hyperdrives, so unless they were going an extreme distance, they didn't need carrier support. Otherwise very good short film. 4 outta 5 stars.

I didn't expect to get Rebels feels! Nice.

BOOOO!!!😲 YOUR CHANNEL IS THE WORST!!!😡👎🏻

The s-foil wings need to be open for the X-wing attack positions.

Was this made by an 8-year-old?

Absolutely terrible. Downright horrifying animation. Far too reminiscent of "The Amazing Bulk" to be considered good in any way.

The "lasers" look much cooler than in the actual movies 😊, what did you do differently?

1:35 oh nice, Gozanti-Class Carriers 🤩 its one of my favorite Ships. And great Video! I enjoyed every Second of it. 👍

Thanks for authoring something new BUT ... the only three CAP tie fighters were smoked very-early on and the Y-Wings had an open shot at the engines but gave it up. Why??? ISD commander could've yelled, "Freebird!" and crashed his SD into the squid cruiser essentially causing this to be a draw.

I had friends on that death-star😢

The animations are okay so far, but the content of the film makes no sense at all. First of all, the escort carriers carry more than a handful of X-Wings and 4 Y-Wings, just as the Star Destroyer has more than a dozen TIE fighters, which can do more than just fly straight ahead. The most disturbing thing, however, is the fact that the Star Destroyer doesn't open fire at all. One turn, one salvo and the issue would be over.

Great vid but shouldn’t the xwings foils be in attack position.

0:20 If yall dont know that ship its the ghost from rebels 0:44 this ship also from rebels used to be imp i think

constructive criticism : i know animation is not easy but speeding a battle up would help your presentation

Long live the empire 🤚🏻

Would been nice if it was longer

Y would a ship fall down in zero gravity tho?

I didn't think x wings could fire in the closed wing mode

At first I thought it was an Empire At War mod Nice animation, that was impressive

I liked it. Don't get me wrong, but if it was that easy to take out a Star Destroyer, the war wouldn't have lasted long. Also, if all those fighters were capable of light speed, what would be the point in risking the carrier? Plus the X wings never locked their x foils open. However I watched every second of it. It was bad ass.

Why would fighters need to be carried in via carrier? They have hyperdrives, the entire point of the Rebel fighter tactic is fast hit and run on their own hyperdrives. Why would the X wings be firing with S foils closed?

5:15 If there are any survivors, then they might as well surrender to the Rebels

А пилотов империи вообще обучают, или сразу в истребитель и надеятся, что справятся. Повстанцы самоучки их бьют как в тире.

Just hearing the dull radio chatter over the thrum of the engines during the interior shots on the star destroyer's bridge was an especially nice touch!

I love how you really captured the darkness, emptiness and silence of outer space! Brought a welcomed taste of "realism" to a Star Wars setting that's never actually been there before. In space, all you'd see are the glow of the ship's engines and the interior lights coming through the ship's windows. I'd like to see MORE of that!

Can I ask a question. Can you do a fan film about thr First Order taking over Coruscant. This was inspired by the Duel of the Fates script.

The X-wings did not lock the foils into attack position.

Princess Katerra

That was the phenom.bomb!

Pretty gutsy exiting hyperspace into an asteroid field; guess that’s what shields are for. :). Awesome work! Edit: love the A-Wing shots…ohhhhh! Did that A-Wing sacrifice himself? Just curious, can the A-Wing’s side cannon swing in a circle? That is, can they rotate to fire backwards? Anyway, spectacular job, this was really great stuff.