The Plymouth Separatists were willing to return to the Church of England if it cleansed itself of Popery. They were not second degree separatists as was Roger Williams who reviled anyone who would while back in England attend a C of E Church. Now the Church the Pilgrims left has gone Woke much like Pope Francis. The Pilgrims did the right thing

This is a FAKE 🤥 WHITEWASHED Image of John Winthrop and STOP 🛑 WHITEWASHING OUR HISTORICAL FIGURES! Blessings and Hugs 💖💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕💕!

if he was escaping calvinisim I dont think he belived much in prediestiny

Great analysis.

So we are informed by the narrator that in reality, Sylvia Plath’s father is a nice guy? Yet the poem is praised by feminists for its “unadulterated rage towards male dominance?” Also, this is NOT one if the “best” examples of confessional poetry because the poet herself said explains that the character in the poem is a woman who has an Electra Complex. Even the quote, “childish” tone of the character would would make feminism seem rather childish, bitter, and whiny. The problem with this analysis is that narrator (a disgruntled woman) keeps trying to apply a feminist critique to it, instead of even TRYING to understand Jung’s fascinating Electra Complex, or basic human psychology. Sylvia Plath was far smarter than this cry-baby drivel presented here.

Kinda boring

This analysis is horribly wrong. The Feminist use of it's construct is ludicrous and offers a clear indication that the poem is not understood by them.

A liberal rant. Blames on others not self.

Thank you, Suzanne, for your commentary. It was excellent and a big help. You put a lot of work into doing this, and I'm thankful because you helped prepare me for my composition class coming up.

I did not even consider the imagery in this story

My English teacher told me about her poems, so I thought I'd look them up as I am trying to learn how to right complexed poems like this. It's quite a hard thing to write, wish me luck! ❤️

Suzanne! Sister of light and insight-of wise whisper! Thanks so much for this excellent, helpful video. It brought clarity to me. God bless you! 💛🙏🏼 PS, I do vary a little: Roger Williams and Ann Hutchinson were, I think, only heretics in JW’s eyes. They had very good ideas-which weren’t appreciated. 🙂

Clearly depicted what exactly hidden in heart of poem . It’s could barley find what’s inside the a girl as much the poem .

This was such a helpful analysis, thank you so very much

I strongly disagree, and I am sure that Baldwin would, too, that there is "not one clear meaning or lesson in this story". There are many meanings and lessons in this story; too numerous to name. "Sonny's Blues" is intended for Black readers who know the inner-workings of urban communities. This analysis is another example of how Black lives are marginalized by non Black readers.

Thank you so much!! Really helpful. You've covered soo many topics within 7 minutes that too with excellence.

I wanted more info on John Winthrop

0:09 1950's Harlem - Danger of housing projects, Inner City Ghetto - Drugs, Crime, Prostitution, Homelessness --> Helplessness Jazz Music connects the struggle Narrator & Sonny Narrator educates himself, still lives in The Projects - Logical, but Cold - Emotional between anger and sorrow + Learns to understand Sonny 2:15 Heroin --> First Escape Music --> Second Escape Empathy Struggle With The Despair Shares Sorrow, Provide Temporary Salvation Drink The Cup of Trembling, Take Your Forgiveness 4:08 Conflict: + Jazz Music is good 5:07 Dealing With The Pain of Racism Looking Out For Your Brother 6:57 Darkness & Light Light = Hope Joy/Saddness 8:14 Louis Armstrong - Mellow, Controlled, Accepted, Respected Charlie Byrd Parker - Fast-Paced, Complex, Un-Accepted, Noise 8:51 Post-Modern

I disagree with most of your analysis. I was prepared to deconstruct your opinions point by point, however, a phone call interrupted my response and now I am struggling-- I am literally at a loss for words. So....I looked at the pic, noted the tone of your voice, the pedantic form, and your .....look, I'll just suggest that it might be a good idea to read it again, read or listen to POV's differing from your own, and peel several layers more off this metaphorical onion. If you still stand by this analysis-- you haven't convinced anyone outside the feminist dogmatism camp. No offense intended. P.S. you have an excellent vocabulary.

Alright so you keep saying the speakers father died when she was 10, where the hell do you get that from?

Thank you for this analysis!

Ryan Reeves has a fine channel which has many great short videos dealing with all topics relating to John Calvin, Puritanism, and all things Reformed.

You explained it really well 💓

Stream of consciousness is a technic used by modernist writers, not postmodernist. :)

Good lord, let it be felt by the reader..Intellects, what a bore...

Nicely explained thanks!

thank you so much

Terrific analysis!

Well analysed.

Tom Sawyer kzbin.info/www/bejne/m3mpl5pmj9tribc. Like please.Gracias

Thanks!!

Why did John Winthrop sail to America?

Your sound is to loud

is there any truth that Winthrop and his group of Puritans abused, killed and sold native American Indians into slavery??

Panzer man - a german tank???

this is such a helpful video for my english studies!

thank u it was very helpful