This performance/recording takes me somewhere. Somewhere familiar yet so far away, until now. Their voices!!! And the glorious voices of those pianos. Nothing sounds quite like a Steinway. Thankyou for sharing this

It is my favorite. Thank you, Bon Iver.

HAHA OH WOW 🤣 exceptional unique beauty and THAT voice uhhhhhh , I'm melting both of those voices gel so perfectly , opposite sides of the scale , loooooooooooVe this , SUBBED 🔥🔥🔥

Amazing recording the sound is so pure True talent 🤩

Now this has helped me zone out and become numb years back but I didn't realise how much it helped 🙂‍↕️

Awesome

this makes me so nostalgic

This is a late comment, but to the dude who said that Sean Carey doesn't have rhythm: do you realize this guy has a degree in percussion? Rhythm is probably one of his strongest suits. Whatever.

Luis Suarez sure can sing

James Arthur did a cover of this for an audition for the X Factor, you should check it out in my opinion its better than both of these artists, he should do a full cover

I just recently got into Bon Iver and Wow! This is one of the best recordings I've ever heard from a artist. They make it look so effortless too!

Such a beautiful song. I wasn't prepared of Sean Carey starting off the song, but he pulled it off quite great! I think I prefer the "original" cover with Justin only. Still a great song!

I need sheet music for this!! Help anyone?

oh GOD I forgot how good this is.

bromance look at 0:06

Versions of this song: Prince>Bonnie Raitt>Bon Iver>George Michaels Sorry, but if you want to hear a squealy-man version of this song, Bon Iver can't hold Prince's jock. That's not saying Justin Vernon isn't good...but he's standing in the shadows of greatness.

I actually like this version more than his other version on his own

why would you even try and compare these two singers? they're both perfect at singing this in their own right. all the self righteous critics calling out falsetto should also realise what falsetto is and that it's a necessary singing quality for some songs and music is sometimes about putting the right things together and not just making it as difficult to sing/play as possible. just appreciate it and stop trying to figure out who is "best". At this level, it's incomparable.

The song starts at 2:10

I like S. Carey but i don't think he did this justice, he did exactly like Justin's former version, and it was like a Falsetto standoff and it's almost impossible to put your falsetto side to side with Justin and make it sound better, not to mention Justin sorta re-created his version here made it sound so much more soulful going in and out of falsetto, breathtaking.

This song hurts my insides

How do the top comments get chosen if I can't up/down vote them?

I have to say that I disagree with you. Sure, Sean is good. However, particularly in this song he is not. He's off beat for most of it, it seems. He doesn't have the rhythm that Justin does, at all.

They are so talented! it's so fucking amazing! there aren't many great musicians in these years! but THEY ARE REALLY AWESOME!

does anyone maybe recognize the headphones they are using?

Cannot get enough of this.

It couldn't have been said better. In fact I wish there was a version of just S.Carey's solo vox

Everything you just said is so broken. 'SEAN' (Not Scott) has an incredible voice, he holds falsetto so much longer then Justin, speaking of which Justin's falsetto range is very limited, Sean's has such depth it's unreal. Yes Justine can sing 'loud and soulful' but that doesn't make him better or worse it just means that's his style. Sean is very talented and in no way sings like an average white guy he has a fuck load of skill. no one 'owns' anyone, they compliment each other. Use your ears..

you are aware that "the first guy" Sean Carey is a part of Bon Iver? Bon Iver is the name of the band...

Here is my Fluval Edge 6 Gal. I have a couple questions. 1. I have the 50w jager heater but as you can see from the video it is very obtrusive in the tank. Can i hide it under the sand? Is there any better heaters that are less obtrusive? I live in michigan so I need something that will last a winter. 2. How is my aquascaping? 3. How is the position of the power head koralia? Its a koralia nano 250. Should i point it into the rocks?

you must be deaf

Bon Iver is the band... Justin Vernon is the guy

Im a massive Justin Vernon fan, but Scott Carey's voice OWNS him in this one. He sounds beautiful. Especially on the "don't patronise....me"

not nearly as good as the one bon iver did himself. the first guy changes it completely, in a bad way

Where was this all my life?

tonga is all together makes it seem fake

What a load of shit

i wanna make a nano reef in my 10 but it seem like alot of fucking aroun considering i have never done saltwater before in my life so i'll probably try a "just fish" tank first then try to upgrade it.

too crowded in my opinion.