Пікірлер
@KurtusCobainus
@KurtusCobainus 3 сағат бұрын
The genetics claim using Haplogroups also makes no sense to me. For starters, Sardinians are one of the most isolated European groups on the planet, with their population practically serving as a modern proxy for the ancient Anatolian Neolithic Farmers for instance, and being devoid of almost any IE ancestry all together so considering that these Haplogroups are so prominent, why isn't their autosomal DNA any more different? Sure, Haplogroups don't equal Autosomal DNA ancestry, but there is most certainly a correlation. Did the Vandals really affect the Sardinian population that much through paternal ancestry but not through autosomal DNA? The only way in which I can see that happening, is if these Haplogroups don't in fact just come from somewhere else and aren't actually Slavic at all, or that the Vandals barely intermarried with the population at all, but somehow managed to spread their Haplogroups over a large area. The article citing R1a on its ownas an example is also rather idiotic too, as R1a has numerous different subclades that can be found in different populations, so how do we not know that this frequency of R1a is simply coming from pre-Slavic population with the Haplogroup (assuming by your claim that the Vandals were Slavs) and not Slavs? In the end, with the linguistics and other things, I just can't see how the Vandals could be Slavic. This is almost close to reaching BHI levels of absurdity, and the last person I debated this own decided not to continue and just kept citing me stupid place names in Iberia that were supposedly similar to Polish ones when I gave out actual vidence, with their excuse for not making a better argument being that "I have no time for a lengthy answer". Unlike what the comments are saying here, no, you should not ask to wiki editors to change it, because there are simply too many holes I can see in your arguments which I am sure they would be able to see too. Some guy being called "Stilicho" isn't really proof of much either, since not only did I mention that we still have examples of Vandalic and it's reconstructions, we have to remember that the East Germanic branch is a lot more different and slightly more archaic in comparison to modern Germanic languages, so a lot of words may look strange or unfamiliar to modern Germanic speakers. I'm not saying that your study of this is complete rubbish, but this just isn't a good conclusion to come too with the amount of holes that could be filled in in terms of linguistic evidence, genetics, and a lot more. I highly doubt that they were Slavs.
@KurtusCobainus
@KurtusCobainus 3 сағат бұрын
Also, the way medieval or ancient authors categorised ancient groups is far different to how we do it today. The Goths and Vandals weren't considered to be Germanic by the Romans, but neither were the Scandinavians. Once they picked the geographical location of what would come to be considered Germania, they didn't intend to spread it further just because of linguistic connections. Latin is also a Centum IE language, and is arguably a tadbit ore similar n some respects to Germanic and Celtic languages than it is to Slavic and Indo-Iranian ones, so it isn't "Eastern". There also may be a Germanic example of a word relating to "our own", and just because it isn't listed, doesn't mean that it doesn't exist. Take the name of Sweden for an example. It's name is said to have come from the PIE root *s(w)e, also meaning "One's own". The fact that Portuguese sounds like Russian could also just be a coincidence. It is said to have a lot of consonant clusters in a similar fashion to Russian and some Slavic languages, but we can't really prove that it was Vandalic that caused it since I have also said in a previous a previous comment that we already have full blown reconstructions and samples more similar to Germanic languages than Slavic ones. The Vandals didn't even stay in Iberia for that long, and didn't really cover the largest area that I've ever seen, so it is even more unlikely.
@KurtusCobainus
@KurtusCobainus 6 сағат бұрын
That's not quite right. The wiki does actually explain that the Przeworsk culture cannot simply be linked to one singular ethnicity, so in the end, it could be linked to both Slavs and Germanic people living in a similar area. We also have reconstructions of the Vandalic language and word samples from it, all of which are far more similar to Gothic and Proto Germanic than they are to Slavic languages. You could actually check out the wiki and see for yourself, or else I could just use some word examples for comparison. You also commented about the Vandals being Slavs ruled by Viking overlords when the Viking Age wouldn't start until nearly or around 200 years later.
@JasonDeville-fi4dh
@JasonDeville-fi4dh 14 сағат бұрын
Brother im not going to lie i only believe your theory. It makes perfect sense. Instead to try to figure out why there seems to be no purpose you solved the delimma in a way that makes sense they just started fortifying themselves they must have been at war and that kind of explains why they were found by humans later or new civilization deserted.
@TheKiwiKooker
@TheKiwiKooker Күн бұрын
Been subscribed to you for several years. I appreciate your never ending thirst for knowledge and ability to problem solve.
@shl24yw89
@shl24yw89 2 күн бұрын
There is no dinosaur in that book because the word didn't come before 1842. It was more than a hundred year too early for dinosaur to be a thing! Although the book is surprisingly just shy 20 years away from the birth of great inventor Michael Faraday.
@duckpond01.21
@duckpond01.21 3 күн бұрын
Do a video on the martyrdom of antipas. Martyred south of “Genebad” on “bald mountain”. There is a “beaumont” south of “Geneva” .
@peterruberto6879
@peterruberto6879 3 күн бұрын
Always thought provoking, expanding on different perspectives, trying to get into the thought process of the ancients. Very falicnating…..,, i mean fascinating 😮
@2008sean1
@2008sean1 4 күн бұрын
Wow been a long time. Saw you in X today and a new video. So nice to see you again.
@oz2chauvet282
@oz2chauvet282 4 күн бұрын
Also its a letter M on the main rib/collarbone - next to T pillar as you suggest
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 4 күн бұрын
Good catch. Alphabet super ancient. M could be two humans together hance 'mateing/meeting/meading'. Or Waves.
@oz2chauvet282
@oz2chauvet282 4 күн бұрын
Mmm .. sounds about right! The ribs are expanding and contracting the M, as above so below. So M could also be the waxing crescent plus the waning crescent (2 letter C's rotated and joined). Just as his hand is a waxer on the Corona of the pole/sundial of his. On (K)neeling and Knowing there is a little Kenning type thing, that Monkey = moon key. Going with sounds:- mouth closed Mmm to open but tongue still pressed Nnn to C/K mouth opens. Just like monkey emerged from a rock in myth. Notice also how the letter N is shaped like a kneeling figure. Sound in stone - might not be a beard coming out his mouth and also the rock is fractured at the diaphragm region with a box
@boredom.victim
@boredom.victim 4 күн бұрын
UK, U-Kraine - sounds similar, don't it? also, even recent mythology depicts babies being brought by a stork or a crane... couldn't possibly be anything more than a coincidence, right?
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 4 күн бұрын
Good catch. Information synchronicities may indicate relations in teh universe's program.
@scharbon4089
@scharbon4089 4 күн бұрын
The 23 ribs must been a lost knowledge that just have been pass on, readapted! So humans goes even further then the Tepes! If mans are from Mars and women from Venus ...how does that relate? Trough your previous video, I was talking about humans living on Mars and fleed here from the Sun! Interesting!
@metalhead5284
@metalhead5284 5 күн бұрын
Only 5 minutes in, just found this channel, and I'm already seeing parallels to my research. 🍿
@jerichothirteen1134
@jerichothirteen1134 5 күн бұрын
The Aboriginal people of the Arnhem land region beleive in a people called the Mimi. Thats what those poles represent. See they have a little head at top and little legs at the bottom. The Mimi are a tribe of men who live in the cracks of the rocks around the Western Arnhem region. They taught the people language and ceremonies and dances. Some Aboriginal may spend time with them in their lands.
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 4 күн бұрын
Same root, good catch.
@jerichothirteen1134
@jerichothirteen1134 4 күн бұрын
@TheTimeDetective42 you and I spend our spare time in the exact same way 👍
@d-redfusion
@d-redfusion 5 күн бұрын
Min. Minimum. Not a lot. The irony 😅
@chateaugrief
@chateaugrief 5 күн бұрын
ok i'm really late with this comment but all this talk of Buddhism makes me want to look into the etymology and history of Budapest.
@peterdeans4635
@peterdeans4635 5 күн бұрын
Why the ribs??? Static electricity in the atmosphere something we have seen a lot of lately can look like feathers or the ribs on this dude. This guy I think is Libra, they were astronomers also Dr Charles 👍😊great video,,,EDIT the clouds lóok like the ribs you'll see them on cloudless hot days if that makes sense
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 5 күн бұрын
Thanks so much, good points!
@Sool101
@Sool101 5 күн бұрын
13 moon phases to each annual cycle which is one year. Hence 13
@SB5SimulationsFerroviairesEEP
@SB5SimulationsFerroviairesEEP 5 күн бұрын
Intéressant, mais pas facile à suivre et à comprendre! C'est le M sur la poitrine qui vous fait penser à Moon? Les fissures me font plus penser à creusements le long d'un pan de montagne, des ruissellements! Et le phallus peu vouloir représenter une divinité masculine, ce qui là aussi mettrait le M en situation. Et pour la couleur de la Lune, certes on peu penser à de la rouille, mais pas que! Il y a plein de cristaux de couleur Orange sur terre! Donc cette poudre qui reflèterait le soleil, pourrai aussi bien être du cristal orange, comme de L'Obsidienne par exemple! Sinon merci du partage! Stéph.
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 5 күн бұрын
Merci Steph.
@tombra7
@tombra7 5 күн бұрын
Karahan and Gobekli are aligned with Civita di Bagnoregio , Distance between them is 1/64 of Karahan -Civita line .
@מוגוגוגו
@מוגוגוגו 5 күн бұрын
I don't think its ribs....its actually snakes ... you can see the head on one of them.
@angiebear8727
@angiebear8727 5 күн бұрын
“His roof and gutter sealant” 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 think I laughed a little too much about that one. Ty! Needed that
@K22channel
@K22channel 5 күн бұрын
.. excuse me...but the red moon isn't that due to the earth atmosphere?
@boredom.victim
@boredom.victim 4 күн бұрын
and smoke in the air during fire season
@K22channel
@K22channel 5 күн бұрын
😂 moreover...if you don't want to piss on your feet you must direct it with your hands... Expecially when is cold weather...
@K22channel
@K22channel 5 күн бұрын
😂 monkey could do "that" too
@andrewmoore5628
@andrewmoore5628 5 күн бұрын
I'm sorry don't listen to you often, don't know why, I'm going to put the work in and sort this monumental error out.
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 5 күн бұрын
Nice.
@Stonecutter334
@Stonecutter334 5 күн бұрын
Unmm European? Why?
@OkiOkiMataara
@OkiOkiMataara 5 күн бұрын
Sacana/Sakana in hebrew means Danger, Mesukan - Dangerous, Misken - miserable, Sikun means risk.
@yowwwwie
@yowwwwie 5 күн бұрын
Hey Kos, 6 fingers. Starving man (ribs showing)...looks like he's circumcised. יוי
@monakw
@monakw 5 күн бұрын
Thanks Charles! Fascinating stuff. That statue with the ribs is amazing. Moon had a lot to do with a lot of things. YES 🌙🤍
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 5 күн бұрын
Thanks Monakw!
@CroMagnon42
@CroMagnon42 5 күн бұрын
Is that the roof and gutter sealant they used on the structure 🤔
@luck2know
@luck2know 5 күн бұрын
you really don't know what your talking about
@manyamulder4312
@manyamulder4312 5 күн бұрын
@@luck2know and you do? So tell us please.
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 5 күн бұрын
Katerina! Every country on the planet is against you! SAD!
@jerichothirteen1134
@jerichothirteen1134 5 күн бұрын
No it's just everything you think you know is wrong.
@boredom.victim
@boredom.victim 4 күн бұрын
​@@jerichothirteen1134 oh, mutton
@manyamulder4312
@manyamulder4312 4 күн бұрын
@ ok. But still no answer about the subject. If you know it better. Than say it.
@vikingskuld
@vikingskuld 5 күн бұрын
Hey good to see you again. I miss your videos. I really am glad to see you making a vid. Thank you so much.
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 5 күн бұрын
Hi Vikingskuld!
@vikingskuld
@vikingskuld 5 күн бұрын
@TheTimeDetective42 I hope you and yours are doing well. Enjoy the holiday's but make a video once in a while and let us know your still kicking. Great to see you on here again
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 5 күн бұрын
@@vikingskuld Thanks so much!
@gitmoholliday5764
@gitmoholliday5764 5 күн бұрын
Maybe it is about most people nowadays are clearly descendents of w*nkers 😊
@lukeallen4398
@lukeallen4398 5 күн бұрын
More🎉🎉🎉
@lukeallen4398
@lukeallen4398 5 күн бұрын
❤ 😂 double video 🎉
@TheTimeDetective42
@TheTimeDetective42 5 күн бұрын
Triple!
@WebenHad
@WebenHad 5 күн бұрын
Add a dash of thermite in the mix and bake.. it’s either acid or fire and both are better… Food for thought , Thanks, Great Content !