Пікірлер
@gowerdave
@gowerdave 23 сағат бұрын
Please sort your sound out, it's uncomfortable to listen to due to squelch muting.
@garyday6681
@garyday6681 2 күн бұрын
If you own a spectrum analyzer, your video is not for people who actually use baofeng radios and you are just showing off your gadgets that no one wants.
@jimrossmeissl2726
@jimrossmeissl2726 2 күн бұрын
I tried to program FRS frequencies into it, but it doesn’t seem to accept any.
@Milo30066
@Milo30066 7 күн бұрын
Very good information, thanks
@ricdonato4328
@ricdonato4328 9 күн бұрын
My wish is an IP 68 rating. This is important for folks needing to use H3 and H8 outside. Changing weather catches us by surprise, what I do is carry plastic sandwich bags for those times.
@daveparker7207
@daveparker7207 11 күн бұрын
What dummy load are you using?
@JohnMacFarlane-p2i
@JohnMacFarlane-p2i 11 күн бұрын
I have tried multiple times to use this antenna and cannot get it to tune on any band. It is a 'dummy load' at best - I could not, in good conscience, recommend that anyone purchase it. It was expensive and unusable.
@slappychap969
@slappychap969 12 күн бұрын
All the clowns attacking a $30 dollar radio. Its like all the prissy jeep soy bois criticizing a Subaru AWD
@slappychap969
@slappychap969 12 күн бұрын
Or all the gun dudes attacking a hi point hahahaha.
@BakerStudiosIndy
@BakerStudiosIndy 14 күн бұрын
I have the GA-510. TX is fine, RX is garbage. Worst of any Chinese rigs in my collection. Intermod city.
@Dr2Rock2
@Dr2Rock2 17 күн бұрын
You should do a comparison to one of the big 3 or all of them for comparison purposes.
@barrychapman9813
@barrychapman9813 17 күн бұрын
I'm a licensed Radio Amateur call sign G4DIP
@stevevarholy2011
@stevevarholy2011 22 күн бұрын
I was sent a review unit of the MaxTalker TK-W60. I have been unable to figure out exactly what it is because it does not resemble any of the Chinese handhelds out there. It has no FCC ID at all, so after a review of the reception and UI functions, it went back in the box. In fact the literature and box have no branding at all on them - just a computer printed sticker and barcode with MaxTalker printed on it.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 22 күн бұрын
Thanks for the comment. I did see that since I receive the TK-6 that they now have the TK-W60 also. It did look more unique, I also don't know what radio that would be. Was the UI similar to anything you've seen before?
@talkpodtech
@talkpodtech 22 күн бұрын
Like the video
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 22 күн бұрын
I'm glad you liked it! Thanks for taking the time to drop a comment and for the view! Any new TalkPod radios in the near future? :)
@talkpodtech
@talkpodtech 21 күн бұрын
@@KC4NWK Nothing new😂. Give us some times
@jhill4874
@jhill4874 23 күн бұрын
I compared the MaxTalker and Quansheng on Amazon, and except for the programming cable, they are exactly the same.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 23 күн бұрын
Ok, that would be cool to show a similar package. I just looked and could not find one that came with the two extra antennas and a carrying pouch (I know you said it didn't have the programming cable). Do you have the link to the package that is similar? If you do I'll link to it in my video description. 73s!!
@normrubio
@normrubio 23 күн бұрын
In your harmonic test, how does that translate into performance?
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 22 күн бұрын
Thanks for the question. Any spurious emission can rob from the total output power. When you measure your output power with a watt meter, you are seeing the sum total output power of the radio on all harmonics/spurious emissions. In most cases, you will not lose very much power from your fundamental frequency, but the power output on the spurious emissions can be high enough to interfere with other radio services such as first responders etc. This is the main reason for having a clean radio for me.
@AndrewSchott
@AndrewSchott 24 күн бұрын
The stubbies I got from DIamond and Comet are quite good. As good as my SignalStick, no. But at its size, its an amazing antenna. When around I can hit any of the repeaters I want and I can connect up to my car mounted antenna whilst driving. So yeah, they are actually good.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 24 күн бұрын
That's some good news. I think the key might be making sure you have real Diamond/Comet versions! I wonder if there is a way to tell. Thank you for the comment!!! 73s!! (PS - At some point I would love to devise a setup to make objective comparisons on HT antennas... there are so many variables.)
@Yozimbo
@Yozimbo 26 күн бұрын
Thank you for your excellent review...! As a new aspiring HAM, although I keep hearing about the "chinese junk" from older HAMs, I am inclined more and more towards the newer better and improved HTs from China, such as the H3, as they represent a tremendous value for money... I was considering getting at some point a "good" HT, but I cannot honestly see the point to spend 3-4-5 times as much to get the "same" VHF-UHF functionality (simplex and repeaters use, no APRS etc...just the simple stuff)... 73 from Athens, Greece!
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 24 күн бұрын
I agree with your comment. There are many things that make the "good" radios different from these lesser priced radios. The double-conversion super heterodyne receiver is one. They are generally more suitable for applications requiring high sensitivity, selectivity, and dynamic range. The direct conversion radios are obviously less expensive to manufacture. The "good" radios generally also have more features like APRS, and possibly digital modes like DMR, D-Star, Fusion, etc. These "cheaper" radios are great for people entering the hobby, or having a radio you can use without worrying too much about what happens to it. As long as your use is limited to analog communications, they are hard to beat. Welcome to the hobby! Thank you so much for the view and the comment! My wife and her family are 100% Greek. :) 73s!
@Yozimbo
@Yozimbo 23 күн бұрын
@@KC4NWK thank you for your very informative reply! Indeed, the HT quality is directly related to one's needs... Having said that, Chinese brands like Wouxun are already cutting into the superheterodyne niche, albeit at a higher price range than "cheap chinese radios", but still competitive vis-a-vis Japanese brands... Overall, like all things, I hope the competition in the end of the day, benefits us with better, less expensive HTs to use! 73s and kalimera to your wife! :)
@user-qe9gu5bl7q
@user-qe9gu5bl7q 26 күн бұрын
Will we have here is fraud who has a plan to monopolize and belongs ranked as a waste of time, and a bad example.
@michaelpage4199
@michaelpage4199 27 күн бұрын
I really enjoyed your review. Thank you for sharing.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 24 күн бұрын
Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it. Thanks for watching and dropping the comment! 73s!
@BarticusMax
@BarticusMax 27 күн бұрын
Cannot see your wattmeter at all in the video, what are you using? (I need one).
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 24 күн бұрын
Yes, I know. ;-( Sorry, I need to get to a point where I can invest in some better top-down cameras that I can manually zoom and focus much better!!! That watt meter is a SureCom SW-33PLUS. :) Here is a link: amzn.to/4dPjm46 Thank you for the comment and for watching!! 73s!
@the1spyderryder
@the1spyderryder 29 күн бұрын
What difference does it make the radio has an FCC aproval and it doesnt matter what you think about it.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 29 күн бұрын
LOL, well unfortunately a lot of people think that same thing, and they are also wrong. The FCC ID on these radios has NOTHING to do with whether they are a good RF transmitter and legal according to Part 97. If you were to look at what that FCC ID certification actually is, you would notice its mainly Part 15B and one test on 15C (This is for the Bluetooth). This certifies the device doesn't interfere with other electronics. Here is the link: fccid.io/2A4FBTD831 Or the main FCC website: www.fcc.gov/oet/ea/fccid Grantee Code: 2A4FB Product Code: TD831 You can read through each test and see exactly how the test was conducted and what the results were. Your timing is great though. I will refer you over to a video that @TheSmokinApe just posted on this very subject!! kzbin.info/www/bejne/hqelnGx4erp9h7c Excellent video.
@jasonandtaramc
@jasonandtaramc 29 күн бұрын
This was a great vid and I really like your channel. Could you share your solder station setup with us?
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 29 күн бұрын
Thank you so much, I greatly appreciate your comment! I will try to show the soldering setup in a future video. Its nothing too special. I use a HAKKO FX-951 for my pencil, and a QUICK/861DW (be careful on these, there are knock offs on Amazon. If it seems too good of a deal, it is.) for the hot-air station. In this setup right now I'm just using a HAKKO FA-400 fume filter, but will be adding an actual fume extractor soon. Thanks again for the interest and views!! 73s!!!
@dennis8196
@dennis8196 Ай бұрын
does this enable the feature in the ZTE2246 they locked out to allow the BT-Comm profile giving users a real comm port - UART that can be used with any software?
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 29 күн бұрын
I'm gonna guess that it does not. I tried discovering it with both my phone and PC, and it will only show up in the ODMaster software.
@terrarecon
@terrarecon Ай бұрын
I think the picture in picture is an okay idea. However, switch them so that your audience can better see what you are doing. Your face should be in the small picture box and what you are doing should be in the bigger picture box.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Yep, this was addressed in a previous comment. Totally agree! I shoot these videos “real time” and I forgot to change scenes to the proper overhead shot. Still learning to get everything right. :-)
@putteification
@putteification Ай бұрын
Please use gloves when handling chemicals such as epoxy.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Very good reminder!! Thank you!! I even had my box of gloves next to me! Thank you for the view and comments!!!! 73!
@putteification
@putteification Ай бұрын
A coil with that small a diameter and with no space between the turns is going to have very high losses. Low Q, wide bandwith but low radiation efficiency.
@HOAHamRadio
@HOAHamRadio Ай бұрын
I see someone was making use of a 360 cam : ) I have this same base / antenna sitting in a corner of the shack patiently waiting for a look. As soon as I picked up the magmount, I had the exact same response as you...the boots just fall off when you look at them. I've not owned a magmount before, so I don't have anything to compare to. Your effort to improve the manufacturing were stellar! I know these types of antennas get sold, so people must just expect to have to go through the manual tuning process. That, or they get resonant on a band and never change. Thanks for sharing.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thanks Bob! Really appreciate you dropping in and leaving the comment! Yes, learning how to use the Insta360!! ;-) I will be anxious to see if you have the same experience with the wobbliness! I feel like it could so easily be addressed in production with the addition of an extra 20-30 seconds. 73s!!
@sharif9360
@sharif9360 Ай бұрын
The Stephen A. Edit was on point i laughed so hard.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK 22 күн бұрын
Thanks, my editor was having some fun. ;-)
@adcraziness1501
@adcraziness1501 Ай бұрын
I do not know what dBc is here. Decibels celsius? lol. I did a quick search... decibels as related to a carrier? So I'm pretty new at all this. I got my technician amateur radio ticket this past January so I'm quite novice. But -12dB is... 4x less? So about... half of one watt? That actually seems like a lot. That's higher than low power on my little FT1XD. The other harmonics will likely not even reach the end of my coax... but that first harmonic at 293MHz is a doozy. If I'm not mistaken here. That is a lot of power that could be focused on my fundamental frequency, Baofeng. EDIT: I need to do this with the baofeng I have. Their QC is pretty loose from what I undertstand. Who knows they likely vary from radio to radio.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you for viewing and dropping the question! :) Yes, dBc is dB from the Carrier (or fundamental) frequency. The FCC requires these radios to have their harmonics more than -40 dBc and also each individually below 25 uWatts. Some people don't seem to care too much about this, but I like to present everyone with the data so they can make an informed decision on what radio to spend their money on. Why buy a dirty ILLEGAL radio, when for a very similar price their are choices that are legal and clean. Keep in mind that when you measure your radio output power with a watt meter, you are measuring the total amount of power out of the radio, not necessarily all that power is on your fundamental frequency. Hope that helps!! Happy to have you here, and I hope you are really enjoying the hobby! 73s
@adcraziness1501
@adcraziness1501 Ай бұрын
​@@KC4NWK ​It does not help that half of their customer base truly does not care, and actually pokes fun at people who do want to minimize interference. I don't want to output half a watt into 300MHz. I'm not licensed on those frequencies and I do not want to say my callsign over those frequencies. The common idea, I think, is that they don't travel more than "a few feet" but half a watt is half a watt. And you were testing on low power too, high power is what 5x this? So you'd be putting out 2.5 watts into that first fundamental on high, if I'm reading this right? Into frequencies you don't even know who uses them. I know I don't know who uses 300MHz. A very brief google search suggests "aeronautics, satellites, and radio navigation" none of whom I want to be saying my callsign to. They can. Millions of others can but my radio is going back to the big A and I hope they ask why.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Just for clarification purposes, here the 2nd harmonic is ~12dBc from the carrier. If you round your output power to 2W then your 2nd harmonic power would be around ~ 0.125 watts. You can look up the equation for power ratio. It’s a little hard to try to write the equation in a comment. Power Ratio = 10 to the power of (dBc/10). In this case 10 to the (-1.2) power. This equals 0.063. Multiply the power ratio times the original wattage: 2 * 0.063 = 0.126 watts. You can also approximate by the every -3bB is half the power… since -12dBc then half the power 4 times: 2W -> 1W -> 0.5W -> 0.25W -> 0.125W
@adcraziness1501
@adcraziness1501 Ай бұрын
@@KC4NWK ah yes, there is a lot I still get incorrect. Thank you for clarifying. That makes sense.
@bolivarnj
@bolivarnj Ай бұрын
What a great review! Thanks!
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you for watching and dropping a comment! 73!!
@vpnconsult
@vpnconsult Ай бұрын
excellent review
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you so much! Greatly appreciated! 73s
@sekibulja-fu3bv
@sekibulja-fu3bv Ай бұрын
Another excellent video, thank you!!! In your opinion.....do you think Tid radios have better quality components inside when compared to Baofeng and Quashengs? Thank you
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you so much for the comment! I don't honestly think there is much difference at all in the quality of components. On all of these radios they use basically one of two options for the "radio on a chip." They vary slightly in what microprocessor they use. I think its just down to taking the time to try to make sure the radios meet a certain specification before they leave the manufacturer. TIDRadio has definitely shown that they listen to users comments and concerns. They have continued to make rather regular firmware updates to address things that users have found, such as Mic gain, added receive frequencies, etc. The TD-H3 has the same radio chip as the Quansheng UV-K5(8) or UV-K6, but the microprocessor was a little more difficult to reverse engineer. @nicsure is doing some GREAT work on custom firmware for the TD-H3 that will hopefully have it doing similar things in the future as the various custom firmwares for the UV-K5(8)! Thanks again and 73!!!!
@sekibulja-fu3bv
@sekibulja-fu3bv Ай бұрын
Another excellent video you have produced here, thank you!!!!! Have you managed to tear apart one of these tid h3 or h8? I wonder if hardware is better quality compared to Baofeng and quasheng radios???
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you!! I think I answered this in another comment. :) Thanks for the views and comments!!! 73
@Marco-vq7hf
@Marco-vq7hf Ай бұрын
Grazie molte ! Con piacere mi iscrivo al tuo canale. Apprezzo la tua professionalità e "calma" nel mettere a disposizione la tua capacità tecnologica
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you so much!!! I had to run that through Google Translate, but I greatly appreciate the comments and the sub!!! 73
@MrErik038
@MrErik038 Ай бұрын
Very good reveau! These ht's are manufactured from differend parts, the differend signals can differ from the different part-collection as the boulding-batch consists of. For example whit carparts or whashingmachineparts alike ,all expencive bosh- parts consist of tiny components made and sold by weigth and massproduced 😂 the bosh-sticker makes the extra bucks€$£ dollars 😠 Same whit ht devices👍 Nevermind the fancy dark screen, the signal of the one with the bleu screen is clean & strong in watts. Can you not get the wheatherstations anyway like any other ht?! Just progrem the frequentie in the memory to easely recal if needed?! Greetings from the netherlands🇳🇱👍
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Yes I completely agree! You are correct on just programming in the WX frequencies. These manufacturers just like to add little things to try to "wow" the consumers. Its a nice little interface for the WX, but it doesn't make a bit of difference in listening to the forecast! :) Some of these do allow for a WX alert function which will actually alert you if there is a WX alert for your area. Thank you so much for the view and comment!!! 73 to the Netherlands!!
@jaspen8181
@jaspen8181 Ай бұрын
I have had at least three tri band radios, and 220 was always lower output on full power, which made lower output settings closer toether.
@kyawkyaw-g4t
@kyawkyaw-g4t Ай бұрын
how much
@norrinradd8952
@norrinradd8952 Ай бұрын
Well, now we know! Thanks for keeping us informed. Seriously great content you're putting out. That big radio has all the features that nobody asked for on top of being dirty. The frequency scan detection thingy is pretty cool, though. I believe most of my HTs have the CTCSS scan feature, but not frequency, pretty neato. I own about a dozen of the original GT5R. Haven't tested them, but hopefully they really are clean unlike this Pro version. Thanks again for all you do.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you so much for the comment! I was obviously surprised that the Pro model failed. I hope they address this and make sure they are clean moving forward! 73s!
@HOAHamRadio
@HOAHamRadio Ай бұрын
Uh oh, GT5R is supposed to be the clean Feng! Did I hear you correct, it how has air band receive?
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Yeah, honestly I was surprised and disappointed. I'll be curious to see where things go from here. They obviously felt it was still clean based on their advertising. Yes, it does claim air band. Once I saw the radio wasn't clean, I didn't do much more testing. I have it sitting here now on local airport frequency and do hear some activity. It also has that same frequency/code search that I showed on the UV-25, you just press and hold the BAND button. Thanks for stopping by, I appreciate the view and the comment! 73s!
@ugsisr
@ugsisr Ай бұрын
I appreciate you taking the time to perform these test... WOW ! Granted some of these radios are close but these two are Way Out of the Ball Park.. Most all of these low Price Radios are Unpredictable in Power and Spurious Emissions. My guess is Quality Assurance at these factories is Awful... Reason being? Some are clean... Look at the Tidradio TD-H3 Model as a example... I purchased two of these models and luckily they both test clean with power consistency across both Bands I also get good reports when portable. Others I know who purchased them were not as fortunate. Thank You 73's KC3ZDW
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you for the view and comment! TIDRADIO does seem responsive on customer comments. They also generally offer to replace bad radios. Thanks again and 73!!!
@3henry214
@3henry214 Ай бұрын
That's really disappointing to see the regression of the GT-5R Pro back to the UV-5R dirtiness. I too, have the original GT-5R, and it also tests out as a clean radio like yours. And why would anyone want the big brick of a UV-25 ?? I guess if you have the propensity of losing things... it would be difficut to misplace.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Yes I agree, like I said in the video, that must be why they include the lanyard to make sure you don't accidentally misplace it. :) The GT-5R Pro results are really disappointing. They now need to regain our trust by correcting these issues. Thank you so much for the comment!! 73s!
@putteification
@putteification Ай бұрын
Very sloppy of them to send a dirty unit for review. Radioddity should just change their suppliers after this.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thanks for the comment. It does make you wonder how this happens. They obviously thought the radio was still clean based on their advertising. 73s!!
@nine7295
@nine7295 Ай бұрын
Thanks for your honest reviews. There are too many "bought" reviewers on KZbin!
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you so much, I greatly appreciate your comment! Nothing influences my reviews. I show you exactly what I see when I test. I feel I owe it to my viewers to see exactly what I see. 73s!
@craigspada1676
@craigspada1676 Ай бұрын
Excellent video! interesting how bad the radios are, I thought they got their act together with the GTR 5, I guess not. Take care will be looking for the next video. 73's WA2TWF
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Yes, I really didn't expect the results on the GT-5R Pro. I think you can tell in the video how surprised I was. Thank you for the view and comment! 73s!
@ptsoris
@ptsoris Ай бұрын
Thank you for your really comprehensive videos and detailed tear down. I usually do the same with my "toys".... Bad habit since my childhood: first we see what's inside and then we enjoy bring everything together and play. A small question.... Do we have any more info regarding KC251 ? I have bought six H3s and one of them has no power output, while it can be heard within the house, therefore I suspect a faulty output power amplifier. Thanks in advance, Pan.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Yes, I have that same issue. Almost everything comes apart first. :) Thank you so much for the comment and view! I'm sure that they will replace the one bad radio, but if you would like to try something before going down that path, try using their H3PowerTune software. It isn't very intuitive on how to use it, but I messed around with it a bit, and was able to get some of those original low-output power radios up to "spec." There is a problem with the software and if your serial ports are numbered too high, but it is possible to get it to work. There is also another youtuber (@nicsure) that "modified" the executable to fix the issue if you want to download his fixed version. I have no reason to distrust him, but use at your own risk. Here is the link to his video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/sJiYqXZ6dtKpbMU He is also working on an amazing software package for use with the TD-H3!!! Let me know if you have any success with this if you decide to try it! 73s!!
@ptsoris
@ptsoris Ай бұрын
​@@KC4NWK Thanks for yout thorough reply. I have tried both nicsure (actually I am using his altered firmware in most of my devices) and the PowerTune software (original and nicsure's). The latter shows the same values for all bands of the "low power" device as in the normally working devices. I played in the rahe of 25-50 for the lowpower parameter and up to 130 for the midpower. The highpower is not counted by the H3s as I have read and the value there is 255. When you were fiddling with your low powered device which ranges did you alter and which values did you select? I will give it one more try if you provide me with your experienced results. My instinct says though that the output power amplifier is the issue. I downloaded from nicsure the schematic that TIDRADIO provided to him, identified the KC251 as "Q1" in the scematic. If you click on the scematic, each component provides extra info (i.e. Reference description, Reference type, Part description, PCB Decal and Value). For Q1 provides the following extra info: HTU7G_SOT89-E1. Google didn't provide much feedback, but definitely more than searching for KC251. Thank you in advance for your any help!
@elfenmagix8173
@elfenmagix8173 Ай бұрын
The thinig with the UV-5R volume knob really blew my mind!
@mdfogarty
@mdfogarty Ай бұрын
27:38
@SlavaVB
@SlavaVB Ай бұрын
I got my uv5r8w in May 2024, how can I know if it's clean?
@PINOY489
@PINOY489 Ай бұрын
and Now We Know tnx for the effort 73
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you for the comment and view!!! 73s
@Ishkatan
@Ishkatan Ай бұрын
Checking the harmonics is really useful, and seeing the boards fun. Thanks.
@KC4NWK
@KC4NWK Ай бұрын
Thank you for watching and commenting!
@randyguay7115
@randyguay7115 Ай бұрын
I myself wasn't sure so i found a crazy good deal and figured i would try it out . So i love the size , the battery in awesome. So far 1 month in it warks amazing for me. 1 feature that i found and wish more ht radios did this. Mic gain setting. Some ht radios feel like you have bite the face off to speak. This has an amazing mic. And maintians a good audio sound. I am using a luiton lt 771g antenna it works very good for my gmrs and the recieve for other frequencies has been more than adequate.. Thumbs up . For the money you can't touch this radio.