Nope. Dumb rule. If it's obvious, it stands. If it's in question, re roll

Pronounce the game right first

I've been using this rule for fifteen years

The Holiday Hijinks Collection Kickstarter launches October 15th!

The demonstration clearly shows the problem with this approach.

That looks really neat!

Glad you had fun. I know they have a Vegas version in the works.

You had me right up to the wagging finger!

Imagine trying to balance and D20

I play DnD and the rule is that you roll again if it’s cocked at all, no matter how minor, but if it’s a nat 20 then it’s a group decision on if it’s cocked enough for a re roll.

I like it, I'm using it (except on D4)

What, I just take them as they come

what if someone, say A got a high roll (which is good here) but B doesnt like that and says the dice is cocked, so he on purpose pushes it slightly so it falls and get it to reroll?

Ngl, not an issue if i can see the face its indicating. Not gonna sit here and perfectly balance a die on its edge. 😅

Yes

It's a stupid rule, because depending on how careful you are, you can increase or decrease the chance to successfully stack the dice, so it's not 100% random anymore.

Great work, Matt!!

Bananagrams 𝚂𝚝𝚎𝚊𝚕

In the infamous words of Murph “ya gotta honour the cock”

That's a stupid rule if any person with an interest in the result is performing the stack, because it can easily be done in ways that have very different chances of falling. Perhaps okay if the player objecting gets to choose the player they believe would be happiest with the roll, and that player has to do the stack.

Instruction unclear, buying magnetic dice.

No, just roll them in a box or on a surface with no lips if it’s that serious. But realistically, if you can READ the dice clearly you then their value is what the top face of the dice say. It’s not difficult

Instructions: if the roll doesn't favor you, implement this rule. Otherwise, the roll counts.

how fast is it compared to just rerolling whenever a dice ends up like that regardless of if it would have passed the test or not?

I use a size tray so I literally never have to worry about this shit

Personally my rule is, if you can push it onto flat surface and still see the same it’s not cocked.

Can i purposefully stack the die really badly?

if it’s obviously on one side, then it counts. otherwise, reroll

When you start calling a single die a dice is when I begin to disagree 😅😅😅😅😅

you literally demonstrate how this rule is bullshit???

I’m not interested in making the game last even longer😂

During the auction phase I believe the cards are supposed to be faced down so you only see the back of the cards

I just press my finger on the die if if rotates i use that number

No, I'm not stacking anything. We'll find another method. Maybe a smooth, plastic dice tray. Or just reroll everything that is on two surfaces.

Looks very nice

That's a good rule, and one I'll take into all my future dice games.

No d4 is valid

Roll in a box

If its on alege the roller decides

No I just reroll if it's even a lil cocked

Someone tell Laura Bailey and Ashley Johnson

The Lion King, but the live action remake.

An obstruction doesn't remove the randomness of a dice roll so long as its favoring one face, like the 5 in the video. Re-rolling does remove the randomness because it hurts the roller if the roll was favorable or the opponents in an unfavorable. Unless you get the same number again (removing the purpose of a re-roll in the process), re-rolling makes the game less fun for someone.

Does racism play a role ?

This is dumb, if you know where the top is to put the other die…. That’s the top and that’s the rolled result… just use digital dice if people can’t roll dice lol

That's rlly cool, also CATAN TOURNAMENTS ARE A THING? That rules!

If it's a good roll it's valid, if it's a bad roll you reroll

See, my D20 dice towers were just practicing!

You literally displayed way that rule doesn’t work by having it fall off once a then stay with just a slight adjustment to the top die.

Buy a dice tray