Bhai i am literally in love with your videos I mean WOW!! Bhai, i am speechless after this video. It was not at all like a YT video, it felt like a movie. BC fire 🔥 🔥 🔥 Keep it up bhai❤

I know it might be a lot to ask, but can you please add sources of your video. Kinda like a text at some corner calling out the movie or the documentary where the clip is from. Really great work regardless.

Very informative thank you

Yesss Bollywood destroy indian cinema

SATYAJIT RAY THE GOAT

After Long Time , I saw A Good Video on KZbin. This is not Only a Video It's something More......❤

Satyajit Ray was more influenced by Italian neorealism movies like Bicycle thieves to make films than other Indian directors. He wanted to bring that style of film making with amateurs to India

Unrealism simply reflects the temptations of the human condition. European and South American films also feature these "hero temptations," but why do they succeed globally? It's because: They present these elements as perspectives. They allow the characters to navigate these illusions, but from a distance - we, as the audience, understand this, and the director is on our side. This is a key difference. Rather than getting lost in the hero’s dreams, these films have structured plot points, climaxes, and conclusions. The narrative is carefully crafted, and as the character progresses, we are drawn into the story. In contrast, masala films tend to stagnate after the first plot point, with characters remaining static and lacking development. As a result, it's hard for the audience to connect with them unless we’re immersed in those circumstances ourselves.

love this video! keep making these!!

Marathi and Bengali directors jante the film ko kaise bnaya jaata hai

Like how Dhoom 1 was better than Dhoom 2. They focussed on story than foreign locations and weird tech.

Tired of people constantly blaming Bollywood, when mainstream Telugu and Tamil cinema haven't evolved in decades.

That's not pattthar(पथथर) i.e. pather (পথের/पथेर ) @Lokesh Marathe

TWO things happened: 1. Capture of cinema by COMMMUNISTS for propaganda and corruption of Indian culture. 2. Capture of cinema by ISLAMISTS for Urdu based propaganda and distortion of our culture. These are the two main reasons in my opinion.

Most people are not educated enough to understand cinema art...sad but true

Even though many scene from 3 Idiots are also copied from hollywood movies Still This is definitely my most favourite movie

The problem is the people if Interstellar was directed by Christopher nolan with same story and cinematography but with indian actors and sell it as a Bollywood films i cam guarantee u it would be a flop or disaster. Just facts. And then people say it was a masterpiece 😂😂😂 and thath drama.

Chandu champion, the best movie of kartik aaryan and one of the best 2024 movies earned just 90 crore, same with ajay devgan' maidaan which despite being an amazing movie bombed at the box office, on the other hand a movie like Pushpa 2 earned 1570 crore, and after all this people are asking why does Bollywood release good movies

What the hell ending😮

Satyajit Ray: Indian audien are fairly backward.

brainless audience destroy Indian cinema ,, they don't challenge movie makers ,, they just want to see their stars flying on the screen

This is what happens when any form of media attempts to please the general audience instead of showing something to them. And don't think that the general audience is not guilty. They refuse to learn,watch something which is thought provoking, which teaches you something.

Sh Ray and Sh Ghatak were legends. They never took inspiration from any other Indian film directors. Offcourse Sh Phalke and Sh Shantaram were greats.

He predicted his future

Bhai if possible, please try to use the devnagiri script and a better Hindi in your videos. I appreciate your content and right now don't have my Hindi keyboard, but am very puristic about our culture. But if you can't, that's fine too. Please consider my comment.

Initially, I judged Sri Satyajit on his accent thinking "another brown sahib, he must be totally mentally colonized" but as the video progressed, I was left thinking "if there was one person trying to pull us out of the colonial mindset, it was him". Jai Shri Ram bhai, keep up the good work.

Not Patthar Panchali bro. PATHER PANCHALI is pronounced as "Pother Panchali" .. Great video anyways. Keep it up.

Bhai itne bhi sach nahi bolna tha, audience ko hazam nahi hoga 😂 Satyajit Ray and Shyam Benegal were the real pioneers of parallel cine.. but aaj ke Zamane mein audience have adapted to mirch-masala. Swades, masaan, bhumika, jaane bhi do yaaron and there are so many more to be named that deserved recognition.

Good video essay, but too many factual errors bro. Like, 1. You said Sholay is a copy of seven samurai, but showed "Once upon a time in the west" as scene copy. 2. It's "Memento", not "Momento", also I wouldn't say Ghajini is a direct copy, it's inspired, in the right way.

Loved to watch this video but Ray's Pather Panchali sounds different in your narration, it's not patthar. As people spell Path then notice Bengali prefer to say 'o' rather than aa so we Bengali say Pother it means Path's and panchali is lyrical naration. A lyrical naration of the road/path. Actually it's an age old tradition when bengali housewives used to recite the lyrical note of mata laxmi on her grace. If we go back then we shall be able to understand the term 'Panchali' derived from the ancient bengali poetry collections of God and goddess. So original writer Bibhutibhushan Bandopadhaya saheb used such word(Panchali) to describe the journey of economically poor people of India. Hope this helps.

Farah Khan is going to remake one more 2024 Bengali Movie "Bahurupi"

Satyajit Ray, the creator of "Feluda" ❤

Patthar panchali nahi, That's "Pother Panchali"

Hollywood mein kb normal logo ya real world pe film bni ....ya to insaan bda Chhota kr denge ,kutte,khargish le aaenge, dinosaur,spider man ye wo

Everyone is talking about our indian cinema but as a Bengali I truly disappoint how Bengali cinema dying day by day. Once they were considered as a peace of art...you can found gems amonge these...like soumitra, uttam kumar, mrinal sen, hrithik ghotok and all above, main star of the video, who was face of indian cum Bengali cinema to the world at a time was The Great Satyajit Ray.

Indian audience needs to GROW UP

Simple advise to those non-bengali cinema lover: start watching bengali art film , you'll fall in love in our film.

It's not patthar panchali, it's pather panchali here poth means street/road and panchali means lyrical poetry.

Absolute cinemaaaa

Actually It's not Patthar Panchali , It's Pather Panchali , It's referring to the bengali word " POTH " meaning the " The Road ".

2:08 its Pather Panchali which translates to The Song of The Road and not Patthar Panchali

2:44 Definately Correct.

Stardom my foot, mere kuchh favorite actor & actress hai, par agar wo mere sheher me kabhi aate hai to me lawda unhe dekhne nahi jata hu, wo apna kaam kar rahe hai, jaise nagar nigam ka staff mere mohalle me jhadu lagane aata hai, jabki nagar nigam walo ka kaam jyada nada hai

Making people laugh and entertain is also a art. Making boring cinema in the name of art isn't a art. This intellectual superiority mindset doesn't change anything. People choice of cinema depends on many factors like culture education and tradition

Art is subjective

Good Video, Satyajit Ray stays ever true. People are indeed backward and art, proper art will always be a failure at the box office with this audience. However I cant say much of other regions but in Bengal we have a couple of good artistic movies coming out in recent times which are having a moderate success. Windows production house is a pioneer in my opinion.

Mann this was actually a really inspiring story it just shows that if you work hard you will eventually get the things you want you will need to lose some blood and sweat but you will see the results to your efforts . Someday i also want to meet him . Even though my dream is completely different from his i am looking forward to seeing him in the future.❤

Thank you very much for showing really deep and artistic masterpieces! I was surprised by the quality of classical Indian cinema. It is not very well-known abroad though it is really beautiful. ❤

Indian population is unsophisticated in its tastes. Harsh but true words by Satyajit Ray Even when he was making "Pather Panchali" no producer invested in his film and at last the government did to some extent the Indian public didn't accept it but when it got awards in the west very likely our audiences lapped it. We copy the west,we accept everything the west accepts,we reject everything the west rejects but west has no civilization we do 😂😂😂😂😂

Every era movies are made as per the generation watching them. Like if you sit with your Grandfather you will have difference in opinion, he is right as per his time but your understanding does not line with it. Movies are reflection of present society and also entertainment. However we know that the cycle repeats so we may see the fashion change again