Russia Brief: The Stakes in Ukraine
1:07:18
Russia Brief: Soviet Nostalgia
1:01:10
2 жыл бұрын
Russia Brief: Belarus in Exile
1:00:43
2 жыл бұрын
Пікірлер
@user-km3hv8qo9p
@user-km3hv8qo9p 19 күн бұрын
Ani Chkhikvadze’s recent interview with Noam Chomsky showed her to be fantatical US propagandist. She is completely brainwashed and has no understanding of Ukranians, but just reads the propaganda lines fed to the US. Having lived in Ukraine myself 2015-2020 the overwhelming view of the public is the opposite of her idiology. You think they view the US as a more free country than Russia? Wake up. Ukranians want a stable life, economic development and education and don’t care what the US wants for itself. The US goal of future NATO membership in all surrounding regions of Russia is to provoke conflict with Russia, and not even regarding that it is a nuclear power. When Cuba was legally defended by USSR we almost blew the world up in response. The rampant US and British NGOs activity in Ukraine with vicious anti-Russia rhetoric over for years prior to the 2014 coup in Kiev - which I saw with my own eyes in horror - have now led to all of these hundreds of thousands of deaths. The same will be for Georgia if US interference there is not made illegal. You can understand why Russia offered protection to Crimea after the 2014 coup - without that the whole place would have been a NATO de facto military base almost instantly. If we just stay away from the affairs of Ukraine all would have been well, and if we get away from trying to influence Ukraine today, it will be the fastest path to allowing the country to be safe and capable to economically develop.
@edsgerdijkstra3488
@edsgerdijkstra3488 23 күн бұрын
Saying sometime is incorrect is an opinion. Try using some facts next time. Maybe provide a source.
@Dumpsteret1
@Dumpsteret1 29 күн бұрын
A comment on your recent interview with Noam Chomsky. In your efforts to prove there is an inherent Russian aggressive nature that poses a threat justifying a country's Nato membership, I would remind you all the conflicts on Russia's southern rim you mentioned, including Georgia, erupted as a result of the dissolution of the Soviet Union and liberation of Central and Eastern Europe in 1991. A dissolution Russia was instrumental in facilitating. The conflicts all spontaneous ethnic border enclaves wishing to remain with Russia, none were planned in the Kremlin. The plan in the Kremlin was the dissolution of the SU and liberation of Central Eastern Europe. Citing them as proof of an inherent Russian aggressive nature people need to be worried about is a hollow propaganda narrative crumbling under scrutiny in my opinion. As is your citing Chechnya, a state in the RF, a civil war between Chechens wishing to remain in Russia and a foreign backed radical Islamic revolt seeking to establish a Chechen Caliphate. Would you cite U.S. aggression if we crushed an Islamic takeover of Texas? All Russia has wanted and needed from Europe the past 100 years is security guarantees. Not giving it to them is what caused the Russian Civil War, WWII, and now the Ukraine war. Russia isn't your enemy, U.S. GB Neo Con psychopaths are.
@user-km3hv8qo9p
@user-km3hv8qo9p 18 күн бұрын
I agree with all of these words. Furthermore it often not appreciated that the dismantling of the USSR was not at all internally or structurally catalyzed, but rather the result of continual rampant US and British political interference in USSR starting well before 1992, even as far back as the 1980s it was in full swing. If USSR had not been dismantled, all of the conflicts near Russia’s borders would not exist.
@peterbusscher8356
@peterbusscher8356 2 ай бұрын
Great lecture. Beware frightening audio distortion at 49:11
@agiaa5879
@agiaa5879 3 ай бұрын
Jakkolwiek, wywiad byl okay, nie moge sie skupic na tym, co.pan Prezydent mowi, skupiajac sie na jego krzywo zawiazanym krawacie😅
@Michail781000
@Michail781000 4 ай бұрын
ПРИЯТНО ПОСМОТРЕТЬ !!!!!!!!!!
@shoesuite
@shoesuite 7 ай бұрын
nice obstructed view
@blueeyeddevil9441
@blueeyeddevil9441 8 ай бұрын
What is the fixation with the number 6,000,000 to Judaism? nanomatic.fi/pdf/6million.pdf
@100lb_stull
@100lb_stull 9 ай бұрын
Respect for the speaker, but you can here in his voice, how he stressed about his bun..
@thestratocaster
@thestratocaster 7 ай бұрын
wtf is this comment...
@100lb_stull
@100lb_stull 9 ай бұрын
Лекция длительностью в час, это мощно, мощнее только нервы, спикера, который понимает, что его булочка уже не его...
@henrykstopikowski5379
@henrykstopikowski5379 9 ай бұрын
Kwasniewski est un mauvais agent communiste du Kremlin. Il n’a jamais été le président des vrais patriotes polonais et ne le sera jamais !
@henrykstopikowski5379
@henrykstopikowski5379 9 ай бұрын
¡El señor Kwasniewski no es ni un hombre ni un presidente! ¡Es un ladrón y traidor comunista que es un agente del Kremlin!
@henrykstopikowski5379
@henrykstopikowski5379 9 ай бұрын
>tow. kwasniewski vel stolzman, bolszewicka gnido, dlaczego w 2000 roku zmusiles swojego ministra Siwca do szyderstwa z gestu papieskiego blogoslawienstwa i nakazales jemu aby dalej obrazal naszego Wielkiego Papieza Ojca Swietego Jana Pawla II? Do konca zycia nie zrozumiem jak taki parch jak ty, mogl do tego sie dopuscic. Z jednej strony nadskakiwales Papiezowi, chwalac sie, ze na zamku kaplice wybudowales a z drugiej strony tak go ponizales? Soviecki durniu w swoich obrzydliwosciach szatana przerosles. ZACHOWAJ TALMUT RAZEM Z LEGITYMACJA PARTYJNA, MOZE CI POMOGA? tow. STOLZMAN, KOMUNISTYCZNY GENIUSZ SPOD BUDKI Z PIWEM, PRZYWODCA KOSZER NOSTRA, NACZELNY SZABES GOJ, POWIELACZ MOWY POGRZEBOWEJ. NEGOCJATOR W MONOPOLOWYM. ZASLUZONY SPORTOWIEC prl-u NA 4X100%, CZY POLACY NA CZELE Z PREZYDENTEM DUDA PYTALI CIEBIE JAKIE GLUPSTWA TY POPELNIALES? WIEKSZEGO GLUPSTWA NIKT NIE MOGLBY ZROBIC, JAK TY, KIEDY NA UROCZYSTOSCI W CHARKOWIE/KATYNIU PIJANY JAK SWINIA SLALOMEM MIEDZY GROBAMI ZAMIATALES, DAJAC TYM WYRAZ SWOJEGO UBOLEWANIA I WSPOLCZUCIA DLA RODZIN POMORDOWANYCH. JAK SPRZEDAWALES KOPALNIE NA SLASKU (dzisiaj ci ludzie sa tam bez pracy) I POLSKIE POLIGONY ORAZ JEDNOSTKI WOJSKOWE Z DRUGIM ARCYZLODZIEJEM, KTORY JEST SAM BEKARTEM, A MOWI O POLSCE, ZE "POLSKA ZACHOWUJE SIE JAK WRZESZCZACY BEKART", tow. SS-STURMBANNFUHRER-em, kpr MILLEREM, BOLSZEWICKIM WROGIEM RZECZPOSPOLITEJ KTORY ODMOWIL GAZU Z NORWEGI WCISKAJAC KLAMSTWA POLAKOM, ZE GAZ Z ROSJI JEST TANSZY I USILUJACY PODPISAC UMOWE Z KREMLEM NA DOSTAWE TEGO GAZU AZ DO 2045 ROKU. MILLER, PO CO TUMANIE TO ZROBILES? W D.PE PUTINOWI JESZCZE GLEBIEJ CHCIALES WEJSC? AZ AFERA RIWINA CIEBIE ZGNOILA UKAZAUJAC JAKIM ARCYZLODZIEJEM BYLES. A TERAZ JESZCZE W BRUKSELI POLSKE OCZERNIASZ? KWASNIEWSKI W 1998 ROKU STOCZNIOWCY POTRZEBOWALI TWOJEJ POMOCY GDY STOCZNIE GDANSKA SPRZEDAWANO ALE TY PRZEZ 7 (SIEDEM) DNI WRAZ Z BALCEROWICZEM SIE UKRYWALES ABY NIE MOZNA BYLO WAS ZNALEZC, BO ROZKAZ Z MOSKWY NADSZEDL ABY KOLEBKE SOLIDARNOSCI ZLIKWIDOWAC! CZY ZASTANAWIALES SIE DLACZEGO Z SEJMU PO DRABINIE PRZEZ OKNO WYCHODZILES? NIE! PONIEWAZ BYLES PIJANY JAK PROSIAK. DLACZEGO BANDERA ONZ-tu SIE OWIJALES? ZIMNO CIE BRALO LUB ZA MALO % W TWOIM ORGANIZMIE BYLO? PREZYDENT DUDA JEST DOKTORANTEM I TYM SIE NIE CHWALI, NATOMIAST TY, SWOIM TYTULEM mgr-a, ZDOBYTYM PO 3 AKADEMIACH (1majowej, lipcowej i pazdziernikowej ORAZ AKADEMI NA LUBIANCE), LUDZIOM CIEMNOTE WCISKALES. DLACZEGO UKRAINCOW SAVOIR-VIVRE PO PIJAKU UCZYLES? CZYZBYS CHOROWAL NA NADMIAR FILIPINSKIEJ ZARAZY? DLACZEGO DO SAMOCHODU PRZEZ BAGAZNIK WCHODZILES? SIKAC NA MUR (szkoda, ze nie kremlowski), ZADNEMU PREZYDENTOWI NIE PRZYSTOI, CHYBA TAKIEMU JAK TY, PAJACOWI. PREZYDENT DUDA AGENTEM SOVIECKIM NIE JEST PODCZAS, GDY TY W DALSZYM CIAGU PRACUJESZ DLA NICH, DLATEGO CIEBIE ZROBILI PREZYDENTEM ABYS POLSKE ZNISZCZYL. DO DZISIAJ POLACY PLACA ZA TWOJE EKSTRAWAGANCJE, PODCZAS GDY TY I TWOJA Jola, EXPERT OD WIELU "CHARYTATYWNYCH FUNDACJI", D.PY W HISZPANII WYGRZEWACIE I PO INNYCH KRAJACH SIE WLOCZYCIE ZA POLAKOW PIENIADZE. PREZYDENT DUDA NIE CHWALI SIE, ZE putin JEMU "GUZIKI ATOMOWE W SAMOCHODZIE"? POKAZYWAL (jak widac, nawet nie chcialby z nim rozmawiac) A TY OD CHWALENIA SIE GDZIE BYLES I CO WIDZIALES I JAKIE MOWY POGRZEBOWE PAPLALES ("WOJCIECHU SPOCZNIJ", SOVIECCY AGENCI BACZNOSC!)? NIE MOZESZ SIE USPOKOIC. POLSKA WSTAPILA DO NATO I DO UE ALE NIE Z TWOJA POMOCA.TY I SIKORSKI ROBILISCIE WSZYSTKO ABY DO TEGO NIE DOSZLO. PIALES JAK PODRZYNANY KOGUT "NIE IDZCIE TA DROGA" A TERAZ KLAMLIWIE WSZEDZIE GLOS ZABIERASZ I KOTA OGONEM ODWRACASZ, BEZCZELNIE UDOWADNIAJAC, ZE TO TWOJA ZASLUGA. GORLIWIE ZACHECALES ZACHOD ZA NAMOWA SOVIETOW ABY PRZYJETO federacje rosyjska DO NATO, CO W KIJOWIE NA WYKLADZIE POD 45% DOPALACZEM JAKO PRAWDZIWY WIZJONER POWIEDZIALES: ..."придет день когда Россия будет в НАТО..." (NADEJDZIE DZIEN GDY ROSJA BEDZIE W NATO). WSZYSTKIM RADY DAJESZ TYLKO SOBIE NIE MOZESZ POMOC I DALEJ FILIPINSKA ZARAZA CIEBIE ATAKUJE! POLACY GLOSOWALI NA CIEBIE PONIEWAZ BYLI OTUMANIENI SOVIECKA PROPAGANDA (wg mnie to nie byli Polacy, inaczej bys nigdy zadnych wyborow nie wygral). POLONIA NA CALYM SWIECIE NA CIEBIE NIE GLOSOWALA! DLATEGO PRAWDZIWI POLACY, PATRIOCI DO DZISIAJ ZASTANAWIAJA SIE JAK DO TEGO DOSZLO? DLACZEGO W CZASIE SWOICH KADENCJI 196 TYSIECY ODZNACZEN PANSTWOWYCH ROZDALES, W TYM 69 OSOBOM ORDERY ORLA BIALEGO, WLACZAJAC KOMUNISTYCZNYCH AGENTOW I WROGOW RZECZPOSPOLITEJ NA CZELE Z adolfem putinem, POLITRUKIEM mjr-em sokorskim, SWOIM KOLESIEM KOMUNISTYCZNA SZUJA - RECZKIEM. ZDRAJCAMI: KURONIEM, MODZELEWSKIM, KOLAKOWSKIM, GIEREMKIEM? DLACZEGO W OSTATNIM DNIU SWOJEGO URZEDOWANIA NAJWIEKSZYCH POLSKICH KRYMINALISTOW ULASKAWILES? (w tym, agenta sb piotra filipczynskiego ps "peter fogiel" naczelny bankier Bank CUS w Szwajcarii, ktory CIOTKE SIEKIERA ZAMORDOWAL A WASZE BRUDNE PIENIADZE DOBRZE TAM CHRONI na kontach cyfrowych) i DO DZIASIAJ NIKT NIE WIE, GDZIE TEN MORDERCA SIE UKRYWA? tow. STOLZMAN W 1995 ROKU PODCZAS PREZYDENCKIEJ DEBATY WYPOWIEDZIAL NASTEPUJACE SLOWA: "CHCIALBYM BYC TAKIM CZLOWIEKIEM I TAKIM PREZYDENTEM Z KTOREGO BEDZIECIE DUMNI A MY RAZEM BEDZIEMY BYC DUMNI Z POLSKI, KTORA TWORZYMY" (pisownia oryginalna), "Z KOMUNISTYCZNA, BOLSZEWICKA SZCZEROSCIA, ALEKSANDER KWASNIEWSKI", DOPOWIEDZIAL PREZYDENT WALESA. WG MNIE MIAL 100% RACJE PONIEWAZ TWOJE OSWIADCZENIE GRABIAMI NA WODZIE BYLO PISANE! JAKO PRAWDZIWI POLACY, PATRIOCI NIE MOZEMY BYC DUMNI Z TAKIEGO "PREZYDENTA" KTORY DO DZISIEJSZEGO DNIA NIE WIE GDZIE JEST JEGO OJCZYZNA. NIC NIE PISZESZ O SWOIM OJCU? Plk IZAAK STOLZMAN NKWD-ki AGENT, LUDOBOJCA. DOBRZE PRZYSLUZYL SIE SOVIETOM W MORDOWANIU POLSKIEJ OPOZYCJI, ZOLNIERZY AK, NSZ, JENCOW NIEMIECKICH I MARYNARZY SZWEDZKICH. DLACZEGO TO ROBIL? BO WIDZIAL POLSKE SOVIECKA NIE POLSKA, PODOBNIE JAK JEGO SYNALEK - (niedaleko pada jablko od jabloni)! DLACZEGO POD NAZWISKIEM DR KOWALSKI ZWLOKI SWOJEGO OJCA NA CMENTARZ W Wwie W 1998 ROKU PRZENIOSLES, DORABIAJAC MU HISTORIE, ZE SIE "PRZEFARBOWAL" I JEST KATOLIKIEM"? POTRZEBNE TO BYLO DO TWOJEJ, ZBLIZAJACEJ SIE KAMPANI WYBORCZEJ. "KUTY" TO JESTES NA 4 NOGI! KOSZERNY, STAN KROCZEM DO SOCJALIZMU, NAWET W BANANOWEJ REPUBLICE ANI NA KUBIE TEGO GOW.A NIE ZBUDUJESZ! P.S.: tow KWASNIEWSKI vel STOLZMAN, W JEZYKU FRANCUSKIM, MOWI SIE: "sawlar-wiwr" ("L" Z KRESKA UKOSNA) a nie (samwar wiwre) - na Lubiance nie uczyli? - nie wymazuj tego wpisu, MAM KOPIE I BEDE POWIELAL! 27/07/2023. Kwaśniewski ułaskawił 3295 osób; odmówił ułaskawienia 795 osobom (I kadencja), ułaskawił 993 osoby; odmówił ułaskawienia 1317 osobom (II kadencja).
@lauramaria7753
@lauramaria7753 9 ай бұрын
Romania , SECRET SERVICE, TAKE THAT RAPIST AWAY FROM ME ,THAT DANGEROUS RAPIST ANA-MARIA RUS DUMITRACHE , WHO CONSPIRED W/ YOU TO HAVE PLACED ON ME A CRIMINAL SCHEME. AFTER ALL HER SLANDER ABT ME TO THE ROM. SECRET SERVICE 2006, THAT I GOT PLACED ON WATCH LIST BODY DESINTEGRATION PROGRAM. TAKE AWAY FROM ME HER CESAREAN THAT YOU PLACED IT ON ME TO PAY FOR IT . SATISFACTION FOR WHAT IF SHE CONSPIRED AGAINST ME W/ ROM. SECRET SERVICE. TAKE OUT OF ME THE OTHER RAPIST OANA ALINA CIOROGAR WITH HER HUGE NATURAL VAGINA THAT SHE WANNA PERFORM ON ANOTHER WOMAN. AND MONICA MORARU the german favourite with her order of BURNED OVARIES. GET OUT OF ME ROMANIANS WITH YOUR LAND MOLDAVIA. Take off me THE HIGH END PROSTITUTIES aka models, PRINCESSES YOU PLACED ON ME on 1000 schemes together with the murderers English Mi5 TO STEAL MY BODY PROPORTIONS & MY PERFECT HEALTH w/ nuclear radiation. Get the he'll out OF ME RAPISTS w/ your high end prostitutes. GET OUT RAPISTS, GET OUT RAPISTS, GET OUT ROMANIANS RAPISTS. GET OUT OFF ME ASAP ROMANIANS MURDERERS & REFUND ALL U HAVE TAKEN FROM ME. EVERY SINGLE PIECE, EVERY SINGLE cm, EVERY SINGLE mm. You played a game by yourself & dropped on me , either away I beat u 100 times. You transferred my spending to the Indian woman Oshin Tomar, Greek woman Elena, Scandinavian woman, british mixed races woman. And take away from me the other DANGEROUS criminal MONICA MORARU WHO PLACED A ORDER TO BURN MY OVARIES COZE ITS MY FAULT FOR HER SUPPLYING SLANDER TO THE ROMANIAN SECRET SERVICE BACK IN TIME . REFUND MY FINGERS ASAP, AND MY INTERNAL ORGANS.
@piotrdobrzynski9803
@piotrdobrzynski9803 Жыл бұрын
SLD (a left-wing party) is nothing more than a fake secularist party and a pseudo-secularist party. During the time the party has ruled Poland, SLD has done nothing to preserve the separation of the church and state, which has happened by the enactment of the 1993 concordat (the agreement between Poland and the Vatican) being signed by the ex-president of Poland Alexsander Kwasniewski in 1998, despite of the fact that the majority of the SLD MPs were against the concordat. What Aleksander Kwasniewski did was a form of treason towards Poland, as signing the concordat violated the rule in the Polish constitution with regards to the separation of church and state. Aleksander Kwasniewski has mindlessly enabled the politically catholic influence and political pressure into Poland from the Vatican by signing this concordat, which has lead to crosses being displayed onto the walls in public places and taxpayer funded places such as schools. I think that signing the concordat has lead to adding praying rooms in public places and tax payer funded places such as airports due to my experience of going to an airport in Lublin, Poland and have seen a sign under the ceiling saying as to where the praying room in the airport is. I have mentioned Aleksander Kwasniewski, because he was a member of SLD. Aleksander Kwasniewski has betrayed SLD MPs. In conclusion, Alexander Kwasniewski is nothing more than a criminal traitor that has committed treason towards Poland, the people of Poland and SLD MPs. I think that Alexsander Kwasniewski should be in prison for mindlessly enabling politically catholic atrocity. What I am saying is hypothetical.
@wlook7192
@wlook7192 Жыл бұрын
Best regards from Berlin
@nilyushamishkina3069
@nilyushamishkina3069 Жыл бұрын
I wanted to come many famous scientists writers and celebrities to Uzbekistan! At that time different unknown actors come here, who never thought about Uzbekistan before sanctions
@ROMANABSOLUT
@ROMANABSOLUT Жыл бұрын
Would you care to present the facts in Romania between 1948 - 1965 ? Also to includ a "Democracy" chapter in the mentioned period.
@indonesiamenggugat8795
@indonesiamenggugat8795 Жыл бұрын
🌹🌹
@denismorgan9742
@denismorgan9742 Жыл бұрын
Moldova has to desolve Transnistra as a Russian enclave and declare it 100 percent Moldovan and under NATO.
@ANM1991GEORGIA
@ANM1991GEORGIA 2 жыл бұрын
all historical facts wrong and fake
@henrykstopikowski5379
@henrykstopikowski5379 2 жыл бұрын
Kwasniewski is a good actor who perfectly senses political trends. Once with the communists, once with the nation! Nothing concrete can be seen from his speech. I am surprised that such an excellent University invites a meaningless politician who deceived the Polish nation during his tenure and today does the same by telling nonsense.
@jacekguchowski3374
@jacekguchowski3374 8 ай бұрын
Prezydent Kwaśniewski to klasa sama w sobie-jako człowiek, jako polityk. To jemu w znacznej mierze Polska zawdzięcza szybki rozwój , a dziś bezpieczeństwo. Mógłby zadbać o swoje interesy, ale nade wszystko jest przyzwoitym człowiekiem. Nie było drugiego tak godnego najwyższych zaszczytów Polaka. Może miarą będzie, że Królowa Elżbieta obdarzyła Jego i małżonkę przyjaźnią? Prezydenci amerykańscy również wypowiadają się o nim z uznaniem. Teraz mamy śmiecia na urzędzie. Bo to nie jest nawet do śmiechu. duda to okropna kompromitacja Polski. Zastanawia mnie, jakich to wspaniałych rzeczy dokonał henryk stopikowski, żeby tak opluć wielkiego człowieka. Najprawdopodobniej jest to kolejna miernota, którą trawi zawiść, o to, że nic sobą nie reprezentuje! To takie polskie! POlacy zamiast czuć dumę z dobrych, skromnych, znanych ludzi, zazdroszczą, że nimi nie są!
@henrykstopikowski5379
@henrykstopikowski5379 2 жыл бұрын
l dit folie de parler. Il n'a rien dit de précis. Dommage que l'argent que Kwasniewski ait été payé pour cela.
@gregorykupicz9699
@gregorykupicz9699 2 жыл бұрын
THE BEST PRESIDENT OF POLAND....
@henrykstopikowski5379
@henrykstopikowski5379 Жыл бұрын
avec vu
@henrykstopikowski5379
@henrykstopikowski5379 9 ай бұрын
@gregorykupicz9699 Do you know this traitor? Did you know he was the greatest thief? Did you know that he betrayed Poland to the Soviets because he was their agent? Did you know he's a staunch communist? He became the president of Poland because the Kremlin put him in that position!
@m.k.s.7417
@m.k.s.7417 2 жыл бұрын
What if: EVERYONE, (In the whole -Wide: World): "Refused to join; either: Militaries, Gangs and/or; Terror-ism/terror-ist orgs.!!"??
@m.k.s.7417
@m.k.s.7417 2 жыл бұрын
**Also too: what if: "The [very]_Eurasian"/"Trans-Continental"/Mid. East-ern and/or; Med. Countries/Nations ALL: "Worked to make PEACE!!"??** -(M.K.S. They can!!)!!
@wiktoriawojcik5373
@wiktoriawojcik5373 2 жыл бұрын
Doweaszcyui
@genghissu1185
@genghissu1185 2 жыл бұрын
Obsessed with the number 6 Million since 1915
@michaellawson6533
@michaellawson6533 2 жыл бұрын
No , since 1850
@djpatc63
@djpatc63 2 жыл бұрын
Paula has great legs!!
@GIGACHAD-KR
@GIGACHAD-KR 2 жыл бұрын
awesome, legend videos never die
@kittie_el_fantazmobulsara4302
@kittie_el_fantazmobulsara4302 2 жыл бұрын
👋 hey Mark, ❤this book.. can't wait to read Smashing the liquor machine:)
@Cheesg
@Cheesg 2 жыл бұрын
Please dont see this guy as somebody who represent Poland, he is the red piece of shiet from previous regime in Poland. He is the disgrace to Poland and we feel ashamed that he speak as polish guy.
@rais.online
@rais.online 3 жыл бұрын
I am also interested in this topic. Thank you for the video (almost after 8 years, but anyway)! I really enjoyed it! Many things are true, but there are also some minor mistakes. 6:02. It's important to mention here that Tatarstan held a referendum for independence in 1992. People were asked whether they want or doesn't want Tatarstan to be a sovereign state, a subject to international law which establishes relations with other republics/countries based on bilateral agreements. 61,4% of Tatarstani people approved the message. 7:00. I agree that some Tatar nationalists considered the treaty a betrayal, but many of them supported it because Tatarstan failed to cooperate with Bashkortostan. Tatarstan & Bashkortostan could've joined together and got the Quwandiq and Ghaysin districts of the Orenburg region (with approx. 50-60% indigenous Tatar-Bashkort population) and finally got the border with Kazakhstan. That's how Tatar people were thinking in the early 1990s, but because the negotiations failed, the project for independence was not an option. 7:30. The 2007 treaty is a new treaty; the Russian government abandoned the old one in 2003-2005. There were no treaties between 2005 and 2007. Actually, during these years, the Tatar parliament upvoted the new version of the constitution, which considers Tatarstan a sovereign country and a federal subject. Following the original constitution, sovereignty is undeniable and inalienable quality of Tatarstan. It is interesting that Tatarstan's constitution still has articles on the republic's sovereign status because they cannot be amended by the parliamentarians or other republican or Russian authorities. 9:00. Jihad idea is nonsense in the case of Tatarstan because of the secular character of Islam here. As you said at the beginning, many professors and academic men supported the sovereignty movement. In the 1990s, Fandas Safiullin was the head of All-Tatar Public Center (one of the Tatar nationalist movement's key organizations), and he is a very secular man. 11:00. They were also kolkhozes in Tatarstan until the end of the 1990s. 16:20. Tatarstan has no duma; it's a Supreme Council of Tatarstan before 1995 and the State Council (Tatarstan Comhuriyate Dawlat Shurasy) :) 17:40. The Tatar Yangalif-2 alphabet adopted by the Tatarstan's SC was based on a common Turkic alphabet, but instead of using some Turkic letters like ä, ü, ö we used ә ü ө in our Latin alphabet. Suleymanova wrote a good article on the Latin script: www.zora.uzh.ch/id/eprint/31944/. 20:30. I agree, but Wahhabism is not a big problem for Tatarstan because of a very secular culture of people and a strong Sufi movement. Thank you for reading all of my comments!
@kadambaykhudaykulov3446
@kadambaykhudaykulov3446 3 жыл бұрын
👍
@rodolfovitangcol208
@rodolfovitangcol208 3 жыл бұрын
Million Dollar Potential in Ruvol I have invented a Board Game [still unpublished] that is guaranteed to be far more challenging and exciting to play than CHESS. I called it “RUVOL.” Over time, Ruvol will surpass chess as the “Number One Board Game in the World.” Why am I so sure about this? Because I am an avid chess player myself. I found chess to be so repetitive that any clever player could easily master the moves to a point they could even play against opponents blindfolded. It is for this reason I invented a game where every game is always a new challenge and exciting to play. Ruvol is played almost somewhat like chess. The kind of people who play chess will be the same kind of people who will play Ruvol. I invented Ruvol primarily to give chess a direct “apple-to-apple” competition. Right now, there is no other board game in the world within the same category of chess “where chess players can switch to.” Chess is entirely a monopoly in its class. And Ruvol will change that! In my Google search, I learned there are around 800 million chess players in the world. These 800 million players comprise the “Total Potential Buyers” of Ruvol across the globe. At an average profit of just US$5 per set, the “Global Income Potential” of Ruvol then is US$4 billion. Assuming only 1% of it will buy each year, the annual global potential sale is US$40M. I AM SELLING MY COPYRIGHT TO RUVOL. For the reason that I don’t have the resources to publish Ruvol on a global scale, I find it “wiser and faster” to simply sell my copyright. If you are interested to buy my copyright, email me your BEST PRICE OFFER-[the copyright goes to the highest bidder]. My email address is: [email protected]. [Or perhaps you can help me find a buyer, and I’ll reward you with a commission.] Early bird catches the worm! RODOLFO MARTIN VITANGCOL The Ruvol Inventor
@tamrikojojua3317
@tamrikojojua3317 3 жыл бұрын
A great man and patriot! How we miss him.
@johndock9164
@johndock9164 3 жыл бұрын
It's very much obvious, mostly Russian sources have been used for this lecture, because most historical facts she is talking about are wrong or never happened.
@vanS808
@vanS808 4 жыл бұрын
Brenda Shaffer is a paid PR Whore for corrupt oil rich dictatorships with strong relationships with Turkey & Azerbaijan her opinions should be taken with a grain of salt, as she sold her soul a long time for a few gold coins
@user-qx6dc2yh9r
@user-qx6dc2yh9r 4 жыл бұрын
Published on Oct 2015 and no comments. Why?
@michaellawson6533
@michaellawson6533 2 жыл бұрын
Returned error , thats why.
@brandysheriff2515
@brandysheriff2515 7 ай бұрын
What do you mean? Returned error?
@crackerjack4790
@crackerjack4790 4 жыл бұрын
This is a great book! It sure explains a lot.
@allenmarcelin6323
@allenmarcelin6323 4 жыл бұрын
That is the topical Euro-centric world view ,any where you find black excellence in achievements he was from a slave origin .Never indigenous Never original creators of nations ,Empires ,civilizations .History has proven this method false
@DanielOnidi
@DanielOnidi 4 жыл бұрын
Appalling sound recording… The Chairman's paper folding, or grunts, override the speakers mic. Added to which, the guests seeming disinterest (continuing to eat throughout) doesn't help the speaker to focus. Interesting discussion - terribly produced!
@calripson
@calripson 5 жыл бұрын
Somethings are so laughably transparent as to deserve no comment. This is one such example.
@hyacinthfindlay5806
@hyacinthfindlay5806 5 жыл бұрын
Thank you professor for your research and the fairness in your report I hope your book does well.
@GreenOrchid9
@GreenOrchid9 5 жыл бұрын
Great hidden story...so many untold💡🍸
@nicy1544
@nicy1544 5 жыл бұрын
Center of Eurasian Russian ..., thanks so much. I went back and back on the story. It's so fascinating. Thanks for having the courage to display it, regardless.
@nicy1544
@nicy1544 5 жыл бұрын
Professor, I can't thank you enough for such a beautiful piece of history. As a Black Caribbean woman, I am touched and very grateful. God bless you.
@Ronbo710
@Ronbo710 5 жыл бұрын
Sad this has received no comments in the last five years. No wonder history repeats itself in all its tragic forms.
@vinzholton
@vinzholton 5 жыл бұрын
stop bringing these kgb spies to talk!
@goofballfilms1
@goofballfilms1 6 жыл бұрын
Well done Dr. Kangas! Very comprehensive, good pacing, fluid, and engaging.
@AlexanderJohnLee
@AlexanderJohnLee 6 жыл бұрын
I liked that much of the presentation was dedicated to the long history of the region, however, I wish you had spoken more regarding the military conflict in 2008 and current diplomatic relations. For years leading up to 2008 the Russian government had been giving citizenship to Abhazians and to people in Southern Ossetia. When Saakashvili attacked Southern Ossetia and then threatened to attack Abkhazia, Russia "justified" military action by looking at Article 51 Chapter 7 of the UN Treaty that states that Russia (any UN state) can defend itself (it was defending the sovereignty of it's citizens) without consulting the Security Council. It is a very intersting region to study.