Thank you Victoria for documenting the most brutal and unfortunate episodes of our national life and dedicating your 50 years or more to cover our saga.

Hoodboy = confuse.com

Absorbing discussion. Islam is not just a religion, but also a sharply defined way of life . The spread of Islam therefore resulted in effacing several cultures and languages. Hence the denial of the pre-Islamic in vast swathes of the West Asia and parts of South Asia. The language predicament in Pakistan is rooted in this historical process. There is a distinct Confirmation Bias among the more vocal section of intellectuals in Pakistan when it comes to comparing other countries in the region . False equivalences are a part of their tool kit

There is no place for a sensible , educated and decent person like Prof Hoodbhoy in the Terrorist Republic of Pakistan.

Secularism is the best

Notwithstanding all the anti-PAKISTANI comments here....at 28:40 -- got to COMMEND that guy for asking the RIGHT QUESTION re the Army! 👍👍

Poor sound quality. please review it and upload again

Unless you get rid of hardcore islamic ideaology.nothing will happen. Look at school education.the basic brick of development.what is being taught in madarsa is what Pakistan is today.

Hoodbhai is dog of hell

So Hoodbhoy is promoting western so called modernism - separation of church and state. Mulla never stopped you learning from and progressing in science, lakin tum science parhnay k bajaye angraiz ban jatay ho aur islam sy he bahar nikalnay lagtay ho

So Hoodbhoy is promoting western so called modernism - separation of science and church

Nabi ka zamana urooj ka nahi thaa, sirf science ny zara taraqqi ki tu golden period hogaya. Quran hadith elm nahi thaa, sirf science elm hy. Science kon c tahzeeb aur tameez insan ko sikhati hy aur insan ko insan banati hy

Dono foolish eak sath bethy howy

2 cheap product pretending to be an expert of something they r not. Both useless trash talking to each other

Education - at every level - in this country is driven by economics. Institutions exist not to produce knowledge but to increase profits. I say this as one who has been teaching in the recent past.

❤️❤️❤️

❤️❤️❤️

Sitting in pakistan, some Dogs are discussing about Democracy in India. How funny😂😂😂

Dr Hoodbhoy is an Islamic apologist.

I agree with you

Best

Bayshak

Hoodboy is an Anti Hindu. He thinks he is a scientist. Good job for Pakistani.

Bayshak

These much hyped intellectuals don't bother to study their/own own golden age. Taksha Shila, which is close to Islamabad, had the world's oldest and largest university, where the great Chanakya taught. *There is only One World.* *There is no Muslim or Christian or Hindu world.*

Jinnah helped India by separating most of the Jihadi population from India. This helped India develop scientifically and economically. The Two Nation Theory should have been fully implemented by exchanging almost all the population on the basis of religion, since almost 90% of the Muslim voters voted for the partition of India based on religion in the 1946 provincial election.

It was the golden age for Arabian Muslims and Christians, and not all Muslims. Backward Pakistani Muslims gloating over the past achievements of Arabian Muslims is as absurd as Ethiopian Christians gloating over the scientic developments of Christian Europeans.

Sethi sahab what about Pakistan?human rights of minorities

Pakistan is just obsessed with India they have to include us in everything 🇮🇳🇮🇳🤣

Pakistanis have no right to talk about democracy reminding them about their bloody problems and that India is still the largest democracy in the world so shut up and Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

مولوی اور فوج کی جس دن اکائونٹبلیٹی شروع ہوگئی پاکستان سدھر جائےگا ان شاء اللہ ☝

تعلیم جمع ہنر یہ ہونا چاہیئے ملک کا تعلیمی نظام

ٹیکنیکل کسان ملک کی طاقت بنے گا

ساری باتیں ٹھیک ہیں لیکن ان شاء اللہ کہنے میں کیا حرج ہے ؟ یہ واضح کردوں کہ میں غزالی بخاری کسی کو پسند نہیں کرتی

Ye hoodboy bhi molvi ban gaya

Jadeed duniya ke sath judne ke liye Mard aur aurat ko liv in me rehna zaroori he kya?

2 intellectuals in 1 form! Masha Allah❤

Sir, this is a great series for expanding people's knowledge. I have a few suggestions to enhance the video quality: 1. Edit the videos to include pages or visuals that highlight key points. This will help emphasize important information. 2. Remove any unnecessary pauses to maintain viewer engagement. 3. Add light background music to smooth out vocal vibrations and enhance the overall viewing experience. 4. Include subtitles for better accessibility and comprehension. 5. Consider splitting the content into two 20-minute parts instead of one 40-minute video to keep the audience interested and avoid fatigue. Thank you for your hard work and dedication to education!

There's a very strange and peculiar struggle in this society. A troubling and confusing discussion on religion and science. " Hatred towards non-believers, an ideology based on hatred, and expecting to become a successful entrepreneur, scholar, thinker, and capable person - it doesn't seem like a right match at all. Blasphemy ka kanoon khatam karo Jahilon.

Very very bad argument

Golden age was when Christian, Jews and Greek worked together in Baghdad. Muslim propaganda was always lies. Just like prophet Muhammad with all his slaves and wives were showcased as the virtuous man.

Hudbhoy is a jehadi in the garb of a scientist

The two most important men in Pakistan right now.

Good thinking

Par ye to bata do Doctor g ye ejaad kinki hai kya Christians ka naam lene mein shram ati hai

Facts 0% and propaganda 100%😂😂😂

The golden age of Islam has nothing to do with Pakistan. There was zero contribution to the so-called golden age of Islam from native Muslims of this region. It is like converted Christians of India and Pakistan talking about and taking pride in the golden age of Christianity and in the accomplishments of European white Christians's empires and achievements. It just does not make sense at all.

Wonderful interaction ❤

سر اس خاتون نے پریس کی بات کی لیکن ذرا اپنے اندر جھانک کے دیکھیں کہ سائنس کی ترقی کے لئی بہترین موقعہ میسر تھا جو کہ صرف اور صرف دماغوں کے فتور کی وجہ سے کھو دیا اس قوم نے۔ کچھ صدیوں پہلے کی بات کرنا چھڑ دیں

One wonders if these folks even believe in God and Quran. If they did they would not have questioned Ghazzali as these concepts are coming from the text.