Пікірлер
@HAKOBO
@HAKOBO 8 күн бұрын
Cool video but your volume is on the low side
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 8 күн бұрын
Yeah, sorry about that, but I’m getting a mic soon.
@MrShaosi
@MrShaosi 9 күн бұрын
Try Perilous forays, in combination with The Necrobloom and anything that provides mana on Landfall (like Lotus Cobra f.e), you can pretty much play all lands in your Deck in 1 turn. Furthermore there would be an insane amount of mana to dump into spells like Torment of Hailfire or Exsanguinate :x
@tristanfain2561
@tristanfain2561 15 күн бұрын
Just copied almost this whole deck list bar for bar, ordered it all for $84. Can’t wait to see how it performs, thank you for the help. Cheers from Appalachia 🎉
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 15 күн бұрын
Nice!
@JannikRonnau
@JannikRonnau 22 күн бұрын
Griselbrand is banned 🧐
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 22 күн бұрын
Thanks for pointing that out! I was unaware that card was banned!
@briannoone7047
@briannoone7047 29 күн бұрын
"Breathe new life" is something people are overlooking. If someone plays once or twice a month, i can understand their want to play good decks and run powerful cards. Full stop thats a great point, play what you love. I am blessed to play 3 times a week, and i am tired of seeing it. I understand other people's joy, but the challenge and restrictions that come with budget cards has made me a better player. Overdoing synergy and finding ways out of problems with worse tools makes my game more enjoyable, personally. I like everything that you've put forward in the video, i hope to see you use this platform to release some of your budget deck techs!! Play your passion and good luck with the content!
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 29 күн бұрын
Thanks, love your support!
@user-ui1ry8ge5o
@user-ui1ry8ge5o Ай бұрын
Hullbreaker Horror can't be countered😂
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
Sorry for that 🤦‍♂️
@bmell2945
@bmell2945 Ай бұрын
this is like the art of war by sun tsu but it’s mtg😭 i love it
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
Thanks!
@Pupalah
@Pupalah Ай бұрын
Slow down. Breathe. Annunciate.
@Evan345gdf
@Evan345gdf Ай бұрын
it is psychological warfare btw
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
Thanks
@stompykingmtg9699
@stompykingmtg9699 Ай бұрын
Great video dude! It’s a different take on a very common video for magic channels! Keep up the good work man.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
Thank you!
@power_SERG
@power_SERG Ай бұрын
I've been playing Neera, Wild Mage - summoning Eldrazi with low cost spells. Even though my buddy who is playing Dragons with copy and Blink, which is waaaay more threatening, everyone always attacks me instantly cause Eldrazi just scare the crap out of everyone.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
That’s how it is sometimes.
@ToxicSentinelTTV
@ToxicSentinelTTV Ай бұрын
I built a Neera deck, used Mind's Dilation to cast big things on my opponents turn, it was a fun deck. Named it "Random Magical Bullshit, Go!"
@theknight660
@theknight660 Ай бұрын
2:01 mystical tutor reveals what you tutor for, so if you say "im getting a counter spell" then reveal the card you tutor was "Candlekeep Inspiration" expect a few puzzled stares.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
Thanks for catching my mistake
@zweis
@zweis Ай бұрын
I think something you should have mentioned is how you can only lie once, so make sure your one lie wins you the game.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
You’re right!
@rudixy7808
@rudixy7808 Ай бұрын
This only works once unless you play with new players everytime.
@SwedeRacerDC
@SwedeRacerDC Ай бұрын
I think that is the importance of learning to bluff without lying. Opponent goes to tap all their lands..."I have 3 mana open, are you sure you want to do that?"
@bobwinslow1920
@bobwinslow1920 Ай бұрын
I have a Kenrith deck that is all about making sure that all my other opponents are even by giving stuff to those behind and punishing those who are ahead. Then when the board is nice and big I mass goad and cast wound reflection. Always makes fun games.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing!!!
@joejojo5966
@joejojo5966 Ай бұрын
Sounds interesting what do you use for mass goad
@Red_Mag3
@Red_Mag3 Ай бұрын
I run Bjorna and Wernog, and give all of my opponents that extra card draw from clues without making the clues I get too punishing (just goading whatever is too threatening). The real goal isnt the clues, but having both my commanders die often, once they've died and been recast a few times I wait for or use a boardwipe. Then I follow up with Skull Storm with 4 or 5 additional copies. With no board, my opponents usually go from 80 or so life to death's door.
@gehnzou1
@gehnzou1 Ай бұрын
My Wilhelt the Rotcleaver was cool, but then I turned it in to "you either all kill me as quickly as you can or I win every game." I put a good amount of money into my precon over the last year and I love that it is now the biggest threat in my pod. Fastest win was turn 5. Adding and subtracting, little tweaks here and there. I think that's what I enjoy about the precons as a new player is you can learn it, break it down and rebuild it while learning about mana curve and how to play. Usually very affordable and you get everything you need in one box except sleeves and dice for counters. I love undead and zombies so I saw Wilhelt and was like "cool, he does zombie stuff." Now, as I approach my one year anniversary of starting to play magic, I wanted a new deck. I was thinking "maybe not get a deck that goes infinite"... So I just got Stella Lee, Wildcard. I'm sure she won't go infinite... Right? ....
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie Ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing your experience
@ecos889
@ecos889 2 ай бұрын
For showing how Budget does not necessarily define power just pilot a Zada deck when she pops off you are an unstopable force, just be wary, she be a glass cannon that dies to boardwipes so haste's creatures are a must.
@kasskastrull3676
@kasskastrull3676 2 ай бұрын
Jus wanted to mention that your video volume is way lower than the standard, which means I had to increase the volume to hear anything, but when an ad played it blasted my speakers. Otherwise great video <3
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks
@jestmaki
@jestmaki 2 ай бұрын
In my Voja deck, the most expensive cards are Voja and all will be one (which i pulled) and Cryptolith Rite and everything else is promarily cheap elves. If you want a disgustingly powerful but cheap deck, make Voja Jaws of the Conclave your commander and populate with cheap elves and mana ramp. You can negate needing Cryptolith Rite by just having elves that tap for mana. Throw in something to give haste. The nice thing is it has a lot of room to improve. All Will Be One is very powerful but not necesary to be competitive, and you can replace it with the much cheaper Shalai and Hallar for a similar effect, which also gives you that elf synergy. While All Will Be One lets you target anything on the field, with Voja youre going to try to be smacking in the face as much as possible so Shalai and Hallar will do essentially the same thing. Bonus is you can use both if you decide you like the archtype in the future.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
You’re so right, thanks for the feedback!
@Snipfragueur
@Snipfragueur 2 ай бұрын
Just print the cards you need lul
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
If your group allows it
@Snipfragueur
@Snipfragueur 2 ай бұрын
@@mtgmookie Unless they are sponsored by WotC, I do not see why they would not
@CatManThree
@CatManThree 2 ай бұрын
@@Snipfragueur A lot of people are uncomfortable with the idea of playing with people who play proxies because of the limitless potential of stuff they can run. Youve come to commander night with the fun deck youve made with the cards in your collection at a table with others who've done the same, only to have a guy running a high powered deck full of proxies of cards noone at the table could possibly afford. Vast majority of tables are at least fine with proxying if you either already own a copy of the card or aren't proxying anything too crazy. For the most part the only tables fine with open proxying are CEDH ones.
@voxvire2350
@voxvire2350 2 ай бұрын
​@@CatManThreesame thing can happen by someone just buying the cards tho? But if some prints a banger deck, I can just... Print one myself? Can't do the same if I have to buy these cards
@CatManThree
@CatManThree 2 ай бұрын
@@voxvire2350 Most people arent spending 5000 dollars on a deck, let alone over a hundred on true dual land or mana crypt. That asside, theres nothing wrong with proxying. Its just a matter of preference from table to table. One of the best things about commander is its casual nature, and part of that is different tables holding different preferences. Some tables wont like proxying for reasons like this, thats all Im saying.
@paulgaither
@paulgaither 2 ай бұрын
Gotta say I disagree with cutting Three Visits. It gets you any Forest, not just basics, and into play untapped. It gets you Ravnica Shock Lands, and even if you are hyper budget, just getting a basic forest means it really only cost you 1 net mana this turn to be +1 in ramp for the rest of the game. Still very good.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Nature’s Lore is so much cheaper and does the same exact thing.
@paulgaither
@paulgaither 2 ай бұрын
@mtgkookie - I didn't watch the price history. I got like 12 of them for different decks for my wife and I at like $3 each. I didn't know they rose to $8-$10 and are back "down" to $4-$5. That's because they are good. Now, concerning Nature's Lore, yeah, that's the point. You play both. Budget means different things to different people, but Three Visits is one of those staple cards that I made sure to snag and am glad I did both at the time and now seeing the price go up a bit. I have been playing magic since 2005 with the 9th edition starter and something I learned long ago and applied when I try to help other players: Do not overlook the value of "staples." I would still tell "you" to buy Three Visits and play both in your deck over buying some random hot new creature or synergy card. Three Visits will go into "every" green commander deck you play for the rest of your life, while that other $5 card won't. Most people don't like to "put in the work" for anything in life. Working out, studying, whatever. They want results, and Three Visits is a card that doesn't say you win the game, but it helps you play consistently. Hit your land drops, find your colors, and doees it efficiently. Just loke with sports and playing music and whatever, being consistent is the hidden key to success. Three Visits - and cards like it- wins you more games by keeping you on schedule than, say, Rampant growth which outs you down two mana and only a basic for the same mana cost.
@paulgaither
@paulgaither 2 ай бұрын
Advice from a content creator myself, and an English teacher who wants to be helpful: If you still have the script and video editing file, please consider recording the audio again with a better microphone or improved settings. Practice your speech and record it in segments to get the best takes. You can do it :) It feels, many times, like you lack confidence in your words. These are your words. Believe in them and yourself. Be bold and assertive.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the advice!
@GutsyTen42
@GutsyTen42 2 ай бұрын
Fairly good content within the video, but it sounds like it was one take. If possible I'd recommend doing a few lines at a time and syncing them up that way it flows better. The cadence seemed fine to me but felt like you were a bit nervous and didn't go back and rerecord anything if a mistake was made. Still, a good starting place, subbed
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the feedback, I’ll keep your advice in mind for my next video.
@cryptidzilla1742
@cryptidzilla1742 2 ай бұрын
nice video, im trying to go for a more win with less approach in my decks by going budget and this helps alot
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
You’re welcome!
@MasterofTongs
@MasterofTongs 2 ай бұрын
Why is this so frickin quiet?!!
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
I’m sorry about that
@lukab780
@lukab780 2 ай бұрын
Brago is $50?!?!?!? Im rich!!!1
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
The deck is $50
@lukab780
@lukab780 2 ай бұрын
@@mtgmookie ik
@dantemalick2872
@dantemalick2872 2 ай бұрын
easiest way to build a budget deck is to proxie. i mean even wizards sold proxies for the anniversary
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
You’re so right
@joshhuffaker8490
@joshhuffaker8490 2 ай бұрын
Ngl I like the faster speaking though
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks
@Mcslave10101
@Mcslave10101 2 ай бұрын
Scripting is fine for a video essay. I just think you’re reading too quickly and it’s causing some stumbling in your speech. Otherwise throughout this video, you’ve just explained how to budget decks but you’ve set an expectation that the standard budget isn’t the right way to budget, which works against the point you started with. Provide us a 500$ deck, with a mix of staple and value cards, and make 2 or 3 decks using budget options to prove your point. I’ll sub to see your progression as a creator
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks
@TheKingOfNone
@TheKingOfNone 2 ай бұрын
Breathe. You're reading a little quickly I feel, and you start to trip over your words. Your audio levels had your voice a little low as well, if you're able to adjust that. The script used was well written and helped convey your point very well, but your cadence was rushed. Don't be afraid to slow down or even make cuts in your recording to get a clean and impactful feel to add weight onto your key points. Knowing where to slow and enunciate or bring focus to a word/phrase will help to engage your viewer. Practice reading your script to yourself or to a family member or friend. Recording and listening back to your voice over will allow you to perform retakes of areas you find rushed or not as impactful as you wanted. Recording your voice over in smaller takes can make that easier to do as well. Finally, your video ended so abruptly I was startled. That rushed flow, into a cold stop was incredibly jarring, slow the pace down at the end and maybe mention your other videos! I really enjoyed your video and learned a great deal about how to restructure my current first build. I can see you doing even better in the near future as you learn editing tricks and become more comfortable with your speaking.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
I’ll try slow down, I always try but it is very hard for me. I will try my very hardest to breathe between statements!
@Derpingmuffin
@Derpingmuffin 2 ай бұрын
The video is very quiet, but I liked the content otherwise :3
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
I tried turning up the audio, but next video I will try again even more!
@Ohkapi
@Ohkapi 2 ай бұрын
Hello , thanks for making this video. I followed the "buy singles instead of precon for 2 months, turned out getting 1 to 2 precon instead of just useful singles swift my mtg gaming quality. in the end I did not have to micromanaging which cards to construct into a deck. Have to say all my bad mtg gaming experiences were when anyone (includes me) using non-precon
@Ohkapi
@Ohkapi 2 ай бұрын
my first precon is Painbow (30USD) followed by Gavi's Timeless Wisdom (18 USD) minus that Fierce Guardianship card. The starter commander decks Chaos Incarnate and Grave Danger are both powerhouse and so much fun to play. less than 20 USD each. 28 USD for Sneak Attack precon. Wins everytime against any precons I have listed. I am not saying all precons are powerful / fun to play, but playing precons without adding/take away cards are ease and almost balance as long as other players are using their precons without upgrades
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing!
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Playing Precons against Precons are a very fun way to play magic; I agree with you.
@SwedeRacerDC
@SwedeRacerDC 2 ай бұрын
I can see how other people are reacting the way the are, but you raise a lot of great points. The thumbnail image of The MOM Knights deck not being worth it is pretty much clickbait. As you stated in the video, some are better than others and typically dominate. I agree that MTG has a lot of precon problems. One being that there are literally a lot of them. Too much these days. We used to have 4-5 rather focused decks per year with a ton of value packed in. I'm still using some of those commanders and a lot of the building blocks of those decks are still very useful today. I think you did a great job, so don't hear my criticism as not liking the video, but I wanted to offer a more constructive take to some criticisms I have seen so you have more of a direction to go with it. Besides the mana base, one of the big underlying issues that causes such variability between the strength of each deck out of the box is that each deck is designed not around a single theme or even commander, but that they often have different ideas for commanders that fit into the same color combination. For instance, both Doctor Who and Fallout villain based decks have very different key commanders in them. You could theoretically plug and play usually 3 or more commanders for each deck. Let's zero in on Ceasar and Mr House. The deck is built more around Ceasar, but Mr. House was iconic and needed to be shoved somewhere. Wizards thinks: "Why not throw him in this deck?" From the perspective that they have too many decks already, I agree. But clearly, they want to be in completely different decks. Let's look back at one of the best Mardu decks ever printed. Vampires under Edgar Markov! As it is, the other two featured commanders fit into that deck, since they're both vampires and support him. But they both could have decks built around them. The Wizards deck from the same release has Marisil the Pretender, who kinda stood out as completely his own thing and barely fit in. The other Wizards were much more effective in that deck. He was handcuffed and barely effective without being built around. Thus, the Wizards deck was the worst one from that year, and we got two very busted commanders from EdgUr
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the feedback!
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
You make very good points!
@ColdShocker1
@ColdShocker1 2 ай бұрын
Interesting take. You make a lot of great points, its suck your using Tinker Time as your example being its one of my favorite precon of all time. However you are very much right. There are similar precon like this that share these problems that I'm going to go over, but Tinker Time is the weakest maybe of all precons ever printed. It doesn't help that the theme is one of the most niche theme ever (differently named artifact tokens). So its chance of getting support are second to none. That being said when it finally gets support, we get cards like {Transmutation Font} that tbh are mid. Next the precon itself didn't bring much card to support the theme as well, excluding the commander of course we have {Sandsteppe War Riders} that's it. Which in relating to another video made the commander an [Monolith Commander]. {Rashmi and Ragavan} don't count because they work of the number of any artifacts not referencing the theme of (differently named artifact tokens) so flavor fail. Second because of the them trying to make the niche theme work better they add a bunch of removal that did created a artifact token but were all sorcery speed. In which made the precon much weaker compared to good cards like Path, Swords or even a more synergistic card for their precon like {Murderous Rider} for Knights. Also funny enough because of the niche theme you're also waiting for other token artifacts themes to get more support like {Map/Junk/Incubate/Blood} to steal from them and add to upgrading your deck. In which all those themes were created for there own set, and will most likely not get any more new cards relating them in the future. [See how long ago Crimson Vow was release and we haven't gotten a new Blood Token card until {Transmutation Font}]. Hope to get feedback on what you or your community thinks about these points I bring up. BUT LETS BE HONEST I'VE DONE THE RESEARCH FOR THIS DECK AND WE ALL KNOW I'M COOKING. lol.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
You are cooking! Thanks for your opinion!
@89qwyg9yqa34t
@89qwyg9yqa34t 2 ай бұрын
You missed a bigger issue with all new precons. When you check the value of them, they're always $90-$100 in value, but weirdly if you were to just buy the singles of things you don't have, you won't spend more than $20. Additionally, the precon version of a card is sometimes 10x higher than the pack version, which makes sense on no level. Somebody is artificially setting prices to affect sales. Cavalry Charge was a huge example of this. I preordered it for $35 and it was stolen off my doorstep, so I ordered just the cards and I have a screenshot of Conjurer's Mantle at $11.42 from the deck and $1.20 from the collector packs, both at TCGPLayer.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
I should’ve added that!
@Solidus-
@Solidus- 2 ай бұрын
Precons are worth if you’re gonna upgrade
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Agreed
@Beaudunk
@Beaudunk 2 ай бұрын
Honestly, video wasn't bad. Was fast paced enough to keep my ADHD brain engaged. Will sub for the next one lil boss man.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks
@MattHorton
@MattHorton 2 ай бұрын
You can build Arcades for $43 fwiw. But also Tinker Time was also my first deck. It blows. And that Command Zone upgrade sounded cool but never worked.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks for the feedback, but I was saying Arcades can be built with some really expensive cards.
@MattHorton
@MattHorton 2 ай бұрын
For sure! Wasn't meant as a tear down. I just know because I did it and it whips 😅
@bartholomewallen3937
@bartholomewallen3937 2 ай бұрын
This video makes it sound like you or someone in your playgroup has had terrible experiences. The video reminds me of magic the Noah though, so if this video was meant to be sarcastic you should work on the delivery of your lines.
@MagicManAleister
@MagicManAleister 2 ай бұрын
Content of the vid aside, it shows you put a lot of thought and work into this video, kudos on that and I hope you grow into a good sized MTG channel
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
Thanks
@Joke_Of_All_Trades
@Joke_Of_All_Trades 2 ай бұрын
This honestly is a bad take. I have played many precons that have lasted as long as decks way more expensive and optimized and have never been taken out turn 6 as you say. Precons such as the ixalan dinosaur precon, the M.O.M. knights precon the fallout dog meat precon and the hobbit precon have, with little to no upgrades, won or held their own in games. So either you are using absolute bottom of the barrel low power precons or you have a play group that is expressly targeting the precon because i have never seen the ones i play preform as bad as you said.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
I said in the video that one or two precons are pretty strong, and can win some of their own games. Thanks for the feedback, much appreciated!
@Joke_Of_All_Trades
@Joke_Of_All_Trades 2 ай бұрын
@mtgmookie I think it's closer to 1 or 2 PER set of 4 it is not only 1 or 2 total its more like 30-40 percent of all precons are of high quality and others need a little mana fixing or some extra synergy cards and you pay ~$45 for what is usually 100-145 worth of card precons are almost always worth it a very small amount are not worth buying and never buy on mark up.
@josephcourtright8071
@josephcourtright8071 2 ай бұрын
You say its a bad take. But that was 100% may experience with commander. First game I convinced everyone to play precons. It was okay. Next week people played their own decks. Probably the 2nd worst experience I've ever had in a card game. They weren't even playing anything that crazy. I made the choice to quite commander rather than upgrading my deck.
@mtgmookie
@mtgmookie 2 ай бұрын
@josephcourtright8071 Thank you