My sister has owned the Evenflo Dualride for about a year and says she’s had nothing but smooth sailing with all their Evenflo products. She said it might be the luck of the buy, but it has maintained a high quality feel so far and all five years with the EvenFlo Xpand stroller. It’s been their go to for any terrain because it’s so smooth. My family has owned the Donna for just over a year and we feel the same way about the quality of it. We love the Doona! I think we would get the Evenflo if we could go back in time, mostly because it works with the Evenflo Xpand stroller that we still use constantly after almost 8 years. I can’t give you personal feedback on how each car seat has held up beyond a year or two, but so far we personally haven’t had mechanical problems with either one. Hope that’s helpful!

Thank you so much! I’m glad it was helpful :)

I’m so glad it was helpful for you! ❤️

I’m so glad it was helpful for you!! I had the same exact problem when I was trying to figure out which one to get my sister. I ended up going with the EvenFlo, and we were so excited it worked 🎉