Пікірлер
@DaveSCameron
@DaveSCameron 23 күн бұрын
The horror of ones split apart humanity when War cracks open wide our reason…
@DaveSCameron
@DaveSCameron 23 күн бұрын
Zero mentions regarding fighter escorts, early raids on Berlin and how Great Britain was writing #OurHistory. ☘️📚🎚️
@doradora3170
@doradora3170 29 күн бұрын
Is Hero Churchill always COWARD!
@doradora3170
@doradora3170 29 күн бұрын
he showed how the Naxis did the same thing, frying people in England, Poland, France, Greece
@JohnnyNorfolk
@JohnnyNorfolk Ай бұрын
Just like today you cannot trust any politician. They are the lowest of the low.
@andrewwrobel2255
@andrewwrobel2255 Ай бұрын
54:50 "Stifford Crapps"--the best characterization of that paragon of virtue.
@michaelkinsey4649
@michaelkinsey4649 Ай бұрын
Falklands War - Black Buck - Harris was at a service in the RAF Church in London when news of the raid was passed to him. He smiled. Biplanes to Vulcans....
@henriyoung3895
@henriyoung3895 Ай бұрын
Good movie.
@xcel5203
@xcel5203 Ай бұрын
Wars are not won by wimps .
@rob5944
@rob5944 Ай бұрын
Never underestimate the Germans.
@user-sq5uo8oh3g
@user-sq5uo8oh3g Ай бұрын
20th century record. Played 2, lost 2. There’s more to war than having smart uniforms.
@rob5944
@rob5944 Ай бұрын
@@user-sq5uo8oh3g Germany could of beaten any two of the Allies I suspect, it was only the channel that saved Britain, distance that saved Russia and in the case of the USA, both.....There, that wasn't bad considering I just made that up and it's nearly one in the morning! Lol
@Anakin_Sandy_High_Ground
@Anakin_Sandy_High_Ground Ай бұрын
@@rob5944wehraboo delusion. The Germans were doomed to lose from the start.
@raspberryridge8840
@raspberryridge8840 Ай бұрын
Excellent discussion. Is there a moral way to do the immoral ? My father was bomb aimer in an RCAF Halifax. He didn't talk much about it. Brave to face death, and brave to continue with life after.
@michaelgardner2581
@michaelgardner2581 Ай бұрын
This poor man got the blame for a lot of things Churchill wouldn't admit to
@davidmaule3266
@davidmaule3266 Ай бұрын
A Bomber Command clasp was finally struck in 2013. I received this on behalf of my father, who had completed a full tour. As a bomb aimer he flew missions to the Ruhr, Hamburg and Berlin - not Dresden, though he would have done so if ordered. He died in 1991, still hurt by the cowardice of those who had sent them out to do the job then backed off, denying responsibility. It takes little courage to ask young men to die an early death, even less to deny you did so.
@TheGixernutter
@TheGixernutter Ай бұрын
Robert Hardy as Churchill was sublime, and the bar others are judged by. Probably the most authentic I've seen
@marioceva7163
@marioceva7163 Ай бұрын
To kill civilians in purpose in war is war crime.
@ChristineRead-ck1uq
@ChristineRead-ck1uq Ай бұрын
So the 80,000 British civilians killed ON purpose by the Luftwaffe wasn't a 'war crime'? The RAF didn't knowingly bomb German civilians at all until well into 1942. But by then, tens of thousands of British civilians had already been deliberately bombed by Germany. That's why 'all bets were off' once the USA entered the war. As Harris says in the film, 'Germany sowed the wind now they'll reap the whirlwind'.
@TheGixernutter
@TheGixernutter Ай бұрын
Now we're just giving it all away.
@Brommear
@Brommear Ай бұрын
Nuclear bombs are not a change in morality, only in technology.
@lenwilkinson672
@lenwilkinson672 Ай бұрын
Vincde Kerrigan. Appreciate your reply.thanks,I am 94 now good memory good health mustn’t grumble.almost at the end of the road.The world I grew up in no longer exists.I dread the thought of what awaits this country.
@lenwilkinson672
@lenwilkinson672 Ай бұрын
Vince Kerrigan. I agree wholeheartedly . So many chumps on here far too young to even jknow about the war.
@Morbius1963
@Morbius1963 Ай бұрын
My mother, babe in arms, in South London, turned a corner and found her house gone. She had to live with relatives and they weren't very welcoming. She didn't see her husband for three years. Try and get inside the head of that young woman. See if you have any sympathy for Germany.
@conveyor2
@conveyor2 Ай бұрын
It was the UK and France that declared war for the sake of Poland, that heartland of the British Empire. Two weeks later they saw the USSR invade and played dumb.
@TheKira699
@TheKira699 Ай бұрын
Hugh Caswall Tremenheere Dowding, 1st Baron Dowding Didn't get the recognition he deserved for saving Britain in the Battle of Britain. Leigh Mallory and Douglas Bader were not that good. Posers.
@martaalvarez4859
@martaalvarez4859 Ай бұрын
Extraordinary film and history.
@uttaradit2
@uttaradit2 Ай бұрын
the dam busters raid - brilliant 4 morale
@TheBezaleel
@TheBezaleel Ай бұрын
Excellent movie, excellent acting. QUALITY !!
@lenwilkinson672
@lenwilkinson672 Ай бұрын
Major Manfred Rex. Well we realised that,but the Yanks refused point blank to share the progress of the Manhattan project. They ook over the complete running of the war.we were sidelined.They didn’t bother with us until their fleet was attacked.All talk since the war of the special relationship between us and America is pure fantasy. And for dreamers.
@brucehubbard4685
@brucehubbard4685 Ай бұрын
according to Western European historians Hitler had no chance of winning "post late September 1941" - after USSR defeated Nazi Germany. It was over, his targets had no military conscience or effect.
@michaelbruchas6663
@michaelbruchas6663 Ай бұрын
This feels like a stage play with historical film clips.
@ChristineRead-ck1uq
@ChristineRead-ck1uq Ай бұрын
It's British TV film not a big Hollywood production.
@Nine-Signs
@Nine-Signs Ай бұрын
I dare say barely a bomber in the air didn't feel bad about the people below, but they did what had to be done in dire circumstances. When you go and look at the scale of the German military machine and its deployment you realise that even after the mass bombing, the invasion by combined allied forces still found it incredibly hard going yet what nobody would know until long after the war, was that they were only fighting circa 30% of the German military. The rest was on the eastern front in Russia, and had the Russians not sacrificed so much, it is highly unlikely the allies would have been able to break the nazi state before it had developed sufficient weapons and technology to make such impossible. Had the war have lasted another 5 to 10 years as it may well have done in absence of the war in Russia, it may well have ended in far more nuclear bombs being dropped than 2 on Japan and I may well be sat here in England now speaking German with a photo of bloody Adolph on the wall on pain of death lest it not be so while neighbours inform on each other and families are led to camps. I shudder to think what the world would be had the Nazi's have taken over western Europe, and stopped there.
@dokskwyr4353
@dokskwyr4353 Ай бұрын
Harris definitely got a raw deal concerning Dresden, left to twist in the wind. Especially since he wasn't the sole planner or even the first to suggest it. Its just that the rest were better at covering their asses, using the media first to twist the facts to their advantage in the public ye.
@richardmarshall4322
@richardmarshall4322 Ай бұрын
Bomber Command were betrayed. Highest British and Commonwealth casualties of the War. 47500 KIA. 55000 total losses. 50 % loss rate. No campaign medal. National disgrace.
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
Bomber Command aircrew casualties were why Harris was nicknamed "Butcher" by Bomber Command - not because of the civilian casualties. Their deaths were as pointless as the 600,000 German civilians they killed, mainly refugees and woman and children, which is what makes it all the sadder. Nobody who flew got a "campaign medal" for it - NOBODY. What they got was a clasp to the '39-'45 star and the France-Germany star if in that theatre, which is what the 3,000 Battle of Britain pilots got. Harris wanted a "Bomber Command" clasp for all Bomber Command, up to a million of them including ground crew who never flew or left their base in the UK - that was never going to be acceptable and never has been. It's like the RAF demanding Afghanistan and Iraq medals for drone pilots who "flew" drones there from the comfort of an office in the UK - which the RAF have demanded more recently. Totally unacceptable and unjustifiable.
@richardmarshall4322
@richardmarshall4322 Ай бұрын
@@John-G First point. Harris was known 'Butch' not butcher. 'Butcher' was a term coined by post War lefties who were quick to condem the bombing campaign as 'terror'. The bomber offensive both in Europe and the Far East made a major contribution to winning the War. Unfortunately civilians become targets. The German War machine could not have worked without millions of munitions and industrial workers. Yoy can argue as soon as you pick up a spanner to put a tank together you then become a legitimate target, i happen to agree with this. Easy to sit back on the moral high ground years later. I think Harris got it pretty much right, although i think he became a little obsessed with Berlin. As Speer was quoted to say after the War. 6 more raids like Hamburg the War would have been over. Bombing did finish the War. Japan was 95% destroyed and the A bombs brought back peace to the World...for a while. As a well read student and historian of the air war i could go on all day, i will leave it there.
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
@@richardmarshall4322 First point - laughable. Even those commenting here whose parents and relatives were in Bomber Command say that they said he was nicknamed "Butcher". It's also explained in detail in his authorised biography by Henry Probert, in the official history of Bomber Command, is detailed in the official IWM biography (reel 4), and I not only heard him say so himself in 1975, unashamedly, but he said so himself in 'Bomber Command'. Somehow I doubt they all got it wrong, including the man himself, or that they're all "post-war Lefties" including Harris himself. You can indeed argue that as soon as you pick up a spanner to work on a tank you're a legitimate target, and few would disagree. Unfortunately for your argument none of those in Dresden had ever picked up a spanner to do anything and most were women, children, and refugees as were most of the 600,000 killed by Bomber Command. That isn't the fault of those men in Bomber Command who risked and gave their lives, but sadly they did so for little reason. I'm sure you could go on all day, but that wouldn't make you any better informed or any less of an armchair hard man talking about something he's never dared experience.
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
@@richardmarshall4322 and for a "well read student and historian of the air war" you're remarkably uninformed if you think Bomber Command Aircrew didn't qualify for a campaign medal. All, without exception, qualified for at least the '39-'45 Star and the France-Germany star. What they didn't get until decades later, which is very different to a campaign medal, was a separate clasp to the campaign medal like the Battle of Britain clasp. The reason, well documented, was that BoB pilots didn't qualify for the France-Germany Star for obvious reasons and because Harris wanted the clasp awarded to all Bomber Command, not just aircrew, even if they never left the ground or the UK, which was as unacceptable then as it is now. Edit: my original reply to your comment about Harris being nicknamed "Butch", not "Butcher", seems to have disappeared. Those commenting here who's parents and relatives were in Bomber Command say that he was nicknamed "the Butcher". So does his authorised biography. So does the official Bomber Command history. So does the IWM (reel 4). So did Harris himself, unashamedly, when I heard him speak in 1975. So Harris said himself in 'Bomber Command'. I doubt they're all wrong or post-war Lefties, including Harris.
@richardmarshall4322
@richardmarshall4322 Ай бұрын
@@John-G I didn't mention campaign medal. Ofcoarse they should have had one. At least they got the memorial in London. The crews played a pivital role in winning the War and later becoming the means of delivering the Nuclear deterrent, which they would have done with the same zest as the loads delivered on Berlin. As for 'Butcher' will have to disagree.
@bran756
@bran756 Ай бұрын
First class,Harris was a legend.
@tiamatxvxianash9202
@tiamatxvxianash9202 Ай бұрын
"Then shall the right aiming thunderbolts go abroad; and from the clouds, as from a well-drawn bow, shall they fly to the mark" Wisdom v.21 From the Air Ministry handbook Bomber Command, 1941
@Horgi-vv2kh
@Horgi-vv2kh Ай бұрын
Even though Germany was badly destroyed in many places that was exactly what Hitler wanted so that when British Russian and american troops entered Germany there was nothing for them to get. Hitler tried to get Speer to destruct it all even villages but he did not do that. SoHitler let the RAF do it and Churchill wanted to blast German towns and Villages to the ground but Eisenhower stopped it from happening.
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
"Hitler let the RAF do it" ? Seriously? Nobody tried to shoot them down? 😢
@teslar1
@teslar1 Ай бұрын
Everthing that’s wrong with Britain today stems from Tory austerity which led to Brexit and a section of population who believed Brexit would bring back the past. The people who lived through the war knew different and that’s why Europe got united and broke down nationalistic barriers vowing to never let this happen again. Britain was instrumental in setting up the beginnings of this along with the ECHR. It’s Ironic that the Tories and Brexitiers believe withdrawing from the ECHR is now a good thing, forgetting the lessons learned by the people who actually fought in the last two wars
@conveyor2
@conveyor2 Ай бұрын
The EU isn't a thing of permanence, comrade!
@petergarbe2459
@petergarbe2459 Ай бұрын
ERZFEIND!!!!! immer ....
@philcoombes2538
@philcoombes2538 Ай бұрын
AAAARGH no subtitles...
@andrewfrancis7272
@andrewfrancis7272 Ай бұрын
Was Harris a fanatic, as Churchill said? He probably was but he was fighting against fanatics but fighting on the right side, which was our side. Apart from ending the agony of Nazi tyranny and occupation of Europe, the Allied victory ended the Holocaust. Of course his strategic decisions can be criticised now from the safe distance of eighty years, but Bomber Command helped win the war. Never forget it could have gone the other way.
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
It nearly did go the other way, as Harris was nearly responsible for Coastal Command losing the war in the Atlantic until he was over-ruled.
@GaryNumeroUno
@GaryNumeroUno Ай бұрын
The way the world is heading it looks like it was all for nothing. We as a species have learned absolutely nothing from the horror of past wars and sacrifices made on all sides. 😢
@erikr007
@erikr007 Ай бұрын
At 2:40 what is the secondary target referred to as "R.C.M."?
@IvegottobeFrank
@IvegottobeFrank Ай бұрын
Does anyone know why noone calls him Arthur, but something like "Burt"?
@Anakin_Sandy_High_Ground
@Anakin_Sandy_High_Ground Ай бұрын
Why do people call Charles Portal "Peter"? Its a nickname used by his friends.
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
"Bert" was a common nickname for anyone named Harris at the time, apparently after a popular racing cyclist who'd died young in a cycle race.
@IvegottobeFrank
@IvegottobeFrank Ай бұрын
@@John-G Wow! That is so strange it sounds true! May I ask how you know such an arcane notion?
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
@@IvegottobeFrank I googled "Bert Harris"!
@IvegottobeFrank
@IvegottobeFrank Ай бұрын
@@John-G Honest to God, sometimes simple ideas are the best! Please put your fact checking skills to good use!
@saliksayyar9793
@saliksayyar9793 Ай бұрын
Did Churchill push Britain into an unnecessary war that killed millions?
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
No.
@chuckgilbert2035
@chuckgilbert2035 Ай бұрын
When I see movies about WWII air war I think of my friend General Alpha Fowler of the 8th Airforce. Loved hearing his point of view on the war.
@chuckgilbert2035
@chuckgilbert2035 Ай бұрын
My Grandfather was General Eisenhower's transportation officer during WWII. I loved hearing his stories. That drove me to learn as much as I could about the so called war to end all wars.
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
The "war to end all wars" was WWI - not WWII.
@chuckgilbert2035
@chuckgilbert2035 Ай бұрын
@@John-G yes, He fought in WWI also. Both of my grandfathers did. I am so proud of you for all your knowledge.
@John-G
@John-G Ай бұрын
@@chuckgilbert2035 Sorry, I wasn't trying to be one-up, but if you re-read your original comment I think it'd be fair to say that it sounds very much as if you're referring to WW2 as "the war to end all wars", not WW1.
@MrDonJBerg
@MrDonJBerg Ай бұрын
Interesting..My Uncle an MP and was Eisenhower's jeep driver, I have a picture of him with Eisenhower, General Clark and two female aids in the jeep..
@chuckgilbert2035
@chuckgilbert2035 Ай бұрын
@@MrDonJBerg My Grandfather was badly burn by mustard gas in WWI. They did not take many pictures with him in them. BTW the General had him check out the M1 before it was issued. The third one in production was presented to him with serial # 3 on it.
@grantsmythe8625
@grantsmythe8625 Ай бұрын
Did Eisenhower order an unnecessary invasion? Did Eisenhower prevent a certain war with the Soviets had air power alone been the only weapon available to stop the Soviet push to the Atlantic? Having only air power alone to stop the Soviets would be like having atomic weapons: it wouldn't preserve the peace.
@AndyGabrielPowell
@AndyGabrielPowell Ай бұрын
John Thaw's Finest Performance.
@TrustMeiamaD.R.
@TrustMeiamaD.R. Ай бұрын
Sir Stafford Cripps went on to wreak havoc on British aircraft manufacturing after the war. 😮
@timobrien2813
@timobrien2813 Ай бұрын
Captain Mannering was there 1:21:41. Good film, thank you. UKUK
@comicmania2008
@comicmania2008 Ай бұрын
A great docudrama about Harris, played by a brilliant actor. Yes, our leaders had big balls back then, that had to make shocking decisions, taking lives in order to save many other lives. Shame, how we are now riddled with wokism and left wing bullshittery and are now doomed to fail in Britain, thanks to people like Sunak and Starmer, and military leaders that won't say boo to a goose.
@brigidsingleton1596
@brigidsingleton1596 Ай бұрын
I was born in August 1953...not quite the 'anniversary of the bomb', (or bombs) of Hiroshima (& Nagasaki) ...but perhaps close enough to sadly commemorate the events _and_ _continue_ to hope that no further weapons such as they, will ever be employed again, on our world, or, indeed, any other, especially where any form of sentient life (at least) exists. With respect and thanks to those involved in making this film, to the now deceased actors within it, to Lady & 'Bomber' Harris...and R.I.P. to the lost souls of the services throughout the war(s) and likewise, to the civilians, who suffered injuries, and / or lost their lives to the senseless, yet necessary actions of war brought about through the actions of the evil which (some) men do. ... R.I.P. John Thaw & Robert Hardy, (et al).