I never get tired of watching this! 😍

And that's why every time I start to sing a Sutton Foster song at karaoke, I apologize for Sutton Foster not being there to sing this song with me, hoping for ... well, this :-)

A simple choice, nothing more This or that, either or Marry well, social whirl, business man, clever girl Or pin my future on a green glass love What kind of life am I dreaming of? I say gimme, gimme ... gimme, gimme Gimme, gimme that thing called love I want it Gimme, gimme that thing called love I need it Highs and lows, tears and laughter Gimme happy ever after Gimme, gimme that thing called love Gimme, gimme that thing called love I crave it Gimme, gimme that thing called love I'll brave it Thick 'n thin, rich or poor time Gimme years and I'll want more time Gimme, gimme that thing called love Gimme, gimme that thing called love I'm free now Gimme, gimme that thing called love I see now Fly, dove! Sing, sparrow! Gimme Cupid's famous arrow Gimme, gimme that thing called love I don't care if he's a nobody In my heart he'll be a somebody Somebody to love me! I need it Gimme, gimme that thing called love I want it Here I am, St. Valentine My bags are packed, I'm first in line Aphrodite, don't forget me Romeo and Juliet me Fly, dove! Sing, sparrow! Gimme fat boy's famous arrow Gimme, gimme that thing called love!

was this planned

Love Erica so much.

An here i was looking for fraNk Sinatras song...strangers in the night was turned into a parody when i was growing up I would hear kids sing it and my older siblings.😂😂😂😮

When she began to sing😳…Sutton Foster is just amazing😭……

Came over here after seeing this on Brandon’s channel. Wow. Very nice. This needs way more views. Added to my playlist. Subbed.

I love this supporting each other it’s fabulous

I think my insides would boil out of my body if I ever had to sing this song in front of Sutton.

kickass Erica!

I love your voice so much! I remember your other video of you singing this, and your voice sounds even better than before! Lovely job. 👏

no because I would just immediately pass out 😭

💕💕💕💕👏👏👏👏👏👏 beautiful voice and performance

Hah, that was great!

Ugh I wish Sutton Foster would look at me the way she looked at you when you started!!!! I’d die!

You are great actor

Wow... Incredible... Love the accompanist too!

This video makes me smile. In fact, i have a feeling that I'll be smiling for the rest of the evening.

Watching Sutton move with the music...she knows it so well it's just a delight

This is totally cool. I'd love it if Sutton appeared at one of my performances like this. I love that she is so so incredibly down to earth and kind. 🥰 One if the reasons she is my Idol and she is such a massive part of my life.

First!!! Erica can you sing "Dream A Little Dream Of Me"?

2:33 I was like "YEAH THAT's Tomorrow" :D

3:07 - 3:19 cured my depression

Your voice is so powerful and strong. You give so much emotion. It gives this song the power it needs. You voice is amazing!! I am so sorry that you are under appreciated this is truly amazing. Thank you for sharing.

I started laughing immediately.

OMG where was this?

Imagine having Sutton Foster looking at you like that.

When people cheered during Sutton’s part I was like “SHUT UP I WANNA HEAR HER SING”😤😤

Love this!

I have been obsessed with this video which I only recently came across. So was Sutton there by chance or was this agreed?

2:40 Sutton sings 2:47 she’s getting into it a lil 2:50 *inner Millie snaps* SHES INTO IT

Wow!! You're both spectacular! What a fabulous surprise!

I hope you get a Tony nomination.

Omg I would’ve #died

Burt Bacharach is so great, and was such a deep influence on me, seeing the awesome Erica do this medley is just perfect.

Well done Erica.

If you imagine hard enough you can hear my crying in the wings 😭❤️❤️ miss this and your sweet joy!

you’re like astonishing omg

"slack, no. You'll find slack in the dictionary between shit and syphilis"

You sound so good together. Well done!

Whoever is playing Marcy is a phenomenal actress.

Was it just me or was I the only one just watching Sutton

This is so good

When Sutton Foster says "I'm totally here", her hands start shaking 😳 and honestly, same.

Erica was MEANT to be Sister Mary Robert! Holy Cow😍

i love watching sutton watching her- she looks like a proud big sister

Great cover! Your awesome

Listened to the soundtrack a couple of days ago and wanted to play Rose. After watching this, I REALLY want to play Rose