He was before the Universe, he created the universe, when Jesus was made flesh he says God is eternal to eternal, meaning he is not bound by anything, with man it is not impossible but with God everything is possible, human mind cannot comprehend God, The bible says lean not on your own understanding, but trust the lord
@tamanwar203Күн бұрын
If Denisovians and Neanderthals were merely previous creations of Allah that were not humans, does that mean we hybridated with animals ? Because we definitely have some of their dna in us.
@matswessling66002 күн бұрын
"contingent", "dependent", "necessary" etc are all abstract concepts without any counterpart in reality.
@DarthDeist2 күн бұрын
Prove that god is wise without the teleological argument as it necessitates scripture to show the unknown nature of god.
@R.leo11104 күн бұрын
then the problem is that muslimssee everything as hostile towards them, in the western world people nave free speech and they hate many things, but those are words, while what muslims (the non integrated ones i hope) is burning christian churches, bibles, gatekeeping certain areas and cause chaos wherever they go, some say that it's because the muslim law was the only thing keeping them from doing certain things and once they find themselves in a different situation they become like beasts, and many of them do say that they are meant to conquer all nations and impose sharia and taxes
@acercamful5 күн бұрын
It is so obvious how deviating from the topic serves him well on distracting the audience from actually demanding the point
@Ihsaan1c5 күн бұрын
I’ve done a refutation of this lecture
@Anonymityfan7 күн бұрын
On the pool jumping vs being pushed analogy I think it does work because it's an analogy or thought experiment so yh the jumping person could be argued to be to be determined but it's an analogy not an explenation so the man jumping is an analogy to the free will not an example of it and the one pushing is an analogy to destiny not an example of it.
@barakaringo99048 күн бұрын
This man just lied because it is specific to Islam as it says Allah's Messenger (SAW) said, "The blood of a Muslim who confesses that none has the right to be worshipped but Allah and that I am His Apostle, cannot be shed except in three cases: In Oisas for murder, a married person who commits illegal sexual intercourse and the one who reverts from Islam (apostate) and leaves the Muslims." Another Hadith says Some Zanadiqa (atheists) were brought to 'Ali and he burnt them. The news of this event, reached Ibn 'Abbas who said, "If I had been in his place, l would not have burnt them, as Allah's Messenger forbade it, saying, 'Do not punish anybody with Allah's punishment (fire).' I would have killed them according to the statement of Allah's Messenger , Whoever changed his Islamic religion, then kill him.'"
@matswessling660013 күн бұрын
just more claims...
@Airguy233414 күн бұрын
Shit Quran 😊
@mohammedmatagi798314 күн бұрын
lie', how do you seperate mohammed from quran? i think you reject mohammed and allah
@dhruvyamdagni585815 күн бұрын
what are you presuming happiest and all that,and another thing, even if you could make it legal then, does it change the fact that all of the common sense and maturity and biological knowledge we have now its clearly very wrong for this to happen to a girl of young age .
@dhruvyamdagni585815 күн бұрын
did you say a child didn't complain who didnt anything of the world so why would we? Are you serious ?.
@JudeKillswitch-vj8cx15 күн бұрын
So the answer is simple. And this is all muslims answers. Because allah said it lol. That is why muslim are so backward lol
@at898117 күн бұрын
The q&a section just proves how big of a problem this is within the ummah 😅
@gedliness197918 күн бұрын
Consciousness is an emergent property of the neural activity of the brain.
@charlievaughan130818 күн бұрын
I AM. NOT AN. ATHEIST. I AM AGNOSTIC. THE CONTINGENCY ARGUMENT IS NOT THE TYPE. OF. ARGUMENT THAT KEEPS ME AWAKE AT. NIGHT. WONDERING IF I SHOULD GO BACK TO THEISM.
@Laymen6219 күн бұрын
__**Al-Imām Al-Bukhārī (رحمه الله) reported :**__ **Abū ʿAbdi Allāh [Al-Imām Aḥmad] (رحمه الله) said :** **“Their movements, voices, acquisitions, and writings are created. As for the Qurʾān that is recited, clear, and recoded in the Muṣ-ḥaf, written and inscribed, memorized in the hearts, it is the speech of Allah and not created.** Allāh said (as translated to), “Rather, it [i.e., the Qurʾān] is distinct verses [preserved] within the breasts of those who have been given knowledge.” [Al-ʿAnkabūt: 49].” [Khalq Afʿāl Al-ʿIbād, Vol 2, p. 70]
@charlievaughan130819 күн бұрын
USER-- KJ619ei. I have been trying to reply. I am busy at present. But will replay later.
@charlievaughan130818 күн бұрын
REPLY TO USER--- KJ619E1 It is evident to me that you have not read my reply properly. I have a number of questions so that you can clarify what you mean. You say "" that statement in and of itself is refuted for that accepting that statement you depend on logic"" What statement are you referring to.? The second point I wish to make is this: I am agnostic. I am arguing that no philosophical argument conclusively shows that God exists, Have you got an argument that could show I'm wrong? The third point: You say "" When you cannot refute something you start to speak like a Christian": What have I tried to refute? Also you make a bigoted/ sectarian to reference to Christianity.
@AbhishekTiwari111119 күн бұрын
Human history in Qur'an are Allah's attributes ?
@charlievaughan130820 күн бұрын
I MUST ADMIT AS AN AGNOSTIC, THE CONTINGENCY ARGUMENT DOESNT KEEP ME AWAKE AT NIGHT, WONDERING IF I SHOULD GO BACK TO THEISM. I AM REMINED OF PROFESSOR PETER VAN INGAN OF NOTRE DAME UNIVERSITY HE SAID "" I HAVE TO ADMIT AS A PHILOSOPHER, YOU'D BE CRAZY TO BELIEVE ANYTHING OF ULTIMATE SIGNIFICANCE ON THE BASIS OF A PHILOSOPHICAL ARGUMENT."". END OF QUOTE.
@user-kj6jl9el1j19 күн бұрын
that statement in of itself is refuted for that accepting that statement you depend on logic . it is funny when the only thing you gotta say is someone saying he does not know greater philosophers than that dude believed in god and vice versa. when you can not refute somthing you start to speak like a christain lol
@charlievaughan130819 күн бұрын
@@user-kj6jl9el1j I can't find my first reply. What I said, I am busy at the moment but I will get back to you.
@charlievaughan130819 күн бұрын
@@user-kj6jl9el1j My reply keeps disappearing. I am busy at present. I will be replying to you.
@bigbowss981713 күн бұрын
Yet you're using a philosopher's quote as ultimate truth to stand by. How non-theist can live in constant cognitive dissonance without realizing is fascinating. Whats crazy is entertaining for more than 5 seconds that anything can conceivably proceed from nothing, thats actual insanity mate
@charlievaughan13089 күн бұрын
@@bigbowss9817 I would now like to reply to your posting. As it may be a wee bit long, I will have to subdivide my reply. Let me state again that I am not an atheist. I am agnostic. Its possible.ffor an Einsteinian God to exist. Einstein, when asked if he believed in God, replied "" I believe in Spinoza's God" Einstein rejected the Abrahamic God. I will nowsubdivide my reply. Back in about 15 minutes.
@TexasBig21 күн бұрын
**** Before the Quran it was recorded. The Bible (Collection of books) is filled with stories of intelligent women who played significant roles in shaping the course of history and inspiring others with their wisdom, courage, and faith. Here are a few examples: Eve, the first woman created by God, is often misunderstood as being naive or foolish, but she is also described as being intelligent and aware of the consequences of her actions. Her decision to eat the forbidden fruit shows her ability to think critically and make decisions. Abigail, the wife of Nabal, is an example of a woman who used her intelligence and wit to diffuse a potentially dangerous situation. When David and his men came to her husband’s property, Abigail intercepted them and convinced David not to attack her husband’s household. Her cleverness and diplomacy saved many lives and earned her a place in the Bible as a wise and resourceful woman. Deborah, a judge and leader of the Israelites, is often referred to as one of the most intelligent and courageous women in the Bible. She led the Israelites to victory over the Canaanites and was a strong advocate for justice and equality. Esther, a Jewish queen of Persia, used her intelligence and cunning to save the Jewish people from persecution. She risked her own life to approach the king and plead for the lives of her people, and her bravery and quick thinking ultimately saved the day. The Proverbs 31 woman is a biblical ideal of a virtuous and intelligent woman. She is described as being capable, intelligent, and virtuous, with a heart that trusts in her husband and values her family. She is a model of wisdom, hard work, and devotion to her family and community. These women, among many others, demonstrate the importance of intelligence, wisdom, and courage in the Bible. They show that women are capable of making a significant impact in the world and that their intelligence and abilities are valued and respected by God.
@TexasBig21 күн бұрын
**** Before the Quran it was recorded. The Bible (Collection of Books) is filled with stories of intelligent women who played significant roles in shaping the course of history and inspiring others with their wisdom, courage, and faith. Here are a few examples: Eve, the first woman created by God, is often misunderstood as being naive or foolish, but she is also described as being intelligent and aware of the consequences of her actions. Her decision to eat the forbidden fruit shows her ability to think critically and make decisions. Abigail, the wife of Nabal, is an example of a woman who used her intelligence and wit to diffuse a potentially dangerous situation. When David and his men came to her husband’s property, Abigail intercepted them and convinced David not to attack her husband’s household. Her cleverness and diplomacy saved many lives and earned her a place in the Bible as a wise and resourceful woman. Deborah, a judge and leader of the Israelites, is often referred to as one of the most intelligent and courageous women in the Bible. She led the Israelites to victory over the Canaanites and was a strong advocate for justice and equality. Esther, a Jewish queen of Persia, used her intelligence and cunning to save the Jewish people from persecution. She risked her own life to approach the king and plead for the lives of her people, and her bravery and quick thinking ultimately saved the day. The Proverbs 31 woman is a biblical ideal of a virtuous and intelligent woman. She is described as being capable, intelligent, and virtuous, with a heart that trusts in her husband and values her family. She is a model of wisdom, hard work, and devotion to her family and community. These women, among many others, demonstrate the importance of intelligence, wisdom, and courage in the Bible. They show that women are capable of making a significant impact in the world and that their intelligence and abilities are valued and respected by God.
@matswessling660022 күн бұрын
"why is there something rather than nothing" is not a question that bothered sane people.
@runiyobeen1223 күн бұрын
how did necessary existence B become (any other way )you did not explain it
@runiyobeen1223 күн бұрын
can you explain more how one of them becomes contingenct I did not quit understand it from the video?
@user-bw7wm4pk4m23 күн бұрын
Subboor brother. Do you have any course on how to deal with darwinism & course on DNA & Genetics. So that we can deal with people who says we share same DNA with chimps so we have common anchestor. When i hear about DNA & genetics, things go over my head. So i think i nead a course to understand this.
@user-gu6gm1fm8f23 күн бұрын
There are no fissils records for evolution because all fossils are fake
@matswessling660023 күн бұрын
grown ups playing with words insteading trying to actually find out about the real world... pathetic.
@matswessling660023 күн бұрын
what we think about the universe doesnt dictate how the universe is.
@user-gu6gm1fm8f24 күн бұрын
Allah didn't mention dinosaurs because they never existed. The Qur'an can be ever undermined. There are no other human species other than Adam and his progeny. All those other human species are fiction. They never existed. It is haram to attribute things to Allah which He has not ascribed to himself under pretext "Allah creates whterver He wants" the ge general statement is true but the specification without reliable authentic proof is false. Scientific evidence cannot be taken as proof because they are the works of human imagination and fabricated evidences. The big bang did not happen. it is a false theory . The earth is not 4.5 billion years old only only Allah knows how old it is. The idea of deep time is a scientific myth.
@VirtusetVeritas25 күн бұрын
As christians say the blood is on Pontius Pilate's hands for killing christ even though he gave the decision to the pharisees to make. Much the same way the blood is on Muhammad's hands for the massacre of the jews.
@nasirbhat405226 күн бұрын
Nabeel qureshi was never muslim he was an ahmadi.
@opkique716627 күн бұрын
b thoery of time is all you need for a infinite future and past
@mohamedshaafi958127 күн бұрын
Yes a explanation of the his book would be amazing 😂
@CalvinPug.m828 күн бұрын
"a rose by any other name would smell as sweet". Meaning it is what it is. Regardless of misdirections.
@CalvinPug.m828 күн бұрын
The same old answer. Your interpretation is wrong.
@marc3dartist60119 күн бұрын
I'm here two year later and yes, all this blabla while the hadiths are crystal clear. Women are deficient in intelligence and religion and they form the majority of dweller in hell according to the peace be upon him guy.
@idrisschaalale32529 күн бұрын
The last thing he said ''U can not have endless boundaries, and then have no forgiveness'' isn't it the opposite of what he was speaking of?
@dionjewitt181629 күн бұрын
Trying to defend slavery is weird Islam never banned slavery so why even try to defend it Guy is tapped
@silkydude24 күн бұрын
The word slavery is misleading here as it's linked to transatlantic slavery. This was more akin to a system to deal with prisoners of war since prisons did not exist. Islam gave these POW rights and standards of living. I recommend you read Jonathan Browns book slavery and Islam for a detailed deep dive as a KZbin comment section is not enough
@dionjewitt181629 күн бұрын
Hijab talking shit
@ifrahimansari936329 күн бұрын
also what is the link to original
@ifrahimansari936329 күн бұрын
keep posting man, i know you took a break but keep posting i love the clips you post
@matswessling6600Ай бұрын
just a quagmire of baseless assertions. explanation" is not a property of the physical object. It is a model in our mind only. same with "depenency". its a model in our mind only. universe can be eternal. universe can be necessary. universe can be independent. there does NOT need to be an "external " reason. you have no idea weather things of limited qualities cannot give rise to themsflves. you dont know if the universe could have been otherwise. you dont know if it would have been possible for universe to exist.
@ayeshayasir866529 күн бұрын
Syperficial understanding of the arguement on your part, which is reperesented by your cognitive perception. Everything in the universe is self evidently contingent. The eternality of something does NOT undermine its dependancy. Here is an analogy. Say we have the eternal sun with its eternal rays. Both the sun and the rays are eternal. hOWEVER. THE RAYS STILL ARE AN EMINENCE FROM THE SUN AND DEPEND UPON IT FOR ITS EXISTENCE. Indicating dependancy and maybe even causality on apriori grounds. Another analogy, say we have the eternal ball on top of an eternal pillow. Both are eternally existent. HOWEVER. THE INDENTATION ON THE PILLOW IS STILL DEPENDANT upon the factor of the ball being on top of the pillow. It is, an IMPECCABLE arguement. And the conclusion of a necassary existence is the ONLY LOGICAL DEDUCTIVE CONCLUSION WHICH AVOIDS ABSURDITY. AND ABSURDITIES BY DEFINITION CANNOT EXIST! A
@ayeshayasir866529 күн бұрын
Also, the universe or the cosmos. Or the MULTIVERSE or even an infinite regress CAN NEVER BE independant or necassary. If the universe is made up of CONTINGENT PARTS there the universe IS contingent. Because this very thing that you prescribe as the UNIVERSE is dependant or composed ofthose dependant parts. Contingent parts such as energy. Which's form or attributes or behaviours are DEPENDANT upon certain circumstances or factors. Its an INESCAPABLE conclusion.
@matswessling660029 күн бұрын
@@ayeshayasir8665 it doesnt become INESCAPABLE just because you want it to be. You have to prove it.
@ayeshayasir866529 күн бұрын
@@matswessling6600 stop strawmanning my arguement, and with all due respect. Provide a valid arguement. Blind assertions are no valid postulate.
@matswessling660029 күн бұрын
@@ayeshayasir8665 strawmanning? you presented no argument, you just claimed that universe is contingent. you have not shorn that the universe is contingent follows from that the parts of universe is contingent. You just claimed it.
In Surah 9:23 "O believers! Do not take your parents and siblings as trusted allies if they choose disbelief over belief. And whoever of you does so, they are the ˹true˺ wrongdoers." it clearer labels parents and siblings who don't follow Islam as "disbelievers" so when it says "disbelievers" they are not referring to solely those who break the peace treaties. Accordingly, Surah 9:29-30 ""Fight those who do not believe in Allah and the Last Day, nor comply with what Allah and His Messenger have forbidden, nor embrace the religion of truth from among those who were given the Scripture,1 until they pay the tax,2 willingly submitting, fully humbled. The Jews say, “Ezra is the son of Allah,” while the Christians say, “The Messiah is the son of Allah.” Such are their baseless assertions, only parroting the words of earlier disbelievers. May Allah condemn them! How can they be deluded ˹from the truth˺?"" So at the very least it says not to entertain the validity nor give any respect whatsoever to Judaism nor Christianity additionally it speaks of using the threat of death to extort people for money. If I am mistaken in my analysis or understanding please correct me.
@twatik28 күн бұрын
The amount of braindamage i just got from this is absurd. Mate, before u give us your tafsir kuffar, search up the definition of context👍
@andrewedward518128 күн бұрын
@@twatik I asked for a correction and you gave me nothing so all your comment did is tell me I'm still correct. Again I'd like a correction if I am wrong
@JJK-iu5fu27 күн бұрын
In understanding the Quran, it is crucial to consider the verses in their entirety and context. Regarding Surah 9:29-30, the mention of fighting non-believers refers to defensive warfare against those who actively oppress and harm Muslims, not a call for indiscriminate violence. It is important to interpret such verses in the historical context they were revealed. According to Surah 2:256, "There is no compulsion in religion," emphasizing the principle of not forcing beliefs on others. Additionally, Surah 60:8 highlights the importance of justice and kindness towards those who do not oppose Muslims based on their faith.
@ChromeMan04Ай бұрын
She was likely 14 according to a Sahi hadith
@tar-elenionmaranwe1275Күн бұрын
Provide the hadith.
@IndDhruv.kАй бұрын
That person was saying there won't be an Jewish or Christianity, but that actually happened by mughals in many part of Asia. And one more thing that book is actually provoking Muslims to fight against non Muslims, as he saying in video specially for non -muslims. Person may change the context of a statement, but the book clearly mentions can't be overwritten.
@JosephHyde84Ай бұрын
So, in short, what you mean is that the murder of all the men and enslavement of women and girls for sex, IS OK BY YOUR LOGIC. You are a dirty pedophile follower. SHAME ON YOU, YOU DESPICABLE LIAR. MAY YOU ROT IN HELL.
@user-ou2fq1mc7mАй бұрын
I think you mean Texas, not NY
@TexasBig21 күн бұрын
WRONG. But hope this helps. a few states where a person can marry at 12 years old with certain conditions. Here are the details: Massachusetts: A person can marry at 12 years old with parental consent. New Hampshire: A person can marry at 12 years old with parental consent and the consent of the judge. Mississippi: A person can marry at 12 years old with parental consent. New Mexico: A person can marry at 12 years old with parental consent, and a 12 or 13 year old can marry with judicial approval and parental consent.