George never went to England. He was from the Middle East.

Didn’t watch. Just wanted to comment a good thing for the ACNA.

Wow, the Anglican Church was at the Council of Nicea! I didn't know that.

Need more

It’s always struck me as fairly obvious that only the Anglican Catholic Church in N/A can be relied upon to hold the line against the encroachment of female clerics. The down side for you would be that they aspire to become a rite of the Roman Catholic Church if and when the Pope may decide that he could tolerate them. But failing that then the only other refuge from the monstrous regiment of women would have to be one of the eastern churches such as the Orthodox Church in America.

So I can choose to commune with a baptist type church that believes the creeds or a church with apostolic succession and celebrate pride month all year long with them. Christ Chuch is invisible and made up of all believers irregardless of denomination. Tares and wheat, he will sort us out in the end.

Reminds me of the local parish here. Very nice and good to see good reformation anglicanism.

Beautiful ordination service. May GOD bless your ministry.

Hi yes I was consecrated a bishop by bishop Macek Gbu. + Monsignor Steven Hartley

Very interesting presentation. ... I have always seen the value and benefits of written prayers either for corporate or individual contexts. Are there any books besides Book of Comman Prayer that are collections of Anglican prayers??

I found this very interesting, instructive, insightful and illuminating. ... I have been in a journey for over 15 years in a deconstruction process away from Evangelicalism and Fundamentalism including a healing process from religious abuse. .... Your lecture was excellent. I would like to continue to explore, read, study, and integrate some elements of this form of Spirituality into my personal spiritual life. What are some your recommendations?

I think becoming Orthodox is the solution ☦️

Thank you. Question answered that I have been asking

the celtic christians were not protestants.

What a load of rubbish!

Years ago I delivered a message on the church’s “organic” unity in spite of institutional disunity - that the Body of Christ is one, in spite of human institutions. When you can accept that, Christians are in all denominations and polities and their unity is in Christ, you can be a much happier Christian. It gives freedom to be in “the pro-life March with Roman Catholics,” as you stated. I worked (secular work) for several years in a church-related institution under an administrator who was a defrocked minister of the sponsoring denomination. I was working alongside many very devout and faithful Christians of that denomination, but this guy was an obvious phony. I could see why he was defrocked. Church institutions are a necessary evil, helping create tools for the work of the Body, but they shouldn’t themselves be considered the sign of unity. That is only found in Jesus Christ.

wow. That was fantastic!! 😄

I love this title! Because so many are not aware that AC was autonomous from the Roman church from its beginning until the end of 6th century.

PLEASE COME HOME TO THE FULLNESS OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH ⛪ MARY AWAITS YOU ALL OF US TO YOUR SYMBOL SERVICES WILL BECOME THE EUCARIST ENOUGH OF THE FLUFF REPENT NOW

I understand that you desire legitimacy through tracing the Anglican Church back-especially as a religious. However, ultimately, the Anglican Church is a compromise which adapted as a result of an extraordinary and long-standing persecution of Catholics. It is a denomination created by, and subject to, the state. The ‘Christianity’ of the Celts was a Christianity that was subject to Rome and occurred as a result of St Patrick and his disciples in the AD 400’s. The Christianity of England resulted from St Augustine in the 500’s. Both were subject to the Pope and Rome, although, like all Catholic regions, both possessed individual characteristics and, indeed, the Irish Catholic Church was influenced by some Druid attitudes and practices - after all, St Patrick catechised a Druid country. The Anglican Church was formed by Henry VIII and, as such, the break with Rome and the installation of Thomas Cranmer as a substitute pope meant that the church was within the jurisdiction of the crown and the lands of the Church - basically communally-held property in trust for the poor- were handed over to those who would support the Tudor claim to the throne. This, the priories- hospitals for the poor, became elegant dwellings for wealthy families loyal to the Tudor rule; the abbeys, similar- once the centres of learning and teaching, now the property of the wealthy, and the chantry chapels, once centres for praying for the souls in purgatory and which also served as local schools to teach the non-aristocracy children, were plundered to the coffers of Henry viii, (after an inventory by Cromwell). This desecration of the chantry chapels resulted in the lack of literacy that England was familiar with in the subsequent centuries and which was wrongly assumed to have existed prior to the Reformation. The Alms houses, too, were houses given to the poor in return for praying for the souls in purgatory. The poor had no relief at all until the awful workhouses were brought in later. This was the church established by Henry VIII under the guise of independence from Rome. Christ established his church on earth under a visible head who was the vicar of Christ - the minister analogous to Elias. You can parse the history all you like, but the Anglican Church was founded in the 1500’s as the result of a huge and traumatic rupture with the Church founded by Christ. Thousands of Catholics were killed by Henry VIII and Elizabeth I for the fact of being Catholic. That is simply a fact. You cannot create a history that predated the reformation because, although Henry claimed to be Catholic , even while desecrating Christ’s body on earth, the later theological justification for the creation of a new religion was based upon Luther, the puritans and the theology that arose at the reformation.

Thanks for the video. This is something I personally struggle with given I hold to the 1689 2LBCF and so Im one that sees a bit of wiggle room with the RPW as you mentioned earlier in the video.

No such thing. The English Church was always Roman up until they broke away. The Church is always Roman cuz of Peter & Paul

England was Roman Catholic up until the reformation. The English Catholics owed their faith to the Papacy. All those saints and missionaries that went to England Ireland Wales and Scotland they all looked to Rome. The papacy has always been the centre of unity within the church. It has always retained the faith and morals of the church from the time of the apostles. The Chair of Peter is the chair of unity. Outside of the chair of Peter there is no unity. One congratulation can believe what it wants. Gbu. + Monsignor Steven Hartley

I could use some guidance. I come from the Baptist tradition (been Baptist all my life) but was recently convinced of infant Baptism, and now looking at where to belong. Really, I am Reformed, and almost went there, but found Anglicanism instead as there are many aspects of this tradition that I do greatly admire and think is the most faithful expression of Christianity. I am very conservative theologically though. Thought the ACNA was Conservative, but this issue of women Priests is beginning to push me away. I don't want to go away, but how can we deal with women Priests? I don't prefer the order of Worship in the Reformed Faith, but at least they know their Bible and follow it!

About the Bayside appearances of Mary in Jesus don't forget the church rejected Saint Joan of Arc Saint Bernadette and many many others and were they from God yes they were and especially at Bayside ask millions who are blessed cured and came into the church and came back to the church I witness it and they were over 265 radio stations that carried the messages from heaven as Mary call them and Canadians came out in the past messages out in America and messages went in different languages across the world and you have to understand when the Catholic Church went liberal you can't expect them to approve of something that is good from God it's going to take the church to come back to the true traditional bible-believing Roman Catholic teachings and that won't happen until the great revival starts period in Christ is king..

I have come face to face with brothers Priests because I rejected the B C P., for the reason that they are incomplete (Protestant). I use the American Missal. What a difference! Both on Sundays and on weekdays. (every day Mass). I bless those people in Oxford who literally labored in the drafting of the Missal, but also endured the attacks of the Protestants during its presentation. Like those in America who dared to separate from the Episcopal Protestant Church and present the Anglican Catholic Church. Not the Roman one, but the Catholic one..

Try Orthodoxy maybe

And if one Bishop goes liberal....the whole Diocese goes with it...in spite of all the people in the congregation, as with what happened in ECUSA and UMC. What a disastrous polity.

Roman Catholic term made up by Anglicans to make Catholic s seem foreign

England was so geographically far from Rome that it was difficult to control it

Thank you for making this video. I was studying Church history, and I had a crisis of faith based on the historical foundations of my denomination. I almost jumped to Roman Catholicism, but this video really gave me pause and it’s making me really examine Anglicanism. The Roman Catholic Papacy is very hard for me to accept, but at the same time most Protestant denominations today have gone off the rails in terms of Church doctrines, and there’s no real solid historical foundation in these denominations. Anglicanism is a viable alternative to Roman Catholicism IMO.

No...the English Church WAS Roman. If not, what did Henry VIII and Elizabeth I seperate themselves from?

You made this crap up to justify your false Organizations validity...

Thank you Fr. Macias! What are aome good books for further reading on thia subject?

Having traveled the road from being a Reformed Christian, to Roman Catholic, I have learned that there are three different "histories" of the church- the Roman version, the Protestant version, and the secular version. It is nearly impossible for a well-meaning layman to navigate these waters- even one who has studied the Bible for many years. I find myself wondering if I crossed the Tiber hastily given the current state of things in Rome. An authoritative list of references would be especially helpful here, father. Thank you for your informative discussion.

Glad you agree that Constantine was a tyrant

Marazion in Cornwall comes from the import of Zion.

Yes, st dagobert from way before the seventh century ...anglicanism has rather most shamefull beginning the celtic faith was started by catholic missionaries based on the principle that lough the the sun god became jesus christ this happened because they wher awaiting a sun gods son to be born ...and it went from ther ...anglicanism was born in the Worst way possible.. a church full if witch's and warlocks henry and ann Bolin are like jezabel and ahab ...it was born in iniquity my boy accept it ...Peter is the vice regent of christ the king that's what the key is about you bitter boy ...😂 but before henry england had the Sarum rite that was way more commendable. ...old merry England pity henry 8 put her to death replacing her with grey england ...now she's being replaced by ...gay england.

What religion did GOD GIVE Adam ??? None!!!! Adam sinned & world changed - We MUST BE BORN AGAIN TO UNDO THE ALLEGIANCE TO WORLD FLESH DEVIL RETURN ALLEGIANCE TO GOD /JESUS PAID IN FULL FOR OUT SIN ALL THIS IS MAN MADE WORLDLY RELIGION - nothing of God! Would Jesus sit in your church? Never I do not believe he would undermine all his sufferings to be involved with useless manadeceigopn Jesus told the religious leaders of His day -“ you will die in your sin because you read the holy scriptures because you believe in them you will find eternal life- but the scripture speaks of ME I AM THE ONLY WAY TRUTH LIFE NO MAN GETS TO THE FATHER BUT BY ME JOHN14:6

What absurd nonsense

God or a supreme being is apriori in most cultures... except atheism. Many cultures change the ontological nature of a supreme being... Odin and Zeus come to mind. The understanding of an supreme deity devolved into polytheism. The supreme was demoted from omnipotence. A pantheon was also created. Deity was highly anthropomorphised. Nimrod was the propogator of this antichrist religious ideology.

I would suggest that the period 680-1014, when England had adopted the Filioque but Rome had not, is the longest period of an arguably non-Roman English Church in ancient history. This may be the opposite of what various fantasists are wanting to hear.

St George is not England's patron saint, but the Protector of England. If you are going to go back into history like this, then you need to start getting it right. St Peter would appear to have been the original patron saint, being a fisherman.

Thank you so much for the talk; I truly appreciated it. It introduced me to Kuyper, and it has inspired me to study him further for the glory of Christ. I’d like to offer a suggestion, shared with love. I found myself struggling with the rhythm of your delivery. At times, it felt like you were rushing, and I could almost sense the need to catch my breath because of the pacing. This is something that will likely develop naturally over time, but if you could slow down a bit, adding pauses here and there, and focus on emphasizing key ideas rather than every word, I think it would greatly enhance what is already excellent. Blessings to you, my beloved.

Mary the mother of Jesus appeared in Bayside New York for two and a half decades starting in 1970 with Jesus and she said no one can call themselves Catholic unless they come under the pope she talks about the separated brethren that's all other churches Protestant orthodox and she said if you're coming back to the true Catholic Church you must accept the truth that you protested against... And Christ is king.

Agreed that IRL being church, fellowship, worship and discipleship is the way forward. What is YOUR circle of influence? I think of RZ's Reconquista plan which is nothing more than a slightly organized version of working within one's own circle of influence. Are you a layman? Find an orthodox pastor, join his church and support the heck out of it. Can you join a committee? Join it! Can you join a seminary faculty? (not achievable by everyone of course) Join. Can you become a seminarian for a "squishy" ACNA diocese (or heck, even TEC) and watch what happens to your circle of influence! Nothing will change over night but remember that the progressives won because they played the long game: they didn't pack up and leave after various setbacks, plodded long even for decades, worked out how to form friendly relationships with conservatives and traditionalists, waited for people to retire, joined committes, slowly voted for their friends to various offices, joined seminaries, got ordained, waited some more and then slowly and incrementally brought in changes. It worked for them, it will work for us.

8:30 I was at an Evangelical Anglican church that watered down the Anglican distinctives do much that I left and went Presbyterian because at least they did what they believed with conviction. I say that with mega churches, baptists, non-denoms and pentecostals on every corner, Anglicans gotta carve our their niche! What difference do Anglicans bring to the table?? BE that difference!

34:17 small determined minorities can effect great things. This is how society and the churches went crazy in the first place.

Out of interest, how common are new female ordinands in the ACNA dioceses which have them?

The shrinking Episcopal Church in America. It is quickly becoming a church of the past, and will likely not exist by the end of this century.