Marcus do you have a list of all those pop up references you could put in the show notes? Thank you

1:09:36 no question: they used Roberts rules of order and the King James Bible 😂

39:42 this is cultures biggest problem

❤

Awesome seeing Jordan on here!!!❤

Anyone know the story of the bees they’re referring to?

What a gem. Thank you.

I went back to this, as I’m in the middle of his book right now. The ending of the podcast was indeed particularly powerful. I am inspired to try to get my students to use stories we read in a conversation, like he did with his children-as a way of showing mastery of the texts. Also, would love to see you do a CS Lewis school in Ireland. Apparently there are Chesterton schools in America. And thanks again to your guest for his book! I highlighted a bunch today, that I could use in the classroom, most notably the map vs the landscape idea under “the purpose of literature” section. - Jeff

I was only telling friends of mine about Paul Kingsnorth and John Moriarty last night ! Martin Shaw and Paul show up in my timeline this morning. Synchronicity? Tom Holland is excellent also. Thanks.

This guy is an almost endless well of knowledge.

Please get these two gentlemen for a round 2 conversation!

Inspiring story. Thanks for being so open and sharing it.

Very interesting guest and great interview. It was an insightful point about dance being left behind by the church. Dancehalls and nightclubs carry so much religious symbolism and are a great way to commune but the church seems to have given that space over to secularism. I also like the idea that Love can be explored through Soul music. Given God can be expressed as love it's nice to think listening to my Stax records I'm actually doing some theology homework. I hadn't even thought about the name "Soul" music much before but if course it carries such obvious religious connotations.

Keep your mind in hell but do not despair!

This book and video is truly a treasure! Thank You!

When you asked him if he has a different approach from Vervaeke he proceeded to recapitulate one of John’s most central arguments 😆. Those two should talk.

Very good discussion thank you, Marcas

Thank you for this video

JBP is a lucky man. Tammy’s witness is inspirational, charming and insightful. God bless her and her family

Sorry that ;you have had so much suffering. Your faith shines through.

Underrated channel with an underrated guest.

This is the conversation brought me back to God one year ago. I am thankful for all those who made this possible..

i loved this, thank you

Ok but I want to hear the bees story…

Gotta love a podcast with a 75 item booklist attached!

Thank you for sharing this wonderful testimony. :)

Very interesting. Thank you. And God bless you.

Perhaps intentionally "Slipping the moorings" to re-read the Bible may have been an act of faith? Chesterton describes his conversion as feeling like he was a magnet rotating at just past the distance of attraction until one day it grabbed him. Then the rest of the journey begins...twenty years in as a Wiccan-to-Catholic and still learning every day. Great discussion.

Can you send me to the version of that intro song...its bevome one of my fav intros in all of YT

34:00 traditional life

Thank you Calvin, a voice of reason in troubled times, God bless you and your ministry.

Bernardo is one of the greatest minds of our time, excellent interview, thanks for the video.

Another EXCELLENT one! Thanks, Marcus.

This was an insightful and deep conversation, thank you so much for making this happen! The ART of the Hebrew Bible is simply sublime, and Robert is absolutely THE person to demonstrate this to us all. God bless.

Prof. Jacob Mitchell at Georgetown does a lot of work on how woke is based on religion. His book American Awakening is great on this. He said, the right can't effectively fight the woke, because its "canons" are pointed in the wrong direction - at socialism, not at woke as a religion. According to Mitchell, one way to beat woke is to expose it from the Christian point of view as a false religion, a lie.

What about telling some of your dreams Martin ..the mythic thinking you and JBP have the insight and courage to mention our connection to our inner nature,sensory functions . As it now proved even scientific that We dream Every night ,our creativity source the purest source of imagination ..

Loved that he mentioned the Hungarian myth in connection to Nimrod since I had just learned about that today. Providence. The source I saw indicated that this was probably to lay a claim to the lands of Attila the Hun, since they claimed Nimrods two sons were the founders of the Huns and Magyar

I sincerely enjoy your interviews. You ask thoughtful, clarifying questions in a gentle manner that is so healing to listen to. Like Holly, I grew up reading Tolkien (and Lewis) since the age of ten. I read the entire Hobbit and Lord of the Rings aloud to my dyslexic little brother the summer I was 15. I have never stopped reading him and collecting books, art, letters, maps and of course the wonderful Histories by his devoted son. I have just ordered Holly’s book and it will arrive tomorrow…I am 73 now and am looking at my grandchildren now reading, drawing and discussing Middle Earth. So happy to have passed the gift of reading and this treasure of a story to them. And I have a new addition to my library arriving tomorrow! Thanks to you and to Holly for such a satisfying interview. Namarië.

Wonderful interview! Both informative and uplifting! Thank you! 🥰

Tolkien's faith has always been an enigma to me, but I think it is the difference between his perspective on the work of Lewis and his own. If the Types are buried deeply they will instantiate themselves deeply. Of course the difficulty also stems from the Protestant and Catholic experiences of faith and all the misunderstandings that are produced. This biography is one I think I will have to digest. Thanks to you, both!

Great interview, thanks!

I think Fr Calvin is briilliant and good.i agree with him about race and Christianity and many thingx. There is a world language called Esperanto and you won't find rCially negative in Esperanto. It was created tohelp peace friendship and understanding. Many Christians are in it and thereare three Catholicism saints it in. All major religions approve of it. It is easy to translate into and out of it. It keeps down translation costs. The secod point is i approve of stay at home mothers. My mother was a teacher too and i resented her working. She didnt really care about me only my older brother who had isssues. She had no time for me as she was too wrapped up in her career. I stayed at home and talk the children sll i could beofre they went to school. I asl fed the children as nature intended for as long as i could because i belueved it was better. How can you do that if you are working.expressed milk in bottles is not as goid. I also cared for the extended frail in the nuclear and extended famiyl. I done believe in care homes and nurseries except in special circumstances. I hated my mother working but i didn't say because she'd have done what she wanted any way and only cared for my brother. I didn't bond with my mother although she thought all was fine. Ipicked up the slck from working mothers sho neglected their aged parents. The headmistress next door poured scorn on me being being at home with my bevy of children yet had the nerve to expect me babysit her children while at school meetings! Never mind if i want a doze through twice nightly night feeds and feeding every night for 1 to 2 years. WHO recommended if possible and so do I. Hosewives can be the salt of the earth. I was highly qualified but the most important path ibtook was being a housewife and doing voluntary work when i could.

Fr Calvin will not find racism in the Esperanto community. Many Christian all in it, in fact people of all faiths and nn. Their are three saints in it, two priests and one pope. I cannot separate my Christianity from Esperanto. This is the best way in combating racial inequalities. The more Calvin says I am convinced that Esperanto is a very good aid to world peace, friendship and understanding. I cannot separate it from my Christianity.

I saw an animated series lately called Vinland Saga. It follows English and Viking history and has many famous people in it but what really captured me was how they treated Christianity. It first Christians seem weak and pathetic, you feel sorry for them but as the story goes on the main character finds himself and others in an endless cycle of violence and the subtle teachings of Christ prove to be the only answer and response that can end the hate, the slavery, the murder, etc. I’m not sure that the maker of the cartoon had that as their purpose, but it was just so powerful to see.

Loved this interview and your thought-provoking questions!

Here's the thing. The countenance of sincere Christians is the telling thing. There is always such warmth and intelligence in their faces. Just something I've noticed.

The problem with process theology is that is clearly not biblical. Philosophical ideas have the upper hand in it.

And yeah Tom Woods is great - how I heard about Gottfried in the first place. I actually emailed Gottfried about something he said on Tom's podcast and he emailed me back! :-P

Who is the Canadian mentioned at 36 minutes - Richard Douchen? I don't know how to spell his name so Google has not been fruitful. Thanks!

I love the phrase "the luminous present" reminds me of RH Thomas's poem The Bright Field "Life is not hurrying on to a receding future, nor hankering after an imagined past. It is the turning aside like Moses to the miracle of the lit bush, to a brightness that seemed as transitory as your youth once, but is the eternity that awaits you."