What have I just stumbled upon..! A KZbin video from when KZbin was small and new! And you're still here and posting!

huh

Rest easy ❤

This video is 16 years old, amazing! I feel like an archaeologist digging up a treasure

Very interesting conversation. I don’t think Balmuth is likely correct here about Wittgenstein not having intended to repudiate the Tractatus. But hard to say for sure. Been a matter of controversy - like much with Wittgenstein for decades. In any case, Wittgenstein’s thinking from the Investigations is desperately needed these days.

They were reading Heidegger, but had they put in the background work to be able to understand what they were reading? When I hear about architects reading Heidegger's "Building Dwelling Thinking" I am always reminded of the scene in the film "My Dinner with Andre" when the protagonist quotes Heidegger, but it's so out of context that it's obvious that it is only being done to try to score intellectual points.

You were right

I must say, I'm inclined to agree..

thnx

Daniel, you can aggregate and submit these clips in one big interview now :D

Oh dear, Charles Tilly passed away April 29, 2008 - that is just 5 months after this interview! :'O

Groetjes naar alle voc mensen van de rug

mad lad

The worker in Argentina are not thinking this way. When they got wind of the fact that the owner of the factories and machinery was going to sell the company out from under them to an outside hedge fund investor(s) the workers realized two things contractual relations were violated by the owner(s). By selling the machines the owners was taking away the productivity of the workers and so the workers occupied the factories, slept overnight next to the machines and continued working them by themselves by day completely under their control and organization. In short, the Kirschner government are not cracking down on the workers that took over the factories of the owner and they remain in court over the breech of contract with the owner but the government, national guard, police, community and society are finding out that the worker take over has raised the GNP, making society less endemic of poverty. Why aren't workers in America doing this when companies are being sold out from under their feet by Wall Street investment firms? So the workers learn solidarity, community and merge education with their trade work in the factory, to which less kids are on the streets, and would never work for a boss again in Argentina. Infected by the bug of real emancipation Argentinian working class are more revolutionary in a positive way than American workers ought to be given the American working class is far more the most powerful in the world but is the least intellectually developed, makes America a paradox.

12 سنه ولا تعليق اول تعليق 2020/11/3😂😂

Just read his 'How to Be an Anti-capitalist in the 21st Century'. Brilliant book. Very clear, insightful, pragmatic. Helps you think clearly and systematically.

Rest In Power...Your work here is done.

Thanks for this interview, it was very stimulating for my thesis work. Greetings from north of Argentina.

Crema

A powerful and enriching series about a sister who continues to inspire, guide and nurture on a local global work of Love. I am so thankful for her existence. Thank you

This is good information for all who want to imagine alternatives and possibilities - such a clear thinker and speaker.

i love him

Thanks for conducting, recording, and posting this interview. Lots of nice insights.

Let us keep Trump out of the conversation; let's keep Obama out of it, forget about climate change in this conversation, set aside race for the moment. And I am right there with you.

Se pronuncia "Tili" o "Táili"?

Science should aim at developing agency with respect to its subject matter. Or science that matters makes a difference to our agency in relation to its subject. Perhaps the reason why (say) physics, electrical engineering, chemistry, metallurgy, medicine, etc., have the value that they do, is precisely because they make a difference to our ability to manipulate our relationship to the pertinent phenomenon, that results in some useful (practical) advantage. To wit- ‘you understand something to the extent that you can control your relationship to it’. Understanding in the absence of agency is redundant.

Hello. Could you translate this interview to spanish? That's will really hepfull to me. I'm studying for a midterm that I'll have. Thank you

RICH AND FAMOUS

Por favor necesito informacion de charles tilly en español o subtitulada y no encuentro aqui en you tube, solo en internert, pero no me es suficiente aun :(

I'm very overwhelmed by his works, and yes, he truly deserves much more attention. On the other hand, however, it is also understandable that such an academic figure doesn't get enough attention. People and press wants something simple, something that can be put into a slogan. Tilly would've never engaged in such an enterprise.

the dynamics of the revolution

Great interview Charles.

I know exactly what you are talking about

Thank you Daniel Little for this very informative interview. Semra Somersan

Brilliant. He does not dissolves our individuality away, he marks out the individual a result of the social. Classic Systems perspective. Love his mind,Brilliant. God rest his soul.

It is painful to see how little recognition Sociologists get compared to Economists,Philosophers and Physicist. It is true economist,physicist are of more value but on sheer intellectual terms Sociology is as interesting. They are way too undervalued. A comparable giant like Tilly in Economics or philosophy would have got 600 and 200 comments I guess. Tilly was trult the greatest American Sociologist of his time.

Not really, Physics or Chemistry cannot tell me when will the world economy recover. I need Economics for that. so and on. The biggest statement ever made may be Why something exist as opposed to Nothing? But that does not make me very intelligent or knowledgeable. Too big a brush may not always be equal to knowledge.

por favor quien puede colocar subtitulo a esta entrevista

The mind is of nature and matter.

@JamesDestry1 That depends on the nature of the mind. If it is only physical (which most philosophers of the mind think), then it certainly is within the domains of the natural sciences. It is not for any of us to decide what the realm of science is. Nature is what it is, wether you like it or not. Philosophy has long seemed like a dead-end to me.

@astroboomboy Fair enough, but I believe that the mind belongs to philosophy. Let matters of nature belong to science, let the mind belong to philosophy.

@JamesDestry1 What are you on? If this Magnus turned out to be wrong, well then the scientific approach worked.

Why is it that in videos on social sciences and humanities there are comments like the one below? You would never find a comment like that on a video on the natural sciences. It makes me wonder what kinds of people are interested in social sciences, if anybody is the jackass it is the guy below me...

Interesting, i'm reading about state formation at my Uni right now.

is there an underlyin law?

The most fundamental question of all: What is The underlying law of nature?

thank you for putting this up

land reform by importing jihadis form bangladesh, bhai ho.

A great scholar. RIP