dude i'm devastated, literally THREE of the characters in my main team got a VA change.. argenti, huohuo, and now her. (argenti was the most heartbreaking one tho)
@Grey_Silva38 сағат бұрын
The new one feels like more tingyun the old ones makes me feel like its phantylia
@F2p_gacha_addict15 сағат бұрын
This is downgrade why did hoyo do that
@drea4pres97019 сағат бұрын
I like the new one more. She sounds like a real person, unlike the first one.
@BobassukiКүн бұрын
I just started playing and new voice is so much better than the old one , I understand Hoyo sometimes kills characters like in ZZZ they did to Lucy but here nah
@kokonat8092 күн бұрын
The old on is more suitable for her 💔💔
@Lowe-c8b2 күн бұрын
The old Tingyun had an almost sickly sweet quality to her voice which made her seem like she was always scheming and trying to sneak information out of you by being kind. The new voice is good, but it lacks that tone.
@SanyKiwi3 күн бұрын
imagine the next one would be Firefly...
@228Drake3 күн бұрын
Imagine if Aventurine...
@sishakur67153 күн бұрын
The new one feels a bit more... Down to earth... As in she lowered her guard down when she's with us, no more acting as a tour guide. Just her. And maybe i am coping but eh Ting yun is Ting yun
@santiagoramos13134 күн бұрын
It could be just me or does the writing feel a bit...odd. I can't put my finger on what in particular, but it seems disjointed. It could be that the nuances of the chinese version didn't carry through in the english version or that the writers assumed that the chinese term of phrases would be the same in english, but the dialogue just feels a bit roque.
@Florin20D4 күн бұрын
They murdered Tingyun with this change.On Fugue it would have made sense to have a new va since her former self is long gone but why replace the va for both?
@danalynch1185 күн бұрын
She doesn’t sound cutesy anymore :(
@cheshireshadow5185 күн бұрын
aww, she's not cute and perky in the voice anymore. the gap moe, it's gone 😔
@nucleardamage15 күн бұрын
Everyone in this comment section is a completely nonsensical lunatic. Her new voice is super cute and sweet. "Fight as one" always hits right. Everyone else needs a job.
@awesomeawesome41884 күн бұрын
@@nucleardamage1 People have a right to feel different about the change because the new one is taking on a completely different tone than the old one. Calling everyone a lunatic for not liking the new one immediately makes you the insane one. The voice that has been Tingyun’s since 1.0, the release of the game, suddenly gets changed in 2.7, nearly two years later, people have a right to feel disappointed and sad and they also have a right to express their thoughts on the matter. Maybe you’re the one who needs a job if you’re here ranting about people disliking change (which is completely normal).
@Yummers3215 күн бұрын
Bro turned into summoners rift announcer 😭
@Yummers3215 күн бұрын
Tingyun if she was depressed 😔
@QSZ-o7o6 күн бұрын
EN dub is so cringe 😂
@mariababer79506 күн бұрын
I don't mind the new VA, but the old one made her...stand out to me and feel different Why'd they have to change her VA though?
@alexia35526 күн бұрын
Am I the only one on the internet who exclusively battled in 2x speed? That's where my nostalgia is locked and I can't find recordings of OG Tingyun in 2x 😭
@pokeygem67836 күн бұрын
I somewhat get it like the old va represents Phant(that chick that off tingyun) and the new old va represents ones identity lost but reborn yet no longer the same so basically a different person Or in a nutshell va replacement
@Flexiawan6 күн бұрын
Okay, the new one make something "arise" on me
@garyoakham97236 күн бұрын
Blame the va for striking. This is all on them. Japanese, Chinese, and Korea va are literal gods but American ones want more for the same work
@ashotpetrosyan5756 күн бұрын
Team old
@kuron69287 күн бұрын
Why would they change it? She was one of the VA I looked forward to hearing perform! :(
@sabre43827 күн бұрын
Hmmm… after listening side by side basically, ntm doing the story. Think I do like the new one more. And seeing a lot of people whine about certain lines not being there anymore, but always typing the wrong lines
@FlamboyantlyNecoArc7 күн бұрын
we’re losing such great voices 😢
@teahunter63377 күн бұрын
Why, hoyo.. Old VA was one of my favorites. The new one sounds more like an NPC 😢
@xxintimexx99738 күн бұрын
Honestly, they should keep “Tingyun” voice as old one, and change only Fugue.
@ashchusatoshi9448 күн бұрын
Ngl the new one sucks compared to the old one... But there's nothing we could do about it... sigh.... goodbye tingyun
@Zukie-8 күн бұрын
why is it always the foxians bru😭
@Gyatt_game_698 күн бұрын
Old ones were much better
@Gambit86428 күн бұрын
Why they changed her va?
@onlyuwaku8 күн бұрын
Ruan Mei, What did you do to her voice?
@sh.ouroboros8 күн бұрын
When the game came out, Tingyun was the first character that brought me a little closer to the world of Lofu and the game as a whole. Even though the characters weren't the reason I started playing, it was because of individual characters like Tingyun that I decided to give the story and characters a chance. The original voice actor's VO was great. Her performance made it clear, hinted that something dark was hiding behind this fox, despite her carefree and kind attitude towards the squad. There were other factors, but the actress's work contributed a lot to it. At least for me. Seeing the life and joy sucked out of her voice and character so much... It breaks my heart as someone who chose to trust the quality and sincerity of English voice actors. I guess I won't be able to look at EN VO again anytime soon and will switch to JP or CN...
@writerducky25898 күн бұрын
The new one makes sense for Fugue, but old one makes sense for Tingyun. Why did they change VA? Even if Tingyun was an exact copy Phantylia made, Fugue's voice could have been altered due to what she went through. I can understand if it's due to IRL stuff, but if it's just for lore reasons they didn't need to do this at all😭 I'm gonna miss: "Can we talk?" Especially since the new battle lines, like HuoHuo and Argenti sound like a rush job and not enough time to get into chatacter. RIP
@Infinitely_89 күн бұрын
i miss the old voice so much 😢
@DafontaineArashi-z3s9 күн бұрын
What the heck hoyo Bring back the old one 😮 this new voice only suit fugue (depressed tingyun after her horrible experience) not her old version
@Beryl-W4tt9 күн бұрын
the old va repost en dub strike related topic and got replaced by other va instantly 😂
@sabre43827 күн бұрын
She was against ai stuff herself big time also, rather replaced or just plain quit
@awesomeawesome41884 күн бұрын
I can't believe how many people think it was because of the strike. The studio (Rocket Sound) has already signed the necessary contracts needed for the VAs to continue working during the strike. Tingyun's old VA actually had one voiceline at the end of the mission in 2.5 and didn't get replaced until 2.7 meaning it wasn't because of the strike. Argenti and Huohuo's VAs got replaced before the strike even began. We don't know why these replacements keep happening, but there's more than enough evidence that it isn't the strike.
@gogame4life4999 күн бұрын
the new one more like mommy?? i like it
@z33iihh9 күн бұрын
They gave her the barbruh treatment, at this point i think its a Hoyo rule to do this. No disrespect to the new VA obviously.
@FD-wl7xq9 күн бұрын
New VA shuld be for Fugue only and old VA should only be for Tungyun.Cause New VA fits Fugue very well and old VA works very well for Tingyun
@Kimmy_Too229 күн бұрын
There no more "minus one" misheard 😢
@Anekal-wwwj9 күн бұрын
This is why I changed my hsr to japanese
@Duuia-rv3sn10 күн бұрын
See this is why I always mute her when she speaks
@skinnyboi893710 күн бұрын
I'm still not over Argenti VA being replaced and now this?
@fubukinaufal1910 күн бұрын
New one is Meh
@sacv54110 күн бұрын
No hate but the new voice doesnt fit her at all plus old one was so much more expressive nothing we can do now tho such a shame
@masterplusmargarita10 күн бұрын
Anya is legitimately really good, IMO, but she really misses on "Good Omens, fight as one!", I think. Laci's delivery sounds so excited that she's slightly losing control at the end and it's both endearing and a little scary, where Anya's is pretty flat. Anya matches or even occasionally surpasses the performance on the rest of these though (Her 'evils begone' clears, IMO), and she's really good in story dialogue scenes.
@Kazeshini112 күн бұрын
If you consider that good, I'm afraid to ask what you find bad. I just heard Tingyun for the first time in months and I instantly knew they had changed the VA cause the new VA sounded dead inside and bored. Like she didn't even want to record those lines and did it just to get a pay check and be done with it. I wouldn't have minded if she was like that for Fugue cause new character, different voice it's all good. But for Hoyo to ask her to butcher one of the most beloved characters of HSR is pure trash. She's trash at voicing Tingyun.
@sapphireblue984810 күн бұрын
I liked the new voice for Fugue but I wish that Tingyun's wasn't changed. Laci Morgan's performance will be missed as she was one of my fav voices in the game and part of the reason why I use Tingyun often, Anya Floris sounds good though and I wish both VAs the best.
@yiyang_cheng10 күн бұрын
I’ve never felt this disappointed in HSR before, I will miss the “better late than never” so much, it was my favorite voice line :(