To be honest he good character i did like him as a character i did wish Rick and him could have been friends again like the old days and plus he got upset because he thought his friend rick again was die he did everything to keep him safe and life his friend because i have a feeling he would come back in way really i don't really now yet.
@TPFB12920 күн бұрын
I hate Lori, and Shanes worst mistakes were A trying to keep her, and B, not ditching the group with Andrea.
@DavidSmith-ed5txАй бұрын
He was one of my favorite characters. He would have led the group better than Rick. Didn't take chances like Rick did.
@anya_winters2274Ай бұрын
I know this is an old video, but how are we not going to mention that he sexually assaulted Lori back at the CDC… Lori was not perfect by any means but you cannot argue that he was right in assaulting her
@MrLeroy42Ай бұрын
@@anya_winters2274 He’s a piece of shit for that. I’m not arguing with you.
@user-tg1rf6ox1tАй бұрын
Finally someone that brings lori up in the way I would thank u 💯
@MrLeroy42Ай бұрын
No problem man. I try to look at everything objectively in pursuit of the truth and I feel I left no stone unturned including Lori.
@user-tg1rf6ox1tАй бұрын
@@MrLeroy42 that's the go 🗿
@user-tg1rf6ox1tАй бұрын
He's always been my fav since the first time I saw it
@MrLeroy42Ай бұрын
He’s great. Not as a person, but definitely as a character.
@user-tg1rf6ox1tАй бұрын
@@MrLeroy42 most definitely
@gregorydelorme80944 ай бұрын
This my favourite song by them look at all of their extra gear in the back😊
@adamnerd12364 ай бұрын
Lori is the real villain
@crystalshaw87444 ай бұрын
My mama always said always go with your first mind.
@crystalshaw87444 ай бұрын
That's because you are a robot. At least you sound like one 😂😂😂
@ricgillingham80564 ай бұрын
LORI is the problem she uses people and drops them when finished expecting everyone to shut up and except what she wants ,but at least gets what she deserves.
@Ninpo_Nikku4 ай бұрын
Shane is definitely a top 5 character for me. That hallucination Rick had in his last episode of season 9 was nice way to wrap up the whole dichotomy of Rick being more soft and leanient when Shane was in the show but eventually surcumbing to the way Shane would do things after the prison. It was a pleasant surprise undeed. I know everyone says this but yeah Shane was ahead of the curve he was living in season 5 during his time in season 2.
@MrLeroy424 ай бұрын
Absolutely. He was right on everything that had to do with survival. With Lori he was definitely wrong lol.
@guyhathansaintil52185 ай бұрын
first its irrelvant if he thought he was dead or not its stll wrong scond its implied he was into her like when he asks rick how theyre doing and when he says good u can see slight dissapointment
@user-oy1gw9sc5w7 ай бұрын
Randle could not be trusted as he was very dumb and would have been useless no matter what.
@user-oy1gw9sc5w7 ай бұрын
Shane adapted faster since he was a first responder and could see what was happening unfiltered from the start. Rick would have might have made the same adjustment quicker, but he was in a comma. Hersel and family were isolated in a rural area.
@Satsui_No_Hado8 ай бұрын
Shane loved Rick in the beginning and truly saw him as a brother. That part is absolutely true.
@MrLeroy428 ай бұрын
Absolutely!
@markflakezCG8 ай бұрын
Shane broke the bro codex. That's reason enough to hate him.
@LSMasta8 ай бұрын
One thing ill say about the Merle situation; i think that it was the right call down the line because that act alone had Rick earn Daryls respect. If Rick agreed with Shane, i think Daryl wouldve held resentment towards the group from that point on instead of the route he ended up taking. He ended up becoming one of the most vital pieces of the group. I dont think he wouldve became that for Rick if Rick didnt agree to go with him to retrieve Merle. When it comes to making decisions, sometimes you have to take into consideration which decision creates a loyal ally for you. Creating loyalty and a worthy ally of Daryl was worth it. If i had 2 choices, one made Daryl and ally and another made someone like Dale an ally.. im choosing the choice that supports Daryl because hes just way more useful.
@ArtyBuggy9 ай бұрын
I will say that the difference between Rick and Shane is that Shane lost his morals as he adapted too quickly, Rick didn't. Shane shot Otis in the leg so he could survive, Rick would never do that. Shane shows he has a quality that when it comes to survival he would sacrifice anyone to save himself, Lori and Carl. While Rick wouldn't throw Glenn, Maggie, Hershal, etc under the bus just to survive. Shane was right a lot, if not almost all the time but he is also the kind of person you don't want watching your back on a dangerous mission. Rick's adaptation took longer but he was more healthy, able to be a leader that both truly cared for his group and had the kind of brutal mentality needed. While Shane had the right mindset, he didn't have the love or compassion Rick did for everyone, for him it was always just him, Lori and Carl.
@yosoyaldo94259 ай бұрын
Good!!!❤
@forrestredd27069 ай бұрын
There are so many instances throughout the whole of the series where Rick proved Shane right.
@jhaeck111 ай бұрын
he had some good points.....but mostly bad points......i mean the way he treated his best friend when he came back........who would do that really.....if i had hooked up with his wife like that i woulda gladly stepped aside right when rick got back......there were other females available for him
@MrLeroy4210 ай бұрын
Remember, I like Shane as a character, not as a person. And it’s a complex situation. We can say that we’d do whatever but we’re not in that situation.
@TWDproductions66 Жыл бұрын
shane shouldnt have stopped beating ed
@sheikahmeed4901 Жыл бұрын
I'm so glad that I came across this video. S2 was amazing things were simpler and it was all about surviving. Character interactions were the best of all seasons
@MrLeroy42 Жыл бұрын
Agreed! Plus the dialogue just felt more real. S2 of TWD is my favorite piece of media ever. Well it's at least tied with The Punisher S1.
@ShacolateClown Жыл бұрын
lori '' you should leave'' shane : aight imma leave to much bs lori : excuse me wtf you cant just leave *me* and carl shane : ???????? i loved shane alot. just cant agree with his SA on lori at the CDC yes he was drunk still not a excuse to do it though. other than that i really liked him
@LittleRedTeaCake Жыл бұрын
People tend to forget what normal grief can do to a person. They look for solace and others who share their grief, and sometimes that leads to boning, add in the damn zombie apocalypse and just how much Shane loves Rick, I get it. I don't fault him or Lori for what happened when they thought Rick was dead and were in survival mode. Not one bit. Lori is allowed her anger as well, she trusted Shane and to her, he lied to her and broke her trust more than probably anyone else in her entire life, but god lord! If everyone had just talked to each other like adults, things would have been way different. The part where I start to dislike Shane, is in the CDC when he tries to rape Lori. That's crossing a line. His character went downhill for me after that. Even if I understand and agree with his later actions on the farm and seriously, the group was delusional and he was the only one who already came to terms with their new reality, that was a black stain that I just cannot forgive. Even trying to kill Rick, his best friend whom he loves, is just not cut out for this new world and he wants to protect Lori and Carl, I get it.
@bloodyraven1347 Жыл бұрын
Amazing video dear fellow! 🦋💜
@paulgraf1 Жыл бұрын
W
@anntares172 Жыл бұрын
My motto is "What would Shane do?" Lol
@justinatkins9292 Жыл бұрын
I always wondered if Randall was possibly a savior or one of those claimer guys and it was just still earlier on in the apocalypse
@nicolea-kq1gl Жыл бұрын
Do over
@nicolea-kq1gl Жыл бұрын
You
@jigsjiggyy Жыл бұрын
I 100% agree season 2 was the best because of how grounded it was, like you said it was about survival. I feel TWD lost sight of the real threat and kept leaning more towards heavy action and war against other groups. All the characters had steady development and the love triangle with andy, jon, and sarah was executed so well, like I really didn't like that woman lol shoutout to Glenn, Daryl, Dale, and T-Dog <3
@xaninuax Жыл бұрын
a respectable list
@dr.bright5670 Жыл бұрын
Rick and Shane chose hoes before bros. Cardinal sin.
@trevorturner4227 Жыл бұрын
Season 2 is mad underrated
@user-qz9lc1lt2y Жыл бұрын
i started hating shane after what he did to otis
@FinnishMonarchistzАй бұрын
Why? Would've you preferred they both AND Carl died instead??
@V-man117 Жыл бұрын
Dude you don't go with your best friend's wife. Even if time has passed, even if he is dead. It's called showing respect like come on, both Shane and Lori are wrong for this. And it's not like he accepted it when Rick came back and backed off or tried to make it right. He continued to pursue both Lori and Carl and tried to steal them from Rick. Even assaulted her during that time. He even tried to kil Rick and had thoughts about doing horrible stuff multiple times. And don't say about Lori being pregnant. We don't know if Judith is his, she most probably is but again you don't try to backstab your best friend like that. Lori though is even worse. She completely cuts Shane off and manipulates them both. She is a bad wife for the things she did to Rick.
@EasyStreet88599 Жыл бұрын
Lori is responsible for the death of Shane I believe
@Nelson-Man Жыл бұрын
Shane gives up his morality very easily. You can describe it as adapting fast. But I think he just makes it very easy for himself. The last quote is basically a self-fullfilling prophecy. Rick on the other hand changes, too. But he holds on to his morality much longer. And in my opinion this is an important difference. If all people where like Rick, good guys would stay in control and society could live on. If all people were like Shane, everyone would just protect the people closest to them and people would kill members of other groups out of mistrust or as "preemptive" attacks.
@warrenreid6109 Жыл бұрын
Shane was a good guy who ended up going the wrong way.
@Ptrixle Жыл бұрын
I don't ever hear people mention that they were trying to steal his baby. She was pregnant with Shane's kid, he had every right to want to be a dad despite Rick and Lori's marriage concerns. Rick I believe tells shane "Lori is pregnant, and it's mine" or something to that extent. They were kind of shitty to Shane, granted that doesn't give him a right to SA Lori though. That was the only truly wrong thing that Shane did in my eyes.
@davidspooner4582 Жыл бұрын
6:06 He suggests that they should talk and she tells him to tell it to the frogs? Jesus she really is as bad as they say
@renegadephilosopher5996 Жыл бұрын
Rick became Shane in later seasons.
@pmiller7148 Жыл бұрын
3. Farm 2. Prison 1. Season 4b Honorable mention: 6b
@Noob_Guy2k Жыл бұрын
Whisperers easily the best not close
@yubyub335 Жыл бұрын
The whisperers where interesting, but to me felt a bit stale at some point.
@MrLeroy42 Жыл бұрын
I liked the Whisperer Arc but I do think that they wasted some potential there. I really liked the fear that The Whisperers put into the group when they thought it was just walkers who were talking. (which is terrifying) Choosing to have The Whisperers reveal themselves wasn't smart in my opinion. They should've kept them mysterious which would make them much scarier.