I love the way the stringed instrument sounds, probably 6.5/10

Rate it out of 10? Be honest.

I like it and if you want feedback on my thoughts check the other guys comment, i just commented on there but other than that, thats great work actually, also if you want to go over any music things, i have a discord thing where i help with music if you'd like mate, no pressure, good luck to you man, you'll do great

the melody is very good, and you have a solid base here. it could use a little more variation. i really like the parts 2:19 here, they sound very dynamic and "trippy". i like this track a lot and hope to see what you do next!

This is one of my most experimental tracks, so please let me know what you think of it?

"Your music sounds awesome! I’m new to DTM as well, but let’s both keep at it ☻ I can’t wait for the day we can collaborate!"

1.5x speed makes it better 👍

the shit that goes on with the synth with the almost a key change is phenomenal

It sounds like a song from Portal! Very cool!!

Needs some other layers, like sweeps and swooshy sounds, though that's just the style I go for. A little repetitive, but I will say that the synth that comes in at 1:46 has a very interesting chord progression, especially how a bard ends out of key, but almost like it's trying to push a key change, but it pulls back to the starting chord of the bar. That has some really good potential and just needs to be refined. Good work, overall! 😃

It's not bad. a little repetitive in some areas tho

Be honest, what would you give this out of 10?

7/10

Miles better than my first song

This is pretty good for a first song. I like the percussion loop and great work on the synths

What would you give it out of 10? Be honest. Also this is the first song I ever made on GarageBand

Sounds like a top down rpg game when youre in like, a factory about to face an important story boss. Gotta let the homies know i fux with this

(8/10)I'm genuinely love how the song sounds ominous in contrast to the name. Less like "there is hope." And more like. "is there hope?" and I love it. Song still could use some improvements, but overall pretty good. (I'm not really good at music so I don't have that much advice)

7.3/10 main bassy melody goes super hard, i liked the percussion as well. when that singular repeating note comes in its a bit repetitive; you could have added a little stepwise variation every so often, for example. also, when the next harmony part comes in its very similar to the bassline. when the next part does come in, however, the new synth sounds *really* good with the previous parts. and then the return to the original melody works really good as well. i feel like the next could have been a bit shorter, though, and the ending section could have been a bit different. like the new synth at the end could have been more of a descending line than its original one. overall tho i liked it!

7/10 it has potential! i liked the instrumentation changes and liked the main melody. i would try experimenting with song structure (e.g. ABA structure) where subsequent parts have a different melodies, and then return to the original. i disagree with the other comment about dissonance; the synth sound is a little unstable but it fits the song nicely. and also, if you want, you can try experimenting with other styles/genres (e.g. something less electronic) to get more ideas. keep it up!

A little bit dirty and dissonant on chords side, needs improvement there. A little bit repetitive, would win from more melodic and harmonic variation. Overall it's fine, just keep up the work, I'm making music too and I get the struggle, just keep doing it Also, might be subjective, but consider using some better software (Ableton Live i.e.)

What would you give it out of 10? Be honest.

6/10 sound like music from a space level of a cool maths games platformer (compliment)

Rate it out of 10, be honest.

Rate it out of 10, be honest.

its actually really good! its quite a relaxing piece of music, well done!

What do you give it out of 10? Be honest

Lots of sections for not much going on you could say..? sounds great but i feel like you only let each instrument do one thing instead of letting them each take on each others roles at some points

Pretty cool

Love it. Hate the people saying "Repeition". MEDIC! repeats a lot and people love it. LET THE SMALL CREATORS RISE UP!

hey man you have some good ideas. reach out to me if you wanna collab

Oh wow I really enjoyed this!! I think this would be a perfect piece of music for a game soundtrack, it really gives me sci-fi vibes. I agree with other commenters who say that it's repetitive, however it's not boring at all in soundtrack context some repetition isn't a bad thing! I think its well made and that it sounds great, keep up the awesome work!

its good, but there's room for improvement. like some other people mentioned, repetition is not great. you can add a bridge and a chorus and i think it would be a lot better.

if you cut out the repetitive boring parts, the song is about a minute long. (🧀 out of 10)

i feel like it repeats a lot

Hey you just got into GarageBand right maybe you should start layering your beatbox even more like adding a bass and some harmonies

Hehe it sounds funni

This song sounds familiar

7/10. My take on it is that, as it is now, it is a great base to add vocals to! I can imagine a few different routes one could take, and I like them all. I think this track has a lot of potential, and the other comments offer solid advice.

ngl i know nothing about making music but that's pretty damn funky

Rate it out of 10, be honest.

Sound selection bro😞

6.4/10 its pretty decent i think mixing could be better though and some more verity and texture in all the sounds would be nice keep practicing and making music though!!

6/10 - A decent song, but there's still some stuff to be learned. That's why I listed my findings below: Instrument choice is great imo. The drums are somewhat quiet though, while some instruments are quite loud (aka the mixing could be better). The melodies are somewhat repetitive and there's a lack of filler parts (the repeating melody part itself is good, but please make more melodies and more variations of them in a song). There is also no outro part where it either fades out (which is something you can do in Garageband) or slowly becomes more relaxed in style until it stops.

Rate it out of 10, be honest.

cool!

Hey everyone! I hope you really enjoyed the EP. All these songs were made about a couple of months ago, I uploaded them to see if people like them and to see if I should keep making more. These videos have actually managed to revive my once dead channel. So I will continue. The next BIG upload will be a full on album, it will comprise of mostly new I’ve made, with a couple of songs I also made at a similar times to these. So I hope you will enjoy my newer songs to!

I'm working on a song that I was also planning to call "Legacy". It sounds a lot different from this, though

doorbell.

i loveee the vibe n feeling i get from this. Love how the ending loops it all real good, if made it longer or copy n pasted n add maybe like 1, 2 or more things later in it ooo itd be real good. I can imagine this go real goodddddd with a lottt of video games n game styles frfrrrr. 8/10🔥🔥🔥🔥🥰🥰🥰