Those harmonies are killer. I like this better than the recorded version.

Since the start, Carrie & Bo were the front runners of this season & Carrie is the most front runner on all seasons.

Absolutely beautiful!

This is so cringe worthy

Love Mikalah Gordon.

Vonzell was like, hmm I can do this way better!

They were pushing Carrie to win and it shows

Since beginnig Bo and CARRIE duet together... Like top 2 !!!!

That was just terrible, if I keep hearing bad versions of the songlike this I’m not gonna be able to listen to it anymore.

❤❤❤❤💯👍🤩💯

Love Really 💖💖💯👍❤

i was about 13-14 when i was hook to american idol, started from kelly. omg, im so old

is this america idols worst season???

1:12 Probably should sing the melody during your solo lol

They are flat

I feel like I'm 11 years old again every time I watch this scene

faces I have forgotten about

This is the best season of American Idol. Love Vonzell Solomon ♥

Vonzell is the rightful winner

Vonzell was for far the best. I love Carrie, but Voncell was a better singer.

Petition to bring all twelve of these contestants together to sing this song again, who's with me?

Love Mikalah on this performance

YAY! So glad I found this.............. :)

: ) GOSTEI. : ) Obrigada por COMPARTILHAR.

the harmony is worse while carrie bo the white jacket guy,the black girl , they sang good

mikalah LOL unique voice

I dont think its perfect but I LOVE the harmony ! Muahxxxx!

I had a huge crush on Anthony Fedorov. Carrie has always been amazing I'm so proud of her.

The best stage presence was shown by Bo, Constantine, and Carrie for sure. And admittedly, I was one of the many girls crushing on Bo and Constantine, and I'm proud! Those men had the sexiest voices! And so handsome!

@HunnyLamb26 it was taken off but its back up now if you haven't seen it.

Carrie and Bo had such great chemistry on stage! I wish Lindsay Cardinale picked better songs, she had such an amazing voice. Constantine <3

ooh ~ Chicken Little. That's right I've totally forgotten he was AI Season 4 contestant.

Vonzell Solomon did a solo version of this song on the show but I cant find it!! I thought it was one of the best performances of the whole season!!

Strongest. Top 12. Ever.

I agree about Scott He wasn't really one of my favorties.

Yep that is Mario's season. You know he left the competition which allowed Nikko a shot at the top 12

Yes I enjoyed her personality. I also enjoyed her on Gone Country 2

Yeah I noticed that too

VONZELL!

love nikko smith

nice video, FYI the correct title of the song is "WHEN YOU TELL ME THAT YOU LOVE ME" originally done by Diana Ross

still loving vonzell!

was it just coincidence that bo and carrie were the last to sing and they were in the final two, and also vonzell before them was the top 3.

worst season.. but the winner is awesome...

I noticed that too. I also noticed how Carrie had more solo spots than anyone else. I guess that was a coincidence too. lol

All of their voices really gelled together very nicely.

I <3 Carrie Underwood! She is my favorite singer. She is the only one i know on this video besides bo. But some of the others are good too,

muito lindo. adoooro Kiefer tb!!!

i love this performance.... what week is this?

great job<3kief<3 is so sweet ***** thanks