The first time I agree with edgeworth

0:52 who said I can’t eat a hammer?

Ocean actually isn’t soup though. First tell me the year of when soup came to be- Mid 1600s. So then what was the ocean before the word “soup” was known or created as? Simply put, it’s not soup if it came first before soup did.

To my knowledge there was no time period in the history of earth where the oceans were consistently at above 100°C for them to boil and at the same time an existence of vegetables and/or organisms(or even meat). Kinda funny but also very interesting if you think about this question too hard.

BASED EDGEWORTH LESS GOOOOO!

No, a hot dog is a taco

wrr, no such thing as silenx or endx or dotx or etc, say, voicx, can say,voicx etc infix any nmw s perfx

For a soup to be a food, it needs to be safe to consume WITHOUT health threats. The average ocean salt level is 35‰ per 1L. That is NOT safe to consume in anything, salt is deadlier than you can imagine. Plus, since unprepared seaweed, and LIVE CREATURES are in it, including litter and dangerous materials disposed in, including waste, toxic and human waste (poop), the ocean is NOT a soup. Yeah yeah yeah, i'd like to see you eat toxic waste, poop and pee, turtles and other creatures, leftover metals, super salty water in one go. Oh, go on and try. Conclusion: The ocean isn't a soup due to the health threats and dangerous parasites with infections. Ocean is not consumable.

The ocean is a soup, but if you want to try it you gonna eat a lotta micro plastics

OBJECTION Soup is a food and food has to be edible, but ocean has a salinity level which is more than inedible

ok but at least it makes more sense than the ocean is a soup

HOLD IT! The ocean is saltwater,unless you want to get sick then I guess you can call it a soup.

theres a cold sparkly( or made with bread lemonade) soup called okroshka

I like eating ocean water

Ok then sir. By your definition, we are steak, as we are being cooked under the sun constandly

1:35 Окрошка такая…

No because the Ocean is not edible

If it isn't a soup, then why are we melting the ice?

OBJECTION! In Europe, We don't put a second piece of bread on top of a sandwich. Would You say that it's not a sandwich just becuse it has a single piece of bread at the bottom?

Objection! the ocean is not soup, it’s broth

"I think eggplants are disgusting, but that doesn't make them any less of a vegetable." Eggplants are fruits, moron

Cold soup = stew end of discussion.

well ocean water is full of salt making it NOT consumable

This actually WAS decided in a court of law. It was about tacos, not hot dogs, but the principle was the same. So, some shopping centers have rules that say that only one of a specific kind of shop or restaurant exist within the shopping center. At some point, there was a shopping center with a Panera bread in it, and then a Qdoba moved in, and the Panera people took the Qdoba to court, claiming they were breaking the rule because it was another sandwich shop. The court ruled in favor of Qdoba though because, by the merriam webster dictionary definition of a sandwich, a taco is not one. And by that same definition, a hot dog is also not a sandwich. So... There ya go, I guess.

Sub sandwiches, which are inarguably sandwiches, have one connecting piece of bread, just like hot dogs. However, hot dogs are standardly eaten with the open part of the bread pointed UPWARD, so that any condiments on the hot dog won't fall off. Whereas sub sandwiches have the open part of the bread to the side. So if you have a hot dog with no condiments (or with condiments, I guess, if you don't mind making a mess) and eat it sideways, it's a sandwich. But if you eat it the way most people do, it's not. Therefore, given that the majority of hot dogs are not eaten in ways that would qualify them as sandwiches, the hot dog, generally speaking, is not a sandwich.

They call me the drink

Eggplants are fruits.

I love how this just Phoenix having a mental breakdown while arguing with idiots

Objection! There one thing what Edgeworth forgot A soup is need to be edible and the ocean water isn't edible

Easy, it's not soup because it isn't in the soup aisle

Underwater vacanos make boiling water to make warm soup

2:30 I do

2:22 OBJECTION! if the servings are smaller, seaweed or fish wouldnt fit in it!

I like cold soup😂

The ocean is not edible. Therefore it isn't a soup.

Soooo ocean water can't be consumed it's extrimly salty and ocean salt is in fact toxic to the human body

I like how he initially questions vegetables rather than the most obvious one...calling saltwater "broth" is crazy work

Unfortunately for Edgeworth, the ocean isn’t being cooked. By FDA standards, being “cooked” means that the food (or soup is this case) has reached an overall temperature of 165 degrees Celsius, as this is the standard temperature to kill bacteria within the food. Since the ocean’s average temperature is 62 degrees, this means that the ocean, is not in fact soup, and though there are technically soups that are not cooked, those soups are not served in a saline broth. 😁

So y'all R just gonna ignore the fact that kids pee in the ocean?

Soup is a type of FOOD. So everything Phoenix said about soup being soup is in fact, right.

Eggplant is also a fruit

2:33 erm actually, the ocean has salt properties and a lot of individuals enjoy sodium intake🤓👆

2:32 me

eggplants are fruit but no one can call me a 🤓 because no one will ever see this comment

salmonella woohoo

No, the ocean isnt a soup. For the sake of the debate lets just say, if you were to eat the ocean youd eat everything, water, plants and fishes. The thing is, for a food to be a food it has to be edible, right? Well, human stomachs cant handle drinking ocean water, nono! Thats not enough. Theres a ton of poisinous plants and fishes. Pufferfishes skin, for example. So, no. The ocean isnt a soup because its not edible

Ocean water CANT be consumed 2:38

Guess people in the oceans are in soup

1. You're not supposed to drink seawater 2. Soup requires other ingredients; it isn't just broth alone 3. Seawater isn't broth 4. Stored in a can 5. Needs to be sold