The Budget: Why aren't MPs told first?
50:22
Will the parties reform Westminster?
1:08:55
Пікірлер
@carpediemcotidiem
@carpediemcotidiem 2 ай бұрын
00:03 Winter fuel allowance regulations pose a political challenge for the government 02:14 Debate on statutory instrument under social security laws 05:58 Labour government facing unpopular decisions 07:48 Challenges and dynamics of the legislative process 11:26 Government budget decisions and lobbying 13:19 Government's lack of clarity on policies and impact on public perception 16:54 Private Members' Bill lottery winners include bills with low complexity 18:27 Effective legislation and the removal of hereditary peers 21:44 Annual private members Bill ballot took place in the House of Commons, giving MPs the chance to bring in a draft law of their choice. 23:29 Private Members’ Bill ballot determines priority for bill debates 27:11 MPs may receive handout bills from the government for support 28:54 MPS signing up to support the climate and nature bill 32:28 Private Members' Bill ballot gives priority to top drawn bills for debate 34:13 Challenges in securing 100 MPs for private members' bill support 37:40 Passing a private members' Bill requires careful consideration and negotiation with the government. 39:22 New MPs may face challenges in navigating the legislative process 42:53 Importance of Private Members' Bills 44:40 Proposals to give House of Lords veto power over statutory instruments 48:09 Formation of a new parliamentary grouping 49:48 Labor MPs face dilemma with rebellion or compliance 53:18 New MPs expressing interest in select committee chairmanships 54:54 Public Accounts committee is a key oversight body for government policy implementation. 58:32 Changes in committee responsibilities post Michael Gove's shift 1:00:16 Selection of chairs for committees and potential candidates 1:03:43 MPs unable to compete for chairmanship due to election timing. 1:05:28 Private Members’ Bill ballot and the role of procedure committee 1:08:51 Engage with Parliament through Hansard Society Crafted by Merlin AI.
@peterdollins3610
@peterdollins3610 4 ай бұрын
The Tory Governments behaved so abominably from 2010 to 2024 July 7th Labour owes them NOTHING. Ignore them.
@drstrangelove4998
@drstrangelove4998 4 ай бұрын
That a Tory MP feels he can cross the floor to Labour is an indicator of how much the party has changed and a symbol of why it has fallen. Alternatively it’s simply an opportunity by somebody with no moral compass looking to save their job.
@alanwood4968
@alanwood4968 5 ай бұрын
Sod all
@IbnBahtuta
@IbnBahtuta 5 ай бұрын
Post Office Horizon scandal: what is Parliament doing about it? As you've asked, I'll answer. What they are doing is a mixture of playing politics, distancing themselves as far away as possible from it as is -humanly- possible, and ultimately kicking it down the road to the next jokers who take over tomorrow. smh
@martincheeseman5809
@martincheeseman5809 6 ай бұрын
Sunak has done got us he took us OUT of the eu , loved being inthe eu Tory bastards!!
@josephshortt3171
@josephshortt3171 6 ай бұрын
The whole thing stinks it tells me that it is in the interest of every constituency to gain control of their local council. Our jobs, our homes, our cars, our children and our freedom is at stake Stop voting for a corrupt government and start voting for what we the people want.
@alanfrost4661
@alanfrost4661 6 ай бұрын
Well well who would have expected that
@alanfrost4661
@alanfrost4661 6 ай бұрын
She wants snubbing because she talks crap
@matthewrowe9903
@matthewrowe9903 6 ай бұрын
Utter coward plus he knows as a doctor he has a better profit margin with a labour goverment he should be recalled and suffer a by election
@JelMain
@JelMain 6 ай бұрын
The whole thing's become a farce. Worse that the lack of data is the lack of choice. Same old failures. Taking the population for granted. If you don't like us, vote for the other side - tweedle dum and tweedle dee. Minimum solution - replace Royal Assent with a plebiscite referendum. Is this what you actually want?
@MaryHelton-ev3wk
@MaryHelton-ev3wk 6 ай бұрын
KZbin channel problem solving and KZbin organic grow Hi Hansard Society I can help you grow your KZbin channel by using KZbin SEO. Below we found your channel issue. 1:Your title is not properly SEO. 2:Your Thumbnail did not go well. 3:Your video is not SEO properly. 4:Your video is not tag count properly. 5:Your video's tag volume is not set correctly.
@anllpp
@anllpp 6 ай бұрын
Proportional representation is required and nothing from any gob currently
@davidjohnson4893
@davidjohnson4893 6 ай бұрын
Look what happened to Tony Blair. A complete whitewash.
@davidjohnson4893
@davidjohnson4893 6 ай бұрын
I net mot one of these executives or senior managers will go to jail. The old boys political and judiciary club will ensure they all get away with minimal penalties.
@michaelmcginley7930
@michaelmcginley7930 6 ай бұрын
They will mostly get peerage as they certainly won't get jailed.forget the law
@michaelmcginley7930
@michaelmcginley7930 6 ай бұрын
Correct david
@fantastichound
@fantastichound 7 ай бұрын
I'm happy future of parliament is in good legs
@fToo
@fToo 7 ай бұрын
Sir Jeffrey M Donaldson is now on his 4th party affiliation whilst serving as an MP - is this the biggest number ever / current MPs ? members.parliament.uk/member/650/career
@fToo
@fToo 7 ай бұрын
George Galloway is also on his 4th party affiliation - but with a 9 year gap in his service record members.parliament.uk/member/609/career
@sammytsang2948
@sammytsang2948 8 ай бұрын
What our elected MPs fail to understand is that UK is only at most 1% of the population of earth. And if we want to talk about democracy then UK shouldn't have much of a say when people of other countries want UK to not get involved in matters that doesn't impact UK. What does matter is ending the war in Ukraine & Palestine with peace.
@odellkercado211
@odellkercado211 8 ай бұрын
Promo'SM
@sadammseoexpert
@sadammseoexpert 8 ай бұрын
Hey Hansard Society I hope you are very well . I came to your channel and I was analyzing your KZbin channel Hansard Society 231 subscribers 86 videos Your content is really good. But I would like to ask you one thing that is have you ever tried to figure out why your videos aren’t getting expected views? I found some serious issues in your YT channel that you have to fix if you really want to grow your YT channel. Could we talk about it ? Thank You so much Regards Md Saddam Hossain Professional KZbin Expert
@futures2247
@futures2247 8 ай бұрын
Liz Truss is as mad as a hatter
@FRM101
@FRM101 9 ай бұрын
curious that safety concerns never necessitated upending this convention before... I suppose it's a coincidence the first time coincided with doing Starmer a tremendous favor 😂
@russellbertrand3242
@russellbertrand3242 10 ай бұрын
It's just soul destroying listening to this unadulterated spin. Knowing nothing will change. parliament = rogues gallery This level of arrogant disconnect from reality cost Charles I and Louis XVI their heads.
@yb958
@yb958 Жыл бұрын
First things first. Our right to protest is democratic and peaceful. Taking it away and regulating it to the point of a tiny quiet vigil in the corner of the streets is autocratic. Get it right.
@drift3rkid66
@drift3rkid66 Жыл бұрын
Beautiful legs!!
@Steven-gr4hb
@Steven-gr4hb Жыл бұрын
❣️ P R O M O S M!!
@jennyaskswhy
@jennyaskswhy Жыл бұрын
Excellent speech! Here is a small suggestion: let it be decided that the upper limit on the number of members appointed to the House of Lords is fixed at and equal to the number of people who can occupy the seats and standing floor space in the chamber comfortably and safely together at the same time.
@gamingwithslacker
@gamingwithslacker 2 жыл бұрын
There's a version with much better quality sound available here : digital.library.lse.ac.uk/objects/lse:jif935kov
@superpacemaker444
@superpacemaker444 23 күн бұрын
Thank you so much! For those clicking the link just put Tony Benn In the search bar and the conversation comes right up. Amazing quality for how old it is.
@James-ss4fb
@James-ss4fb 2 жыл бұрын
I will not pay my National Insurance or Income Tax, anymore, by choice due to the current situation after Covid. I pay road tax still to keep the roads safe and accessible, but I will not fund police activities and I will not fund GP and doctor activities.
@yetidodger6650
@yetidodger6650 2 жыл бұрын
road tax doesn't pay for roads though, so perhaps you need to amend this before you keep posting it on different videos.
@misssarahashplant31
@misssarahashplant31 4 жыл бұрын
I went to the Brexit celebration party in Parliament Square and a good time was had by all. I saw some remoaners but I ignored them.
@Racingnorthstar
@Racingnorthstar 5 жыл бұрын
Please could the Hansard society comment on whether they regard the legal requirements needed for changing a statutory instrument to have been met by the government to lawfully extend article 50 or not ? Or in other words is the extension of article 50 legally valid under uk law or not ? I'm afraid this is now a very crucial legal point that the public deserves to know! Many thanks for making this video ,very informative!
@lilianflynn198
@lilianflynn198 5 жыл бұрын
It is illegal to change the leaving date of article 50 Court case in progress by Robin Tillbrook
@williamread5652
@williamread5652 5 жыл бұрын
Lilian Flynn Yes, And isn’t it amazing that our crooked media, #biasedbbc , haven’t reported on it!!
@stoobydootoo4098
@stoobydootoo4098 5 жыл бұрын
1) No it is not. 2) The case will fail at the first hurdle.
@williamread5652
@williamread5652 5 жыл бұрын
The Lisping Transvestite; Man or Myth? So why have some very prominent QC’s attached themselves to this case?
@stoobydootoo4098
@stoobydootoo4098 5 жыл бұрын
@@williamread5652 So why are some QCs on one side of a legal argument ultimately proved right, and all on the other side, wrong ? Hmmm?
@williamread5652
@williamread5652 5 жыл бұрын
The Lisping Transvestite; Man or Myth? True, but in this case I believe one of the QC’s approached the Tilcock people because: a) he was an expert on EU law, and b) he thought they had an excellent case. In the majority of cases before our courts the legals are representing a side, hence winners and losers, and their personal opinion is irrelevant. But not I believe, in this case.
@Peter-hi2st
@Peter-hi2st 6 жыл бұрын
Please slow down. You're talking too fast.
@Inanoco
@Inanoco 8 жыл бұрын
wonder if Theresa May has studied the EU to this level ? I back Andrea Leadsom for PM
@petergreen1862
@petergreen1862 8 жыл бұрын
Ohhhhh Ohhhhh Ohhhhh 😂
@SkyEcho7
@SkyEcho7 9 жыл бұрын
Sound quality is SHOCKING!
@SkyEcho7
@SkyEcho7 9 жыл бұрын
Can you improve the sound quality of your videos please
@inflivia
@inflivia 9 жыл бұрын
There is no information or expertise provided here. Waste of 8 minutes.
@briangriffiths114
@briangriffiths114 9 жыл бұрын
My concern is that TTIP is being obfuscated by the very complexity of the multiple legal aspects which appear designed to confuse elected representatives who will make their binding and irrevocable decisions on our behalf. It is not unlike how financial institutions confounded legislation makers immediately prior to the 2007 financial crash by the use of entangled sub-prime derivative transactions that few people understood but could not admit to for fear of ridicule by their peers. I hope that our politicians will take this on board before agreeing to anything that could harm the NHS by default.
@SueJamesonEnglishWoman
@SueJamesonEnglishWoman 10 жыл бұрын
No transcript or subtitles. There are over 10 million Britons who can't hear properly.
@Thoughtbubble788
@Thoughtbubble788 10 жыл бұрын
Two Incredible figures, one the last bastion of true Socialism in Britain. The other a highly respected Academic who brough the discipline of Psephology to a mass audience in the study of democratic elections. A thoroughly pleasant listen and a fascinating glimpse into the minds of two Incredible men.
@clnic9
@clnic9 10 жыл бұрын
No, 16 year olds right through to the oldest person in Scotland will decide. Everyone in this category has one vote. I am assuming that 17 year olds right through to 100+ year olds would hold the majority when it comes down to a head count, so no, 16 year olds will not decide the outcome of the referendum. Its very misleading to present this as the youth having control over the destiny of Scotland when the reality is that 16 year olds are taxed.In the uk but 16 year old tax payers do not get representation. This empowers 16 year olds and thats a good thing. Vote YES!