I had the felicity to read the extensive collection of online articles you published almost twenty years ago. Thanks very much for your generosity! I have a PhD and would never advise any youngster not to pursue a formal education, but as someone with a range of interests outside my field and a frequent autodidact, I stand by the value of informal study and practical knowledge. In fact, I'd trust a brilliant self-taught technician more than an indifferent formally trained one! I also remember that engineers and craftsmen until a few generations ago went through apprenticeships rather than formal education, and were perhaps more resourceful than current professionals for it. The critical issue today is that STEM applications require ever more advanced mathematics, which are not easy to learn without going through university.
@piedpiper11723 сағат бұрын
I wish you’d do audiobook recordings of your books. Not as a substitute for the printed book (actually, I think the best would be to include it with the physical book via a download key, or as an add on option), but for those of us who benefit from hearing while we read, or hearing it more than once after first reading. For me, that’s a big tool that elevates from “I understand the broad strokes” to “I am confident that I understand all, or nearly all, nuance and detail in this material.” Besides, you’ve developed a great presentation voice doing these videos, so the skill set is already there.
@danvorobiov7 сағат бұрын
How a different «torque splits» are achieved if all four wheels are rotating with almost the same speed?
@JulianEdgar6 сағат бұрын
Think of a rear wheel drive car. The front wheels are rotating at the same speed as the rears but are transmitting no torque to the road… In other words, it’s how hard the tyre is pushing backwards on the road.
@danvorobiov6 сағат бұрын
@@JulianEdgar Ok, I get that. To my understanding, different «torque splits» - like 40/60 or 65/35, are possible only with some slipping in transmission. Can you explain it a bit better?
@johndb12248 сағат бұрын
ALL of the different suspension systems - what about the Revo-knuckle ?
@JulianEdgar7 сағат бұрын
Yes, front MacPherson struts with revolving uprights (knuckles).
@info14188 сағат бұрын
If only Bill Gates and Steve Jobs didnt drop out of college...
@Alan_Hans__9 сағат бұрын
Nice reply to the questions. My question is where is some info on the human powered vehicle stuff that you've done? I love me some good HPV videos and info.
@JulianEdgar9 сағат бұрын
I cover two HPV suspensions in the book.
@dielaughing739 сағат бұрын
I've been told that a racing series that went from stock seats to allowing racing seats the next year saw a 1 second improvement in laptimes across the board as a result. I don't doubt that at all.
@JulianEdgar9 сағат бұрын
That's quite interesting isn't it.
@inam790410 сағат бұрын
Car manufacturers could buy this book and make better handling and ride quality from factory. Then I will not need to do it.😅
@JulianEdgar9 сағат бұрын
If it's like my aero books, quite a few manufacturers will in fact buy it. However, they need to make cars for everyone: you need to modify a car only for (largely) yourself.
@greatestone4eva10 сағат бұрын
the proof is in the pudding.
@cravejdm12 сағат бұрын
When I first started building my track car I followed the advice he gives and it made things so much better it should me places I didn't have enough aero at and were I had to much.
@allenpaley12 сағат бұрын
Hey Julian! I've been very excited for this book and I ordered it today! I've been watching your videos for a while and one important lesson really struck me, and I'm glad it did; Many modern cars are set up quite stiffly already and are expertly engineered from the factory. This can save a person from getting too lost in the weeds of theory and money expenditure. For the first time in my life I managed to get my Mk1 Audi TT to a track day and discovered that cornering at full throttle with slight 4 wheel drift (the theoretical ideal condition for driving at the edge of grip) is a thrilling and ethereal feeling. Sometimes one has to admit that an office of German engineers probably have a more well-rounded picture of what works (and better access to the Nordschleife to test their product) than the aftermarket bauble-mongers!
@JulianEdgar11 сағат бұрын
Yes it's always wise to start off by assuming that professional car company engineers usually have a pretty good idea of what they're doing. That said, when you read pages 271-272, you'll see that sometimes they're not directed very well!
@briangriffith398515 сағат бұрын
about the deflections, i remember seeing that mentioned in "how to make your car handle" it mentioned it briefly, but basically saying your static alignment changes as rolling resistance (tyre friction) comes to play. 0° toe at static can end up as .2 /.3° toe out just by rolling resistance acting on bottom arm bushings
@JulianEdgar15 сағат бұрын
Wait until you see the graphs in the book. Just amazing. We're talking multiple degrees, not fractions of a degree. And in most modern cars, it's meant to be like that!
@briangriffith398515 сағат бұрын
@@JulianEdgar i'll love to get myself a copy for christmas. i have a project car home at the moment, a JDM Nissan Sunny B12
@nathansmith715316 сағат бұрын
Engineering is about experiments and data.
@davidbryant677916 сағат бұрын
I’ve got his earlier book and lots of other suspension books as well …he does his homework and most importantly explains things in a easy to understand manner
@RwP22316 сағат бұрын
Chassis Engineering is from the 1990's. Dang, it's the 20's and now look at this!
@gotzdevokation107218 сағат бұрын
Ordered from Amazon, thank you!
@JulianEdgar18 сағат бұрын
Hope you like it!
@drazenbudis788118 сағат бұрын
Hi Julian, I appreciate your hard work in making the black magic of suspension/chassis principles and tuning more approachable to us mere mortals, I am getting the book. However just a short question, just because you didnt gloss over it in thie brief overview, are there a few pages dedicatd to scrub radius and ways to measure them in real life etc?
@JulianEdgar18 сағат бұрын
Scrub radius is in the book. That includes diagrams that show it and also a discussion of its implications and the fact that it actually varies with tyre centre of pressure (and so dynamically varies). The book does not cover how to measure it.
@drazenbudis788117 сағат бұрын
@@JulianEdgar Thanks for your reply. Would you then say that we can disregard that parameter when setting up our road/trackday car and rather focus on other aspects of the suspension/geometry? I’ll be open, the only reason I found myself hung up on scrub radius is since I found out that negative amount of scrub radius should produce an effect of car pulling inwards the corner if we’re applying the brake while cornering, and as I personally love to rotate my car on the brake (be it by trail braking or just transfering the load forward), I found that idea rather interesting. Currently I am making big changes on my project car and a lot of things has to be fabricated and custom made from zero so I thought if I can maybe incorporate a bit of negative scrub I’d be happy to test it out. Thank you again for finding the time to answer to our often ignorant questions.
@JulianEdgar17 сағат бұрын
To be honest, I think people often get hung up on what I'd consider to be peripheral issues. I don't think scrub radius is a major determiner of rotating a car under brakes: far more important is front weight transfer unloading the rear, and rear lateral weight transfer reducing rear lateral grip. Scrub radius is important in terms of steering feel and kickback, and (and I don't cover this in the book) self-aligning stability when braking on surfaces with different left/right frictional coefficients. Springs, dampers and sway bars (and at higher speeds, aero) comprise 90 percent of handling, with tyres adding the 'grip' element. I'll leave the book to answer the rest of your questions!
@drazenbudis788116 сағат бұрын
@@JulianEdgar Much appreciated, will follow your suggested guidlines. Looking forward to the book.
@gj914714 күн бұрын
You did not speak about the problem with the fuel. Pump fuel absorbs Air like a dry sponge absorbs water. If we remove the Entrained and Dissolved Air in the fuel,we will clean out dirt on the inside of the Engine,Restore lost fuel economy back to near the Manufacturers figures and stop Fuel Injector Cavitation from happening.
@JulianEdgar3 күн бұрын
Sounds like a crock to me.
@gj914713 күн бұрын
@JulianEdgar fill up a large clear plastic bottle with pump fuel.....the problem will be easy to see. What else would cause Fuel Injector Cavitation?
@JulianEdgar3 күн бұрын
What fuel injection cavitation? I have never even heard of it.
@lostinadream18664 күн бұрын
brilliant explanation!!
@JulianEdgar4 күн бұрын
Thank you!
@dumchican4 күн бұрын
I'd like to thank you Julian, this video made me impulse buy a rear sway bar for my honda fit (jazz in aus). It instantly made me go "OH, this is how it's supposed to feel?". It's night and day the difference it made to understeer, and i actually felt the back end kick out a little bit. definitely going to buy your books when i have the money!
@JulianEdgar4 күн бұрын
Yep, works so well for so little money.
@user-br3nc6mn7q5 күн бұрын
Hi Julian Can I use another ecu from a same model vehicle but just change the eeprom, will the mapping be the same, it's a fiat doblo 2012