I believe that Gobekli Tepe is the lost 'Hall of Records" 2 scenario's here. 1.) it was buried to protect the knowledge because they knew of an impending catastrophe coming. Or 2.) it was built and buried after the / a catastrophe to document what was lost as far as knowledge goes ;) Is why I believe it is / was a record for us to find.
@XBladeGКүн бұрын
It's the nuclear football, BC.
@barryboland3031Күн бұрын
your interpretation is terrible.... a pillar inside a building is depicting 3 different buildings ? but you mock and dismiss other interpretations.... this is why people hate mainstream archaeology
@seanallen81972 күн бұрын
You lost me, as did your credibility, when you questioned the ability of constellation symbols to be passed down through the ages. Taurus has been associated with the Pleiades for tens of thousands of years.
@bardmadsen69562 күн бұрын
I believe it was the very first as that is where the first fire from heaven came from, The Taurids. It is a very simple and obvious pareidolia with the up-side-down Capital letter A, which comes down to us as Alpha - first, as a bull's head. Even Thor fishes for the world encompassing serpent with a bull's head! It is in Lascaux cave art and there are seven birds in a row under Pillar 18 of Gobekli Tepe which is the symbol of The Pleiades. Then the scorpion, that is diametric, which is where The Taurids sink off in after they pass The Earth. 20,000 years as estimated by Napier.
@chris386634 күн бұрын
I'd recommend using home ground einkorn or khorasan wheat. Einkorn came first and was very nutritious and easy to grind using hand methods. Khorasan came later and is much harder to grind, but had higher yield in the fields. Both require a very wet dough and an overnight rest to allow the coarse ground flour to fully absorb the water. The overnight rest period is perfect to give time for a native starter culture to give the bread a bit of levening as well though it will still be a heavy dense loaf, like modern northern European 100% rye loafs. Even when rested overnight, it will be a wet and sticky dough. That is why the tray is useful. Even today, artisan einkorn loaf is baked in a preheated cast iron pot lined with parchment paper to contain the loaf and trap in moisture so it doesn't dry out in the oven. Without that, the loaf would run across the floor of the oven like hot lava. See the overnight artisan einkorn recipe in Carla Bartolucci's book. You might find that recipe on the Jovial youtube channel as well. Einkorn is the oldest cultuvated wheat in prehistory with evidence as far back as the end of the last ice age. Khorasan is much more modern, believed to be hybridized in Persia maybe ~6 thousand years ago. I bake home ground einkorn 2x a week for our family bread needs. Do the designs in the tray leave an impression in the loaf? Might be a way for each family to sign bread loafs and trays baked in the communal village oven.
@KapitanOgor5 күн бұрын
The problem with those "bags" is that we don't know what these things are and for ancient ppl around the World these were important. If these were for example "pointy sticks" no one would talk about why different cultures came up with the same idea and it was important for them, because its a no brainer.... these things on the other hand we have no idea what they were, while it seems these things were very important for ancient ppl around the World... This is a legit mystery. I mean there is like a lots of objects that we would say its ok for cultures around the World to come up with independently ... carved animals no brainer... wheels and other things like that also no brainer... but that specific shape despite different cultures different art styles... I mean lets be honest we don't know, we just speculate and nothing seems to fit that "common important object" so we can all agree what it was...
@galadriel9575 күн бұрын
I think this is a monument for rememberance of Atlantis.And built by Atlas and sons(NOAH AND SONS)
@3DManShadowland6 күн бұрын
There is some possibility the bags and animals depicted at gobekli Tepe are symbolic of the great flood, and protection thereof, a historic marker if you will....
@3DManShadowland6 күн бұрын
Symbolic, the bags refer to currency and wealth. The trade in grain originolly as if it were money, later it was other forms of currency including silver or gold or any other item used for trade. The bags in general is a symbol of wealth and power. Originally, at achient sites it likely depicted a place where grain may have been traded or stored. So on... there was early depictions of water buckets, however in any case it meant status.
@WILLIAMSA.I.ARTVIDEOS-xw8ee7 күн бұрын
This is an embarrassing load of absolute horseshit! So fucking retarded that it actually slows blood flow to the brain.
@jaimevaldez30587 күн бұрын
I am going to go on a limb here and say humans actually built it.
@alexlamuraglia87398 күн бұрын
They have no clue but they don't want us to have an open mind. No clue and don't be looking for answers.
@pedromiguel3919 күн бұрын
That bag along with the vulture that is a cloud a megastorm and vultures are death. Death that came from flooding from megastorms. Why a bag ? A carrier of water that cloud was not common , that's why they conveid one uncommon symbol. Vuktures came and feed on the dead
@NM_HG11 күн бұрын
Thanks for the conference overview. Looking forward to the excursion videos!
@sandyacombs11 күн бұрын
The stone work at Gobekli Tepe shows two different levels of technology and most likely built by two different peoples separated by time. First, there are massive T-shaped columns, difficult to cut, transport and erect. Second, there are the primitive walls surrounding the T-shaped columns that are composed of small uncut rocks that show no sign of the sophistication of the T-shaped columns. It is hard to believe that one people created both the sophisticated T-shaped columns and the primitive walls.
@Sonny-e4o11 күн бұрын
None of these videos ever touch the fact that these dark melanated ppl built these 🙄
@lizardbyte12 күн бұрын
Uncover it all and then we'll talk!
@thearchaeologistslaborator65918 күн бұрын
Archaeologists almost never uncover the entirety of a site, partly because excavation is damned expensive and partly because it may not be necessary to understand the site, and we want to leave some of it for future generations who will probably have better methods. However, whatever you may have heard, excavations have NOT stopped at Göbekli Tepe. Last year there were excavations in Building D, this year they dug in Building B and exposed more domestic structures west of Building B, and there are plans to return to excavating the large area in the NW part of the site in 2026. There are also lots of large and exciting excavations happening as we speak at Karahan Tepe, Sefer Tepe and Sayburç
@danielpaulson883812 күн бұрын
I am astounded at the foil hat comments about older civilizations that were advanced. I believe true cognitive, frontal lobe, human thinking skills have been largely left in antiquity. These places are indicators of a booming civilization and emerging belief system. I see thousands and even millions of humans, suddenly with time on their hands and need to be kept busy. As animals we are aware of our death at all limes and we live scared of that so invent ways to deal with it. Religion. Look at people today. Still that way. Idle hands are the devils tools. Pyramids are the same way. People cannot get out of modern biases and ponder what millions of people were doing, pre-technology, for a life time. Eating food and watching sand blow? These were made by the hands of the humans in their day. Modern humans would never make it if life was suddenly like back then. They don't know how to work or how to count people and accumulated man hours over generations.
@Hollywoodhouse7413 күн бұрын
Puny man didn't build anything megalific. Yet their is lititure out there that clearly exposes who excalty did
@danielpaulson883812 күн бұрын
I'ma gonna get my foil hat. 🤣🤣🤣
@jimjosemusic532514 күн бұрын
This attitude towards hunter-gatherers by elitists is alive and well here in 2024.
@lesjones568414 күн бұрын
What drugs are you taking 😂😂
@lesjones568414 күн бұрын
Are you serious 😅😅😅for some rocks 🪨 😂😂😂
@lesjones568414 күн бұрын
Are you serious 😅😅😅
@lesjones568414 күн бұрын
What drugs are you taking 😂😂
@lesjones568414 күн бұрын
Is there pizza 🍕 in there 😅😅
@lesjones568414 күн бұрын
I sherd do that 😂😂😂sometimes 😢😢
@lesjones568414 күн бұрын
I sherd do that 😂😂😂
@mrpad014 күн бұрын
A fascinating presentation. One thing does keep hitting home though, and that's the understanding that it is archeologists who have (in the past and even recent past, and I would add even contemporary archeologists) given a picture of past peoples as being brutish and uncivilized and of lesser skill and perhaps even intelligence. How silly we have all been to take what archeologists tell us as particularly definitive of truth, rather than an interpretation that then seeps into what we think of as knowledge and truth... We learn more all the time, and sometimes there are outrageous claims make in one period of history that eventually end up with evidence to back those claims up later. Happens all the time, so 'debunking' presentations can often seem disingenuous and rather cute.
@mrpad014 күн бұрын
i would add that some decades ago wouldn't the builders of Göbekli Tepe have been considered an ancient, lost civilization? Civilizations are lost, until they are discovered, after all.
@emmanye475015 күн бұрын
Oh my god yes thank u❤ its getting more and more important for Prehistory archaeologists to look at the East. Thank u so much for sharing. I feel this will be an absolute treasure for us❤❤❤
@taoerjohnson320215 күн бұрын
I am puzzled by why archaeologists persistently refuse to acknowledge the likelihood that lost advanced civilizations may have existed long before recorded history. They cling to the orthodox view of linear evolution of human beings and cultures, despite abundant evidence to the contrary.
@thearchaeologistslaborator659114 күн бұрын
Sorry to have to disagree but, despite what Hancock might imply, there is absolutely NO evidence for a Pleistocene civilization and abundant evidence to the contrary. We have thousands of sites with millions of artifacts belonging to Pleistocene hunter-gatherers, who were highly capable but did not live in sky-scrapers or drive motorized vehicles. They made no use of fossil fuels, let alone more advanced sources of energy, just burning wood for heat and the energy of their own bodies. They had no domesticated animals, no wheels, and had to carry anything they wanted to transport on their own backs. They had no metallurgy, no concrete, and, with just some exceptions in eastern Asia younger than about 25,000 years, no pottery. The Greenland ice cores show no evidence for air pollution back then that would result from any highly industrialized society.
@taoerjohnson320213 күн бұрын
@@thearchaeologistslaborator6591 The notion that Pleistocene hunter-gatherers and Bronze Age peoples, using primitive tools, constructed all megalithic structures and finely finished artifacts is unconvincing given our current understanding of technology and engineering. The available evidence indicates where, when, and how these people lived but does not clarify who actually built these structures.
@danielpaulson883812 күн бұрын
@@taoerjohnson3202 These places are clearly indicators of a booming civilization and emerging belief system. I see thousands and even millions of humans over generations of their civilizations, suddenly with time on their hands and needing to be kept busy. As animals we are aware of our death at all limes and we live scared of that so invent ways to deal with it. Local religions and structures. Look at people today. Still that way. Idle hands are the devils tools. Pyramids are the same way. People cannot get out of modern biases and ponder what millions of people were doing, pre-technology, for all of their life times. Eating food and watching sand blow? These were made by the hands of the humans in their day. A good leader in a successful civilization would feed workers and give them tasks to keep them happy and functional. The strongest argument coming from the science denier camp is to say they could not have done it. Seriously? That's it?
@thearchaeologistslaborator65918 күн бұрын
Again, I have to disagree. "Finely finished artifacts" were made all the time in antiquity. It only takes ingenuity, some brute force, and the patience to polish the stone with sand and grinding stones. And these pillars and such, though impressive, are not as perfect as you suggest. You can see flaws and places where the makers made corrections and adjustments. And the pillars are not really symmetrical either. Again, they're very impressive, but far from perfectly engineered, and they're well within the capabilities of ancient people.
@christianfrommuslim16 күн бұрын
Thank you for this interesting and rather complete overview. How wonderful that you could attend!
@MetaHominini16 күн бұрын
Can you do a video about an overview of all the phallus engravings?
@thearchaeologistslaborator659116 күн бұрын
Do you mean the phallus-like pillars in the cistern (or whatever it is) at Karahan Tepe? Or phallus images more generally?
@MetaHominini16 күн бұрын
@@thearchaeologistslaborator6591 Engravings or statues that suspiciously look like a phallus, maybe more generally
@thearchaeologistslaborator65918 күн бұрын
OK. I'll try to put that on my schedule of planned videos, although I'm already rather behind on that list!
@thearchaeologistslaborator659116 күн бұрын
This is the first of several videos I plan to release related to my recent trip to Türkiye for the World Neolithic Congress, mostly on the sites we visited.
@paulmuller69815 күн бұрын
Looking forward to your next video! This was really inspiring for me still studying archaeology at uni, hope to attend one of these some day :)
@edumorphology16 күн бұрын
3 minutes and you don’t answer the question
@NoNotAChance17 күн бұрын
I have read many different hypothesis as to the meaning of those 'handbags' with links to sites all over the world having similar or widely disparate interpretations. Sitting in on more than a few lectures over the years I have had also noted a wide range of theories, however something that does come up a lot more than not is them being a symbol of knowledge. Until a further breakthrough happens I am happy with that explaination.
@princerupert616117 күн бұрын
No one knows. And most probably never will. Everything is just speculation. One man's hand bag is another's seed basket.. I don't know, nor do you. We're you there? No.. So, your idea is just that. An idea
@thearchaeologistslaborator659116 күн бұрын
I did say that what I was offering was just another speculative hypothesis. Of course, none of us know for sure what these things are, and won't until new evidence turns up.
@thomasbyrne365518 күн бұрын
I wonder was there an earlier dark age lost to History resulting in the deaths of all Scholars and the elites through plagues and wars..?
@thearchaeologistslaborator65918 күн бұрын
The short answer is no. We have lots of evidence for what was happening in the Pleistocene period, coming from thousands of archaeological sites and millions of artifacts, bones, and plant remains. Consequently, we know that they were bands of hunter-gatherers (and sometimes fishers) who had no writing (but presumably oral traditions) and no scholars (but possibly elders or shamans who preserved cultural knowledge). Some of them lived in village-like collections of huts, while others had a more mobile lifestyle.
@andrewporrelli826818 күн бұрын
They could represent houses or temple complexes. I notice each one has a different animal that are displayed elsewhere on "T" pillars in different complexes/areas within Gobekli Tepe.
@thearchaeologistslaborator659117 күн бұрын
That's precisely the hypothesis I offer (though arguing for houses, not temples) near the end.
@samonitus20 күн бұрын
The idea that Göbekli was built by some older high tech civilization is strange. They haven't even found any evidence of a written language which would be the first sign of an advanced civilization.
@thearchaeologistslaborator659120 күн бұрын
Also, there's no evidence for the economy that would be needed to support a civilization: no domesticated plants or animals, no farm fields or factories, and no signal in the ice cores of the air pollution that would have resulted from a technologically sophisticated civilization.
@gracegrace210720 күн бұрын
Not the Ankh symbol. Try again.
@thearchaeologistslaborator659120 күн бұрын
I did not say it was the ankh symbol. I only said that some people might be referring to that, since I'm not aware of any Egyptian art showing deities carrying buckets.
@Iotakappa83720 күн бұрын
Your assertion that Sweatman's hypothesis does not hold up is misguided, as the depiction found below the sunsets can be counted as your "missing" solstice. And in fact, this is exactly what Sweatman proposes. The "handbags" representing the sun on the horizon, with the asterisms seen behind the sun on the equinoxes & winter solstice "inside" the bags. The summer solstice being what is depicted below the series of v's and boxes, with a vulture (interpreted as the "teapot" in Sagittarius) being the asterism seen behind the sun on that date.
@thearchaeologistslaborator65918 күн бұрын
I still think Sweatman is wrong. It's special pleading to find the missing solstice elsewhere on the pillar but, more importantly, the images don't actually align very well with the constellations and he ignores constellations that are missing or animals that don't match up with one. Also, why just this one pillar? His hypothesis would be more convincing if multiple pillars showed constellations.
@LevGreen-Wells21 күн бұрын
The submerged archaeology in Haifa sound really cool, it's awesome that the Cist Graves could remain intact after thousands of years!!
@thearchaeologistslaborator65918 күн бұрын
There was new talk on these sites at the recent World Neolithic Congress in Şanliurfa, Tūrkiye.
@ronniaj21 күн бұрын
This is stupidity arguing for this to be a town BS
@thearchaeologistslaborator659120 күн бұрын
As the evidence grows from other Göbekli-like sites in the region, it's becoming more and more obvious that these were villages. There are now ovens and stone pots and pans at Karahan Tepe, fire hearths and other "normal" signs of domestic life there, Göbekli Tepe, Sayburç, and Çakmaktepe.
@ronniaj21 күн бұрын
You live out important information to make it fit your narrative 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻
@thearchaeologistslaborator659120 күн бұрын
Really? Tell me what I've left out and I'll have a look at it. If it's real, I'll talk about it.