Joseph Marchione

Пікірлер

@mkultrakill1385 14 сағат бұрын

watching silo is like waiting at a bus stop

@BW9971 23 сағат бұрын

The last few episodes of Season 2 was great. The first few episodes were slow.

@BW9971 23 сағат бұрын

I thought of a new story arc. What if.....the Silo was on another planet? They think that they have been on Earth for hundreds of years, but once they start to delve into "why are we here?", They realize they are not on Earth.

@КрасимирНиколов-щ3б Күн бұрын

I am trying to FORCE myself to finish episode 1. Im not sure i can. Its dark. Theres NOTHING going on,just muffled speech,banging noises in the dark and useless flashback memories. If this was how it was in the book them im wasting my time on those series. If i am able somehow to finish episode 1 and episode 2 is the same ill just stop watching the show. U gotta have severe brain damage or mental breakdown to say season 2 ep 1 was good and i actually saw some such coments. Its crazy how stupid people have gotten. " I liked it,it was slow blah blah' THE ENTIRE EPISODE HAS NOTHING GOING ON IN IT FOR FUCKS SAKE !

@epiceagle2050 Күн бұрын

Wherefore are you clickbaiting by claiming to rank EVERY dune book if you actually dont?

@JosephMarchione Күн бұрын

@@epiceagle2050 i consider the brian herbert books to be fan fiction. I think most people clicking on the video assume im only ranking the Frank Herbert novels

@deadtoadsoup Күн бұрын

"I watched every episode and hated them all!" -ignorant children of the Tik Tok generation

@deadtoadsoup Күн бұрын

slow? duh a whole generation that thinks everything should be a 7 second tik tok video.

@villegas-su6fg Күн бұрын

very slow, solo thing got old, then there's 3 teenagers hanging out here the whole time, lame, Lukas Kyle and the mystery he's solving is all we got.

@Sergey_Brin Күн бұрын

s1 was still slow if you like silo u will know it's rlly slow

@Giggity1080 Күн бұрын

Thought it was really good actually

@johannesson77 Күн бұрын

I felt there was way too much filler. Only 50% of the season went anywhere and the rest was a slog.

@siphesihlesithole6055 Күн бұрын

opinion rejected

@MikeG-mp2sj Күн бұрын

I enjoyed it a lot, they are taking time to tell the story. I think my only nitpick was the cliffhanger episode felt out of time with both stories a bit, and then the sudden appearance of a fire room at the end was just weird. I think, we need a view of that to explain that it was there in the first place.

@coldinwisconsin2017 Күн бұрын

To everyone saying “It followed source material” as a way to justify the pacing issues: is the goal of the TV show to entertain an audience (including those who haven’t read the source material) or is it to adhere as perfectly to the source material as possible?? Obviously they didn’t achieve “entertaining an audience” as well as they did in season one, and they’re going to see a drop off in ratings and viewership next season. Only time will prove me right, but we all know I’m right about that.

@Sergey_Brin Күн бұрын

i really doubt that cause no way u truly like s1 and watched s2 and say u not gonna watch s3 not the way it ended, and by my statement i mean its not gonna be a massive drop

@coldinwisconsin2017 Күн бұрын

@ Well, I didn’t use the phrase “massive drop”, did I?

@КрасимирНиколов-щ3б Күн бұрын

iM TRYING TO FINISH EP 1 OF SEASON 2 ATM AND IM NOT SURE I CAN DO THAT ! And i was a big fan of the show. If i am able to finish this d ark and completely USELESS FILLER EPISODE and the 2nd one is like this i quit watching the show,i dont give a FUCK what the story is and how original it is

@coldinwisconsin2017 Күн бұрын

I agree that, compared to season one, the pacing was VERY slow. There was very little in the way of intrigue and mystery. “The Safeguard Procedure” was the only mystery added. The ending was weird. The suspense was NOT replicated from season one. I give season one a 9/10 and two a 5.5/10.

@nerian777 Күн бұрын

The second book had the same problem. It lacks the mystery of the first one, and it just verges on depressing. The series follows the book, and frankly they managed to make season 2 of the show more entertaining than the second book.

@dakattackgoesham Күн бұрын

I agree with most of your points! Me and my gf were pissed at the pacing

@Trippibash Күн бұрын

You nailed the 3rd season. It felt rushed and half of it was pointless. But still one of the best shows ever. They were able to give as many unanswered questions as lost which I like.

@Trilly8647 2 күн бұрын

Weak critiques

@JosephMarchione 2 күн бұрын

@@Trilly8647 your mom

@Trilly8647 2 күн бұрын

L video

@nnkk7742 2 күн бұрын

Silo delivered on the suspense but consistently came up short in worldbuilding and interpersonal dynamics. The whole show just feels like theater kids playing make believe commune in their moms basement. They could have done a lot better job at conveying the significance of certain aspects of silos culture and a lot of the character interactions, communications and motivations were straight immersion breakers. I didn't even get through the end of S02 and I'm out for any future seasons.

@perez-balen 2 күн бұрын

I agree. The pacing was awful. Compared to season one there were too few significant revelations. It’s not stated how long Juliet stayed at the second silo, but given what she did on screen, it felt like she was there for an afternoon.

@jcm9890 2 күн бұрын

Second season is great, this review is not.

@l0uisss 2 күн бұрын

The secondary cast failed to step up and make their arc interesting. Rebecca and the mayor carried the season.

@DonThato 2 күн бұрын

Worst review ever. Don't do it again.

@R3nz_ 2 күн бұрын

thumbs down

@Glorious.Return 2 күн бұрын

The British accent did come out often glad I am not the only who noticed that since English is not my main and I thought I am imagining it 😀

@ua7632 2 күн бұрын

Totally disagree.

@cesarp6761 2 күн бұрын

Remember this is a book adaptation (with some changes).. so you won't get something completely new and exciting.. they need to twist the book into something that makes sense for TV.. so no, there will not be a multi-verse Silo fight between all the people :p

@Radimunto 3 күн бұрын

I liked that season very much. Yes, it was slow but I don't mind. And people who are complaining about the screentime of Rebecca Nichols: There is simple no main characater in an ambivalent story like this. I liked the other characters, too. And i sincerely hope that Bernhard Holland survived. That character isn't really evil, never was. I want that redemption arc.

@YvesDarbouze 3 күн бұрын

Horrible takes

@tobiwan001 3 күн бұрын

Season 1 was much better than Season 2. hopefully season 3 will be better.

@mellotron_scratch 3 күн бұрын

The show follows a book source.

@HeadbangersKitchenNew 3 күн бұрын

I loved it. I didn't see the show when it came out, I saw it late last year, season 1 and then followed it with season 2 and I enjoyed the full season. Loved it, was a bit slow in the start but the payoff at the end was worth it for me at least.

@ZakuRX82 3 күн бұрын

The whole uprising from Mechanical and IT killing mayor was so badly written. Exposition galore, awful dialogue, forced fast pacing, continuity errors, illogical and out of characters decisions. Also the whole reading graffiti that has been there for decades and only now reading one part of it is so fucking stupid. Writers really thought they had the dumbest audience ever.

@Baki89Mr 2 күн бұрын

Just because you didn't like something doesn't mean it is badly written. I am so sick of you wanna be intellectuals

@hmp01 3 күн бұрын

damn dude you got 10 ppl to agree with you. the show is amazing

@Buxus 3 күн бұрын

The show is essentially an adaptation of the book Silo, and since it closely follows the source material, the pacing feels a bit slow at times due to the book’s detailed nature. Personally, I found the middle part of the season to be quite slow as well. However, next season will likely be very different-if you’ve read the book, you’ll know what I mean. That said, some of the upcoming developments might turn off a lot of viewers.

@JoshuaDay0550 Күн бұрын

The books are called Wool, Shift, and Dust. Season 2 ended towards the end of the first book, Wool, but left the ending out. People whine about shows like this because they wait a week and expect something awesome to happen instead of the story moving forward and the world being setup. Ive found that binge watching the episodes once the season is done is much more enjoyable vs waiting a week between episodes. Pretty easy to stay away from the spoilers (if you havent read the books).q

@adithya.m.bharadwaj8603 3 күн бұрын

Yeah, I agree with you ..

@twist3d537 3 күн бұрын

says you

@JonnyBlueChair 3 күн бұрын

Silo has been renewed for seasons 3 and 4.

@kansmansen8609 Күн бұрын

WHY?

@JonnyBlueChair 3 күн бұрын

Rebecca Ferguson is Swedish, not British.

@narem1092 3 күн бұрын

their plan "lets drag out 9 episodes and most of episode 10, and then in the last 20 minutes BOOOM! everything moves fast, we are tired" I hated the whole thing of "lets drag the rebels into this 'safe' so that they can witness our hero's return" would have been awesome they were super depressed, no hope type of thing, edge of giving up, then someone tells them that there is someone approaching on the screen AND MILK THE SHEET OUT EVERYONES REACTIONS, buut Juliette just appeared, she took a long ass time to reach Silo 17. The showrunners new what they were doing with that scene(no they didn't). I haven't watched a lot of series, kinda hard to invest in a show then magically gets cancelled, the problems I had with Silo is the same problem that had with other TV shows, aka House of The Dragon and From(which is dope, I think you'll love it, haven't snooped around your channel yet, so I don't know if you have reviewed it) is that they are meant to be 'binged' and INCOMPLETE final episodes, no way Silo episode 10 was meant to be the finale, everything happened too fast compared to snail's pace we got for 9 episodes. The Mechanics were boring show got greenlit for Season 3/4

@bcarr1122 3 күн бұрын

The writing for Season Two was much weaker than that of the first season. Some say that Season Two was "boring" or "slow"; I don't agree, but it lacked the wonderful cohesiveness and forward thrust that defined Season One. Perhaps the writers' strike had an impact?

@sethd6485 3 күн бұрын

no, they wrote Season 2 before that and filmed it in close conjunction with Season 1. Season 3 is already filming and Season 4 is 100% written. the only episode Apple hasn’t read is the series finale (4x10). i thought Juliet’s storyline was frustrating at times because it could (at times) feel aimless. helping Solo with this or that when the overall payoff isn’t clear. i also have a few issues with the “back at the ranch” storyline, in our main silo; namely, i don’t care for many of those characters the way i do for Juliet (hey Knox and Shirley!). but that said, i think once the series is complete, S2 will not seem as “weak” to the viewers who believe it was. i actually reject the idea that Season 1 was much stronger - it was a slow burn at times. but it all built up to a perfect finale with real payoff, one that answered some questions (what’s the world outside like? do people really die on the hill? are they all alone?) and raised others (what’s going on in the other silos? who built the silos and why?). i felt that Season 2 was similar in that way. yes, it was a slow burn at first, but it built up to a final few episodes that offered a lot of great payoff. the finale in particular did exactly what a great finale should do - like S1’s finale, it answered some questions and raised more questions. IMO, the payoff of the finale was so great that it completely justifies any “slow burn” that preceded it. yes, there were frustrating moments with Juliet’s storyline but overall (in my opinion) it actually wasn’t that slow, and it wasn’t always aimless, because there was payoff in the finale. if there hadn’t been, yeah, i would’ve been frustrated. but there was, and it was exactly what was needed. they gave away some but not too much. S3 will partly focus on the origin story which sounds fantastic (the two actors from the final S2 scene are series regulars in S3). so i get where people are coming from, and no show is perfect, but the finale made it all worthwhile for me. sometimes you just have to stick with it and i am so glad i did. narratively-speaking, this model works for the show IMO. it starts off a bit slow (i hope they can keep it from ever feeling aimless in future though) and then accelerates to a masterful rounding off of things, then leaves us with a satisfyingly open ending.

@bcarr1122 2 күн бұрын

@@sethd6485 Agreed, mostly, but for me there's no question that the writing was inferior to S1. It wasn't awful, but it simply wasn't of the same caliber. Hopefully it's not a portent of the remaining seasons.

@nerian777 Күн бұрын

The second book had the same problem. It just fails to set up intrigue or mystery. It just feels like the first book drags on. It verges on depressing.

@bcarr1122 Күн бұрын

@@nerian777 Interesting---thanks for your comment. I haven't read the books, but the impression I've gotten is that, at least in certain ways, the first season of the series is actually stronger than its source material. How unfortunate the writers couldn't maintain the momentum for season two.