Пікірлер
@FlandiddlyandersFRS
@FlandiddlyandersFRS Күн бұрын
2 old men talking medieval nonsense. This is why the world is in such a mess.
@shaistajanjua2557
@shaistajanjua2557 Күн бұрын
Respect your opinion Sir.
@MuhammadSaleem-kf4bz
@MuhammadSaleem-kf4bz 2 күн бұрын
Great discussion
@ozgun6611
@ozgun6611 3 күн бұрын
this is a bit sad.
@khurramhkhan
@khurramhkhan 10 күн бұрын
Fantastic discussion! Rabbi's last five tips nailed it in the end! My prayers are for all three of you for doing these talks
@althea_is_smokin_hot
@althea_is_smokin_hot 10 күн бұрын
Sir, islam is stuck in trivialities with counter narratives among muslim scholars,muftis and ulema.
@ricetanzania4148
@ricetanzania4148 14 күн бұрын
For me it would be telling the truth and answering difficult questions
@ebrahimmasood1564
@ebrahimmasood1564 14 күн бұрын
Very important discussion! The impact of an unqualified religious teacher is extremely harmful to the larger part of society as students go on to become parents, professional servants in various fields of civil society.
@wowgrape-j1v
@wowgrape-j1v 15 күн бұрын
Exmuslim sahil already exposed this rubbish cult
@yumnafareed3147
@yumnafareed3147 15 күн бұрын
Fractured irrational and rubbish answer!! How can one be getting married with the man or woman having distorted believes!!
@ZafarIqbal_1947
@ZafarIqbal_1947 21 күн бұрын
Dr. sahib, keep to your profession and don't interfere in something you are not qualified for. The view you have just expressed are against islam. if you are not an Alim then please refrain from this subject. keep to whatever you are qualified in.
@mubarakisonline
@mubarakisonline 24 күн бұрын
Engineer MIRZA Junior pakka munafiq
@khurramhkhan
@khurramhkhan 24 күн бұрын
Please continue these dialogues between the two respected religious scholars. I love to hear them have such insightful dialogues.
@prankytoons123
@prankytoons123 25 күн бұрын
You are a PhD and you cant even hear lectures properly of EMAM. In all of his speeches, he says Quran is the basic book of islam and Hadith are secondary. and you clearly misheard or intentionally stated vice-versa. It doesnt behoove to lie so blatantly on someone. You are a kazzaab.
@rationalbeing17
@rationalbeing17 25 күн бұрын
He's not a scholar khalid sb rest is secondary When he doesn't have basic knowledge in arabic , hadith etc
@syedkazmi6487
@syedkazmi6487 25 күн бұрын
Neck and hair are part of Aurah for post puberty girls and women. That has to be covered. Those are erogenous parts that’s what is called as private.
@amirdar3453
@amirdar3453 26 күн бұрын
Engineer Muhammad Ali mirza is a great islamic scholar ❤❤❤❤❤❤.......
@afrazamjad1644
@afrazamjad1644 27 күн бұрын
I welcome all hindus to listen Dr Zakir Naik where Millions of hindus changed their Religion for Truth
@Andhnamazi_of_Deceiver_Ch3v54
@Andhnamazi_of_Deceiver_Ch3v54 28 күн бұрын
Welcome to open debate in Exmuslim Adam Seeker or Exmuslim Sahil Official
@althea_is_smokin_hot
@althea_is_smokin_hot 29 күн бұрын
Sir, Abrahmic dialogues have been all about monotheism, mostly between 3 branches of Abrahmic faith. But,the tragedy has been that they have never been at peace with one another. Surprisingly none of the 3 ever think about this dilemma which started withthe origin of monotheism and continuing till date.
@ahmedisl8
@ahmedisl8 28 күн бұрын
If you look at history of the islamicate world you will find many evidences of Abrahamics living in peace with each other living and learning from each other, especially in the academic and mystical spheres
@salampakistan3691
@salampakistan3691 Ай бұрын
Am I mistaken by what you said??? Did you say to recite the ritual prayers in our own language...??? Correct me if I heard wrong. If you did say it, you are seriously misguided. Do not use your intellect when Allah swt ruled something and Prophet ruled something we cannot go against it as Allah swt created the perfect religion. The Quran and Sunnah are above our opnions. No scholar can rule otherwise. The precedents been set by the Prophet, the Sahabah, The Tabi and Tabi Tabiyeen...accept it. I will not accept a letter or word to be changed from the Quran and Sunnah. Forever wearing my burka
@talhazaheer507
@talhazaheer507 29 күн бұрын
😂😂😂😂 if you don’t understand what you are saying, it’s never going to be as meaningful or as powerful. Stop being ignorant.
@ahmedisl8
@ahmedisl8 28 күн бұрын
A part of the prayer is left to our own discretion, this includes but is not limited to praises and prayers in ruqu, sujud and tashahud. There is no obligation upon us, to follow set utterances. Neither did the prophet (upon whom be peace) command us that and neither did the early muslims understand it to be so. Infact you will find evidences of people praising and making supplications in prayer according to their circumstances and needs at the time
@salampakistan3691
@salampakistan3691 28 күн бұрын
@ahmedisl8 No your wrong. The Salaf all prayed in Arabic, and any thing dua you want to make your language say it in your heart. Do not try to change 1400yrs of islamic scholarship. Somehow after 1400yrs you genius suddenly discover the truth...no way. The pious predecessors knew more hadith then Google sheikh. We do as they do. You spreading misinformation. Why are you soo lazy to learn Arabic and recite. It's soo easy. You can do your personal dual in your own language after the ritual prayer like anyone else. I seen jewish Rabbis setting up meetings where they discuss how to get muslims to change and reform their religion. This looks like one of their ideas 💡. Never will we change a letter let alone a word of our faith based on some radom academic and his opnions. We have a beautiful Islamic tradition which we will never change. I have sakinah and tranquility in my prayers even in Arabic. Just do daily dhilkr specially in Tajjud time, reflect and dua in your heart and watch your ritual prayers will get better. Allah swt chose the language of Quran and formal rituals to be done in Arabic to preserve our religion. It's done a good job of that. Often we pick hadiths not knowing the timeline of hadiths and another hadith overrides it. Like for example, before sahabah use to be able to look around and give salams in the ritual prayers. One Sahabi left to go Yemen to teach the people during that time. After Prophet (saw) ordered that no one talks and looks around in prayer. So the Sahabi came back from Yemen not knowing the new ruling. And continued talking in prayer. All the other Sahabis looked at him shocked at what he was doing. He wondered why they looking at him strangely. They told him the Prophet Muhammad (saw) ruling which was new to him as that they did not have phones to tell each other of the change. So if you read hadiths, you need to know science of hadiths. Otherwise you cannot extract ruling from it. Forever wearing my burka
@ahmedisl8
@ahmedisl8 28 күн бұрын
@@salampakistan3691 you clearly are not here for dialogue and are just reiterating dogmas without trying to understand what is being said. And you discredit and demean the knowledge of those you disagree with. And insinuating the existence of "jewish conspiracies" is one of them. Try to, with complete ikhlas understand the arguments of the other side without citing your dogmas to protect the dogmas.
@salampakistan3691
@salampakistan3691 28 күн бұрын
@ahmedisl8 What you trying to say, a dialogue does not mean me accepting everything you say. Also somethings there is no dialogue in. To say they up for dialogue is to say maybe there could be be another way. They Quran and Sunnah, they are obligatories and sunnahs of Islam. They are not up for dialogue. Either you accept or face the consequences in the hereafter. I do not accept any radom weirdos to come with their hairy fairy and whimsical opinions. We need Quran and Sunnah and consensus of the 1400yrs of islamic scholarship. Radom acadamic Abdul cannot change 1400yrs of Islam just because he has a degree and PhD in some western school
@raeesshaikh4631
@raeesshaikh4631 Ай бұрын
I am myself a khua shuda Just go to darul- Qaza Tell them your problem fill the given form. It's better to tell your husband first ,through a common person If he ready,both comes with respective family Qazi will talk with both the person. Through mutual understanding Nikah is nullified And institute issued a certificate for that And received a nominal amount for their service.
@akmalkhan3401
@akmalkhan3401 Ай бұрын
Yor r not mufti dont transgress from your experties.be afraid of judgement day
@althea_is_smokin_hot
@althea_is_smokin_hot Ай бұрын
Of course, they are interest bearing certificates. One can call them islamic interest bearing certificates. That will make them halal. The Arabic word islam purifies everything it touches. In a lighter note, it can even purify pork.
@Zohra-b9j
@Zohra-b9j Ай бұрын
Death is an absolute Reality no one can deny . We meet death everyday when we sleep our Past has died too. Every day indicates GOD blessings . We must be Thankful to GOD and Respect Boundaries to follow Prophet ( PBUH ) and we must know Prophet followed Quran only ( But we have to follow Prophet and it requires wisdom therefore we must ask Guidance from GOD for this we have to establish Prayers .
@Zohra-b9j
@Zohra-b9j 2 ай бұрын
May Allah Guide us all towards straight Path as SHETAAN is our Very Jealous Enemy .
@user-jl6ep9wk9x
@user-jl6ep9wk9x 2 ай бұрын
what is this non sense , asking this to a sheikh ?
@ISMIHANI
@ISMIHANI 3 ай бұрын
Nafs or desire is in everyone and Satan is the greatest enemy of all. That proves life is a test that everyone has to go through despite guidance provided by Allah SWT.
@2AN3M
@2AN3M 3 ай бұрын
Atheists believe in humanity and value it. Their purpose or goal is to leave this world a better place for next generation because they are going to a part of the future generation living a little bit in allnew born life on this planet. That makes them put themselves in other people shoes and feel for them. Living by the principle that what you don’t like for yourself shall not be done to others. On the other hand religious people believe in the hereafter which devalues life on earth and their sense of accountability which is a good thing is so skewed in all religions that even the heinous crimes are forgiven when you “ believe “ in something ( mostly a human figure) which any rational mind can figure out what lies behind. Is it good to work and progress with known and proven facts or with myths created in ancient times that cannot be seen or proven? I want to ask Dr Khalid zaheer if intercession on the day of judgement is fair? That is mentioned in Quran. And Hadith endorses all levels of intercession . When bacteria and viruses were not discovered all kinds of myths were invented to explain their effects. Once they have been discovered many answers are found and now there are ways to deal with them. We will do the same with God. Why BELIEVE in him now and indulge in all myths and play by irrational and illogical rules???
@Areusureboutdat
@Areusureboutdat 3 ай бұрын
Disgusting
@khurramhkhan
@khurramhkhan 3 ай бұрын
This dialogue is a great effort, don't discontinue please
@Zohra-b9j
@Zohra-b9j 3 ай бұрын
We Muslim also believe in Risalat and Akhirat Beside Toheed .
@Red.Pensil
@Red.Pensil 4 ай бұрын
آج زرا سورج کو طلوع کے وقت دیکھیں اور پھر غروب کے وقت دیکھیں اور سمت نوٹ کریں۔ اور پھر سردیوں میں بھی یہی نوٹ کریں۔ آپ کو معلوم پڑ جائے گا کہ سردیوں اور گرمیوں میں سورج اپنی سمت بدلتا رہتا ہے۔ زرا نوٹ کرنا شروع کریں کہ گرمیوں میں سورج کی مشرق میں سمت بدل جاتی ہے اور سردیوں میں بھی سورج کی سمت بدل جاتی ہے۔ بالکل اسى طرح جب گرمیوں میں سورج جس سمت میں غروب ہوتا ہے وہ سردیوں والی سمت سے مختلف ہوتی ہے۔ اور سورج سارا سال اپنی سمت بدلتا رہتا ہے جس کی وجہ سے موسم بدلتے رہتے ہیں۔ کوئی مجھے سمجھائے کہ اس میں کون سى راکٹ سائنس انوالو ہے؟ .
@cmashfaq
@cmashfaq 4 ай бұрын
Alhumdulillah. Beautiful presentation Ustadh Ji. I'm Chowdry Ashfaq from Bangalore India. JazakAllahu Khairan.
@ImamZaydInstitute
@ImamZaydInstitute 4 ай бұрын
Very Important topic ustadh, keep it up
@Zohra-b9j
@Zohra-b9j 4 ай бұрын
This important message should be in urdu too ! Thank You !
@khurramhkhan
@khurramhkhan 4 ай бұрын
Dear Dr. Sahab this explanation is more like pre-programming of the destiny. For example this is how a software programmer does that who codes pre-programmed options within software for the software to choose from so this isn't free-will. I would like to share another opinion and explanation about how foreknowledge of God seems to work and how free-will fits in that, for those who are interested, please watch these two playlists. There is no claim that these explanation are 100% correct, it is just that it is a complicated subject so we should also hear others opinions and assess and whichever makes more sense, we should accept that. Foreknowledge of God: kzbin.info/aero/PLaGDv4HYCLaJpwIZSfuf_ItM9zeqawL8T&si=bLL2CUY_KyFGAHLl Concept of Free Will: kzbin.info/aero/PLaGDv4HYCLaLGFoaUEoywMUYKSs71xUVO&si=K2LfY3HrsRCjOLb6
@khurramhkhan
@khurramhkhan 4 ай бұрын
Awesome dialogue between two great religious scholars and teachers! Loved the prayer by the hostess in the end! I hope we get to hear more dialogues like this one in the future as well.
@abduljalal6501
@abduljalal6501 5 ай бұрын
Salam alaikum, exept humans , god's creation s not die in hungry why? Example flys, snakes....../ human is a separeted animal.
@amirdhanjee4950
@amirdhanjee4950 5 ай бұрын
Don't unnecessarily interpret.God only nows the best
@yasinhamza574
@yasinhamza574 5 ай бұрын
Nope it is the sun rise and the moon rise(2×) and the sun set and the moon set(2x)
@abdulraja1151
@abdulraja1151 5 ай бұрын
Ibrahim yusuf2636 has the correct explanation . People you don’t have true knowledge of the Quran and the Geography should not attempt such answers ! It is crime to interpret the Quran without proper studying and research !
@Red.Pensil
@Red.Pensil 4 ай бұрын
The sun has started changing its setting direction / point and sun is now moving/drifting gradually from north west to the west and in the month of December the sun wud be setting exactly in the direction of the west. So, See how simple and Easy way to make a layman understand the words Rabul Mashrikayn Rabul Maghribayn.
@ya7771
@ya7771 5 ай бұрын
Dear all, with al respect....a possible correct explanation is.....The Quran has been sent to mankind on earth! The earth experience two rises and two setting! WHICH ARE THEY? The first pair is the SUNRISE AND SUNSET....The second pair is THE MOONRISE and MOONSET.....THEREFORE THIS EARTH HAS TWO RISES AND TWO SETTINGS! That is the clear meaning of the verse ' Rabbo almachriqayni wa rabbo almaghribayni' THE LORD OF THE TWO RISING POSITIONS AND TWO SET POSITIONS! AND IF ALLAH WOULD SEND THIS Quran to an alien nation where there are 2 sun's and two moons then it will be " LORD OF THE FOUR RISING POSITIONS AND FOUR SET POSITIONS......I hope you enjoy this logic and clear reasoning....that is Quran and Allah knows best!
@Zohra-b9j
@Zohra-b9j 5 ай бұрын
Aaj Kal K Door Mey khud ko Hadayat Yafta Samjh leyna hi Ghumrahi hy . Allah ham sab Musalmanoo ko Hadayat par rakhy , Allah Ghumrahi sy Bachaay Ameen
@ibrahimyusufu2636
@ibrahimyusufu2636 5 ай бұрын
Poor and incorrect explanation. What Allah meant here is simply that sometimes the sun rises at East/South and another time the sun rises at East/North. Also sometimes the sun sets at West/South and another time the sets at West/Noth.
@Red.Pensil
@Red.Pensil 4 ай бұрын
The sun has started changing its setting direction / point and sun is now moving/drifting gradually from north west to the west and in the month of December the sun wud be setting exactly in the direction of the west. So, See how simple and Easy way to make a layman understand the words Rabul Mashrikayn Rabul Maghribayn. NO rocket sainse is involved.
@abduljalal6501
@abduljalal6501 5 ай бұрын
Salam alaikum, 'allamal insaana maalam ya elam' in quran chapter alaq.news this is a imagene pole.realy not east, west ,north and south.rabbul mashriqain va rabbul magribain, this 2 is total 4 .'alam naj alil ardha mihaadha valjibaala awthaadha' in quran chapter naba e.we all r creation of allah, this earth is a cradle of his creations.sun is rounding and earth.'val qamaru qaddharnaanu manaazila hathaa aadha kal urjoonal qadheem" in quran chapter yaaseen'.al samsu wal qamaru bi husbaan'.quran chapter rahman.he is creator universe, but muslims not call him father.totaly he is father of universe.muslims using 99 names allah's.
@saudqadir7444
@saudqadir7444 5 ай бұрын
GOOGLE search NASA found a planet which has two sun SubhanALLAH
@rizwanwasi7019
@rizwanwasi7019 5 ай бұрын
I did not understand what he wanted to say.
@jameelahmedkazi3193
@jameelahmedkazi3193 5 ай бұрын
The explanation is ambigious and off the mark.