I fully support switching to electric and away from diesel where applicable. However... Why doesn't the MBTA purchase new (or used) electric engines to operate on the Providence/Stoughton Line? If the overhead wires are already there, what is the MBTA waiting for? Buy one or two. Test them, then get them into regular service. Unless there is a magical half billion or multi-billion in financial resources ready to spend, trying to electrify one or more lines seems a little unrealistic. Likewise, where will all this electricity come from? Does electrification also include $$$ for new windmills, solar farms, or anything else that will make electricity? Amtrak seems like a reasonable buyer to purchase used locomotives from as they plan to put new locomotives into service within the next decade.
@railfanning.productions18 күн бұрын
I agree!
@southmassrailfan22 күн бұрын
Knowing Dovetail, I was so excited to see how they would cook up my home town, and out of every area of the map Ashland is the only town that was completely disrespected. The downtown area looks NOTHING like real life.
@railfanning.productions20 күн бұрын
Yeah I was also disappointed about the downtown part of Ashland in the game. Wish they did better
@MAAndNCRailfan22 күн бұрын
Awesome Video
@railfanning.productions20 күн бұрын
thanks!
@MAAndNCRailfan20 күн бұрын
@ When Dose Amtrak Pass On The Route
@MAAndNCRailfan20 күн бұрын
YW
@railfanning.productions20 күн бұрын
@MAAndNCRailfan I did it in the scenario mode and spawned in the train. It doesn't leave on a time. It's also an ACS-64, which actually can't run on the Worcester line 😂
@MAAndNCRailfan20 күн бұрын
@ Ok. 😂😂😂😂😂
@LSR44924 күн бұрын
what in the acs64
@railfanning.productions24 күн бұрын
It was the best I could do 😭
@LSR44923 күн бұрын
@@railfanning.productionsyou can use HSPs as p42s by finding a livery. I also made a wannabe viewliner if you need to use it.
@KAP-cdr26 күн бұрын
Great video - nice job capturing the 2024 trains 2:44
@railfanning.productions25 күн бұрын
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it!
@mx33827 күн бұрын
Battery electric EMUs as designed by European train companies are made for small branch routes, which can't justify the infrastructure investment of proper electrification, not for longer commuter trains with 30 minute services, which are just looking for short term infrastructure savings.
@protosheep28 күн бұрын
Im still salty for missing 507 leading the Geo even though I have seen practically everything else
@SuperOwensTrainsYT28 күн бұрын
Great videos and catches!! Have a great new year
@stoneybrookrailroadvids273628 күн бұрын
Good closing of the year
@railfanning.productions28 күн бұрын
thanks!
@Tommy-mh3jd29 күн бұрын
the thing is Electrification would look Ugly and cost too much new diesel locomotives would be a better alternative
@stoneybrookrailroadvids2736Ай бұрын
Good shots and great video once again!
@railfanning.productionsАй бұрын
Thanks!
@SuperOwensTrainsYTАй бұрын
Great video!
@WendyMangels-uv9loАй бұрын
Where is the shot of 1405 taken?
@railfanning.productions18 күн бұрын
It's at Willow Road in Ayer
@SuperOwensTrainsYTАй бұрын
3:08 there’s me (bottom left corner)
@ericschwartz35592 ай бұрын
June 14, 2022: 1069 is currently in rebuild and 1057 and 1074 were fresh out of rebuild. 1029, 1033, 1053, 1062, 1067 and 1070 were all at mpi being refurbished.
@NortheastCorridorFilms2 ай бұрын
correct me if im wrong but EDSA is NS
@railfanning.productionsАй бұрын
It's operated by NS locomotives, but it runs under the B&E line, which would make it a B&E train, I believe.
@NortheastCorridorFilmsАй бұрын
@ you are right
@jasonhadfield15512 ай бұрын
I enjoyed the video
@railfanning.productions2 ай бұрын
Thanks!
@jasonhadfield15512 ай бұрын
@railfanning.productions u are very welcome
@jasonhadfield15512 ай бұрын
@railfanning.productions u are very welcome
@jasonhadfield15512 ай бұрын
@railfanning.productions u are welcome 🙏
@qualitytraders53333 ай бұрын
In 1922 The Netherlands decided to electrify the rail network. So, the US is running more than 100 years behind. The main reason is that in the US railroads are private while in Europe they are managed by governments. Anybody, saying private companies running infrastructure is more eficient, is just crazy.
@grommit70021 күн бұрын
Imagine 1) having the right to access a resource (such as water) from a local supplier that is located across a bridge, and 2) provide a resource for community benefit. But because the roads on the leadup and even the bridge itself is privately owned, these private owners say who can use the roads and bridges. This is pretty much how rail lines in USA are structed as where Amtrak (funded by the gov) does not have ownership rights. A little backwards compared to railways in Europe I hear. When American railroads as a whole declined around the middle of the 20th century, private ownership and acquisition by freight companies made things more difficult for passenger service (which was reduced as the automobile industry took off in the second half of the same century). This begins to explains why Amtrak struggles to provide on-time service where they do not own track, and why it's taking a long time for any passenger service company in USA to improve service where there is demand...
@grommit70021 күн бұрын
Now also imagine having a fraction of the budget (and income) some of the freight companies have. This is the constant variable Amtrak deals with year after year (minus the lack of track ownership). Whether Amtrak will become a private railroad one day, that's up to the U.S. Congress to decide considering they created it. Brightline is a new American railroad dedicated to passenger service in USA. So far they seem to be doing well. Yet I question their ultimate parent ownership (who are in the Middle East) Anyhow, if freight companies really wanted to, they could easily replace 50 and 100 year infrastructure nationwide in record time. A simple overpass is pennies in the grand scheme of things. For the time being, Amtrak's success is determined by tax-payer money and cooperation by those private owners. Plus American values too.
@samstranghorwitz3 ай бұрын
Yes 1052 horn is fixed!
@F40-RULES3 ай бұрын
This is old. 1052 is south now.
@byronchavarria49543 ай бұрын
The Montauk Branch Goes From New York City To Montauk Not Long Island City
@RoyalcaribbeanFan-g5l3 ай бұрын
3:52 Thats not a F40...
@tracksidewithtom533 ай бұрын
I was with you! :)
@railfanning.productionsАй бұрын
Good day!
@tracksidewithtom53Ай бұрын
@@railfanning.productions true!!
@SuperOwensTrainsYT3 ай бұрын
Nice
@protosheep3 ай бұрын
i fumbled bro
@zostrelling_3 ай бұрын
nice video, keep it up
@railfanning.productions3 ай бұрын
Thank you!
@CSAviationandTransitChannel3 ай бұрын
PL42ACs are not new, and only the ALP45DP is Dual Power.
@girodavivere3 ай бұрын
Not that anybody outside of Philadelphia should be expected to know this, but Cynwyd is pronounced "Kinwood"
@stevenroshni12284 ай бұрын
Great overview. :) It would be helpful to put your own captions since this is very dense with the names of lines and such.
@railfanning.productions4 ай бұрын
Thank you! What do you mean by captions? Like my own graphics on the screen like maps?
@MirzaAhmed893 ай бұрын
There's autogenerated captions already. Just press the CC button on the video (or click C on a laptop or desktop).
@jasonhadfield15514 ай бұрын
I enjoyed the video
@railfanning.productions4 ай бұрын
thank you!
@jasonhadfield15514 ай бұрын
U are welcome
@SouthernCtRailfan4 ай бұрын
Nice action
@railfanning.productions4 ай бұрын
thanks!
@Mishastrains4 ай бұрын
Yea but they chose the fairmount line which is i guess a good choice cuz if those trains broke down on the nec then trains might get delayed really badly and the nec is really busy so idk
@NortheastCorridorFilms4 ай бұрын
how are you catching all this when i went and only saw 16R and B101
@railfanning.productions4 ай бұрын
You should go in the early morning. This day just so happened to have a grain train come into Ayer so that’s why there was a lot of action
@hannamaniacrailproductions50824 ай бұрын
0:50 my favorite spot! Ball hill
@railfanning.productions4 ай бұрын
Nice! I like this spot too! It's right in my hometown so I hear the trains all the time!
@hannamaniacrailproductions50824 ай бұрын
@@railfanning.productions Same here
@PeterBlack-nl5hy4 ай бұрын
Drawbridges should not be a problem. The New Haven Line and Shore Line have lots of drawbridges, and all but the Cos Cob bridge have continuous electrification. At Cos Cob, the trains coast across the gap in electrification. With the M8 cars, at least one set is powered at all times. Catenary towers last at least 100 years. About 20 years ago, the New Haven Line's catenary was converted to constant tension, with sets of pulleys, weights, and cables whose expansion in heat kept the power wires at a constant height. The Shore Line, and rest of the NEC from New Haven to Boston, was electrified in 2000 with new constant tension wires. Electrification isn't new technology. It's entirely doable.
@grommit70021 күн бұрын
Speaking of SLE... I'd like to see SLE and MBTA service expanded to Westerly. This would replicate the New Haven and Hartford main lines where two passenger railroads provide economical and premium services for passengers. However, for this to happen some major track work needs to be done in the form of making double track station triple. This way both the economical and premium trains operate without bottlenecks. Some of the stations in CT appear to have the space to expand. But it will come down to whether local property owners are okay with giving up some of their land for the railroad.
@peter793621 күн бұрын
@@grommit700 A lot of stations have room, so no need for takings. But the stations are generally new, and cost millions of dollars. This problem was foreseen when SLE went bidirectional, with platforms on both sides of the tracks. Yes, service to Westerly would be good, but more critical is service during commuting hours. There is a huge gap between 5:30 PM and 8:30 pm for evening trains out of New Haven. That's a very long wait for typical commuters who cannot make the 5:30 train, which is a lot since most are coming from Fairfield County. I the CTDoT folks think SLE is for New Haven commuters, not Fairfield County, and that everyone has the hours of state employees, and can leave work at 4:30 pm. My town's parking lot was full pre-pandemic, now it's mostly empty after service cuts.
@grommit70021 күн бұрын
@@peter7936 Yeah it's amazing how in one part of the state service is frequent. Whereas in the opposite, it's much less. Now I understand why the state wanted to reduce SLE service. Bristol and Manchester CT have good size populations on both ends and along the way on both the roads and rails. I could see a new service being implanted here one day. Eastern Connecticut to the RI border seems more tourism and local user oriented. Maybe if Westerly's and New London's economy expanded, I could see both states working together quickly to provide passenger service. Perhaps there is a case to create seasonal service for the warm weather season? I've used CT Rail quite a bit. It's nice because on either ends there are moderate sized cities, and a mix of everything in between for people to use the train for.
@peter793621 күн бұрын
@@grommit700 There's no passenger service to Bristol or Manchester. Are you suggesting a new line? The thing with SLE is there are a lot of folks who live out here and commute to Fairfield County or even the city. Train service is a good commuting option for those long commutes if it is frequent enough. I would also help if CDoT enforced paying for parking at Metro North stations like West Haven and Blackrock.
@grommit70021 күн бұрын
I am suggesting service between B and M. Because 84 in both directions is unpleasant no matter the time of year wet or dry. The XL Center and CCSU are two examples of reasons people would take the train. I used SLE before. It's faster which tops MNRR on the NH Line. Yet I sensed the general demand is why it's struggling ever since the pandemic and remote work. I hope demand goes back up.
@MarcelosalivaTRENESArg4 ай бұрын
Excellent video my friends 😊awesome 😮fantatic Greeting 🙋🏻♂️ from Argentina 🇦🇷
@railfanning.productions4 ай бұрын
Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it!
@ArchsStanton4 ай бұрын
battery locomotive = *PURE PATHETIC JOKE.*
@LSR4495 ай бұрын
3:40 speedy boi
@TLT_Productions5 ай бұрын
i would make one but my laptop decided to delete all my footage 😭
@railfanning.productions5 ай бұрын
Oh no! Hope you get it back
@LSR4495 ай бұрын
might also make one around 31st
@railfanning.productions5 ай бұрын
Nice!
@LSR4495 ай бұрын
@@railfanning.productions also I forgot to mention that was phenomenal editing, and catches were incredible!
@railfanning.productions5 ай бұрын
@@LSR449thank you!
@TLT_Productions5 ай бұрын
the mbta train hitting the switch at the start is heaven