You have a beautiful way of speaking and editing. I can tell you make great effort into making these videos. Keep at it! You’re going to amazing KZbinr one day.

10:05 I like the meta-ness of that

9:10 this is a bad shot to put here. This shot is supposed to represent Bob's sense of exhilaration, victory; NOT loneliness

3:59 incorrect: they never spent a night together.

Next year the before trilogy will be 30th anniversary of the movie

good job

e39 m5 @4:07

Really liked your interpretation and analysis. Just a very small improvement that I would suggest is I find a slight difficulty in hearing your words maybe because the the sound of movie clips overpowered at some places and the other places I found your voice level dropped to sort of murmuring. However, I liked that in analysis of some scenes a you had gone to really good and subtle depth, and above all liked the way you synthesised things into the broader view, and outline.

9:29 "Masses who live alone together" and that shot of everyone talking or listening to their earbuds really freaked me out. I live on a college campus and I'm telling you not a single person outside is without airpods. It looks exactly like that shot. We might not have ai like Samantha just yet, but Her's near future is here.

Thank you. I would never have made this sublime connection on my own

I come back to this video every so often, as it encapsulates everything I feeling when I think of these of films. To me, these films, depict a reality about relationships, no other film or films, has in my knowledge managed to demonstrate.

What a beautiful analysis. I need to rewatch both.

Made handle..dark room of illiterates

Her is sad to me lost in translation is too but her is a scary and sad

I really like the way you put it that the trilogy is like a painting and not a photograph. This is just so true and exactly why I love the trilogy so much. The painting actually reveals more than what a photograph can ever capture. Before Midnight is my favorite, although this is a close call for each one of the said trilogy is special in their way. But, the conflicts and arguments are exactly the building blocks of a solid relationship, fostering growth, understanding, and bonding. By the third film, the love between the two characters matured like a fine wine but is tinged with a sadness forged by compromises of hurdles in real life. The rosy-tinted glasses were long gone. True love is actually imperfect. An imperfect relationship between two imperfect human beings in an imperfect world.

they shared scarlett in the divorce

For me the kiss at the end of Lost in Translation ruined the movie.

It’s so crazy that both of the movies directors were married to each other…

Funfact: I love LiT and don`t know Her. I klicked through this video and didn´t find one single image from Her that I liked. Is it`s cinematoghaphy that bad?

Her is one of my favourite films. I watched it at a time where i was struggling to find media that interested me and it blew me away. Its so simple, but its so emotionally complex. Thats what i love to see in cinema. An old familiar story, reframed with a fresh perspective and new adversities. Its similar for lost in translation. I love the simplicity. The slower pace, to match the relationship. Isolated but together. Lonely and not alone. Heartbreak. These are tales as old as time, but told through much more current or even futuristic lenses. Making you the viewer rethink. Thats what art should do. Shake up your perspective while making you look at yourself+the world around you.

LiT is an enjoyable movie, but I randomly watched Her right after a breakup and it hit me like a ton of bricks

this is a very good video, and you should be proud of it.

okay, so which is the superior film? I think we can all agree they are a duality of classic Indie Film. they are both wonderful movies. but they were made by two halves of a marriage (what a world we live in--we get both perspectives of a singular relationship made into two kickass movies!) but which is the superior movie? which movie succeeds the most in what it's doing? my gut goes for _Lost in Translation_ absolutely every time. I respond most to that movie on that guttural level. but then _Her_ I think does more with less. it goes for SO MUCH and captures very nearly all of it. it invents an entire future that is _exceptionally relatable,_ which in itself is a wonder of cinema. it happens so, so rarely. and it's all about the triumph of the human imagination, intellect and then ultimately its end. all those AIs off on some literally unimaginable adventure and quest for its own creation. yeah, I dunno, _Translation_ will always be the movie I both saw first (it was the first real Character Drama I remember liking more than any action of adventure movie; it started my whole appreciation for character and place and themes), but . . . I do think _Her_ is the superior piece of fiction. _Lost in Translation_ is two people in Japan, gorgeously told. while _Her_ is about kind of everything we are. they're both artistically unimpeachable. absolutely. and, of course, since, God is Good, BOTH wife and husband won an Oscar for _Best Original Screenplay_ for their respective stories about that one relationship. like I said, it really is some amazing world we live in.

What a weird coincidence, I just had another video recommended to me of Spike Jonze and Sofia Copolla (the writers / directors of these 2) being interviewed on 90s MTV

The critique of Charlotte's husband is a little unfair, he seems primarily distracted while on a work holiday whereas Charlotte is seeking existential purpose and relational connection. Both in very different headspaces

What was the piano song you included?

Omg these two films have always been my favourite films ever and I just found out that both the directors use to be married and it’s added a even more meaningful layer to it all

Poo - you've just got a thing for Scarlet Johansson (and the sound of your own voice reciting a thesaurus!). Love and kisses. Alice xx

(Lost in Translation)

I used to watch this movie every night.

I feel the connection of these two films when I am watching them.

What happened to this channel? It’s fantastic. I wish there were more videos.

Thats why I felt nothing while watching her. It always felt like a copy of my favourite movie.

I just found this video, it brought me to tears. Her and Lost in Translation are two of my favorite films, it doesn’t surprise me that they were birthed from the same flame. Thank you for this beautiful video, wishing you the best.

i found out that charlotte and theodore have the same mbti personity type as me, an infp. Maybe that's why i relate to them a lot

Tbh was just looking for some dirty gossipy video explaining the reason their marriage fell apart so this kinda caught me off guard and is waaay more than I deserved -- effing beautiful essay!

Amazing analysis, please return to yt 🙏🙏

Beautiful and amazing analysis

How did this video/channel go so criminally unnoticed?

I need to rewatch both of these films. They are both so fantastic and both impacted me so much upon first watch.

Such a well put together analysis of both films, two of my favourites.

Beautiful recollection ❤️ thank you!

What's the music at 3:13 ? It's beautiful. Couldn't find it from the description box.

Please, tell me your name. I fell in love with your voice.

I've never seen anything more beautiful. Every time it touches my soul. Thank for this trilogy.

What's the song in 02:11?

Her.. incredibly inane.. Lost in Translation...brilliant.

I watched both because Scarlett is there

You put this so beautifully. Thank you. ♥️

I think the series will be complete with a forth part. We rarely get to see an elderly couple portrayed in the media. I think it would be sweet to see them as little old people still in love, fully reflecting on love. Ethan Hawke said it was complete because it came full circle with the middle aged arguing couple on the train in the first one. But also on the train in the first one is an elderly couple sitting side by side quietly and contently.