very poor standard

mamma mia !!!forse cintura gialla 😅

Laughable...... sorry Even Zenku kokutsu stances not correct Kanku sho there is no jump with JKA in the end just rotate

I expect abit more for the kata. It looks like they were plodding through it. Put some effort in for god sake.

It's easy to talk about them. It's not just the technique that's evaluated, which is obviously important. Other aspects such as age and physical condition of the person taking the exam must be assessed. The important thing is the BUDO and the attitude of the person.

Танцоры

I practiced jiu kumite many years like that in another organisation. I must say, i was always unhappy with that, even after many tournaments. With aging and more experience, for me, that kind of jiu kumite is not a good idea. Because you have to control not too hurt your partner, but you have to put enough kime to mark the point, you have to touch, but not too much… and you program your body like that, and once you you need your technics, they probably won t work. I prefer now that Young people make jiu kumite like sport karate in wkf, or you do full contact karate and you put full power in your technics. But that kind of mixing of control and soft touch : bad. Do sport karate or do karate combat. In that video, the referee was bad.

beaucoup de commentaires négatifs. Ke ne suis pas pour. Je ne me permettrais pas de juger les candidats présents sur cette vidéo, ne serait-ce q par respect et courtoisie élémentaire. Je préfère les commentaires constructifs. Je voulais voir un dan test JKA, car un de mes amis ne juge q par JKA. Je m interroge plutôt sur JKA : j imagine q ils ont 3 juges principaux, vu comment ils examinent les candidats… y a t il un timing à respecter q il faille liquider 3 katas différents en même temps? Pour le kihon, ce type d enchaînement ressemble bcp à ce q on m a demandé il y a de très nombreuses années quand j ai fait mon nidan test. Et n en déplaise au maître de l Ecole ou j étais, qui ne se veut pas apparenté à JKA, son karaté était bien issu en grande partie de JKA, même si je passerais certainement pour un Hérétique chez les ultra de dire cela. Je ne sais pas quel dan est présenté la. Mais si c est au delà de nidan, je vois pas trop l idée pédagogique de ce kihon. Bref : jka me semble pas mieux, pas pire q ailleurs, n en déplaise à mon ami. Karaté non pas traditionnel, mais académique et classique. Actuellement, le karaté japonais semble un peu en perte de vitesse, et les gens s intéressent plus à du karaté Jutsu, du karaté combat, ou revenir au karaté Okinawa. Le karaté japonais au sens large (je ne parle pas de jka en particulier) a t il les capacités d effectuer une auto critique?

Ma è uno scherzo ❓ massimo 2 dan mah

All you see in comments in these Grade tests is put downs a lot of times. These people are more then likely doing there best.

You guys are lucky, you got to test in front of Koyama!

Nice :D

Everyone missed in the jyu ippon,

Dan grading and still kick like a wee girl .

Rubbish 😡😡😡

is this a joke? damn it's bad

Those kicks are appalling.

I hope I will be able to move at that age

To those that are complaining: it is really difficult to excel physically after certain age, especially if you started later in life. For older men karate means more of a struggle against your own physical limitations rather than achieving technical excellence. I believe that's what you are graded on in the JKA and similar orgs: how you deal with the limitations imposed on you by father time. Otherwise, only young people, capable of impeccable physical technique would be able to be graded above nidan.

should be more dynamic and convincing as oppossed to just going throught the motions.

When I was in my early 20's there was a older guy in my University JKA cub, mid 50's I'd say. While no one made fun of him directly there were snickers between us when he made 3rd Dan. Only now that I had reached that age I see how much more effort he had to put into everything than we did.

very very useless test and the competitors .

His sochin dachi is wrong wrong wrong. There no torque…the entire point of the stance is forward torque to 45 degre angles for grappling and multiple attackers

you too have to go back to 5th kyu,

This is actual JKA????? Their body mechanics are not so good. None of them understand stance, or movement mechanisms.

Sloppy.

Horrible !

Эх, как Шотокан деградирует...

это было что?

Bassai dai .. Não deveria está fazendo este kata. Envergonhando o karatê

When i realize how exigent they are with us in Haiti, the would't have graded even 3rd kyu!

please delete this video, this is super bad to JKA image, you both must go back and train from 8 kyu..DELETE THIS VIDEO FROM KZbin AND FROM YOUR LIFE.

Se me escapó un gas

This is a JKA exam?!? You all 3 sucks!!!

Kendo footwork is different but still poor form. I have trouble with my feet too but for black belt they should have failed

Бедный Шотокан! Во что ты превратился мой любимый Шотокан... Что это? Но не каратэ точно. Если это 3 даны, то про кю что тогда? Шотокан великая школа каратэ, но то, что на видео - к каратэ отношения не имеет.

Very bad!

Do you mean testing for 1st dan ?

Sad

I trained in the mid 80s to mid 90s. The fact that these guys are even 1st kyu is an indictment on how far the JKA standards have slipped! This is one reason why so many different factions of the JKA have broken away. ISKF, ISKA, SKIF ect. Testing is about money now, not skill. People don't pass tests, people go elsewhere. I say good riddance! All those old Okinawan masters would puke if they saw what their "te" has become....

Like Andre Bertel said these guys technique are no good. Andrea not everyone can be like you. We are the 1% .....hahahaah

Good job . You guys pass. Money for the organization . Will you be able to defend yourself on the street. Np. Call the police.

Very poor standard for sandan ,no focus, no kime and no balance,sandan I don’t think so, 3rd kyu possibley

Oh how the jka has fallen brought it on themselves

Poor technique...

JKA guys got poor standard, doing kids stuff.

Poor kata performance, they should do a retest.

Poor level !!!! No kime, no stances, no te-ashi doji.

this is not good....

io sono cintura nera come amatore schotokan posso dire che questo bassai dai e da cintura arancione i dispiace di vedere queste cose ! chiusure Zero parate fatte a caso e posizioni tutte alte così e capace chiunque