Cut the video so much

Nauman is Right here,

bro, right, the hafs version of the word "inda" becomes "ibada" in qs 43:19 does it still mean the same? because Christians accuse this verse that this verse has changed the real Qur'an

Why Allah asking non belivers dat did u saw ?... At the time of big bang no human was ther either kafir or muslim.. Then Allah asking to whom that u didnt saw... How can they saw when therr was no human existed

I don't see the problem here. This just shows 2 different interpretations of the same verse. Every religious book has had different people interpret itin different ways.

جواب : قرآن کریم نے اصحاب رسول کو مختلف قسموں میں تقسیم کیا ہے،اوراس میں کوئی فرق نہیں ہے کہ چاہے کوئی بدری ہو یا غیر بدری ،حدیبیہ سے پہلے ایمان لایا ہو یا حدیبیہ کے بعد، فتح مکہ سے پہلے مسلمانوں کے درمیان آیا ہو یا فتح مکہ کے بعد۔ لہذا ان گروہ کے اصلی چہروں کو قرآن کریم نے اس طرح ذکر کیا ہے: ۱۔ مشہور منافقین (سورہ منافقون، آیت ۱) ۔ ۲۔ دھوکہ باز اور چالاک منافق ( سورہ توبہ، آیت۱۰۱ ) ۔ ۳۔ دلوں کے مریض (سورہ احزاب، آیت۱۲ ) ۔ ۴۔ فتنہ پھیلانے والے دشمنوں کی باتیں سننے والے (سورہ توبہ ، آیت ۴۵ ۔ ۴۷) ۔ ۵۔ اچھے برے اعمال انجام دینے والے (سورہ توبہ، آیت ۱۰۲ ) ۔ ۶۔ مرتد افراد (سورہ آل عمران، آیت ۱۵۴ ) ۔ ۷۔ مومنین کے علاوہ تسیلم شدہ افراد(سورہ حجرات ، آیت ۱۴ ) ۔ ۸۔ مئولفة القلوب (سورہ توبہ، آیت۶۰) ۔ ۹۔ فاسق (سورہ حجرات، آیت ۶ ) ۔ ۱۰۔ جنگ کے وقت کفار کو پشت دیکھا کر بھاگنے والے ( سورہ انفال، آیت ۱۵۔ ۱۶ ) ۔ اصحاب رسول(صلی اللہ علیہ و آلہ وسلم) کے ان دس گروہوں کو عادل وباتقوی شمار نہیں کیا جاسکتا ،عادل اور متقین کی تعریف کرنے والی آیات بھی ان کو شامل نہیں ہیں ورنہ آیات کے مفہوم میں تناقض لازم آے گا ۔ قرآن کریم نے پیغمبر اسلام ( صلی اللہ علیہ و آلہ وسلم ) کی رحلت کے بعد ایک گروہ کے مرتد ہونے کی خبر دی ہے: ”وَ ما مُحَمَّدٌ إِلاَّ رَسُولٌ قَدْ خَلَتْ مِنْ قَبْلِہِ الرُّسُلُ اٴَ فَإِنْ ماتَ اٴَوْ قُتِلَ انْقَلَبْتُمْ عَلی اٴَعْقابِکُمْ وَ مَنْ یَنْقَلِبْ عَلی عَقِبَیْہِ فَلَنْ یَضُرَّ اللَّہَ شَیْئاً وَ سَیَجْزِی اللَّہُ الشَّاکِرینَ (۱)“ اور محمد تو صرف ایک رسول ہیں جن سے پہلے بہت سے رسول گزر چکے ہیں کیااگر وہ مر جائیں یا قتل ہو جائیں تو تم اُلٹے پیروں پلٹ جاؤ جو بھی ایسا کرے گا وہ خدا کا کوئی نقصان نہیں کرے گا اور خدا تو عنقریب شکر گزاروں کو ان کی جزا دے گا۔ اگرچہ آیت کا لہجہ ایک شرط کو بیان کررہا ہے ( اگر پیغمبر اکرم مرجایں یا قتل ہوجایں توکیا تم جاہلیت کی طرف پلٹ جاوگے ؟)اور قضیہ شرطیہ اس کے واقع ہونے پر دلالت نہیں کرتا ۔ لیکن آیت کا مضمون اس کو بیان کرتا ہے کہ پیغمبر اسلام کے اصحاب کے درمیان اس آیت کے نزول کے وقت یعنی ہجرت کے تیسرے سال جنگ احد میںکچھ ایسے افراد موجود تھے جن کی رفتار اوراعمال اس بات کی نشان دہی کرتے تھے کہ ممکن ہے رسول اسلام کی رحلت کے بعد یہ مرتد ہوجاے ، لہذا یہ کیوں کرممکن ہے کہ تمام اصحاب رسول یہاں تک کہ جنگ احد میں شرکت کرنے والوں کو برابر مان لیں ؟ چہ جائیکہ وہ لوگ جوجنگ احد کے بعد ایمان لائے یا اس کے بھی بعد ایمان لائے!۔ ا گر ان آیات کو مومنین کی مدح کرنے والی آیات کے ساتھ ملادیں تومفسرایک واضح نتیجہ تک پہنچ سکتا ہے اور وہ یہ ہے کہ رسول اسلام ( صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم) کے بعض اصحاب صالح تھے اور بعض غیر صالح۔بعض ایسے بلند مرتبہ تھے جن کی برکت سے بارش نازل ہوتی تھی ،اور بعض ایساایمان رکھتے تھے کہ جو کسی کام کا نہیں تھا (۲) ۔ _________________ ۱۔ سورہ آل عمران : ۱۴۴ ۔ ۲۔ سیمای عقائد شیعہ ، ص ۳۱۵ ۔ حوالہ جات:تاریخ انتشار: « 1401/08/08 » منسلک صفحات

But tabari mentions satanic verses and sucide incident

nouman is more concerned about what evanglicals will say while being experienced daai brother zakir naik didn't care about what nonsense people says.

Thanx for video,,I always doubt hadees al tabri,,,b.coz all things are written about prophet is totaly opposite what we read in sahi bukhari,,👍

I like tafsir al tabir.Dr.zakir naik said the truth. If anyone is saying something wrong about tafsir al tabari.first we have to see who is he?Is he a shaykh ul islam?mufti?mufti-e-azam?

Tom is a lying Islamophobe.

Zakir nayek is wrong.I respect him,but he is not right all the time.Tabari was a persian who hated Muslim Arabs for conquering persian land.So obviously he made lots of slander against Prophet Muhammad (sa).He also claim Arabs had 40,000 soldiers in Battle of Yarmuk.When Muslim Arab historian who were present in that war said Muslim army had 10-15 thousands soldiers.Tabari distorted many history.

Meanwhile the NIV calls jesus Lucifer and RSV bibles get burnt by christians

Shady: we don't know how the prophet recited Also shady: even the prophet's readings were declated shaaz Way to go 👏👏

Dr. Zakir naik won

It’s the oldest book of Hadith. Academically speaking it’s the best source for the history since it’s the oldest source of Hadith and can be proven that those Hadith weren’t made after the first 100 years of Islam. To accept any book of Hadith that was found even later over a primary source like tabari would be against the science of academics. I’m Shia so Al kafi which was compiled in a similar fashion to al tabari was from a student of whom were being is a judge to the 12th Imam. So IMO from understanding history and how to research Sunni souls go to al tabari first and Shia should go to al kafi and al tabari. No book is truly sahih except for Quran.

Nice try to mislead people, the comment section pretty much exposed this dumb argument put forth on the video title.

The Koran preceded the invention of Muhammed.

Nouman Ali Khan is a stupid person He dont know that Imam Tabri was a. mujtahid mufasir and a historian

"تاریخ الرسل و الملوک " امام طبری کی تصنیف ہے ۔۔۔۔۔۔کیا یہ معلومات درست ہیں

Lmao these guys are like a clown show 😂

Ok so i finally decided to listen to what these people who deny islamic traditional historiography actually had to say under the impression that they might have some evidence that they are misrepresenting. I am watching just about every video i can look at and not a single critic has actually offered any piece of evidence or a logical argument. All i am seeing is narcisstic opinions & rants based on wishfull guessing and prejudice. Do they really think any single muslim will take them seriously lmao

haq Allah ❤ AllahuAkbar

Very good video.

And ur bigbang theory is soon to be expired!

When you are able to understand the true meaning of that, fear! for qiyamah is near

Nobody cares what you think or what your western theories are. Sadly for you, you and your way wont even be a distant memory. But the prophet Mohammed , peace be upon him, will be the most loved man in history and the light for mankind until the day of judgement. La ilaha il Allah Mohammed rasul Allah.

kzbin.info/www/bejne/o5mxdWePoctmebs

What did he say..???? Word salad... with no dressing...

ISLAM IS FOR ALL HUMANITY Almighty Allah says: و ما ارسلناک إلا رحمة للعالمين We sent thee not,but as a mercy for the all worlds.(for all creatures). There is no question now of race or nation of a " chosen people" or the seed of Abraham or the " seed of David"; of Jew or Gentile, Arab or non--Arab, European or African, White or Coloured etc. Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) is mercy for all. To all men and women on the world without any exception. The principles universally apply. LO ! RELIGION WITH ALLAH IS ISLAM إن الدين عند الله الإسلام و من يبتغ غير الإسلام دينا فلن يقبل منه o Islam is دين الله (Way of Life given by Allah). How mankind should live in this world. It is not made by Muslim. It direct or has it's root in Qur'an and authentic حدیث (sayings of Prophet) Therefore Islamic laws are in broader intersts of all being. Islamic laws are better than any other man made laws of any country. Problem of Europe is that it does not understand / realise this fact. They think that theirs laws are better than Islamic laws. Almighty Allah says : The revelation of the Book is from Allah,the Mighty, the Wise. Lo! We have revealed the Book unto them (Mohammad) with truth; so worship Allah,making the دين (Deen) pure for Him (only). Surely pure Deen is for Allah only (Qur'an,39:1-3) Kindly make your mind clear that the the mankind is created by Almighty Allah -- the Master Creator. We have to study and research the Holy Qur'an sincerely. It is in broader interests of mankind. Follow Islam to make your life better in this world and in Hereafter. O Allah show us the right path of Islam. " The path of those whom Thou hast favoured; Not (the path) of those who earn Thine anger nor of those who go stray". (Qur'an, 1:7) DR.MOHAMMAD LAEEQUE NADVI Ph.D. (Arabic Lit.) M.A. Arabic Lit.+Islamic Studies) Director Amena Institute of Islamic Studies & Analysis A Global & Universal Institute, Donate to developee this Institute SBI A/C30029616117 Kolkata,Park Circus Branch [email protected] Thanks

Uthman, the collector of the Quran according to Islamic sources, kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4ncgYmwmbKbaqc

Uthman, the collector of the Quran according to Islamic sources, kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4ncgYmwmbKbaqc

Uthman, the collector of the Quran according to Islamic sources, kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4ncgYmwmbKbaqc

Uthman, the collector of the Quran according to Islam, kzbin.info/www/bejne/p4ncgYmwmbKbaqc

Regarding the big bang theory, I heard from Muslim scholars that we cannot use this theory to prove God, because this theory claims to explain the beginning of time and place and that before it, there is no time and no place. And this means this theory is false. If we say that the big bang theory proves God, then we would be saying Allah is out of time and that He is in no place. But we know that Allah was there before the universe was created. Allah is eternal, meaning there was no moment in time where Allah was not there. Same with place, Allah is the most High, He is in a place high above His creation. So this theory actually makes God non-existent. Dear brothers, Allah said this about the creation of the universe: ‎﴿ما أَشهَدتُهُم خَلقَ السَّماواتِ وَالأَرضِ وَلا خَلقَ أَنفُسِهِم وَما كُنتُ مُتَّخِذَ المُضِلّينَ عَضُدًا﴾ [الكهف: ٥١] ‎‏I did not make them witness to the creation of the heavens and the earth or to the creation of themselves, and I would not have taken the misguiders as assistants. ‎‏- Saheeh International So the event of the “creation of the universe” is a singular event that no man has ever witnessed. Thus this event is not part of science, it is part of the unseen or the “Ghaib”. And Allah knows best.

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXnYgYl3q6egbpo learning from other

Please correct yourself sheikh nouman ali khan was saying that we will have people(non believers) saying things about Imam tabri to proverb is from accepting his tafsir

Super important, and that’s only qiraat, but adding this to the hundreds of mistranslations and made up story’s in the Quran and Ahadith it’s one crack more into Islamic myths of preservation.... oh ja and this guy is often loved by Muslims for his bibel criticism man I mean criticism of Allahs word.

mashallah dr zakir

mashallah dr zakir

good talk

Zakir naik talking about tafsir at tabar and nouman ali khan talkin about history of tabari.

If any of you guy's who dont believe in God... were given a conscious in your mothers womb and told before you were born, that you have a mother who gives you food through the umbilical cord, and that one day you would see her and she would give you milk from her breast and that you would grow teeth and see the sun and trees and animals... I'm sure you wouldn't have believed. You would have been arrogant just as you are now.

Great

this proves that the Quran is legitimate even more this is a proof thank you for the video didn't know this before my iman is strengthened

MachAllah Allahakbar que dieu benisse les muslim et non muslim que Allah ouvre les coeur

You who made this video... Enjoy ur meaningless existence.

Okie doke

Stay away from Isalm

NAK WON...!