Thank you for this, I want to read this book again because your really interesting explanation.
@georgeschlaline60572 ай бұрын
DID ANYBODY NOTE ? THAT I'M GOING TO BED?
@suzannewhite7582 ай бұрын
This says it all: Loyola. card Bernadin, common cause, Bishop Stowe
@thegeneral70434 ай бұрын
Catholic Academia has lost its mind. Chardin's theories were proven wrong, and let's take them to their 'naturally selective' end....it would totally contradict the reason for the Incarnation and Original Sin! And a "SAINT???" Go read what Pope Pius XII said about your "Saint"!?? Unbelievable.
@shinseiki2015Ай бұрын
which theory ?
@thegeneral7043Ай бұрын
@@shinseiki2015 Since I'm sure you think I dont know, his entire adoption of Darwinian Evolution as fact, and trying to marry religion to that understanding. He stated that the human species emerged from matter and spirit. At that beginning of "concsiousness", he calls the start of "true religion". He believed there's no such thing as pure matter and pure spirit. What he called, "The Omega Point" in history will happen when Christ appears and unites everyone to make them a "Ultra Human." He says we're still in that development stage, still evolving, until "Christ" finishes the "evolution" of man. This obviously contradicts Roman Catholic Church teachings on Creation, Original Sin, Redemptive suffering of Jesus, Sacramental System, the Sacrifice of the Mas, etc., etc. If you believe that man "EVOLVED" from a primitive species through gradual changes over billions of years, you would have to reject or greatly transform ALL of Divine Revelation. His theories were censored by Church authorities in his day, rightfully so,, even by Saint John XXIII, the "progressive" Pope. For some reason, boomer priests are bringing back his writings and trying to adopt them as a new "cosmology". Unbelievable, but in today's Church I'm not surprised.
What a wonderful talk; thank you so much for sharing your story, and to the Hank Center for making it available to us. Blessings!
@jasonwblakely5 ай бұрын
Thanks to the Hank Center for the invite and for posting
@NicholasKalinosky-nc4lo10 ай бұрын
Dr Viviano is one of my personal heroes, and once I move on more from the Psalms, I look forward to exploring more of her work on Jeremiah & Baruch. (I’m still in straightening out Hebrew vs Greek Jeremiah mode for my own prayer-cycle purposes). She definitely comes to mind every time I translate portions of Psalm 119/118 as “vivify me” (based on Latin, and sometimes for past tense I use “have enlivened me”) There are always things I agree and disagree with: haven’t finished watching, because there’s a lot of “it’s not” type stuff: Hebrew & Greek are not substance gets annihilated for substantiation to occur type stuff. (That is, 😊 I think translating languages is more like con-substantiation type stuff, or at least overlap-substantiation type stuff) There is overlap. Soul *is* neck. Soul is breathing heartbeat, etc. But the Jews knew you use your brain to think.. Psalms are called “wisdom literature” for a reason. (that is, they *are* philosophical - maybe not with a Greek *fronima,* but about loving the type of knowledge that comes from hearing God’s Word type stuff.) Aristotle looked at psee -hee (there is no such thing as sigh-key to Greeks) much like what she is saying about neck. But for Aristotle, plants (“leaf” stuff) has a “soul” in that sense too, but, the intellectual faculty that *distinguishes* human souls from the souls of plants and animals for Aristotle is the νοῦς (νοῦς), because the basic pulsing, breathing (blood, breath type stuff) is present in all three. And good ol’ BEF, what would he say about all these ancient cultures? It’s not just Jews & Greeks - way, way further: Head, Heart, Gut. She gave you all three parts. But the eye breathes and feels too. Yes the heart thinks, but it pumps & feels, and your “gut feeling” can be a kind of “thinking,” and your guts pump and “breathe” too.. Your seeing/thinking, pumping/breathing, emotive/hungering parts, all have some of each other within them. (Thus, I think that’s why some people are fascinated by the spin the Apocryphal Gospel of Judas has about “no eye of an angel” in comparison/contrast with St Paul’s “no eye has seen”) Personhood - *emergence* (just emergence as a topic at all even) - awesome!🙂
@richardloostburg263711 ай бұрын
Smash the papacy
@MrGobluebilly Жыл бұрын
Great presentation. Thank you.
@1330m Жыл бұрын
Caputo's theology can serve as a stepping stone to the theology of Huh kyung young and Rael .
@1330m Жыл бұрын
so good Altizer is truly a great theologian. He looks like Nietzsche before death. 2023 Huh kyung young Eternal milk Kerygma 1st century Israel = 21st century Korea . You have to know that . Amazing historical events are taking place there . Longitude 127 Seoul Okinawa Soul Axis -- Bahai Faith Rael Jesus Huh kyung young Magnificent aletheia .
@paulmitchell2916 Жыл бұрын
Waaaay too wordy.. this is KZbin, not an academic colloquium, so skip the further ado and get to the material your title promises. Edit, edit, edit! I'd really love to see gen Zers exposed to this thought, so I urge you to look at some of the philosophy channels that have a large subscriber base and imitate them.
@margaretmiros1672 Жыл бұрын
I am a 77 year old privileged white woman and really appreciated this presentation. I pray that in the time remaining in my life that I may make good use of what I learned tonight from Dr. Brecht and the inspiring comments from the students who showed up. I plan to share this video when our racial healing group meets on Friday, April 28th 2023! Thank you for your courageous work Dr.Brecht and YES, it's the laity's turn.
@ivtch51 Жыл бұрын
Amazing, insightful, brilliant! Thx. As an agnostic-atheist ex-Catholic he makes sense.
@jakealtman-desole8642 Жыл бұрын
The audio quality on this is recording is quite low, FYI.
@inespinto1613 Жыл бұрын
The sound is very weak. Can we have access to the conference in a written format? It would be great, thank you.
@andresmg Жыл бұрын
You would imagine that some who claimes to have researched Latin American culture would at least know how incredibly disrespectful and condescending the term "Latinx" is.
@josesutil7137 Жыл бұрын
Is it possible to have access to the conference in a written format?
@velkyn1 Жыл бұрын
oh dear, Pascal's wager again? a lovely bit of nonsense that requires a god that is either so stupid or greedy to accep t people who believe "just in case", and a lie that says you won't lose anything if you choose wrongly. You lose time and resources.
@dsnyguy1 Жыл бұрын
Wonderful!
@jokiklos7009 Жыл бұрын
Jesus Christ personally showed me through his holy spirit that there's simply no signs out there that match up with anything that is written in the Bible
What a powerful sharing! Robert Ellsberg reveals the depth of his understanding of Dorothy Day’s life and meaning for the ages. It is such a privilege to have listened to this grace filled sharing. Thank you. Sister Glenda Bourgeois, O S U
@jjcm31352 жыл бұрын
That's the theory; its practice is called carrying your academic cross. Catholic academics need the grounding of the practical experts who are the saints. People like St John Bosco.
@SuperIliad2 жыл бұрын
I cannot think of a single major Catholic University that has not been compromised by modernism, assignations with the Zeitgeist, autonomy, and heresy. There are still some de fide colleges that remain free from such harmful toxins.
@stephenbastasch78932 жыл бұрын
Edward Isaac Leibowitz is *not* imaginary at all. Like most other founders, legendary material has accrued to the genuinely historical figure. Obviously he was not legendary, since the book *begins* with an authentic discovery of his genuine papers and belongings. The lady has gotten it wrong.
@tahoeperfectworkout16512 жыл бұрын
Dr Ann your right on point ! This is so critical to have dialogues on a mass level ! I’m so interested in these ethical questions! It appears woman are taking a more serious look T this on a day to day level ! Yes! Thank you Ann !
@rudejude10002 жыл бұрын
A lot of Midwest Catholics are ignorant, it’s gone way to far right in a lot of churches and it’s disgusting.
@richard_d_bird3 жыл бұрын
i first read this book when i was kid, probably 40 years ago or more. it grabbed me right away, with the bumbling brother francis, the enigmatic pilgrim (who reappears throughout the rest of the book, validating his claim to be the risen lazerus, doomed to wander the earth until christ's return), and the whole premise in general. what really first impressed me though, was miller's depiction of the great simplification. it reminded me of the final battle in mark twain's " a connecticut yankee in king arthur's court." there were differences of course- mark twain abhorred the christian religion, and when his peasants revolted against technical progress, and threw over their great boss in favor of the church's Interdict, twain was making the church into the villain, the face of populist anti intellectual, willful ignorance and atavism. in miller's book the church is the last sanctuary of learning in the long dark age brought about by such a mob movement, and the movement itself, ironically, was inspired, not by religion, but by the atomic war that higher learning itself made possible. but the common factor in both cases was the popular stampede, by the people in general, against all reason in general. this impressed me, in both books, because it struck me that both authors weren't just making this up to shock their readers- they were saying something they really believed about the nature of human race. and i found that given what little i'd seen of the society around me, it rang way too true for comfort, even then. nowadays, of course, i can hardly watch the news at all, without being reminded of this on a daily basis. anyway, great book, thanks for covering it
@drstone11673 жыл бұрын
Remember Cardinal Tobin if you do the work of Satan 👹 a special place in Hell will be waiting for you for all eternity.
@MDBowron3 жыл бұрын
as a final post, there is also another video about cyclical history, using the models provided by the Chinese Dynastic cycles, which even though it had the cyclical rising and falling of empires, the history of such dynasties was recorded also by monks in the monastaries which followed Buddhism, which is similar to Christianity in the saviour/christ-like figure of Buddha, and the video supports how something like the monastic system in general like mutual-aid societies today, can be like an anchor of saving and rebuilding society much like the Christian monastic orders in the West. I can give a link to the video if you'd like.
@MDBowron3 жыл бұрын
another thing I liked about A Canticle for Leibowitz was that it reminded me of the cyclical history in the film "mother!" by Darren Aronofsky. The apocalypse before the beginning and at the end is like the Book of Revelation, but also in ways a re-happening of the collapse of Rome. Fiat Homo in ways represents the premodern/feudal society of religious ideas, the dark ages, oral storytelling, bows and arrows, written manuscripts, spirituality and religious belief, which could represent the first third of human history up until the 1400s AD/CE. It can also represent the wandering Jews expelled from eden, but also living in what could be considered a more closer to eden or nature way of living, the desert being also representative of the wilderness outside of Eden, and the journey through the Exodus, and thus the book of Genesis or the Old Testament and thus the beginning books of the Bible. Fiat Lux in ways represents the modern/capitalist society of scientific ideas, the renaissance, printing presses, gunpowder and iron swords, secular science and humanism, which represents history from 1400AD/CE until around 1900AD/CE. It can also represent the creation of city-states like Egypt, Babylon, Rome and Europe, which represent the middle of the Bible, where religion was fighting against secular philosophy and scientific ideas, in both Ancient Greece/Rome and Europe. Fiat Voluntas Tua in ways represents the postmodern/pluralistic or deconstructions of religious/premodern and scientific/modern belief systems, which may seem a belief in chaotic ideas or meaninglessness in the form of existentialism, which emerged after World War 2 and with ideas like Socialism/Communism, nuclear weapons, the present day era from 1900 AD/CE onwards. It can also represent the modern day or future megalopolises or global groups like superpowers in the present day, the Atlantic Confederacy being either NATO or European Union or modern day America, and the Asian Coalition being either the USSR or Russia and China today. It therefore represents the wars and rumours of wars in the Book of Revelation, the end books of the Bible, followed by the Apocalypse, but also a transcendence of the cyclical history of the Bible, and an ascension into Heaven/Paradise. Why I mention cyclical history, the opening passages in Genesis may read that instead of the earth being "formless and void" it was "a waste and desolation" meaning a world that had gone through an apocalypse, and that God creating heaven and earth in the beginning of Genesis was a repeat of the New Heaven and New Earth at the end of the Book of Revelation, which is also the basis for the cyclical history in the film 'mother!'. Sorry for the overlong post, but I just find these ideas as fascinating. I hope they are of interest to some of you here today. Peace and godbless.
@MDBowron3 жыл бұрын
I wonder what you'd think of the film The Terminator, as its basically a retelling of the Book of Revelation, and The Nativity Story, with John Connor being Jesus Christ fighting against Skynet, which represents Satan or the Antichrist in a future post-apocalyptic war after a nuclear holocaust called Judgement Day. Sarah Connor, played by Linda Hamilton, in 1984 (the date, not the novel or film) is basically Mary, and Kyle Reese, played by Michael Biehn, who is a soldier sent back in time to protect her (and spoilers... father John), is like a mixture of the Angel of Prophecy of the Messiah, and Joseph. The Terminator, played by Arnold Schwartzenegger, is like the soldiers of King Herod, trying to kill the Messiah before he is born. Although it combines the ideas of Horror, Time-Travel, Science Fiction, War, Post-Apocalypse, Action, Thriller, Crime/Police Procedural, and oddly enough Romance, I find it an interesting take on theological concepts, and the idea of there both being Predestination, in not just the religious sense but the science fiction idea of a Predestination Paradox, and yet still promoting the ideas of faith and free will, and the ability to control our fate. It is also reminiscent in the time travel of the recent film Tenet, where it emphasizes that even though history shows that certain plans, like in Tenet, the idea of someone destroying the world, doesn't happen, there still needs to be the effort by humanity to do the work and action to ensure it doesn't happen, even though historically speaking the evidence is there that it didn't happen. It's like one has to take faith in oneself and also faith in not only the future or past, but the present, and how the present of action is most important for both the past and the future to continue to exist.
@SdaCosta223 жыл бұрын
Please no lay people in the church authority
@ranonedy81633 жыл бұрын
GOD bless you, Cardinal Tobin.....
@drstone11673 жыл бұрын
Remember Cardinal Tobin if you do the work of Satan 👹 a special place in Hell will be waiting for you for all eternity.
@Jim5150jvc3 жыл бұрын
Good talk; thank you Rebecca.
@andrewj.diliddojr73403 жыл бұрын
Reading now the only volume of Liebowitz in the library system of the state if Ohio. It’s a very old volume very worn and I will request a new purchase. I know this was a cult classic in the 1970’s.
@nathanketsdever31503 жыл бұрын
For what it's worth, the sound gets better at 7 minutes.
@alphamail4343 жыл бұрын
Bravo !
@andrewj.diliddojr73403 жыл бұрын
This was a wonderful program. I am here reviewing again to flesh out my handwritten notes as chatted with Kathleen McNutt I discussed with Kathleen on chat that the content was so rich it was hard to absorb it all at one sitting so here I am. I liked Michael's comment about Mansfield Park. I cannot afford to buy a lot of books but I like hearing references to them and references to authors and editors like Katy Carl.
@Akkad1003 жыл бұрын
What a pompous gasbag.
@andrearaila94833 жыл бұрын
Remarkable woman, Catholic, writer, and spiritual thinker Jessica Mesman I missed seeing this live.
@jonroyyubeleno5323 жыл бұрын
Why is it so hard for women to exist/live/thrive in America? What is the great divide between males and females in this nearly authoritarian/Marxist country? What is patriarchalism in the Marxist stream of thought? How does it differ from the current liberalism/progressivism that is the regnant philosophy in the American landscape? By the way, I am a Filipino Catholic.
@colorizedenhanced-silentmo53213 жыл бұрын
How are ya, Hank Center for the Catholic Intellectual Heritage. actually quite video. thank. :)