I am interested in CSLewis concept of "second friendship" laid out in Surprised by Joy" Understand the Lewis is mainly thinking of his friend Owen Barfield as a significant "second friend". Would like to learn more about these two as Friends
@thesoultransferprotocol7216 ай бұрын
Ive watched this 7 times now and am still amazed at the idiocy, this left wing agent of Sauron tried to disrupt Malcolm on his pronunciation, during this epic lecture.
@claudette41136 ай бұрын
Wonderful
@julialuminasalsa7 ай бұрын
big fan of this man, that was incredible to listen to!
@normancloss26589 ай бұрын
😂
@rob162489 ай бұрын
This is how religions get started
@Cosper7910 ай бұрын
Just yesterday, YT for some reason put Malcolm on my feed and I was immediately impressed and now this gem as popped up.
@madaxe60610 ай бұрын
Same!
@AdianGess10 ай бұрын
Ditto, just what I needed, my primary sixth year teacher used to read the hobbit every Friday to the class, he was a crofter and used to take us on wildlife walks. Wish school was like that now for my kids. Malcome is a treasure.
@superkool78 ай бұрын
Dude. Same. Ha!
@brendanmcelroy5790 Жыл бұрын
"Lowgos not Logos" -handled beautifully. Image interrupting Malcolm Guite in full flow to correct his pronunciation. A left hemisphere interloper brushed aside by a fully rounded right hemisphere savant .
@b.melakailАй бұрын
It would be cool for Malcolm to talk with Iain Mcgilchrist
@19battlehill Жыл бұрын
Great Talk ---- Rudolf Steiner in one of his lectures says same things as Barfield. Steiner --- Even if the Gospels never existed you would still through your consciousness be able to come to the same conclusions, just by using your interllect. Steiner compares it to Geometry -One can understand mathematics out of one’s own intellectual forces and the laws of space without referring to Euclid’s geometry book.
@nathanfrazermusic Жыл бұрын
We need more clergy like Malcolm!
@DeniseSacks-uh4kw Жыл бұрын
Love Guite’s work and expression except for being so down on Steiner and Anthroposophy - what’s that about?
@DrFranklynAnderson Жыл бұрын
8:43 Oh wow, that puts The Screwtape Letters in a whole new light.
@anthonyhulse1248 Жыл бұрын
Euchatastrophe -> Eucharist
@anthonyhulse1248 Жыл бұрын
Around the 35th minute: great insight that quest stories were about finding, winning, gaining something that makes one’s life better. In LOTR it’s all about giving up, throwing away and destroying something harmful, though at great personal cost.
@nicolamills1943 Жыл бұрын
I only found these videos around four years ago and since then I’ve come back to them many times. Each time I find something new, often startling, for reflection and learning. Thank you.
@AngiefromthesparklingRiver Жыл бұрын
He says so many things I've already felt but couldn't put into words.
@jamesmarsh1212 Жыл бұрын
Enjoy your videos! Love the fact that you prefer Peterson Pipes! Bought my first Peterson from Benaderets Pipe Shoppe in S.F.when i was 16 years old! An L 309 System Special which im smoking as i text you! Have many,many more...im 73 and up to my 50th Peterson! Thanks for the videos...Sincerely Jim Marsh Alameda Calif USA
@mauijttewaal2 жыл бұрын
Charles Williams is a very inspirational writer
@kenbranaugh82512 жыл бұрын
He's right about the body. Quite.
@markballantyne3932 жыл бұрын
The light of reason existed before language, obviously we have lost it ,we prefer the sound of or own voice,and thats all rubbish.
@risin49492 жыл бұрын
13:22 "Nearly all that I loved I believed to be imaginary, nearly all I believed to be real I thought grim". Wow, been there. Thank you C.S, Lewis.
@hansnyman95462 жыл бұрын
1.04.37-52 wow!
@James-xr9pe3 жыл бұрын
48:40 Imagine trying to correct this mans pronunciation, immediately shut down haha
@nickmuzekari61243 жыл бұрын
14:41 "and all quantity and fact is in the objective and is what is really there but contains ... ?" what did he say at the end of that sentence? It was hard to hear it.
@nickmuzekari61243 жыл бұрын
Loving this ... and I think it's kind of cool that Malcom looks like a Dwarf :)
@MortenBendiksen3 жыл бұрын
Very helpful talk, thank you. Night Operation sounds like a description of current affairs, except we're all just sitting indoors in stead of underground, afraid of life and each other, scared of some invisible microbes, clinging to our physical lives as we destroy actual life, and forgetting the most important light in life, each other, our faces, smiles, and wondering if these things really are as important to us or even as nice as the stories say.
@jonathanpowers25633 жыл бұрын
Myth becomes endlessly generative .....
@OldGreyMare4 жыл бұрын
Joseph Campbell's assertion to Bill Moyer, that myths don't give a "meaning" of life, but an "experience of life."
@라오산타4 жыл бұрын
감동입니다!
@irishgoldstacker80184 жыл бұрын
I've subbed your channel but the sound and lighting in this video wasn't great. It was a good talk though.
@annymaytiedye20554 жыл бұрын
John is My favorite too Love you Malcolm Love john Love Jesus Love the Word made flesh
@tracy4aminute3764 жыл бұрын
Enjoying this depth but what in the world is that infernal clicking 37.40?
@questioneverything552 жыл бұрын
I know, it made it to where I could not continue listening on my headphones - brutal.
@kenbranaugh82512 жыл бұрын
Probably some recording device , reel to reel perhaps
@carolinafine80505 жыл бұрын
What a speech. Beautiful
@rej53285 жыл бұрын
이 버전 드디어 올라왔군요 ㅎ 음원 저도 있답니다 ㅎ
@binra37885 жыл бұрын
The grasp of possession and control might be seen as an identity theft in terms of gaining a world and losing awareness of Soul. As in a modern 'phishing attack' we take the form as the meaning and run with it - perhaps first as if discovering something precious and special to a sense of self imaged and then as the pain and rage of violation and loss of what we took to be ourself and world. Pride comes before a fall. There are so many things to consider saying and sharing into a willingness to travel with Barfield in a purpose or restoring the freedom to feel and know our being - and through that to extend TO our relationships and world instead of being framed by it as a sense of lack that seeks to get FROM it. But truth is written on our heart - inviolate and this is witnessed in any moment of a true recognition, appreciation and gratitude. Why do we so immediately forget? Because that is the purpose given the mind that makes a world for getting. Learning to trust again - or rather learning to be truly discerning as to where we are extending trust - is seeing in the heart and not just in the mind-mapped meanings that must now serve the heart's decision. the mind cannot make a decision - excepting to elicit sympathies or fears such as to maintain a belief the heart is weak and fickle. It is never love we fear - but only what we have made of love. I have opened or been opened in many different perspectives on the nature of our condition and all of them serve to witness the truth of love - which is not what we think - but lives! Owen Barfield's work comes in as if another fitting piece of a puzzle that was never broken. Now does our resonance and alighting in any revealing truth move us to accept it by embodiment in act? The inhibition of love and fear of harm and harming as equally threats to a sense of possession and control effectively co-fuses them both. Coming out as yourself is the unwillingness to hide the light and not any kind of demand for recognition. But yet there are truths that may seem dangerous to a world predicated on an adulterated derivative currency of dead words. No matter what meanings we discern from our sources of inspiration, they always yield more depth after willingness of practice. I also feel that like a community bus service, we do not move to where we think we are going for long - because we are intended to meander in such a way as to allow everyone else to alight. Honouring Barfield's work is keeping its wonder, enquiry and devotion alive in each our own light. Lest we become moths that cover the original with mere association at a distance. Alienation is a substitution for love by a distanced association - however personified or schematised. I might say all the same about Jesus - not to confuse unique individualities but to discern shared Purpose as one regardless the forms it takes or comes in. If God's Purpose is One then nothing else can be going on except we are given freedom to experience along the line or our own creation - or else there would be no freedom, sharing and transcendent recognition in which to 'behold and see that it is Good! Waking to the word we are accepting by giving it and therefore teaching ourselves and others - according to their freedom to learn - is to determine no longer to run as one who knows not what they do - as a result of mostly internalised fragmenting self-conflicts that deny us any free awareness to actually see. Which is the device the mind invokes by which to seem to not know - as a result of be-living to already know something else.
@binra37885 жыл бұрын
By the way - I hold that the temporary nature of the 'miracle' of awareness as true appreciation is our framing after the Fact and not IN the changing forms of an electromagnetic world. It is true that experience is only possible through some sense of differentiation, but knowing in the truly Biblical sense is both direct and formless. There is no conflict in the Timeless - and the Timeless is masked by the the mind of space (not here) and time (not now). The Call to peace may be more aligning for us, than focusing overmuch of what to call the Timeless. But the gift of such an instant (that is not quantifiable to the time it seems to take) is a mind renewed - according to our readiness and willingness to receive and share in. And so the same immeasurable love is no less in the moment of stillness that reconnects one in need to their heart's connection and decision in their next practical step within a challenging circumstance; than to another whose release of an ancient hate allows a rise into a glory beyond any capacity to think on. Indeed thinking on what just happened frames it and us in the past - and separates us from our love such that we then look for it 'again' in time... But love is never again but always anew. Letting truth abide in us, will in small ways at first, stir in us as thought from a different quality of our being. For such is truly shared. I see this as our Christ Child. It doesn't need hiding for shame, but holding in the heart's knowing for protection from the mind of lack. Moving with the movement is learning to Feel, better, as willingness to move with the living and neither in front or behind. When we are out of our centre, our timing, our grounding we find dissonance as wanting to feel better, because what we ARE feeling is judged bad and we seek to get rid of it in ways that hide rather than heal. Underneath all experience is the word or meanings we are giving. To see all that we are missing is to miss what is truly here with us now. Such is the power of the mind in focus! I see another term for a lifetime could be a focus within the Soul. The idea that Mind can and does create a whole Universe is not at all strange once we change our mind about our mind. This begins with noticing our thoughts and reactions and re-associating them with outcomes or experience but from the desire for wholeness rather than adding even more burden of setting ourself up to fail.
@marieconstant64525 жыл бұрын
HI JACKET ON BUSH ? A HI JACKET FULL OF MORALITIES DIGNITIES?RESPECT HEYHEY THAT FORKER ON GACY ROOM 200 TRAYING THAT BOY JACKET NO ONE'S CANT GET THAT HI JACKET ON BUSH TO SMALL BUSH STEALLING THE MONEYS. REVELATION
@billwilkie62115 жыл бұрын
I’ve watched this 4 times, and will again...
@mkkim34055 жыл бұрын
이 어둔 길을 걷는 동안 그대 놓지 말아야 할 등불 있죠 비록 희미하여 저 멀리 볼 수 없다 해도 한 걸음 또 한걸음 그곳에 더 가까이 거칠은 폭풍우 지나는 동안 우린 자라나고 또 하나가 됐죠 간절한 믿음은 이미 그곳에 먼저 닿아 소망의 닻 내리죠 내 눈에 아무 증거 보이지 않아도 내 귀에 아무 소리 들리지 않아도 주의 부르심에 소망을 따라 그 깊으신 뜻 함께 이뤄가리
@T.R.R.Jolkien6 жыл бұрын
If this gentleman didn’t have hands, I wouldn’t of understood his message like I did... 🙂. Trump 2020 🇺🇸
@BooksForever9 ай бұрын
Daft.
@naterolboy6 жыл бұрын
I cannot believe the woman who corrects his pronunciation of "logos" at 48:42, and then keeps interrupting throughout. Malcolm Guite is a gracious and insightful man. This is a wonderful lecture.
@nickmuzekari61243 жыл бұрын
Yeah that was completely unexpected. Not sure what she was thinking, was quite rude and arrogant.
@singfree882 жыл бұрын
Cringeworthy. Yet I appreciate the opportunity it gave Guite to comment further on society’s diminishing of the logos into consumer brands - logo.
@bigdavek.83228 ай бұрын
If the lady in question was so adamant on correcting Malcolm's pronunciation and his take on words, the least she could have done was speak to him privately after the lecture.
@not_a_frog5 ай бұрын
@@nickmuzekari6124 agreed that it was unpleasant but always worth considering that she may be on the spectrum and unaware of the social situation she's in. either way he handled the interruptions like a consummate professional! very impressed.
@이름없음레인걸7 жыл бұрын
노래가 참 감동스럽네용ㅎㅎ
@robertjohnston50117 жыл бұрын
How unfortunate, that what should have been a talk on Charles Williams, is hijacked by a primitive-level, "Sunday morning feel-good speech" for the comatose tea-party set that uses phrases and ideas, the standard religion cult's politically astute vapid allegories and the requisite obliteration of all reality, meaning, experience, responsibility, self-respect and consciousness, needed to attend as a "believer" in elfish twaddle. I just kept thinking, "where did the talk on Williams go?"
@kensears50996 жыл бұрын
Only the shallowest and most prejudiced mind could consider a discussion of the things Charles Williams cared about and believed in most passionately and explored most fervently in his writings, to be a discussion that has nothing to do with Charles Williams. Most self-revealing, Robert.... Perhaps you've never even read Williams and, so, can't possibly understand the connections between this lecture and Williams. And perhaps, inasmuch as you are clearly viscerally antagonistic to the Christian faith, if you did actually know what Williams wrote about, you'd discover you have no interest in the least in listening to a "talk on Williams".
@melindalemmon21494 жыл бұрын
The lecture was as promised; a look at Williams and the Inklings. It was very well done.
@melindalemmon21494 жыл бұрын
You sound like the villians in Lewis' Space Trilogy.
@alyoshaproductions7 жыл бұрын
I feel like I'm eavesdropping on a subversive club meeting discussing the club's forefathers. I want to join this club.
@rcwilcox17 жыл бұрын
thank you!
@tbayley67 жыл бұрын
Thank you. I found the examples of 'pneuma' and Odin's bargain very useful. Regarding how the analytical blindness can be understood in a positive way and transcended, I don't see that the pursuit of meaningful separate personhood is so helpful. It seems to me to involve another search, reminiscent of the same drive that led Odin to his roots and blinded him. Meaning is transient anyway, Barfield points out it is a product of change. So perhaps the true lesson of modernity is that the demand for temporal meaning, including separate personhood, doesn't actually lead anywhere. Thus Christ does not seek to preempt the Father's revelation, he waits on it. And he does nothing on his own behalf.
@RonnieLimestone4 жыл бұрын
Great comment, and thank you. I''m confused on your point of Odin's bargain. Odin lost an eye, but wasn't blinded, and is said to have gained wisdom. Just wondering what your angle was, but I am responding from two years after, so I understand if you are not in the same headspace.
@tbayley64 жыл бұрын
@@RonnieLimestone Did Christ make any similar bargains? He did not grasp (or crave, to use buddhist terminology) the way Odin did, or the way Adam and Eve did in the garden of Eden. It's foundational that Christ rejected Satan's lures in the desert, for instance. In this sense Odin was already blind, but I am also (like Guite) seeing his bargain as an allegory for the loss of integrated vision that has come with the ascendancy of reductionist knowledge. On the other hand, Christ's story hints that the integrated vision is not something that needs to be acquired - it's already fully present, just obscured by the grasping demands for knowledge, power, separate selfhood etc.