Jacques Le Goff : l'homme public
1:31:54
Jacques Le Goff : le médiéviste
1:26:20
Пікірлер
@thepatriarchy819
@thepatriarchy819 11 сағат бұрын
I want to say as an Italian, Russian is very under-rated.
@JaouiTomo-dp3tq
@JaouiTomo-dp3tq 12 сағат бұрын
Loom over= cernirse sobre. Este capullo no más quiere hacer la pelota a los anglos. Con sólo los diminutivos, aumentativos, despectivos, y de cariño, ya les vamos sobrando media carretera. ( Ejemplo: perro, perrito, perrazo, perrucho, perrín, perraco...). Y es sólo una palabra, así que...
@lebannen6056
@lebannen6056 13 сағат бұрын
I can guarantee you that Italian has all those terms and allows for far more complex phrasing
@gluehfunke1547
@gluehfunke1547 17 сағат бұрын
I think every language has features that are more and less precise than in others. For example, Chinese speakers might sound like cavemen in English if they don’t fully understand how verb tense works, but English speakers sound just as silly in Chinese when don’t grasp verb aspect. Same thing with European plurals vs East Asian counters.
@fercaism
@fercaism 17 сағат бұрын
Inglés no tiene subjuntivo ni imperativo ni condicional papá qué decis!! Ni siquiera hay USTEDES en inglés tampoco hay ser ni estar! En qué mundo vivias Borges!!
@fercaism
@fercaism 17 сағат бұрын
I’m a Spanish teacher and I disagree with Borges.. English is wonderful and has a mixture of both Saxon and Latin sure but he never wrote in English nor lived “in English” I think he had an unrealistic idea about how this language is. English unfortunately is too literal. When you forget your server’s name at a restaurant what do you call him? In Spanish, amigo, socio, cuate. In English you have to really work around it with a “Sorry” because even if you say “buddy or friend” they might look at you weird. English is just too literal for the clown world we live in.
@fgdj2000
@fgdj2000 19 сағат бұрын
As a non-native English speaker, I agree. It's such an expressive and varied language. It's a language of synonyms and you can say essentially the same thing in different ways (or utter fundamentally the same phrases in a variety of manners, blurt identical stuff out in a lotta ways - see what I did there 😅). I sometimes even find myself getting the English translation of a foreign book, rather than my native language. 😅
@ricardomiranda5228
@ricardomiranda5228 Күн бұрын
Okay, but why does fridge have a d and refrigerator doesn't?
@WilliamFord972
@WilliamFord972 Күн бұрын
This is a fascinating take, although español is sexy.
@brookelawrence9124
@brookelawrence9124 Күн бұрын
I’m a native English speaker who’s learning Spanish and has reached a pretty solid intermediate level. I’d always heard over and over that learning Spanish would open up a whole other beautiful world of speaking, but I’ve actually found myself wishing that I could more easily convey things like what he’d mentioned in Spanish a lot easier. When I use a translator, the phrases just don’t quite hit the same. I didn’t expect it at all. I keep thinking it’s probably just because I haven’t learned how to say them in the language yet, but I’ve found many translations to be too simple and not quite nuanced enough
@aadityaojha6843
@aadityaojha6843 Күн бұрын
If only the guy Ever got to learn hindi
@eric.batdorff
@eric.batdorff Күн бұрын
I love this comment section, it seems like a great community full of people with insightful responses. Thank you everyone!
@OneWayToPeaceOrthodoxy
@OneWayToPeaceOrthodoxy Күн бұрын
Somebody show this to all the French snobs that insult English.
@phemstros
@phemstros Күн бұрын
Great to hear this - teachers in the UK have said for years that it was a class thing because if the Normans. NO! The Romans were there before and what stays true is words stay alive for their particular meaning.
@dbwrc
@dbwrc Күн бұрын
Fascinating
@CarlosValenzuela-sx9xb
@CarlosValenzuela-sx9xb 2 күн бұрын
You can't say "no ni na" in english.
@favilarolandboor89
@favilarolandboor89 2 күн бұрын
El idioma inglés es muy bueno para fábular, tergiversar, manipular y escribir mentiras: Leyendas Negras, Inquisiciones, etc....
@renixmar3373
@renixmar3373 2 күн бұрын
Borges was a sellout
@richardwu8371
@richardwu8371 2 күн бұрын
I love that diction part about English, and how you can dance and weave with connotation and meaning with the shear amount of different words that convey an idea, and especially with that grammatical flexibility as well. It's like painting with language.
@amjan
@amjan 2 күн бұрын
Pathetic, dumb, ignorant and arrogant English imperialist. He knows nothing and pretends to know everything.
@christophermccutcheon2143
@christophermccutcheon2143 2 күн бұрын
The last part is actually really important if you're learning another language... You can't just speak how we speak in English in another language. Like if you wanted to say "dream up" in Spanish you just can't, so the literal translation wouldn't make sense even though the English does to you. This is something that seems obvious, but when you only know one language it's actually not obvious. It's not even on your radar cos you don't have another language for a comparison
@peterwood2633
@peterwood2633 2 күн бұрын
As a native speaker, whenever i meet someone who says learning english is straightforward/easy for them i know for sure they have no idea of the subtleties and intricacies.
@annurissimo1082
@annurissimo1082 3 күн бұрын
I'm going to play the devil's advocate here and as a Bosnian say that I don't completely prefer English to my native language (even though I love them both.) In short: Bosnian is a SIGNIFICANTLY more complex language than English, and that complexity enables unmatched creativity in literature - that's something I find English to lack in. For example, our sentences make sense in almost *any* word order (because each word holds a large amount of grammatical information, unlike English, where words depend on each other to create meaning.) But when it comes to normal or day-to-day communication, English is the vastly superior option.
@ilovekog
@ilovekog 3 күн бұрын
English is a piece of garbage. I hate that it is the most common...
@indianastoned8234
@indianastoned8234 3 күн бұрын
When I was getting good at speaking French this was the most frustrating part was that I had only one way to say anything. It was so rigid and one dimensional
@terrancevanliew1814
@terrancevanliew1814 3 күн бұрын
It's refreshing to hear someone not disparage english for once.
@odorisiogilberto
@odorisiogilberto 3 күн бұрын
Bravissimo Alberto Angela!!
@angelobalconi8013
@angelobalconi8013 3 күн бұрын
Astrazione, trovarsi nel posto giusto al momento giusto. Filosofo scopritore
@TheCompleteJeff
@TheCompleteJeff 3 күн бұрын
Fascinating!
@julianmartinez3048
@julianmartinez3048 3 күн бұрын
Spanish has also a German part. And Arabic. And Euskera. And Pre-Roman, Greek, American Native and even English words thrown in. Both languages has strong points and shortcomings. English is easier to learn, but harder to understand as spoken language especially some accents, its writing and spelling a mess. Spanish has a more complex grammar, but simpler to write, and has far more depth than English, whatever Borges may say. To any English word there are 6 or 7 words, one ore two common, and several less used.
@Ypress250
@Ypress250 3 күн бұрын
Nah Spanish accents are more difficult to understand. You may only find difficulty in understanding some Scottish or Irish accents
@morgan1719
@morgan1719 3 күн бұрын
If you want to play with words: English. If you want to communicate: Spanish
@user-xm9qm7mx3w
@user-xm9qm7mx3w 3 күн бұрын
Español >>>>>> Inglés. Borges was a filoj...w and a traitor. Nada que agradecerle. No hay Quijote en Inglés, sólo en ESPAÑOL. Si no sabes Español no puedes catar eso. Ni la sevillanas, ni los romances, ni Quevedo, ni Unamuno, etc. El inglés es una lengua para el espectáculo, la mentira y el negocio o las ventas. Nada más. Lengua de piratas y corsarios.
@liammelia6843
@liammelia6843 3 күн бұрын
Guys there's a lot of nonsense in this thread. Some quick points: Yes, English phrasal verbs and prepositions allow for great nuance. I love this in English. Comparing size of lexicon is not a good way to compare whether one language is better than another. Yes, we have 'regal' and 'kingly'; in 30 odd years I have never had cause to use either. English is morphologically simple but has some tricky complexities in negation, tense, singular and plural, etc. There is plenty of grammar in English if you look under the bonnet. English is not the world language because it is uniquely beautiful or rich, etc. It's the British Empire and the United States .... end of story. Claims that English is uniquely rich for its Latin and Germanic admixture are probably unfounded given that there are about 7000 languages out there. Thank you for reading my Ted Talk, An exasperated amateur linguist
@JEON_CENA
@JEON_CENA 3 күн бұрын
Mais le gouvernement italien je le comprends pas, pourquoi tu arrêtes des fouilles quand tu sais que t'as une villa énorme encore quasi ensevelie?
@narthex1681
@narthex1681 4 күн бұрын
As a speaker of French, it truly struck me a few years ago, when I realized that we lacked VERY important words such as "big" or "warm"
@brianwyse5810
@brianwyse5810 4 күн бұрын
Where is this in full
@762mm7
@762mm7 4 күн бұрын
These shorts are really reassuring and letting me know I'm not alone, thank you brother
@angelooxoli8939
@angelooxoli8939 4 күн бұрын
Ringraziamo i servizi segeti italiani americani .
@keepitreal665
@keepitreal665 4 күн бұрын
English is very expressive,with alot of verbs slang and adjectives which have the same meaning but are Watson of expressing and conveying more depth and feeling. Like there is blue but there are so many shades of blue. English is very descriptive.Many languages are not.
@payingtoplay
@payingtoplay 4 күн бұрын
Even though I’m a French speaker, I find English to be more concise and direct even in poetry when you try to convey an idea, it is sometimes more poignant in English and more staggering and sometimes I find myself thinking in English. But it all depends of the phrasing I find Arabic, Spanish and French, to be also very impactful depending on the subject. In any case, whatever language you speak if you don’t master it, of course it won’t give the same experience. For example Japanese uses very unique terms encompassing a whole idea. So every language has its beauty and i think what he says is fair but it’s not universal.
@AlbertoBarbosa-it5lk
@AlbertoBarbosa-it5lk 4 күн бұрын
he is plain dumb. there are languages other than english that are blends of 2 or more completely different languages(example: japanese, with lots of words borrowed from chinese) every language has nuance in its vocabulary, even when they seem to mean the same thing to foreigners, they don't. there are expressions in other languages that cannot be directly translated to english. for example something as simple as the chinese proverb "水滴石穿" turns into "dripping water can penetrate the stone". doesn't seem very physical to me. i do not like how that man chooses to look down upon romance languages...such arrogance and ignorance.
@garrisondinsmore5808
@garrisondinsmore5808 4 күн бұрын
this is the first time i've heard anyone say anything nice about english, and from such a titan
@majidbineshgar7156
@majidbineshgar7156 4 күн бұрын
I think the only thing gives somewhat advantage to English over other European languages, is not its vocabulary but its beautiful sonority ( British RP accent ) and the fact that English having ridden itself of absurd, irrational grammatical genders, otherwise English Grammar tends to be absurd , inflexible and lacking many enriching features compared to other indo-european languages .
@dickvandraevan1675
@dickvandraevan1675 4 күн бұрын
Theres a reason English is the universal language
@fastertove
@fastertove 3 күн бұрын
...and it has little to do with the language itself.
@dickvandraevan1675
@dickvandraevan1675 3 күн бұрын
@@fastertove it kind of does, sure the English took over most of the world but it's been a very long time and others would have become more popular. English has a lot of ways to portray things so it's useful
@Ypress250
@Ypress250 3 күн бұрын
​@@dickvandraevan1675it is also very simple (compared to other languages). Like imagine if Russian was the universal language, with all its cases. Or imagine that Portuguese was the universal language and you had to worry about putting the ^ ` ~ and ‘ in the correct words
@naboost9485
@naboost9485 5 күн бұрын
Oh yeah because 40% of English got directly taken from french
@karanphokela5743
@karanphokela5743 5 күн бұрын
This is the first time I ever heard someone praise English.
@federicopalacios7439
@federicopalacios7439 5 күн бұрын
Borges was a giant England fanboy. So his opinion is kind of null. For someone who spoke six languages he should know that every language has words for ideas that are incredibly hard to translate over and have them mean the exact same thing. Spanish as well, has tons of stuff that don't get carried over to English, Borges knows this, but his fanaticism takes over this logic.
@cardsharper1909
@cardsharper1909 15 сағат бұрын
​@@federicopalacios7439cipayo el borges
@user-ng9fj4gd6h
@user-ng9fj4gd6h 5 күн бұрын
Ieri avevamo Moravia oggi Sgarbi e Alfonso Signorini 😢
@sullivandmitry1416
@sullivandmitry1416 5 күн бұрын
I’ve said this for years to all my friends. English has a way to describe anything and everything in both a stylistic and bland way. You can sound eloquent and dumb all based on the vernacular you chose.
@TeoSensible
@TeoSensible 5 күн бұрын
2:40 religion = image de la philosophie ; philosophie = concept ; religion = image du concept...
@egelidos
@egelidos 5 күн бұрын
Probabilmente un refuso al min. 17:10. Filomena fu trasformata in usignolo. Procne in rondine (da cui "garrir Progne e piagner Filomena" nel sonetto Zefiro torna di Petrarca