This piece and its overall sadness in spite of being in a "major" key makes sense when you realize Brahms wrote this in response to the death of his mother.

This is the best recording of this piece by miles. The sound of the horn's stopped notes adds a whole new dimension that is missing from performances on modern instruments.

The entry of the timpani on F at 34:26 is made truly scary, like real thunder in crescendo!

The idea of historical performance is the result of cultural decadence.

Merci, quel chef d'oeuvre...c'est toujours une émotion comme au premier jour.

1 часть 0:00 вступление, 1р 01:36 2р 01:50 контрапункт 1 и 2р 04:49 гп 06:04 пп 08:02 разработка, 1р 8:34 разработка 2р 10:39 разработка 3р, solo ob 11:26 реприза, тв 12:03 кода 13:12 religiosamente 2 часть 13:56 вступление 14:35 1р тема вальса 15:32 второе проведение 15:48 фанфара 15:58 2р, тв F dur в характере вальса 16:10 контрап тв и темы вальса 16:41 мотив судьбы у дд 16:55 реприза 18:55 кода, тв у cl 3 часть 20:05 вст 22:16 1р, т Adagio 27:18 ср р диалог низких стр и д/д 30:25 реприза 31:55 кода 34:12 заключение

Terrible performance and dito recording. I can't imagine that Berlioz had in mind such a dry and unmusical playing and interpretation!

thanks for this clip. If the sheet musc contains the part of cornet à pistons, it is perfect because the sound contains cornet à pistons.

WAY too fast and loud. What's your hurry? How Brahms would have laughed!

メモ 2:15▶︎5:06

This is the piece in my young years that SOLD me on Brahms....Still brings tears......had to learn all his chamber music....HAD TO! performed the piano part many times. most gratifying piano writing ever. of course there's an alternate viola part for the horn. Thank you GOD@!!!!!! dg viola. piano, organ, guitar, etc

3:23 whole tone scale... 8:53 reminds me 16th century music for a few seconds

❤

22:48

What a revelation! I usually am not a fan of this work because it always sounds like the musicians are trying to say something that is not there resulting in an incomplete interpretation. What a joy this recording is to listen to over and over again!

19:34

Que maravilla!!! Realmente aprecio más con esta interpretación el genio de Beethoven. Gracias-!!!

Thank you for uploading! best sound.🐦

Danke vielmals für das Präsentieren der Noten. Erst daraus wurde mir klar, wie anspruchsvoll der Klavierpart ist! Hut ab vor allen, die so etwas spielen können! Ein wunderbares Stück in wunderbarer Wiedergabe!

I really like the dactylic rhythmic and melodic motive of this piece (although it sounded like anapest to me initially - somehow the double quavers sounded like a strong beat?) 😊 Beautiful music 💕

Great piece, awsome performance! Many thanks for the upload.

Un verdadero Maestro! El adagio es una página perfecta en la historia de la música.

The sound of the fortepiano is just amazing 👍

I performed this piece many times during my career with the Horn. Most fun was in Salzburg in the summer of 1985…with a wonderful Japanese pianist who jumped in at the last minute because the original pianist took sick. The violinist was the assistant concertmaster of the Munich Philharmonic. I had a great time and played also on the natural horn. The balance problems that occur with a modern instrument are much fewer with the „Naturhorn“ but you still need a violinist who is not afraid to „dig in“. I have some reservations about the tempi in the Scherzo and the final movement. The opening movement I found quite convincing…the Adagio not so much but still very good. However, Brahms wasn’t a friend of rushed tempo. He wanted every single note to be perceptible. I know this piece inside and out…but someone hearing the two faster movements for the first time might be dazzled by the virtuosity but miss a lot of the wonderful details. This piece is one of Brahms‘ most inventive and passionate works…it needs room to breathe.

I love the no.6!

my first schumann piano piece is einsame blumen, and its sounds are so beautiful

jn which universe is this "Moderato"?! well performed, but wayy to fast

Faust and her horrible, fractured, anemic, weedy sound.

so boring... uninteresting interpretation and wrong readings.

Fabulous! But sad that you haven't uploaded anything for three years!

Why so wimpy fast fuck this

Abschied has to be one of the sweetest things Schumann wrote

Amazing how the written f in the horn give such a "lontano" effect. Beautiful rendition.

20:27 Magical moment. I love how it anticipates the following movement's main theme.

It's a natural horn! Unbelievably perfect intonation!

Nice performance....however, it doesn't sound like a fortepiano---wouldn't be historically accurate either.

4.저주받은 장소 7.예언의 새

Just came across this video and found 'Abschied', which is my first schumann piece! It somehow reminds me of how I used to practice in the early stages, hopefully I can return home to my piano after the whole covid is over....

What a modern artist, i love this trio!!

🌤️

this is great. very expressive , accents well marked , extremely faithful to the score. with just some time being taken here and there in position changing , or breathing in phrases. lovely, thank you.

Beautiful Instrument, inspiring Interpretation

The Picture of Dorian Gray

Non,pardon ,4 ,pas 3 !!

J aime beaucoup cette oeuvre,mais proposerais volontiers un montage qui l'a mutilerait et la desordonnerait en 1,3,8,6,9 What do you think about?

La partie centrale de Jaglied perd selon moi toute sa magie a être jouée dans ce tempo trop lent. Et Abshied est trop rapide !! (Ces remarques sont subjectives,je ne sais rien des indications metronomiques de Schumann)

J enlèverais volontiers de l oeuvre "l oiseau prophète". Je ne comprends pas que ce soit devenu la pièce la plus connue du recueil !!

Is someone just because od musik lessen here? Cause i dont give a shit.

I miss this channel. Are there any plans to 'revive' it and upload new videos soon?

Murakami brought me out of the dark wrestling and brought me here.😍 Where are you Murakami lovers 😊