Ill go even further: not only you are not getting extrinsic rewards but you are USING your resources to go and do that side content so its even less rewarding I like pretty flowers, the sniffer example. I would LOVE some cool looking flowers that are exclusive to it. Maybe make the TORCHflower be an actual light source but besides that I like to have things that are, as you said, intrinsically rewarding Like, ok, most new things in minecraft are horizontal progression to obtain different pretty flowers, which is a great idea. But obtaining these flowers is very tedious and costly, and the flowers arent even that pretty

"The Gameplay Update"

Ideas for mobs that didn't get added: Glares still do what they do, but you can shear them for glare leaves, that can be turned into a "watchers charm" that can be put into your off-hand and gives you x-ray on mobs Mooblooms speed up growth of plants, trees and other nature around them, and can be milked for a new liquid that can be used as a replacement for water in farms that also works faster Crab claws can be turned into a weapon, i was thinking one that snaps enemies and can be made from mixing it with the heart of the sea or really any ocean themed item, we need more use for ocean stuff Iceollogers drop an "ice rune" that can be smithed onto swords to give them a chance at temporarily freeze most mobs (besides the bosses because that would be too strong against them, and blazes because they're made of fire)

Crafting the trident giving people a reason to go to the monument is a great idea

This video is really good but 14:00 is just not a good idea. The biggest problem with minecraft development is the confines of bedrock and expecially pocket edition. Dynamic lighting will probably never be added because it's so resourse intensive. Some lowend pcs struggle with it, it's a really common thing when talking about minecrafts development to compare it to mods. But they are fundamentally different as mojang has to appeal to every type of minecraft player. A mod doesn't have to do that

The llamas could also be a heavy carrier of cargo or some shite. You could put bags on their back to carry a bunch of shit for you

MOJANG HIRE THIS MAN RIGHT NOW

I hate it when people give the argument that stuff is useless. What about the trial chambers? Those give maces and wind charges, among other useful rewards. People only like to focus on the negatives of what mojang adds. The sniffer flowers are *supposed* to be decoration, though the sniffers could definitely do more.I think rather than giving flowers a use (because honestly, since when have flowers ever had a use?), the sniffer should give something interesting instead. That said, it's very easy to oversaturate the game with too many "useful" features, especially when they have little thought put into them - which is the next issue. People say mojang work slow, which absolutely isn't true. Imagine they added everything they thought of as soon as it was done. The game would not only be a buggy mess, but be somewhat reminiscent of something like crazycraft after some time. It simply isn't feasible.

Killing the polar bear should give polar bear fur which is like the bison fur instead if it being ravbit hide

I think you have to work at mojang 😂

finally a good perspective

Llama got the fresh spawn treatment:( 18:34

Pitcher plants should cause damage to Spiders, Endermites, and Silver Fish

18:49 Emotion: Brown 😭

If Jet Starfish was good:

I feel like mojang should start growing leaves and roots instead of focusing on growning branches, they have so many items like copper, amethyst and echo shards that just don't do anything, what they need to do instead of adding some random biome and 5 random mobs that drop nothing is simply give new uses to existing items, give us an echo staff or an amethyst spear or a copper hook, just something useful to the player

Tbh i only play modded because i dont have enough insentive to play vanilla

Imagine the sniffer had more to it, it could dig up ancient crops that buffed food or made unique food with enhancments

I am here for you- *blinks twice*

I think one way Mojang could fix that lack of desire to explore would be to attach all of these cool biomes/structures up in a terraria style way. I know minecraft is supposed to be a "make your own path" type of game, but it already has an ending, so why not expand on the path to that? Have the player find something in an ocean monument that will help them with traversing a deep dark, have treasures in the deep dark only accessible if you find a "ancient key" in a nether bastion. That way they could also fix the issue with loot being not worth the risk. By placing higher quality gear behind later-stage progression it solves that issue completely.

3:52 "just because you liked the flower, doesn't give you the right to pick it"

dude great video, keep up

this video is a fever dream and i love it

I LOVE THIS AND YOUR SENSE OF HUMOR I CANT WAIT FOR MORE VIDEOS!!¡!!!!! 🐬🐬

There are Cold and Warm Bioms. Make it so you take damage based off temp. Polar Bears could drop Fur that can be used to insulate your armor, reducing or eliminating Temp Damage. Also, use the fur with some other items to make a tent, an alt to the Bed. I dunno', that was off the top of my head.

my next recommendation was 'how fast can i find all 23 flowers in minecraft' lol

9:11 Say that again.

just based off ur intro and humor i already know you and your channel is cool.

The goat horn should apply rally to iron golems or if use the mod that let you recruit villagers with weapons they come to your aid, and add tiers to the horn like if combine with expensive or magical materials call for the spirits of ancient miners like that shout of skyrim that summons warriors from sovengarde

This guy did not just say that piglins "don't do enough"...

5:25 Why are u eating axe bro😂😂😂

Not a Minecraft hater - i would describe myself as a Minecraft mourner. For all the paths it could have taken i fear we've been taking the worst paths, or very close, for a while

Someone could make a mod out of this

STOP SHOUTING!

many mobs in midern minecraft are endangered irl, I'm pretty sure those ones have no drops/use to discourage people from offing them

this video is so peak make one more

i love your editing style omg

Hi mojang's biggest shooter here, (/j but still). I am so upset that no one seems to actually understand the ancient city at all. My main evidence for this is that no one knows the biggest reward you get for conquering an ancient city. ITS XP AND DIAMONDS. Not swift sneak, not diamond pants, not the recovery compass. Its xp and diamonds. How? mining the blocks. literally the second half of the entire game and no one seems to think to do it. Okay how you get xp should be obvious, mine up the skulk, the chests even give you hoes to do it quicker. Using an ancient city you can get fully enchanted gear easy, no xp farm, only an enchanting table and a crafting table. The requirements to get this is a little higher than the chest loot, you do have to clear the shriekers entirely, but thats not too much more demanding its just a slightly more risky challenge and it makes getting the chest loot easier too. Its honestly probably partially the intended way to clear a city. Either way clearing the skulk nets you a massive amount of xp, because pretty much every solid wall is covered in the stuff and while each block is only 1 xp the special ones are 5 each. Not a lot on their own but it adds up across the whole city with its thousands of blocks. However clearing the skulk is also doing something else. revealing the deepslate underneath. 1.18 diamond generation was updated, it included a change to how diamonds are exposed. If they are exposed they spawn less ore less often. so exposed veins are smaller and there are less exposed veins. They only told us about the advantages of water caves which don't count as being exposed. you know what else doesn't count. Being beneath skulk. So you clear the shriekers, open the chests, start clearing the skulk and get insane amounts of xp, and you uncover a lot of diamond ore veins. Average ancient city I raided gave me 2 stacks of diamonds (with fortune after making my god gear from diamonds in the same city) rough estimate is about 3 stacks with fortune, 1-1.5 stacks without. Anyway I'm gonna finish your video, just had to defend my favorite structure.

Yep, Explores do not have a lot to do and people want more to do. You shouldn't need to build to play the game. Also Stfu, You're not winning the sound effect guinness world record.

I think it's a really bold choice for Mojang to alienate one of the most creative and passionate communities in the history of gaming. Most companies would be too scared to ruin their reputation.

I really wanted to hear what you had to say but this video editing style is too much

that chomper reference was really unexpected LMAO great video

Finally a nuanced take. I feel like everyone either thinks "its not terraria, bad game" or "its a sandbox game so any criticism is your own fault for not playing it correctly".

Its a really big stretch to say that one of the biggest games of our current time missed some potential when minecraft has unlimited potential with mods and community servers. Doesnt mean that they arent doing any mistakes but missed potential reads like they missed the chance to be more succesfull with their game.

the annoying thing about minecraft is that they release the absolute most vanilla and soulless version of something and pretend it's some ground breaking stuff, while that one mod developer rewrites the whole code and ad 200+ new features fully detail from his garage

So what I'm getting off the video is that you'd want Mojang to turn Minecraft more into Terraria. I see nothing wrong with it, and technically I'm agreeing with you. That's why when I feel bored with basic MC I'm starting up a good modpack that brings all that you mentioned to the table.

the editing is so obnoxious

Dude this is your first video? I went looking for more you’re hilarious:)