good video! The Moog and the Mutron III sounded the best and most organic to me. But the Moog is too big and expensive and the Mutron is too hard to find and also too expensive. So where does that leave us? 😀

😊

what's up with that moded DOD??

The DOD sounds like MXR EF

The Discumbobulator v2 is my fave. You demo the v1 a little late 🙂

EBS pedal surprised me. Really full round sound

I have an MXR Bass Envelope Filter and my personal favorite the Subdecay Prometheus.

😂😂🤣🤣🤣

Nice! Gosh the Maxon is funky. The Emma seems nice to me too. Great job

Excellent!

Nice jam brother 👍🏼

What song is the bass line from? Thanks for these demos, it’s very helpful

😸 Fonky. The smartphones are definitely listening to bring me here: I just finished trying out a Soundblox Manta filter. I think I like it more than this MXR bass envelope and Cry Baby 105Q (all used pedals).

LoL great stuff. That pedal is filthy

Even the cheap as Hell DOD sounds pretty good here. I figured out the trick awhile back that makes ANY envelope filter sound quite a bit better. I always place a Compressor pedal with a "Level" control directly in front of my filter. I use the level to boost the signal up and it gets quite a bit more QUACK out of the filter. Any cheap DOD 440 style pedal can really swing. Boosting the signal before the filter works extremely well on a EH Bassballs. It really ads so much more control to the pedal. This trick works well with passive basses and even with basses strung with dead flatwound strings that lack the attack to properly trigger the envelope effect.

It's so crazy how your saddles move while you playing fingerstyle)))

This is cool

Excellent video!!! Thank you so much! Did you use some limiting or compression with the Q-Tron? Mine can’t open that much of gain/peak without add lots of distortion… and your filter seems to open much smoothier than mine. I don’t know if I’m doing something wrong or if there is something wrong with my pedal…

Excellent comparison. Thank you for using a loop for consistency. I love filters but have not been able to incorporate them into live playing effectively.

Have you tried the Chunk Systems Agent 00Funk? Those things are amazing!!

I prefer the Q-Tron+

I personally think it was a tie between Q Tron and Moog. DOD wasn’t bad either.

mutron only

Did you ever have luck with a Boss AW_3?

This is great - I love filters, I find dialing them in to be hard - I think I need a looper to put in front and experiment like you have done

Mutron wins

I love my 3leaf Audio Proton: so many beautiful and useful tones! Great review, by the way, thank you :)

I recommend the Carl Martin Classic Optical Envelope for Bass. Those are sick!

Thank you sir! I love envelope filters on bass this was great . Which one do you like best ?

That bass. Mmmmm

i think i'm gonna get another maxon af9

Awesome!

I enjoyed this a lot. I have had many envelopes, but currently have the 3leaf Wonderlove. They can all sound great!

Nice demo, big fan of envelope filters here too. Out of these do you have a favourite?