Your 2 mates obviously hadn’t researched the route either. Clachaig gully is an infamous black spot in summer let alone winter. Good outcome though and good video
@OrdnanceTV20 күн бұрын
Simple and informative, to the point, no annoying ass 30-sec intro with drone footage and EDM, just points and examples. Gonna go see if you have any more vids about types of boots (I only own general hiking, combat, and steel toes, but not official 'winter boots' per se). If you dont have any vids, any personal recs?
@stefanherman695221 күн бұрын
Perfect. What month was it?
@doughobbs770622 күн бұрын
Glad the Central Gully day has stayed with you! :)
@richardcarey169Ай бұрын
My classroom in 1980
@ianmarshall9144Ай бұрын
Competence was drummed into us as youngsters , good navigation , good rope work and placing protection , learn about weather systems and learn to be self sufficient , do your summer rock apprenticeship then move on to winter , yes nature will bite your backside at some point but be prepared for some uncomfortable nights , experience is invaluable , you will make mistakes , we all do , today's world of the internet makes access to information so much easier , you should be using all the tools available to enhance your chances , sharing this benefits those with less experience , walk before you run but at some point you have to take of the stabilizers and ride the bike for yourself , your honesty is commendable and hopefully someone watching this takes note , you can have a lifetime of pleasure in the hills , take care all .
@doughobbs770622 күн бұрын
^^ This, rather than just being a keyboard warrior is EXACTLY what people should be saying about this incident, they worked the problem - slowly but safely and got off in one peice, many have died trying to get off by abseiling or trying reversing the Aonach in foul weather
@dougiebicker6458Ай бұрын
Good Advice man great video
@joeallen6734Ай бұрын
Great video mate. Just wanted to say that general hiking boots are considered B0 boots. B1 boots have a minimum stiffness requirement to take a full crampon. There is a possibility that if you use a softer boot with a C1 crampon, it can flex enough to pop out of the plastic bindings.
@charlie.carter.outdoorsАй бұрын
Yeah you're right, though as most other countries don't use the B1, B2, B3 terminology it's difficult to know what exactly is the "correct" stiffness as boot manufacturers don't specify this as far as I'm aware.
@Rwmd953Ай бұрын
Please don’t put music over you talking
@charlie.carter.outdoorsАй бұрын
@@Rwmd953 Why not?
@sherlockholmes2797Ай бұрын
This isn't a criticism because we all make mistakes. I'd say there is no more vital skill, if you can even call it a skill to learn for doing the mountains at any time of year, it's when to turn back. Any doubt at all, is the point at which it should kick in. The mountain will always be there to do tomorrow. Learning it from this comment is much better than learning the hard way.
@craigyb16Ай бұрын
Extremely helpful thank you mate
@Alex__starlingАй бұрын
Perfect timing 👌
@hairymotter5455Ай бұрын
You live to tell the tale and pass on good tips, well done. Had similar on Tower Ridge which turned into an epic, finishing in the dark
@McConnachyАй бұрын
I'm surprised by all this. You started by saying you were an inexperienced mountaineer 😐 Yet you decided to go up the Aonach Eagach in winter. No offence, but there are a lot of people who come up from England who do not realize how temperamental and changeable the weather is in the west of Scotland compared to your weather. Your pronunciation of Gaelic names is entertaining tho, thanks for the vid. 👍
@charlie.carter.outdoorsАй бұрын
@@McConnachy I'd hazard a guess that many indigenous Scots don't know Gaelic either. My Latin is rusty too 🤷🏻♂️
@McConnachyАй бұрын
@ TBF local knowledge still has the pronunciation correct all over Scotland, though the language was made illegal in the 1861 ‘education act’ of Parliament. But you are correct many people (Scots) will get mountain names incorrect, the classic is Beinn Chonzie, near Crieff, I’ve only heard it being pronounced as written, while it’s pronounced Bin a hone. Good luck with your future mountain adventures 👍
@frederick1858Ай бұрын
High quality video, the split, commentary and visuals added really did it for me. Subbed and liked simply wont do it justice!
@charlie.carter.outdoorsАй бұрын
Much appreciated!
@kerrraaazzzyАй бұрын
Great advice, really appreciate this and your honesty also. Massive respect 🙌
@bettygreenhansenАй бұрын
Honestly I came here solely to find out how to pronounce that name. 😂
@charlie.carter.outdoorsАй бұрын
@@bettygreenhansen 🤣
@66oggy2 ай бұрын
I did the Aonach Eagach Ridge this September in perfect conditions. 2 hours up, 2 hours across, 2 hours down, and 2 hours back to the car. I'm a fair weather scrambler as you can only scramble by being alive, so even when it's only just damp, it's routes that only involve my feet and walking poles.
@TheBananaLoverorignal2 ай бұрын
yeah guidebooks say there is no escape on that side that you tried and you need to continue to the pap.
@craigyb162 ай бұрын
Great video Charlie.. thanks for sharing 👌✌️
@peteanenome2 ай бұрын
Climbed the ridge in summer and winter in good conditions and a reasonable amount of experience in winter climbing. It's a difficult call when things go south. You have to make decisions and you can only make them based upon what you think might work. The decision to go back or push on is always difficult on a ridge - less so on a bottom to top winter route. I'd say your descent route down Clachaig was high risk - the safe but long route is better when things go bad, but even then you have to have excellent navigation skills. That you got down unharmed means things didn't go that bad. Night navigation is tough, especially on descent. I firmly believe things only go wrong when you can't make it back under your own steam and/or suffer a bad injury, everything else is just part of the day, no matter how tough that day is.
@largeformatlandscape2 ай бұрын
The biggest issue with the AE in winter is just time. It's a long route and you need to be making decent time on it and you can make that call if you have some set times you expect to hit certain points by. Nothing really predicts thing going awry though. There are actually a few bail points you can take but you have to be familiar with the ridge to really know where they are, you can come down to Caolasnacon via Meall Dearg or Stobh Coire Leith but you need to be hot on your nav and steep ground. Either is better than the Clachaig in my opinion. Learning from your mistakes if the most important, like you say!
@clogsonthemountain2 ай бұрын
Great video Charlie 👍
@mandoesmountains2 ай бұрын
Great video Charlie. Mountains are great teachers for sure.
@largeformatlandscape2 ай бұрын
The Clachaig Gully deathtrap isn't actually the gully, it is that scree path. People slip off that path and into the gully (quite a lot of them!). Thumbs up on the Inreach for backup and also getting proper map skills and practicing them. Well handled, although I think one of your big mistakes was to not continue around and down the Pap of Glencoe path, which is a lot safer and easier (especially in bad conditions when you're really tired). Good video and good analysis (and the headtorch is critical like you say - at least you had two!)
@lessismore830092 ай бұрын
I always take a bivvy and a light down bag, and a foil blanket, in winter.
@moody99312 ай бұрын
Why choose the Aonach ridge in winter. It's not a difficult route, but in winter, that can be brutal.
@charlie.carter.outdoors2 ай бұрын
@@moody9931 Why not choose it?
@ashleyburton86052 ай бұрын
Why do anything in life? 🤷♂️
@beatbasher2 ай бұрын
Why bother getting up in the morning?
@mandoesmountains2 ай бұрын
It's not difficult but can be in winter. Think you answered your own question there.
@moody99312 ай бұрын
@ashleyburton8605 Jesus people are so touchy these days. I wasn't criticising you. Simple question maybe not written in the clearest manner. You said you were inexperienced particularly in winter climbing. So why pick this route for learning winter techniques. There are hundreds of beautiful routes up there, still challenging but less deathy. Did it have significance to you, a route you'd always wanted to do, or one you did as a kid?
@Reece1112 ай бұрын
Great vid, in the same spot myself. How do you go about finding partners for mountaineering?
@charlie.carter.outdoors2 ай бұрын
It's just happened naturally over time for me. Just get out and meet people it'll happen 👌
@Reece1112 ай бұрын
@@charlie.carter.outdoors did you join any mountaineering clubs?
@charlie.carter.outdoors2 ай бұрын
@@Reece111 yeah I mentioned it in the video.
@Reece1112 ай бұрын
@@charlie.carter.outdoors ah my bad
@66oggy2 ай бұрын
It all depends what your goals are. I always scramble alone, grade three and above, and the only thing I ever learned to do with a rope was abseil.... You Tube, trial and error and common sense. Not fucked up yet in many years, but I suppose I'll only ever fuck up once. The actual roped trad climbing does not appeal to me in the slightest, and nor does venturing outside the UK, and like I said, it's what your goals are.
@kurt33063 ай бұрын
5:11 pulling myself up on to grassy steps like that sketches me the flip out..... purely psychological but I always feel like I am somehow being pushed away from the rock into the abyss 😂
@kurt33063 ай бұрын
Great footage! May I ask what cam you use to film? 👍
@CarterCreativeContent3 ай бұрын
Just a GoPro Hero 10 mounted on my helmet
@kurt33063 ай бұрын
Thanks thats great to hear having just had a 10 delivered. My first foray into action cams👍🏻
@naveedarshad56083 ай бұрын
Wow your story is very similar to mine I started trail running in 2020 lockdown and fell in love with the outdoors this naturally started to involve some scrambling around Peak District developed into many scrambles in and around Tryfan and the glyders we are now doing the grade 3 routes free solo Crib goch also did it for me I just wasn’t satisfied after literally flying over it need more !
@spaceyeah93103 ай бұрын
I'm an Italian climber and mountaineer. I think your video is very honest and describes well the path that many take to approach mountaineering. Taking all the steps without rushing, building a good base of theoretical knowledge and experience in the field is the key to enjoying this discipline. I have never climbed in the Scottish winter, but one day I would like to try. Those places look so beautiful!
@charlie.carter.outdoors3 ай бұрын
Thanks, the key is not to rush as I'm sure you agree. Definitely try to go and climb in Scotland in Winter. When it's good there's nowhere like it 👍
@craigyb163 ай бұрын
This was exactly what I needed to hear.. thank you Charlie
@robwoods-u4k4 ай бұрын
Epic video Charlie! Easily my favourite scramble in North Wales.
@lewishikes4 ай бұрын
The perfect video what I was looking for for my progression currently at grade 1 scrambles
@majyuk4 ай бұрын
First off. Fantastic video. Editing is top notch Secondly. Is this also known as pinnacle scramble? A grade 3+?
@mihaibalan19174 ай бұрын
This subject is so gatekept these days due to its very steep learning curve. You wish you could step up your hiking game, want to do something more adventurous, know that it implies a rope and a helmet but there are so many variables. I started climbing in a mountaineering club aswell but it took me a lot do develope my own set of safety rules. Even though it seems widely spread across yt and the internet, it is still really hard to get started. at first it seemed very scary to me because I always needed validation on the techniques I was using
@charlie.carter.outdoors4 ай бұрын
Interesting points, it is hard to get started, mainly because it's hard to find experienced people that will "show you the way". Plus it's a lifelong pursuit and one I feel you can never truly master. 3 years or so in I steel feel like a total novice.
@roqclimber4 ай бұрын
Top Rope until you're comfortable on 5.10, then go Alpine Rock Scrambling.
@secretmurderer4 ай бұрын
You were lucky that you had someone at the top to rope you up. Honestly, just looking at that from the bottom, I would never have scrambled up that to start. I'm a rock climber but I'm very cautious. That top looks like a class 5 to me, a low class 5 but still a 5. (Edit: I'm in the US)
@maxasaurus30084 ай бұрын
The balls on you! Thank you for posting this video, I would never have the courage to put something on the internet but yeah you can see when your knees start shaking so great decision!
@rachelsianphotography59324 ай бұрын
I was thinking of doing this but that music has terrified me 😂
@charlie.carter.outdoors4 ай бұрын
🤣 It's not actually that bad. Just go on a nice day with low winds 👍
@p.richter95924 ай бұрын
You are lucky you started when you did. I caught the alpine bug when I was 54. Better late than never. Love being in the mountains. Have to do a trad course though. ATB from Norway 🇳🇴
@Subydude199114 күн бұрын
The comment I needed to see! Currently up at the wee hours of the morning holding my 8 month old son who is teething so he can sleep. I always wonder when is too late to get into alpinism. Always dabbled in and out of it. But after seeing you got the bug at 54, it lifted my spirits knowing I still have time. Enough fine that u can teach my son some day and go on ascents with him!
@p.richter959214 күн бұрын
@ It’s never too late to start with something. I’m not as fast as younger people, but as long as I stay at my own pace, I will get to the top, weather permitting. There isn’t much that can compete with standing on the top of a mountain on a clear day and seeing the view. It’s just gorgeous 👍🏻👍🏻🇳🇴
@GymandOutdoors4 ай бұрын
I’m part of the army mountaineering association I would love to join an “active” civilian club aswell, what club is it your a part of?
@charlie.carter.outdoors4 ай бұрын
Clogwyn Mountaineering Club
@janlamka84595 ай бұрын
Hi Charlie, i wonder what camera do you use for filming? And helmet mount? Appreciate the content! Thanks!
@charlie.carter.outdoors5 ай бұрын
Just a GoPro with a head mount on the helmet
@enigma10005 ай бұрын
Fascinating. Pity I’m even older….
@shadowrange5 ай бұрын
This is not scrambling mate..find a rock climbing partner before you get into trouble.
@charlie.carter.outdoors5 ай бұрын
Thanks, will do.
@danh23105 ай бұрын
Ive got the bug after striding edge too. Ive only done that, jacks rake lords rake but want to move to grade 2s its such a buzz. Pinnacle ridge at the lakes is my next.
@MrBlebtv5 ай бұрын
so inspirational. see you outdoors!
@johnomalley73355 ай бұрын
Got to take your time and not rush routes, If in doubt rope up. Even on your own you could use an old climbing nut, big chunky one and ab off if you get Craig fast. Means carrying weight but its a fail safe option. I've been Craig fast and had to climb out of it . Climbers never want to ring that helicopter, I climbed the Ben at night to do tower ridge in the morning, went off the path and ended up in that gully at right hand side of the path. Made it to the lake using the moon as my touch compass. Never been as happy to see flat ground camped near the path and got woke up at 6 with walkers. Did the tower and the arret to the other hill across but that gully at night nearly got me.