Nope that’s not why it’s called highgerman or as we say Hochdeutsch. Only a few people in Niedersachsen speak Hochdeutsch, all the other areas has a different dialect. But a lot of people speak Hochdeutsch on their daily basis for business and better understanding no matter where in Germany.
@nzxt_v34 сағат бұрын
Auf der heide...
@ajfrostx6 сағат бұрын
But of course... the defining characteristic of my German village is that it is NOT SCHWABIAN! They are from former Baden, thank you very much.
@maypavletta31066 сағат бұрын
I am German and this video is incorrect. It doesn’t say “German, German above all”. It says “Germany, Germany above all”. The last verse is “Germany above all in the world”…
@keynar72198 сағат бұрын
But parts of high German are still heavily influenced by dialects like Bavarian and Swabian while other parts of lower German are pretty standardized like in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern or NRW
@lucaskook94408 сағат бұрын
rede nicht
@Twelwanger9 сағат бұрын
Yep. Standard German, like school English....
@fuzhe53u9 сағат бұрын
I speak my german dialect because i want that these dialects shall survive.
@fuufuulein2969 сағат бұрын
I would call it "the german dialect every german understands"
@TheWolvesCurse10 сағат бұрын
so linguistically speaking schwizerdüütsch is high-german then? 😂😂😂
@B.Ies_T.Nduhey11 сағат бұрын
3:36 And what should they do, too? A rivulet leading to a pond is like, twice as far from a tourist attraction than is a watchman... Plus, less tangible and depictable by miles...
@B.Ies_T.Nduhey11 сағат бұрын
2:45 I think that looks like a boy with a paper hat... By a brook, definitely 🤷🏽
@matthiasburgey903811 сағат бұрын
....Nazi Song.....oh yeah....😅😅😅
@Shikaschima12 сағат бұрын
It's not a Nazi song/verse. It's just that the world sees it as such. Also, no one actually likes the second verse. First one? Eh, it's honestly okay. But second oen made EVERYONE uncomfortable and it sounds TERRIBLE to sing.
@TheAvos1812 сағат бұрын
Thats BS...
@anroe358113 сағат бұрын
I guess High German is actually just a poor literal translation for what Hochdeutsch really means. Standard German is the more appropriate translation
@jojogrunesalatgurke690415 сағат бұрын
the German name for it is Hochdeutsch, and I think it makes sense to translate it as much, as it makes the most sense :)
@awestruckcardboard343116 сағат бұрын
This just proves the fallacy that is capitalism. Never mind the Berliners that went to the West, We dont talk about their numbers.
@Abcd-j9i18 сағат бұрын
Aschaffenburg isn't a tiny village. It's a medium-sized town with about 75K residents. Do you live in a village near it?
@rewboss14 сағат бұрын
Yes, I live in a village near it, where PO boxes don't exist.
@killyou197818 сағат бұрын
is not true Only the third verse of the Germany song is officially the national anthem. The first two verses are not forbidden, however. You can sing them. But the first verse in particular is considered taboo because of the line "Germany, Germany above all, above all in the world
@MarsOhr19 сағат бұрын
Und wo ist das Monster?
@florentinenice914619 сағат бұрын
Das sollten Lehrer in Schulen am Anfang vom English Unterricht zeigen, um zu verdeutlichen das man bei Sprachen mehr lernt als Wörter. Das Satzbau auch ein wichtiger Aspekt ist. Man lernt das zwar mit der Zeit. Ich denke aber man könnte davon profitieren das schon früh im Kopf zu haben.
@DazzaTravelStories21 сағат бұрын
London is all like this 😂
@asteamsavant999421 сағат бұрын
I have personally refurbished a cuckoo clock and I can attest that they are by far the easiest clock to repair and they will work basically as good as new if you know what you're doing and there are plenty of clock repair men who are willing to consult you if you want to learn their trade. The modern movements are cost cut which is annoying but there are easy ways of disposing of and replacing the cheap components. Also you can deactivate the gong which makes the chime much less grating. It would be even less so with a slower chime and deeper whistle notes as some of the very antique hand made cuckoos have.
@FlakfritzКүн бұрын
Ice on the road may damage your car! Thats enough horror!😅
@Black96futureКүн бұрын
It's not illegal
@Riesenradd1ebКүн бұрын
It's not illegal, but if you sing it, you're a nazi, because the first two verses were occupied by nazis. It doesn't matter what the verses are about. Btw in the first verse, the first line, is stupid because no country in the world should be above another countries.
@Yodi_Loewe19 сағат бұрын
You didn’t understand or were in too few history classes, in 1841 Germany wasn’t a country yet. But the people in Prussia, Bayern and so on wanted a united German state. So above being Prussian, Bavarian, you were German. It was never meant as in „we are better then you“
@xhylidax3185Күн бұрын
And here I am, a German, having been told by my teachers that it's illegal to sing the first two verses 😶👍🏼
@rotum1324Күн бұрын
Yeah cause you can‘t translate Plattdeutsch as low German
@rewboss23 сағат бұрын
You can. Linguists call it "Niederdeutsch" (the ISO 639 abbreviation for the language is "nds") or "Low German"; native speakers of those dialects generally call it "Plattdüütsch" or "Platt".
@benicerКүн бұрын
Can't remember having "pfand" in the anthem. But would be funny
@williamt.marshall1165Күн бұрын
It’s not right. For us, the 3.Verse is illegal. And no, it is not an Nazi Song, read History Books, the German national anthem is older, old man.
@rewboss23 сағат бұрын
Watch the video before criticizing it, young man.
@Yodi_Loewe19 сағат бұрын
You should start watching the video
@KyriaeКүн бұрын
What nonsense. It is NOT forbidden to sing all verses of the hymn. However, only the third verse is the official national anthem and may only be sung on official occasions. People who intentionally say crap to incite people are scum.
@rewboss23 сағат бұрын
Did you watch the video before commenting on it?
@Yodi_Loewe19 сағат бұрын
You should now click „play“
@sams5741Күн бұрын
I don't think that's entirely correct, even if the linguistic derivation is true. The ‘purest High German’ is attributed to the city of Hanover (the Hanoverians). Especially in the southern states, such as Baden Württemberg and Bavaria, dialects are more clearly cultivated out of tradition. In the centre of Germany and towards the north, they are often less present, especially not in urban areas and also more clearly not welcome in schools. Teachers in schools in the southern part, on the other hand, often speak dialect themselves, even in class. As a result, children in German lessons especially in the south are not even allowed to write what they hear, which sometimes causes problems. The everyday language in the south is therefore often further away from what is understood as High German and - as you rightly say - is actually most likely to be heard, at least in the public media. My first job in Baden Württemberg was at a municipal school near Stuttgart. At the first teachers' conference, I had problems understanding my colleagues because I had just arrived from another federal state. They discussed in strong accent from the Alb region the declining competence of their pupils to write correct German. Seriously interested, I asked them whether they spoke High German (i.e. analogous to written German) in their classes? I can still remember the scathing looks I received in response. ;-)
@rewboss23 сағат бұрын
The dialect local to Hannover is a version of Calenberger Platt: that it is considered to be the "place where the best High German is spoken" is so misleading it's practically a lie. The standardized dialect originated in Saxony in the 16th century, but is now spoken everywhere -- it's a standard. Also, as I explained very clearly in the video, there are two definitions of "High German" and you shouldn't confuse them. You're still thinking of "High German" as meaning "the standard dialect", but linguists use a different definition: it's all the dialects spoken south of the Benrath Line, of which the standardized dialect is only one. So Bavarians might say "zwoa" and "schloffa" and you might think that sounds very, very different from "zwei" and "schlafen". But what makes this High German is the consonants "z" and "f": they're there because of the High German consonant shift, a sound change that started in about the 6th century and only affected dialects in central and southern regions. Low German is unaffected by the shift: their words are "twee" and "slapen", more like Dutch than High German. And you should also understand the difference between dialect and pronunciation. Teachers in Swabia don't teach in the local dialect: they teach in the standardized dialect but maybe with an accent and perhaps a couple of regionalisms. They might slip into their local dialect when discussing matters among themselves, but the scathing looks will have come from the suggestion that their students can't write properly because their teachers don't talk like you do. In point of fact, it's actually very common for people to be essentially bilingual in their own language, able to code-switch instantly between the standard dialect and the local regiolect. It's not as if those teachers are quoting Hamlet as saying, "Sei odr net sei, des isch do d Frog."
@Black.Templar_002Күн бұрын
if we call it "high german" then thats the correct name, cuz its our language. simple as that.
@antianti8810Күн бұрын
Nah is only 2 long.🤣 The left make this Lie. 😅
@famejay7318Күн бұрын
Hey win is win you wanna be best at whatever you do
@Guderian2Күн бұрын
No it's not..
@shimanopetermann9068Күн бұрын
It's just funny how standard German apparently was heavily influenced by the southern high German dialects, but today, it sounds much more similar to how Northerners usually talk (most northerners don't actually speak low german on a regular basis anymore) while the southern dialects sound almost like a different language as standard German and people in the sound are also less inclined to actually speak standard German than people in the North. Like, people usually refer to the German spoken in Hannover as "the best high (standard) German" even though the city is in the North. On the other hand, the German usually heard in Munich doesn't sound like standard German at all.
@6KubikКүн бұрын
I sing the first part and i dont care
@angelikastockinger6664Күн бұрын
Sorry, Bavarian near the Alps here - nobody speaks high German here
@rewbossКүн бұрын
By definition, they all do. Just not the _standardized_ High German dialect. As I explain in the video, there are two different definitions of "High German": don't get them confused.
@Maggz109Күн бұрын
Do you even understand the language? Fuck no because if you would this video wouldnt have been made. Also making this Video without knowing that Germany has a extremist right wing uprising right now is just pushing their agenda. Thanks for actively making germany a worse country
@Dystopie173Күн бұрын
Yo you mixed these up my friend^^. High german is spoken north of the line.
@rewbossКүн бұрын
Nope, not if we're talking about the native local dialects.
@Ritrex1Күн бұрын
It's not translatet "we are german above all." it translates to "germany is above all" just saying. German here
@SchlongusdongusКүн бұрын
lel this is so true and wrong at the same time, i am impressed :D
@dominikwolf3608Күн бұрын
bayrisch it des oanzige deitsch und ois andere is a versuach si a so sche ozum hern