😂😂 she is Romila Thapar of Pakistan. (Both are leftist and love of jiahdi)

Not a one word for Pakistani hindus

Sorry but we want Pakistan occupied Kashmir and gilgit baltistan also

Legend

Asghar Nadeem Syed is a talented writer and a learned gentleman. However, as an interviewer, he fell short of expectations. There seemed to be a noticeable disconnect between him and Shabnam. The stage design is poorly conceived, giving off a gloomy appearance. The lighting is awkward, forcing Shabnam to shield her eyes with her hand to see the questioner. The poor lighting caused the shadows of Shabnam and Asghar Nadeem to constantly appear on the background curtain. Unfortunately, this reflects a lack of professionalism and mediocrity often seen in our setups. The overall ambiance was disappointing, with the sole exception of Shabnam's presence.Additionally, the sound system was disappointingly subpar. The quality of the questions was largely disappointing, with only a few exceptions. Overall, it was a letdown.

Sirs&Madam,cavalry was the Forte of islam. Oceanic islam was an exception,mostly relevant to indonesia.Europeans/British/French/Portugese/Denmark entered india through seas as islam was absent on sea routes despite Arabs sea trade with india since Roman times.

❤❤❤❤❤😊

Shame shame shame. Stupid woman

She is a good story teller from Pak Army

"Not a blade of grass grows there!" Is a sentence by Indian PM ,Jawahar lal Nehru in Indian Parliament, while replying to Chinese incursion in Aksai chin & ladhak,Not by any of Pakistani generals.She is lying

❤❤❤❤❤❤Lovely living legend. Love from sargodha Pakistan 8-11-2024

سٹیج پر موجود وائٹ کوٹ والا انکل سچ سننا نہیں چاہتے

Thank GOD (or, you can call Him "Modi" 😉) that ALL such👆nonsensical time-pass ENDED - literally DAYS after this👆silly tosh via the Aug 5th abrogation! 👍

❤

Indians usually speak as a minimum 3 languages: English, Hindi and the local languages. So it is just normal she speaks and like multiple languages. Only to monolingual English found that estrange, It seems very provincial their insistence and disbelief about choosing other language than English to express oneself.

محترم ناصر عباس نیر صاحب کا بے حد شکریہ کہ ان کے طفیل آگ کا دریا سے متعلق اس قدر مفید گفت گو سننے کو ملی۔۔۔۔صحت و سلامتی کی دعاٸیں۔۔۔

Good work sir🎉

Maithree wickramasinghe

Madams,Kashmir scars are self inflicted scars of pakistanis. The issue was settled in 1947 when hindu Maharaja of J&K acceded to india as per the choice offered to princely states. Rest is acrimony without an end.

I think she studied at the Pakistani Board of Secondary Education, and for validation, she consults with her Pakistani mentor Ayesha Jalal.

Two beautiful souls interacting

Great lecture, can’t wait to read

Kaul 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Narivad kha se aa gya😂😂😂😂😂 Aur tm baithi kha ho😂😂😂😂

Kaul is real gaddar😂

From where I can buy this book in Pakistan.

Pakistanis were brave till they came in contact with the Indian army. Pakistan started all the wars and lost them badly. Ask Air Martial Asgar Khan.

Pakistani's feet went cold as soon as Tiger Hill and Tolo ling fell to Indian army. Then Pakistan was begging for peace, but Indians went after them, and it was a massacre.

Indians hit Pakistanis hard in normal conventional way--NOT UNCONVENTIONAL. Propaganda masters.

Silly explanation on 120 posts as all posts vacated by Indian army during winters are concrete structures. If number was so less how did 2,500 Pakistani soldiers die in Kargil.

A congregation of vile vicious people. Haters

People who’re not even seen as intellectuals are given a stage in Pakistan & being portrayed as scholars🤦🏻‍♂️😂 That’s pure Pakistani level😂

Again plain lie by stupid lady that Indian int were saying that they were Afghani in fact paki Army started brainwashing their countrymen through media propaganda that it was not Army but Radical on the heights who have crossed the LOC they intact started playing audios of afghanis fighting the Russians

Stupid lady casting aspersions on Indian troops without actually coming this side speaking to any of the Indian cdrs ,not a surprise the clan is such jahil kaum , it was one of the GOC who getting some zoo

Pakistan army is always under illusion..dimag ghutne main...khwab dekhna aacha hain lekin aaukat gadhe ki aur khwab ghode ke... this nation will never grow due to fact that they always like to evolve around war only..not evolving around progress of nation..

Actually with Siachen, both countries made a move. She has conveniently missed out operation Ababeel. The Indians preemptively put up posts under operation Meghdoot. With respect to the Chinese war, we already have the MacMohan line of control. India didn’t need to nibble away beyond that. It is the Chinese who had an issue with the British legacy. Extraordinary interpretation of history by the lady in the podcast. Pakistani historians are truly amazing.

I did construction work Farhan Bokhari sb( journalist and writer )plaza located in Bahria Town Phase 7 Rawalpindi. After the work was completed, when I went to him to collect the pending payment, he not only refused to pay my outstanding Amount And instead handed me over to the police. The police kept me in the police station for three days and released me on the condition that you will not go to Farhan Ali Bukhari again for Any Payment.

I am here for Durefishan_Saleem ❤❤ Huge Fan of her... Respect, love, regards from India 🇮🇳 🇮🇳 🇮🇳

Read Kumar Verma on 1962

rest is history

no its not true major manish Ex Major Manish Bhatnagar , who was company commander of 5 para had lost 1 jawan on 26- Jan-1999 had reported the Pakistani intrusions in kargil in jan -feb-1999 had officially reported this , in batalic sector . the top army Generals are hiding the true facts. Ex major Manish Bhatnagar has spotted a emeny bunker on point( bunker reported on 08 & 09 Jan-1999 by major Manish Bhatnagar) , as early jan- feb 1999. Major Manish Bhatnagar had reported enemy bunker on point 5770 , which was highest feature captured during operation Vijay . on jan 26 1999, as a company commander his 1 jawan was killed & 4 of javans were critically injured. all reported in higher chain of command The top Generals are not speaking truth . He has shown , offical 12:32 evidence , documents, reports , filed & reported by him of Pakistan intrusions in jan 1999 , on record on you tube as a Company commander to top bosses in Jan 1999 of Pakistan inteusions .It is in this context that a former officer of the 5th Battalion of The Parachute Regiment (5 Para), ex-major Manish Bhatnagar, has raised several questions regarding the discovery of the intrusions and the manner in which these were handled subsequently in the conduct of operations.Bhatnagar has taken umbrage at a recent television interview in which former Army chief Gen V P Malik (retd) said lack of intelligence inputs and surveillance gaps led to the Kargil intrusions. He served a legal notice on the former Army chief on July 8 seeking withdrawal of the comments, contending that disregarded warnings had in fact led to the intrusions. short article insertBhatnagar’s contention is that in January-February 1999, he observed and reported enemy activity at Point 5770, the northernmost and highest peak later reclaimed from the Pakistani army regulars as part of Operation Vijay on June 29, 1999, by 27 the battalion of the Rajput Regiment. Bhatnagar has said that he repeatedly reported enemy activities and exchange of fire while he was in an eyeball-to-eyeball situation close to Point 5770 and that he even spotted an enemy bunker and reported as above, in regular written situation reports, message log books and conversations up the chain of command to his then commanding officer, Col A K Srivastava. These reports were sent up the chain of command to Brigadier P C Katoch, then commander of the 102 Infantry Brigade and Major General V S Budhwar, then general officer commanding of the 3 Infantry Division. The 25th anniversary of the Kargil war has not only served as a reminder of the valour, tenacity and steadfastness of the Indian troops on the icy heights of Dras, Batalik, Mushkoh and other areas of the battlefield but also brought the alleged intelligence and surveillance failures that led to the conflict back into focus. It is in this context that a former officer of the 5th Battalion of The Parachute Regiment (5 Para), ex-major Manish Bhatnagar, has raised several questions regarding the discovery of the intrusions and the manner in which these were handled subsequently in the conduct of operations. Bhatnagar was court-martialled in 2001 and dismissed from service. He had been found guilty of “acts prejudicial to good order and military discipline” and handed out what seemed to be an excessive punishment disproportionate to the offence. The more serious charge against him pertained to disobeying a command to carry out an attack on a position reportedly occupied by the Pakistan army. However, this charge could not be proven in the course of his court martial and Manish Bhatnagar was found not guilty. Bhatnagar contended during the course of his trial that he had reported Pakistani intrusions well before they were discovered in May 1999 but that his warnings had been disregarded by the Army top brass. Bhatnagar says warnings disregarded Bhatnagar has taken umbrage at a recent television interview in which former Army chief Gen V P Malik (retd) said lack of intelligence inputs and surveillance gaps led to the Kargil intrusions. He served a legal notice on the former Army chief on July 8 seeking withdrawal of the comments, contending that disregarded warnings had in fact led to the intrusions. short article insertBhatnagar’s contention is that in January-February 1999, he observed and reported enemy activity at Point 5770, the northernmost and highest peak later reclaimed from the Pakistani army regulars as part of Operation Vijay on June 29, 1999, by 27 the battalion of the Rajput Regiment. Bhatnagar has said that he repeatedly reported enemy activities and exchange of fire while he was in an eyeball-to-eyeball situation close to Point 5770 and that he even spotted an enemy bunker and reported as above, in regular written situation reports, message log books and conversations up the chain of command to his then commanding officer, Col A K Srivastava. These reports were sent up the chain of command to Brigadier P C Katoch, then commander of the 102 Infantry Brigade and Major General V S Budhwar, then general officer commanding of the 3 Infantry Division. Bhatnagar says even the post manned by the late Captain Saurabh Kalia reported heavy exchange of fire in the Kargil and Batalik sectors. While being on the forward post, Captain Kalia (as early as three months before official declaration of intrusions), reported mortar, artillery, anti aircraft guns, medium and small arms fire on February 5, 6, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 23, 25, March 1, 2(Holi), 6, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 23 and 27 in 1999. “Despite reportings as above, and possibly besides numerous others not within the personal and documentary knowledge of my client, which might have been similarly suppressed at some level up the chain, posts were ordered to be vacated and enemy information not even shared with the neighbouring brigade and higher headquarters up to the Army headquarter level,” the legal notice sent by Bhatnagar’s advocate states. The former officer has also contended that weeks into the eviction operation, general officer commanding of the 3 Infantry Division, Maj Gen V S Budhwar, continued to send exhausted and fatigued troops for eviction operations, from one sector to another, including those being de-inducted from the Siachen glacier. Bhatnagar contends that the general officer commanding was ordering deinduction of troops from the Siachen heights of 21,000 ft, making them march for days only to be directly reinducted into eviction operations. The ex-major says the Kargil war has not been evaluated in its correct, full and overwhelming perspective. “The careers of officers who fought in this war on the front line at various levels, failed to rise except a few, to ranks above Brigadier. Many of them were deprived due and appropriate recognition in the form of war/gallantry medals & decorations such as then Captain Cheema of 27 Rajput, Brigadier Devinder Singh, then Commander 70 Infantry Brigade,” he said. Bhatnagar added that while junior officers like him suffered dismissal from service, after one of the most controversial trials, no blame or fault has been found with any officer above the brigadier rank for intrusion having taken place, unprecedented eviction and subsequent fudging and manipulation of war records and documents, leading to wrong lessons being drawn. Questions raised by ex-major Bhatnagar Was it not possible to accomplish eviction operations with fewer Indian casualties? Except for the bravery and sacrifices of the young officers and men, has Kargil war not been reduced into a delusional narrative? Were enemy intrusions collectively termed Kargil intrusions 1999 really a surprise or intelligence or surveillance failure at all? Hasn’t the standard of generalship seen a massive dip in standards, when compared with the 1971 Indo-Pak war? Wasn’t the operational-level generalship totally lacking? Was it not a better ground strategy to starve the enemy in terms of supplies and ammunition by cutting off his stretched supply lines running through bowls and valleys, instead of direct assaults of entrenched enemy at massive heights, by own troops in near-suicidal missions, as was finally accomplished by then Commander 70 Infantry Brigade Brigadier Devinder Singh in the fastest manner and with minimal casualties? © The Indian Express Pvt Ltd First uploaded on: 14-07-2024 at 12:39 IST TAGS: 1999 -

The author is a brave person to write this much staying in Pakistan. As an Indian i appreciate. But question is will Pakistani Army or the powerful authority ever learn from this episode? 😊

Indian occupation of features in Siachin were on the Eastern side of cease fire line agreed at Karachi Agreement. As these features were unoccupied, but Pakistani started sending expeditions to the Siachin Glacier. Indian Army decided to preventive occupation of the features which were clearly on the Indian side

I remember her written drama MARVI. We friends used to make fun of the name which could translated as 'hit me'. The love for education for a girl that made her a rod of steel against all odds is worth praising and watching. Such dramas are not written anymore. I was hardly a teenager then but my comprehension cemented the value of education. This is the first time I have seen this lady for the first time. There used to be a big name appearing on the screen as a writer. I wish she could be asked about her education and way of writing rather than such stupid questions.

typcial pakistani… wants to sell a book but will only speak half truths, skirt the obvious issue of calling a spade a spade and do the usual “soldiers were very brave” but wont say that their military was so heinous that they refused to accept the bodies back and India gave them a proper burial as per their religious customs…

Sleep talking......

Bravery of pakistani soldiers😂😂😂. Sitting on 17,000 ft with artillery fire support, HMG's, LMG's, stinger missiles, still get booted out. Indian flags on Kargill heights flying when Nawaz Sharif meeting Bill Clinton.

Saying indians don't know balti and thought it was pashto is the stupidest thing i have heard many ladhaki speaks balti and kashmiri too , and jakrif was present in the area who were local

Lady mixing some shit in b/w as well, India taking Siachin is very different from Pak's Kargil incursion. Siachin is on LOC and no was manning it permanently. Pakistan had plans to take it over permanently, INdia got wiff of pakistan's cold weather procurement plans from European vendor and beat pakistan into their plans. Now Kargil is well within Indian side of LOC and hence India had every right to pound any one and it is not vicious, if pak had done that, then it would courageous answer? what a duplicity. Someone talking about nuclear option during peace time is very much different than some one talking about during a active conflict engagement. Lady is very hurt about pounding.

I want to read her book "Le Jardin de Badalpour " in english. Is it available anywhere?

If she is a pakistani intellectual then in India we have thousands like her at the tea shop.Riyasat e pudina for a reason.