I worked at The Boy's Store (AKA Piggly Wiggly) with Anna. We had a silly little inside joke where whenever we first saw each other in the morning she would say "eww it's Chad 🙄" and pretend like she about to barf or something. It sounds mean but I was a dumb teenage boy with high school humor. It would always make me laugh or smile. She was just that kind of person. She always looked a little deeper than everyone else and saw you for who you are beneath the surface and found a way to connect with you. She would never miss an opportunity to make you laugh or make your day a little brighter.

This year gone fast seriously too quick.

I had some biscuits again and tasted nice

I was stathis best friend and i had talked to him before everything had happened and i was devastated after the news so sad.

This is nauseating just get on with the story and stop waffling took 7.59 before you got started.

Because she was insane. We all told him she was insane from day one. I don't know how I even found this podcast but I listened and my only comment is she's a sociopath.

Sheeww this hits hard being your own dad 😔

You’re taking way too long getting to the story

Check the lake.

Hi, my name is Arthur. I knew Stathis when we were in high school together in Las Cruces NM. I want to say I am very very glad to hear someone tell this story. I didn't know him very well but I definitely had alot of interactions with him, that I won't mind sharing. I have been following this case very closely since it happened I was a senior still in NM when this happened, there are definitely more details or there about what exactly he did to that poor girl. I really do hope he rots forever. Stathis is the kind of person when you guys meet him you can feel who he truly is inside, Cold and deadly

Based on what u had accesss to this is the mkst comprehensive review of pattys situation i have seen. Well done. I appreared kn dr phil and in the doccumentary 33 and cpjnting but i really wish u also cpuld have seen season 1 eposode 1 of final appeal on tje oxygen network which has bizzarely been supporessed. Happy to answer any questions or put you in touch with jane. Shes innocent. Believe it. Id bet my own life on it.

My husband is from Wetumpka! He played baseball with Josh and Cody growing up.

Janets friends the maids at the blue mill inn KNEW what happened, they were there keep the secret for THIRTY YEARS. All the while living their lives living in town raising THEIR CHILDREN with not one care about janets family

The fact so many knew who what where why and said NOTHING while continuing to live in Holland for almost 30 years is outrageous and they have ZERO good reason for not running to cops asap after wackenhut left town, is disgusting. I lived in Holland for more then 30 years from 94 to late 2023 this was big news when it finally broke in those parts

I grew up in Catasauqua.

I was in grad 9 at the time and will never forget this ... she was also friends with my cousin and when she went missing there was so many roomers at the time no one know what was truth and what was false and it was a sad thing people in town when she first went missing would call the number given at the time if you thought you may have seen her and some people would call and say they seen her even when they didn`t it was so crazy how many roomer and people saying they seen her even it was proven that they didn`t for the people that know Misty I am sorry I know she was a good friend to lot`s of people and she will always be missed god be with her .

Now you’re 41! Yes, I just had to say that. 😂

As a former band member who March directly behind Mistie in the Seaforth All Girls Marching Band...she is still loved and so very missed.

I’ve been waiting for someone to do this…Cecil is my moms ex husband, my oldest sister was the friend of Amanda … it’s interesting what we know and what the public knows.

Just found this, Josh Caspari's best friend who helped him do all of this. Is out walking around town, and it is infuriating. We talk about this all the time around here how the accomplice Cody A is scott free... was trying to find the ID DOCUMENTARY to show someone the story but sent them this instead.

How were you able to get the court transcripts?

Shari was 17, almost 18 when she was kidnapped & killed.

So, vanishing twin syndrome is actually 100% legit, & the fetus who “passes away” pretty much dissolves into the walls of the womb, the amniotic sac, & the surviving twin. 😢 I live here in escanaba as well. Praying for justice for this family, endlessly. 🙏

Beth you are from North Carolina, you might be interested to know Robert Baker is also from North Carolina. He is from Fayetteville. I went to elementary school with him all the way through High School at Westover High School in Fayetteville. Despite all that and going to school that long with him, we were just more acquaintances not close friends. Both of our fathers were in the Army stationed at Fort Bragg. Robert is mixed race. His father is black and his Mom German I believe. Rob ended up pleading no contest and was sentenced in July 2023 to life in prison. Monica is to be tried in April 2024. I was aware of his charges but had honestly forgotten about it until last night when another classmate sent me a photo from our 20 year class reunion when it had me and him in it along with Robert. The photo was taken in 2001. It was the first and only time I saw Robert since 1981 when we graduated High School.

I think Caleb was blackmailing Ricky so Ricky decided to deal with him permanently. Caleb probably secretly made that tape in order to use it as leverage.

I can't get my head around the money on the steering wheel..if the old guy was involved, why wouldn't he have removed the money before the police came? Not that l think the old guy is innocent but that detail about the money baffles me. Are we sure the friend who Caleb said he was visiting, wasn't lying when he said he had no plans with Caleb that night?

My husband is the “creep” that stole the panties & shared a wall with Stephanie. To hear the entire story from his and his parents’ perspectives is INSANE. I’ve heard it 100+ times and I’m still blown away by it all.

Just found your podcast (thru my sister) and Idk why but I had to know which one was Beth and which one was Christy. Anywhoo I was spot on. Love the show. Keep up the good work ladies and happy new year!

If her family wanted this on here they would have posted the story. Maybe you should be respectful

Hey there lovely ladies! This was a really awesome story to broadcast. I enjoyed how you all went thru the fine details of what happened and how this disgusting freak was finally brought down. I've followed this case for many years. As to how it's so well known, there was a film made in 1993 called "Nightmare in Columbia County"... aka in other countries, "Victim of Beauty". The main character is the older sister, Dawn Smith. She is played by Jeri Ryan, which was her first role and put her on the map. She's since played well known character "Seven of Nine" in several of the Star Trek series. She's quite gifted. You ought to check it out. It's available on a few different film platforms. Thanks again for a great podcast! :)

Hi there! We can definitely put this on our list and take a look into it! Thanks!

Can you do the 2000 Jessica carpenter case?

Some of your comments are inaccurate, we took the children in and Nicholas is now a senior in high school and doing very well.

Stacy is a confirmed liar and self serving psycho and DID later say Todd never confessed to the Chicago tribune in 2004 and the New Yorker in 2009, now she’s back to he confessed but in a different conversation in which she originally said he confessed and she SHOULD rot in hell, the neighbor’s testimony was sketch, the science behind the arson evidence has been determined to be junk, Webb, the jailhouse snitch was made promises of early parole for his testimony and the prosecutor was accused of misconduct. He was innocent and murdered by the state of Texas. You have no evidence Todd ever beat Stacy but pass it off as truth. Even the crooked prosecutor admitted to not being able to make sense of ANYTHING she said. This is horrible. I would be embarrassed of this and take it down. This wasn’t thoroughly researched

Ez-can-a-ba Little bay D knock

The lifetime movie is grossly inaccurate.

The suburb is called Collingwood not Collingsworth

So sad I missed this! I love listening to your podcast, it always makes my day! Keep doing what you're doing because you make the world not as scary and sucky, so it lets me leave my closet for a few hours <3 Lots of love from Iceland! <3

I always wondered if the underwear in her mouth was her own that the killer took or if it was a pair he stole or got…just unusual

The first thing that needs to be fixed is the Morgantown Police department was notified first. Then a teletype was sent to the WVSP. This was done all with in the first 24 hours to include the FBI. Law Enforcement took this case very seriously.

nerviger Podcast. Diese ganzen blöden Kommentare dazwischen und immer dieses gegickel... kein Wunder, dass das über eine Std. dauert. Davon sind max. 30 Minuten sinnvoller Inhalt

This is my hometown and I was 9 when this happened. I remember talking about it in class and going over what to do in case someone tries to take you and the town was put on curfew. She also lived a few blocks over from me and we all made signs for her welcoming her home. It was a wild time for our quiet town.

This is Sidnees little sister, Can we please leave her alone and let her rest! It’s been 13 years! Her murder isn’t something everyone should be getting off on! Keep in mind her family is STILL hurting & people coming up with assumptions isn’t making our healing process any easier!

Jamie is deceased. He was my niece and newphews Uncle.

I love this

Also sorry so many comments but she died on mikes birthday! She got one last punch at him!!!! I love it he will never be able to celebrate his birthday without remembering she died that day! He lives in protective custody bc he was beaten within an inch of his life!

If they would have went after attempted murder they would have been able to charge him with murder after she passed it would have been double jeopardy

She wanted to buy cigarettes she already talked to her kids and her mom

Ron and I have two children together they are now 21 and almost 20. Judy was an awesome bonus mom to my children. I was never with Mike

I don't mind if you announce my name it's perfectly fine honestly. Thanks for viewing my crime stories or I should say tragic sad stories !