I agree with just about everything you said with the exception of your dismissal of Frenzy. That film represents Hitchcock returning to themes and storytelling from his early career in the 30s & 40s, but with the ability to get nasty with more modern sensibilities. It’s a retro commentary on an artist’s own earlier work that deserves as much respect as Ford’s Liberty Valance or Eastwood’s Unforgiven.

love the part where you say eric is just cherry on top of a already made sundae it tell me that not only does ariel want be part of our world she now wants share her experience with eric

It was those three in the water tower that.must have done it. Like "uncle Joe" moving kind of slow.

I know you said "movies" but… Would "Penny Polendina" from _RWBY_ count?

Still waiting for that Disney Ranking list "checking watch"

I 😁 glad you did a second part

I 😁 love Pinocchio 😁 ❤️ 😍

34:31 oh I had the picture of this as a kid! Never seen the movie growing up though lol

Anybody watching in 2025? This video has aged so well in the wake of the Rachel Zegler live-action remake.

What's even worse is the live action motion picture adaptation of snow white starring Rachel zegler ruins the original film

9:12 Wow. If I had a nickel for every Walt Disney Animation villain exploding on impact, I would have two nickels. Wich it isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice. Right?

Your forgetting Saban’s adventures of the little mermaid. I’ve been looking all over for it since I remember from my childhood

I remember watching this movie at the cinema. I was torn in all directions, not knowing which lead to follow, and I felt hugely let down when the screening ended.

14:43 I agree, he was the best 💋

Where is starkid’s hit musical Starship?? >:(

The shocking scene of pinocchio laying face down on the beach 😢. Our moral compass is being challenged in this movie

Props to del toro, but disney’s pino to me is totally on another level. Heartbreaking after we found him on the beach and then he gets into a real boy ❤❤❤

I like Characters who clean and do house chores because I can relate to them and also I might have slight OCD. 😂

Hi, comments section. Hungry for more? Here are some suggestions... . The Sandman (Paul Berry, 1991) Cat's Cradle (1974) Not Without My Handbag (Aardman, 1993) Scaredy Cat (1948) The Cat Piano (2009) Svetlonos / The Torch Bearer (2005) The Prospector (Paxson Woebler, 2010) Donald Duck and the Gorilla (1944) From Beyond (2013) The Vanishing of the S.S. Willie (2024) I Live in the Woods (2008, GORE WARNING) Waiting (Emlyn Boyle, 2012) Pleasant Inn (David Romero, 2019) The Case of the Stuttering Pig (1937) Now Hear This (1963) The Hangman (1964)

45:17 AAAAAAAAHHHHHHH!!!!! THE KIDS CHEERING SOUND EFFECT HAS HAUNTED MY DREAMS!!!!!!! THIS IS WAY SCARIER THAN HORROR MOVIES!!!!!! BTW, You Had One Job, You Should've Changed That Horrendous Sound Effect to Something Else Like The SEGA Sound Effect......

This is what happens when Disney cancels a TV series what was in the making and sell this as a fake Sequel to make some money out of us!

Personally, I'd love to see a list of everything that was in the intro please! Thank you. :)

prince florian really does get so much flak for being a character who's just meant to be in the background and a support to snow white 💀 from being called a 30-year-old to a pdf file and a ncrophiac. just slander after slander.

In the Japanese version it's clear from the Cat's voice and lines that she's jealous of Princess Mermaid for stealing attention from the prince. The dub kind of messes up her character by having her be okay with killing the prince, but in the original version she never expected him to jump in and fight the wolves, and you can still tell by her body language that's she's worried he's gonna be hurt. She's just processive, that's all. Also, the movie recently got a Blu Ray release which includes the Japanese subtitled version, so check that out

I think Snow White is still a beautiful and wonderful movie that people can still find a way to relate to today even though it was realeased many years ago! 🙂

Bro the last chapter of this video was awesome especially as someone who has already watched most of these movies and seeing them all wrapped up so nicely at the end was a treat! Thank you so much for such a great video!!

9:33 creative interpretations don’t have to be faithful

Eric having a parallel song to part of your world I thought it went hard personally Also scuttlebut was endearing

26:14 Ursula and triton being siblings isn’t technically a change That was the ORIGINAL plan for the ORIGINAL movie and was a change the og did so this is calling back to that

9:33 I liked that one I thought it was endearing

Nice video! I would love to see more of theses rankings of fairy-tale adapatations, maybe on Beauty and the Beast or Cinderella

(26:51) This is again another beautiful part of your review which I think modern audiences don't get about Snow White and after this part of your review, Snow White became my favourite Disney movie of all time and Snow White the best princess of all time.

This video somehow rerouted my brain, cuz now when I watch the movie I often think about different points you make and how much it all clicks together. Great work 💜

Arg. It’s been two years and you haven’t made anymore. You should just tell us your favorite or skip ahead if necessary to make video about it. No pressure of course. These must take a long time. I’ve enjoyed all these videos so thank you!!!

I do wish the dwarves got at least a little bit more character depth like in the original fairy tale, mainly because they're in the title.

25:43 I'm pretty sure the prince was like a decade and a half older...

I absolutely love Buratino, especially the 1975 version. Dmitriy Losifov is perfect for the role, he has so much life on screen! Soviet movies are so different to any other form of cinema, its like everything is out to get you, so you have to be extra cautious. great video as always 😄

The one made in Japan was my movie I never knew another Pinocchio that movie was so good brings back so many memories 😭😭

I find it alarming how this comparison feels less like a comparison and more of an attempt to discredit the Del Toro film; handwaving it's technical and artistic accomplishments, assigning arbitrary criteria, and reaching outside the scope of the film itself to minimize it, to imply it's far less original than it may in fact be, and omitting several aspects of the story, including, confusingly, the idea that the cricket lived in the tree that eventually became Pinocchio, which is not dissimilar to the German version, which would have actually served your purpose far better than the far more manipulative edits of the puppeteer characters dancing alongside one another, as well as other similarities which should be expected as they draw from the same source material. Rather than reckon with the task of directly comparing the animation styles of the two films, you chose to claim that one "maximizes the medium" while the other doesn't, while providing criteria that is particularly arbitrary; implying that stop motion animation is meant to, and can only reach it's fullest potential as a medium if it plays into the small-scale of its models, and "brings you into the space" as if you are a participant. this bizarre stipulation inherently implies that every film Henry Selick ever directed doesn't take full advantage of it's medium, and is also inferior to Robot Chicken. I'll thank you for not making the far more insidious, but worryingly tangential argument that well-lit, detailed, and fluid stop motion is "pointless" and "should just be CGI", a criticism commonly levied at Laika by sophists and ignorant critics. Your stance on voice casting is one I actually agree with emphatically, but find the way you use it in your argument here questionable; only the original film's cast is given any samples of their work, and are not compared- even unfairly- to their counterparts in Del Toro's film. An easy task to give oneself, I would think. it's as if having a celebrity voice cast is enough to assume the performances will be lacking. While this is indeed usually the case, I feel does a huge disservice to David Bradley in particular, who I believe does a fair job of capturing both the tenderness and madness of Geppetto, especially when he is actually building Pinocchio, whom here serves as a surrogate for a dead son (which is entirely omitted this analysis). While he is known for the screen, Ron Perlman is a voice actor himself, having an extensive list of credits to his name, many of which sound different to his natural speaking voice, including Mr. Lancer, Slade, Clayface, and The Lich King, just to name a few. The extent of the critique on the music in the Del Toro version is to simply compare a single leitmotif that appears in other Del Toro films, and not even by using the actual scores, but by playing a few keys on the piano. Conversely, you pull out an arrange album composed in the 80s to sell the viewer on a bit of the score from the Disney film. in both cases, you withhold the actual score from them in the moment while making your arguments, and I do not understand why. This all speaks to the idea that the films are -not- allowed to be judged on their own merits, a clear contradiction of the lovely monologue that closes out the video, which is amusingly followed by sticking the Del Toro version below the goofy pantomime live action interpretation, accompanied by the least-flattering possible out-of-context clip of it's horrible english dub. It certainly feels as though you allowed your irritation at a certain sect of people's insistence that Del Toro's Pinocchio is the only good film adaptation to color your analysis, and it severely soured the viewing experience. I will grant you praise for being able to hide this scorn in your voiceover and overall evaluation of the films, but it's simply too much to ignore. It's a shame, because I firmly believe the Disney film is more than capable of standing it's ground in this fight, and would hold up just as well in a balanced comparison.

Regardless of the looseness of the adaptation, and the flaws in its storytelling, it feels like a travesty to rate Bubble lower than the trashy cashgrab live action remake of the disney version. For that matter, the Czech version more than deserves recognition for trying to tell the orignal story faithfully.

0:50 noodle arms 😂

Definitely, one of the weakest. Still, it's an infinitely better movie than Pocahontas 2, to be fair.

I love your measured takes on even worst movies, could you please continue reviewing Disney cheapquels?

4:44 who else is here after the live action snow white trailer included her singing a shameless mezzo belt about finding herself

Coming back to this after watching the trailer for the new live action remake. You seem to understand this story better than the writers at Disney today!