Ranking Dark Souls 3's Battle Axe
1:37
Ranking Elden Ring's Estoc
16:22
Ranking Dark Souls 3's Estoc
14:56
Ranking Dark Souls 2's Estoc
17:37
Ranking Demon's Souls' Greatsword
8:40
Ranking Elden Ring's Uchigatana
26:21
Ranking Dark Souls 3's Uchigatana
14:54
Ranking Dark Souls 2's Uchigatana
15:51
Ranking Elden Ring's Scimitar
20:29
Ranking Dark Souls 3's Scimtar
12:36
Ranking Dark Souls 2's Scimitar
14:55
Ranking Demons Souls' Broadsword
9:51
Ranking Elden Ring's Greatsword
13:04
Ranking Dark Souls 3's Greatsword
10:25
Ranking Dark Souls 2"s Greatsword
13:38
Ranking Demons Souls' Dagger
14:45
Ranking Elden Ring's Bastard Sword
17:18
Пікірлер
@Fierce_Chimera
@Fierce_Chimera 4 күн бұрын
People sleep on the Tediore weapons, man. Especially the combat rifles, get yourself one with good parts and you'll be set. You've had some good luck with the Tediore luck, even with the anarchy. That was a good vid man, I enjoyed it 🤙
@IGSA101
@IGSA101 5 күн бұрын
Vehicle weapons count as tediore weapons. Also shock damage is effective against the crab worms of all things, and has a property where it can stun an enemy. I used a shock shotgun on my daze lilith build, it did solo the long angelic ruins so it's not ineffective.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 4 күн бұрын
Didn't know shock could stun people lol. I still don't like it but it's not as useless as I thought
@Gizzor
@Gizzor 5 күн бұрын
if you melee it skips the pump animation on slower fire rate shotguns this is a god send
@afrightenedsloth
@afrightenedsloth 5 күн бұрын
Maybe I should try more Tediore next run
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 5 күн бұрын
Don't sleep on Tediore shotguns!
@Wallrunninglooter
@Wallrunninglooter 5 күн бұрын
My favorite are the tediore mashers. Crazy damage, fire rate and craaazy reload speed. It's almost faster than the time between shots.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 5 күн бұрын
Tediore reload speed bein faster than Jakobs fire rate:🤌
@denode12
@denode12 6 күн бұрын
Great video! I had fun with the commentary.
@anthonyg7623
@anthonyg7623 22 күн бұрын
Do not overlook the fact that the bandit axe is essentially the same thing just better
@isaachostetler9794
@isaachostetler9794 22 күн бұрын
It's a good starting weapon if you wanna do a strength build and start with the Warrior. Millwood Battle Axe is better once you get it tho.
@bananas-ik
@bananas-ik 26 күн бұрын
Рапира:😎
@cameronmackinnon5923
@cameronmackinnon5923 Ай бұрын
Butcher Pete gaming
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious Ай бұрын
How disrespectful of you to upload this on 9/11
@melessthanthree
@melessthanthree 2 ай бұрын
I’ve been loving these weapon comparisons between games! Always looking forward to your analysis on each.
@jennydeaf9O9
@jennydeaf9O9 2 ай бұрын
lies outside the event ;-; da lomger da sord da lomger da reach >:D
@mynameisstepon7860
@mynameisstepon7860 2 ай бұрын
Bestoc
@mynameisstepon7860
@mynameisstepon7860 2 ай бұрын
Unfortunately you don't get Leo Ring Imagine running hops Leo counter attack
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
@@mynameisstepon7860 Yeah I don't use weapon buffs. Every weapon needs to have the same baseline, and some buffs, like Leo ring, don't work for every weapon. Besides, I'd rather have the Havel poise combo anyway
@cameronmackinnon5923
@cameronmackinnon5923 2 ай бұрын
Love me uchi, took me all the way through the game with a heavy armour dex weapon build. Absolute steamroller of a setup
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
@@cameronmackinnon5923 Poise Bois unite! 🫡
@cameronmackinnon5923
@cameronmackinnon5923 2 ай бұрын
I haven't played Demon's Souls in ages, but I was always fond of the bastard sword and its a shame to see it not hold up under scrutiny
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
If you like the bastard sword then it's a good weapon bro. My rankings aren't objective they're very subjective and biased. I'm not trying to tell people their favorite weapons objectively suck I'm just expressing why I personally like or dislike em.
@maxtiis2352
@maxtiis2352 2 ай бұрын
Only two ultra greatswords in Demon's Souls and this one is just heavily outclassed in stats by the Dragon Bone Smasher. All the same attributes, even down to the being able to use cursed weapon on it, just way higher base damage and strength scaling. If you want to see some overpowered stuff in Demon's Souls, try using the Blueblood sword or the Demonbrandt by getting it as early as possible. Both weapons shred the game pretty hard.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
If the dragon bone smasher is shit imma be so pissed cuz you're not the only one who said the greatsword sucks in comparison. I know about a lot of the op shit but that's not really the point tbh
@Ashlevon
@Ashlevon 2 ай бұрын
You gotta try it 1-handed too, it has its merits! Though tbh it does feel like a worse Meat Cleaver.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
@@Ashlevon Nahh man nahhh. One handing it would mean less damage when it's damage is already not good for how slow it is, and it wouldn't solve any of the problems I had with it, like the lack of hyperarmor, the too heavy, the too slow, maybe I'd be able to swing it one entire more time but that doesn't matter. Using it with a shield might be fine if that's your thing but it ain't mine. Appreciate your comment but I do disagree with it with as far as the greatsword is concerned.
@Mr-Protagonist
@Mr-Protagonist 2 ай бұрын
Great video
@jimbolips4458
@jimbolips4458 2 ай бұрын
I do really like this weapon's design and animations, what a searing disappointment.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
@@jimbolips4458 Yeah that rolling attack where you stab it into the ground is fuckin sick. Shame the game's design doesn't easily accommodate such a large slow weapon
@mettlemesh
@mettlemesh 2 ай бұрын
dragon bone smasher's shit little brother
@Animoia
@Animoia 2 ай бұрын
Wasnt hyperarmor based off of armor poise back then, not weapon?
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
@@Animoia Not 100% sure. But I had a few pieces of fluted armor on and didn't notice any change in hyperarmor, and since the sword is so heavy it's hard to wear a bunch of good armor and not be fat rolling in the first place. Possible sure but more work than I'd be willing to put in lol
@Animoia
@Animoia 2 ай бұрын
@Croatilillious looking it up, demons souls didn't have poise yet, but it did have hyper armor for certain weapons r2 attacks. Poise wasn't a thing until dark souls.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
@@Animoia Good to know I didn't accidentally miss a crucial piece of evidence that would undermine one of my major reasons for not liking the greatsword lol
@Ashlevon
@Ashlevon 2 ай бұрын
Hyper armor and poise being tied together only started with DS2, and came into being what you're thinking of with DS3 and the Ariandel patch.
@Corrust
@Corrust 2 ай бұрын
While it's really not great for pve, it was an absolute monster in pvp, running 2H and rolling 1H were great moves. No server support anymore so sort of irrelevant. Guillotine axe was my pve go to. Also use cracked beast talisaman with curse weapon and watch the damage go through the roof.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
Nah pvp performance could be relevant depending on what questlines you're tryna do. That black phantom that shows up at 4-1 if you get pure black tendancy? That mf is a pain in the ass. And something like the greatsword would be amazing for dealing with him. But I don't fuck with pvp in any of these games. And with how I play, I only have to fight an NPC like 3 times lol
@gabrielrodriguez6936
@gabrielrodriguez6936 2 ай бұрын
⁠@@Croatililliousdamn, if u don’t play pvp then ur missing out. There’s a reason why multiplayer is integrated through world building and lore.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
​@@gabrielrodriguez6936 Nahh. There's a reason why pvE is integrated into the world building. And pvP is just tacked onto that. If pvp was so important they'd focus more on making sure the servers had way less lag than they do. If pvp was so important they'd make sure the games were balanced. Like at all. But they're not. PvP is one of the worst things to happen to souls likes and I will die on this hill. If people didn't care so much about pvp then the gank squad in ds2 wouldn't exist. And they wouldn't have filled Elden Ring dlc with a dozen NPC bosses that all suck. PvP is laggy, time consuming, annoying, and disrupts the gameplay of people who want to actually play the game. There's a reason most of the games have an option to play offline, and why you won't get invaded in Elden Ring unless you're already in co-op. It's disruptive and janky. These games aren't built for it in any serious sense. I don't know anyone who likes fighting NPCs. I respect your opinion but I firmly disagree with it.
@gabrielrodriguez6936
@gabrielrodriguez6936 2 ай бұрын
@@Croatilillious Why is it then that the Demon Souls intro shows the main character getting help from player Summons? Why are some some of the first items you get in all the souls games multiplayer items? Characters and entire areas throughout the whole series have been dedicated solely to multiplayer covenants. Whether it was Alvina, Gwyndolin, or Solaire. It isn’t just PvP that’s integral to the Souls experience, it’s the entire multiplayer system as a whole. Hidetaka Miyazaki has had a clear vision for what multiplayer could look like and while it has flaws, the fact of the matter is that there is nothing else like it. Ur a small time guy on KZbin ranting. Ask ChasetheBro, Prod, LostmySanity, or Saint Riot and anyone who watches them and you’ll learn that you’re in the minority. If multiplayer wasn’t there, we would’ve never had the Let Me Solo her guy. I’ve made friends through invading. It’s fine if people say they don’t like it, but it’s false to say that it is tacked on or that it’s unnecessary. The fact is that the most of the games have always received patches to make adjustments to multiplayer. Elden Ring is constantly getting updates because FromSoftware knows how important and fundamental the multiplayer experience is to the game. To make things even more funny, DS3 and Elden Ring had entire systems created only for PVP through coliseums and Arenas. They put man hours and money to put PVP only modes into their games TWICE (to my knowledge).
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
​@@gabrielrodriguez6936 As per my last comment. I said there's a reason why pvE is integrated. And spent most of the comment saying why I dislike pvP. I heard Miyazakis story that inspired the PvE elements of the souls games and it's pretty incredible. I'm saying that PvP was tacked on top of THAT. Not that the multiplayer system as a whole was tacked on top of the entire game. The intro cutscene to demons souls shows CO-OP summons. Not invaders. Because invasions and PvP was never the focus for the multiplayer system. In demons souls anyway, they spent a lot of time making a separate balancing system for pvp in Elden Ring. A separate balancing system tacked on to the normal balancing system because these games aren't balanced. I dislike PvP but the fact that so many people complain so heavily about it that it makes fromsoft nerf or buff weapons that effect people who don't play PVP at all, makes me upset. I know I'm in the majority when I say I barely ever invade or invite invaders to me. Most people who play these games just want to have a good time on their own or with a buddy and don't want to have to deal with sweaty tryhard invaders who'll interrupt their experience and waste their time. But some people like the surprising nature of being invaded and that's good too. I'm not trying to judge anyone for how they enjoy the game. I'm explaining why I personally don't like PvP, and think complaining about weapons being imbalanced and calling for nerfs or buffs based solely on weapons performance IN PvP is silly. Like c'mon dude the moonveil was a masterpiece crafted with glintstone by a sellian swordsmith and people complain that it's not balanced. These games were never meant to be balanced. Sorry I've rambled quite a bit lol. TL;DR I was complaining about PvP, I like PvE but just don't do it much, and I hate when people complain that these games aren't balanced for PvP because I believe they were never meant to be and PvP was just a cute lil thing they added on top of the game and not the focus of the game.
@MrIrdatlan
@MrIrdatlan 2 ай бұрын
its just something some guys say to not feel so bad about not being enough. The truth is, size DOES matter, but skill does too! Now do a no hit run on the all souls games, elden ring and their dlcs, just to show you got skill.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 2 ай бұрын
Im confused. Are you implying I didn't like the greatsword cuz I wasn't skilled enough to use it? Or are u just fuckin with me or smth?
@MrIrdatlan
@MrIrdatlan 2 ай бұрын
@@Croatilillious no messing, i dont even play the game, and from the looks of it, i wouldnt like this sword either, i just always say that size does matter when i see someone say it doesnt. I dont sayit to make people feel bad, i say it because its the truth, size matter, be it too big or too small. Im also hella tired and i feel like im high as fuck when tired.
@jadeyjars
@jadeyjars 2 ай бұрын
incomprehensible
@MrIrdatlan
@MrIrdatlan 2 ай бұрын
@@jadeyjars 👍
@Arkmds
@Arkmds 2 ай бұрын
clang
@Bielznxk7
@Bielznxk7 3 ай бұрын
Uchi is my test weapon, I have it with each gem 😅
@insertusername9755
@insertusername9755 3 ай бұрын
Big sword big numbers
@feddevaldez
@feddevaldez 3 ай бұрын
Very nice 👍
@sankuog
@sankuog 3 ай бұрын
Damn, great video man. Definitely subbing. It's always exciting to see more youtubers making DS 2 videos. Hope you post more.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 3 ай бұрын
Best souls 2 <3
@CrowKing-u6h
@CrowKing-u6h 3 ай бұрын
Good video man i love your Channel
@ScoutScoutScoutScoutScout
@ScoutScoutScoutScoutScout 3 ай бұрын
Gotta question bout counter damage. For the weapons that have a counter damage stat does that effect every attack they do or no???
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 3 ай бұрын
Every weapon can do counter damage, but it only applies when the enemy is attacking. But some weapons do more counter damage than others. Like the dagger and the uchigatana. So if you hit them while they're trying to hit you it'll do more damage. And lots more damage with the uchi. That's how it is in dark souls 2 anyway. Not sure about the other ones.
@ScoutScoutScoutScoutScout
@ScoutScoutScoutScoutScout 3 ай бұрын
@@Croatilillious Thank you so much. I've seen so many differing opinions on counter damage that it just confused me to no end.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 3 ай бұрын
​@@ScoutScoutScoutScoutScout No problem. Take what I say with a grain of salt though, I haven't done extensive testing or data mining or any of that. I'm just fairly sure that's how it works based on my observations.
@MerlinUwU
@MerlinUwU 3 ай бұрын
Is it me or katanas suck way too much stamina on souls games? I love those weapons, tho. And to be fair, in the ice dlc, the enemies are way too tough, not really uchi's fault. I did magic, paladin, full str builds and they were still really resistants. Fun video <3
@gerrylane4753
@gerrylane4753 3 ай бұрын
Good vid , my man 🤌🤌
@animalicon3535
@animalicon3535 3 ай бұрын
NO SILVER PENDANT???? Is wild😭 I’ve never not seen someone have for Manus lol - and bro got killed by Sif and golem more than Artorias and Manus/Ornstein a Smough? 😂 bad rng tho.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 3 ай бұрын
Those golem deaths were pretty embarrassing lmao
@seann9854
@seann9854 3 ай бұрын
put an ai voice or something this is too much reading
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 3 ай бұрын
I'd rather die than use an AI voice, but I appreciate the feedback. Hoping to get a mic at some point.
@animalicon3535
@animalicon3535 3 ай бұрын
@@Croatilillioususe your real voice-makes it more engaging bc got to remember no one wants to read or attention span is ruined nowadays lol, however dark souls lovers will watch the vid anyways.
@dbdcking4502
@dbdcking4502 3 ай бұрын
where the fuck do you farm all the large titanate charts?
@Chrono2254
@Chrono2254 3 ай бұрын
you can buy it from the giant blacksmith at Anor Londo for 3800 souls
@blublugamingchannel
@blublugamingchannel 4 ай бұрын
:)
@goybertgoybert6653
@goybertgoybert6653 5 ай бұрын
Good video, please make more from DS2 weapons
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 5 ай бұрын
I'll get to all of them eventually. Gotta cycle thru all the games yk
@NoireMonay
@NoireMonay 5 ай бұрын
Ethan Ralph and the Memphis micros would be proud
@goybertgoybert6653
@goybertgoybert6653 5 ай бұрын
Real sad Ralphamale hours in mexico
@NoireMonay
@NoireMonay 5 ай бұрын
@@goybertgoybert6653 you a real OG my nig
@Your_Destined_Death
@Your_Destined_Death 5 ай бұрын
You probably knew this already, but the Wanderer class starts with it by default
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 5 ай бұрын
Yeah but it's better if I start with the same base stats every time just in case I need to level myself up to use a weapon. I like every weapon to have the same starting point yk. You'd better not comment that same thing under the ds2 scimitar vid I'm making rn cuz the swordsman's scimitar in that is pre-upgraded! Unfair to start with a pre-upgraded weapon. I'm kidding ofc, I appreciate your comments. But I'm always gonna start deprived wherever possible. Demons Souls is excluded from this rule cuz idk how to cheat in weapons on an emulator.
@bigbenhgy
@bigbenhgy 5 ай бұрын
For the titanite chunk farm I think it's best from firelink shrine, just avoid the first two ghosts and drop down from there to the wraiths.
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 5 ай бұрын
Yea I did that for all my other ds1 vids. But 2 elevator rides, ignoring ghosts which can be uncooperative, and running all the way back up to firelink, or spending souls on bones which would be better used for levels. Is all annoying shit I don't like dealing with. The Darkroot Basin bonfire has one short lil elevator, and I don't have to deal with ghosts which is the main thing. They both work, my vids aren't guides so do whatever. But those ghosts are a pain in the ass so I avoid even having to run past em lol
@blublugamingchannel
@blublugamingchannel 5 ай бұрын
Keep it up bro❤
@blublugamingchannel
@blublugamingchannel 5 ай бұрын
Heyaa🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
@thaneyo
@thaneyo 6 ай бұрын
you deserve more views
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 6 ай бұрын
If you shared my vids around that'd help. I only have a youtube account so its not like i can share my own shit around other platforms. Dont share my ds3 dagger vid tho that one was way toooo looonnggg. Learned a lesson on that one.
@zombieboss5178
@zombieboss5178 6 ай бұрын
@@Croatilillious you got a bit unlucky too with the longer one, only do the longer than 20 minute videos (preferably make each one around 12 minutes) until you reach a stable view count per video and then explain at the end of one of your videos about how you want to try a longer video so your viewers know to check your channel for when you make it rather than it showing up on their home page because it might not cause youtube sucks balls
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 6 ай бұрын
​​@@zombieboss5178oh no I don't want to make longer videos. I try to make these as short as they need to be and in the longer videos there's a lot of unnecessary fluff. I want them to be entertaining but also give an ok idea of how whatever weapon I'm using operates. I'm not nearly skilled enough at constructing a video to make one longer than 30 minutes and perfectly comprehensible. To me anyway Lil edit to say I do value your feedback. Thank u <3
@zombieboss5178
@zombieboss5178 6 ай бұрын
@@Croatilillious your welcome man, tough being a tuber nowadays, especially when you don't use the usual trend seeking and clickbait titles/thumbnails good quality I will say keep doin' what you like I'm sure someday you might blow up, though that might also be disheartening if you then proceed to fall off so don't worry about losing popularity if you ever make it big
@Croatilillious
@Croatilillious 6 ай бұрын
​@@zombieboss5178 I don't exaggerate when I say these videos are just an excuse to play thru all these fromsoft souls games. If I get to a point where I can make a living off it so be it. If not at least I have something productive to do with my excess of free time.
@kratimenospanos
@kratimenospanos 6 ай бұрын
THE PEOPLE DEMAND BROADSWORD ONLY!
@DhaarAk
@DhaarAk 7 ай бұрын
in my impression, the great sword is not such a great weapon, there are better options like spears or great hammers. nice video.
@Your_Destined_Death
@Your_Destined_Death 8 ай бұрын
Bastard Sword……of Judgement.
@Your_Destined_Death
@Your_Destined_Death 8 ай бұрын
Y’know, if you make it enchanted affinity, you’ll have made the bootleg “Greatsword of Judgement” from DS3 😂
@SeanWinters
@SeanWinters 11 ай бұрын
Why no voice, scrub?